Preview
Filing # 144608311 E-Filed 02/25/2022 10:31:12 AM
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22", 2022
The following matters have been set for JURY trial at the designated dates and times.
Attorneys/Parties are directed to be prepared to begin your trial at 9:00 AM on the designated
date. If your case settles prior to trial, you will advise the Court via email to the Judicial Assistant
imiller@ca.cjis20.org.
A Status Hearing will be held on the Thursday immediately preceding the start of the scheduled
trial date at 2:00pm.
No Negotiated pleas will be accepted after the time of this status hearing
Cases not reached on a particular day (when more than one case is set), will roll to the following
day, if there are sufficient days remaining in the week. Otherwise, cases not reached during
assigned trial week, will roll over to the next trial period and will be called up according to issues of
the case (speedy, custody, case age)
NOTE: JURY INSTRUCTIONS MUST BE BROUGHT TO COURT ON THE
MORNING OF JURY SELECTION. THESE WILL INCLUDE:
ONE (1) SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE JUDGE, TO
INCLUDE INTRODUCTORY AND DISCHARGE INSTRUCTIONS;
ONE (1) VERDICT FORM; and,
ONE (1) SET OF INSTRUCTIONS FOR EACH JUROR.
ANY PENDING MOTIONS, INCLUDING MOTIONS IN LIMINE, MUST BE HEARD
A MINIMUM OF 3 DAYS PRIOR TO JURY SELECTION.
Child hearsay motions must be heard no later than thirty (30) days prior to
trial.
Page 1 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 224, 2022
2 Amended Jury Trial Docket
March 7"*- 10", 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 3/3/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days || needed
|
March 7th, Psathas, Thea ASA: Scott Patterson | 2 ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
19-744F, 19-938F Defense: robertd@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
|| Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
I
March 7th, | Schmitt, Wallace ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22
21-528F Defense: patrickm@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Patrick McDonald (APD)
March 7th, Salvesen, Jason ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22
21-753F; 21-765F Defense: jen@rsl-law.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Richard Ruhl
March 7th, Thon, Linda ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22
21-984F Defense: scott@bsrlegal.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Scott Weinberg
March 7th, Sawyer, Jeremy ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5—22
21-1354F Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: John Robson jrobson@lucaslawfirmpa.com
Page
2 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22%, 2022
2"4 Amended Jury Trial Docket
March 14" — 17%, 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 3/10/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
March 14th, Suarez, Armando ASA: Chelsea Maslar 3 ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5—22
20-1026F | Defense: harrisk@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: G. Harris Caplan (APD)
March 14th, Sirangelo, Robert ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin 2 ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22
20-1174F; 20-1175F | Defense: alewis@firc2.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Amaris Lewis
March 14th, Poe, Jamie ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin 2 ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22
21-84F Defense: robertd@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
4
March 14th, | Steele, Glen ASA: Chelsea Maslar 4 ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5—22
21-351F Defense: harrisk@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: G. Harris Caplan (APD)
Page 3 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22", 2022
2"? Amended Jury Trial Docket
March 21% — 24", 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 3/17/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
March 21st, Rice, Timothy | ASA: Jennifer Garczewski 4 ASA: jgarczewski@sao20.org #5-22
2022 @ 9:00
19-1068F | Defense: Russell Kirshy
Defense:
Russell@kirshylawfirm.com
|
March 21st, Smith, Darryl | ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
20-354F Defense: alewis@flrc2.org
2022 @ 9:00
| Defense: Amaris Lewis
March 21st, Pandol, Wikenson | ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5
- 22
20-1124F Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Eric Reisinger eric@reisingerlawfirm.com
March 21st, Portilla De Osborn, ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
Graciela Defense: robertd@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
20-1350F Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
March 21st, O'Neil, Justin ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5 -22
20-1375F Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Dino Michaels dmichaels@escobarlaw.com
Page
4 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22", 2022
Amended Jury Trial Docket
April 11 — 14", 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 4/7/22 @ 2:00pm
{ Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof ‘Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
April 11th, Manes, Eric ASA: Chelsea Maslar, 2 ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org , #5-22
20-818F; 21-302F Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin crebholzrubin@sao20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Richard Ruhl, Jason Lucas Defense: rick@rsl-law.com ,
jlodge@lucaslawfirmpa.com
April 11th, Stowell, Joseph ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
20-1035F Defense: rick@rsl-law.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Richard Ruhl
April 11th, Rowan, Jonathan ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
20-1678F Defense: scott@bsrlegal.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Scott Weinberg
April 11th, Mason, Donald ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
21-543F Defense: patrickm@pd.cjis20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Patrick McDonald (APD)
April 11th, Mendoza, Ricardo ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
21-633F, 21-642F Defense: rick@rsl-law.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Richard Ruhl
April 11th, Shaffer, Derek ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
21-1114F Defense: rick@rsl-law.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Richard Ruhl
April 11th, Umphries, Jessica ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
21-1156F Defense: ben@benbuck.law
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Benjamin Buck
Page
5 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22"4, 2022
Jury Trial Docket
April 18" — 21% , 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 4/14/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof ‘Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
April 18th, McBride, Willard ASA: Scott Patterson 2 ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
19-1853F Defense: robertd@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
April 18th, Manning, Kimberly ASA: Chelsea Maslar 2 ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5 -22
21-630F Defense: Martina@mhlawfirm.net
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Martina Hedvicek
Page
6 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22", 2022
Amended Jury Trial Docket
April 25" — 28", 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 4/21/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
April 25th, Williams, George ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin 3 | ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22 |
18-2198F Defense: Martina@mhlawfirm.net
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Martina Hedvicek
April 25th, Martek, Teshona ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5—22
19-797F; 20-1516F; Defense: Ikps.law@gmail.com
2022 @ 9:00
20-1527F Defense: Linda Smith
April 25th, Roster, Janet ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5—22
20-442F Defense: harrisk@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Harris Kaplan (APD)
April 25th, Mace, Timothy ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
20-456F, 20-516F Defense: robertd@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
April 25th, Saunders, Michael ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
20-683F, 20-685F Defense: harrisk@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Harris Kaplan (APD)
April 25th, Plowel, Royston ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5-22
21-514F Defense: scott@bsrlegal.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Scott Weinberg
April 25th, Tufts, Brandon ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
21-1021F Defense: robertd@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
April 25th, Pettit, Sampson ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5—-22
21-1362F Defense: patrickm@pd.cjis20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Patrick McDonald (APD)
April 25th, Pierson, Rachael ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
21-1569F Defense: RLinfo@rsl-law.com
2022 @ 9:00 Defense: Richard Ruhl
Page
7 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22", 2022
Amended Jury Trial Docket
May 16'" — 19, 2022(Mon — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 5/12/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
May 16th, McNealy, Eddie ASA: Daniel Feinberg 4 ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #2+20
08-619F Scott Patterson dfeinberg@sao20.org 60
2022 @ 9:00
Defense:
Defense: Jason Chapman jchapman@Iwrattorney.com
May 16th, Sanchez, Xavier ASA: Scott Patterson 2 ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
20-957F Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Nathan Dougherty contact@nathandoughertylaw.com
|
May 16th, Skinner, David ASA: Chelsea Maslar | 2 ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
21-322F | Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
| Defense: Michael Powell mike@mikepowelllawfirm.com
Jury Trial Docket
May 23" — May 26", 2022(Tues — Thu 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 5/19/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) T Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
May 23rd, Smith, Corbett ASA: Chelsea Maslar 4 ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
19-2079F Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Steven Wetter stevenwetterattorney@gmail.com
May 23rd, Shea, Joseph ASA: Chelsea Maslar ASA: cmaslar@sao20.org #5-22
20-781F, 20-782F Defense:
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Steven Leskovich steven@southernjustice.com
May 23rd, Sayed, Shahzad ASA: Jennifer Garczewski ASA: jgarczewski@sao20.org #3+20
20-1910F Defense: scott@bsrlegal.com 50
2022 @ 9:00
| Defense: Scott Weinberg
|
Jury Trial Docket
May 31% — June 2%, 2022(Tues — Thu 3 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 5/26/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
May 31st, Meeks, Damien ASA: Michael Colombo 4 ASA: mcolombo@sao20.org #2+20
20-51F; 20-124F Defense: robertd@pd20.org 60
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Robert Denny (APD)
Page 8 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22", 2022
Jury Trial Docket
June 20 - June 21%, 2022(Mon — Tues 2 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 6/16/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
June 20th, Mitchell, Michael ASA: Caitlin Sorenson 2 ASA: csorenson@sao20.org #5-22
20-734F Defense: jeremy@asilialaw.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Jeremy McLymont
June 20th, Robinson, Jennifer ASA: Cynthia Rebholz-Rubin ASA: crebholzrubin@sao20.org #5 -22
20-1618F Defense: harrisk@pd20.org
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Harris Kaplan (APD)
June 20th, Wanser, David ASA: Scott Patterson ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5-22
21-957F Defense: rick@rsl-law.com
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Richard Ruhl
June 22nd, Wittemen, Keith ASA: Daniel Feinberg
92-487F
2022 @ 9:00
RESENTENCING Defense: Thomas Summervile
Jury Trial Docket
June 27" — June 29", 2022(Mon — Wed 3 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 6/23/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number Days needed
June 27th, Torres, Manuel ASA: Scott Patterson 2 ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #5 -22
21-958F Defense: Martina@mhlawfirm.net
2022 @ 9:00
Defense: Martina Hedvicek
Jury Trial Docket
July 25" — July 28", 2022(Mon — Thurs 4 days) — Judge CUPP
STATUS on 7/21/22 @ 2:00pm
Time & Date(s) Name & Parties Hof Attorneys contact info Jurors
Case number | Days needed
July 25th, 2022 Shaver, Lacey ASA: Scott Patterson | 2 ASA: spatterson@sao20.org #1+20
20-2008F Defense: KCSlaw8@gmail.com 70
@ 9:00
| Defense: Kevin Shirley
Page 9 of 10
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION
Order on Assignment of Trial dates per Pretrial Conference on February 22%, 2022
25) 2022.
DONE AND ORDERED in Punta Gorda, Charlotte County, ida on GEE
following the Pre-Trial Conference (PTC) conducted on Fe 22nd unta Gorda,
Florida.
C we
Sc . Cupp, Cire i
Copies to: All Attorneys/ProSe Defendants noted as trial counsel in P: ‘s Section
Public Defender (Charlotte County) — Office Head
Clerk of Court
Jon Embury — Court Administrator
Jury Clerk
Case Manager
State Attorney's Office - Witness Management
charlottehelpdesk@ca.cjis20.org
Original: Judicial Assistant to the Honorable Scott H. Cupp
Page 10 of 10