Preview
FILED
DALLAS COUNTY
8/17/2018 4:59 PM
FELICIA PITRE
DISTRICT CLERK
No. DC-16-16442
No. DC-16-16442
IN THE DISTRICT COURT
THE DISTRICT COURT
Beatrice Stevenson
Beatrice Stevenson
|N
§
§
§
116TH JUDICIAL
116TH JUDICIAL
v.
v. §
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
Nationwide Insurance
Nationwide |nsurance C0,,
Co.,
Ocwen Loan
chen Servicing, LLC
Loan Servicing, LLC
and Ron
and Ron Adams
Adams DALLAS COUNTY,
DALLAS COUNTY,
Defendants
Defendants TEXAS
TEXAS
Judgment against
Summary Judgment Defendant
against Defendant
Motion of
Motion Beatrice Stevenson
Plaintiff Beatrice
of Plaintiff for
Stevenson for Summary
Ocwen Loan
chen Loan Servicing, LLC
Servicing, LLC
TO
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE
THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
OF SAID COURT:
Comes now Plaintiff
Comes now
summary judgment
summary judgment
Beatrice Stevenson
Plaintiff Beatrice
on all claims
on all claims of
of
(Stevenson) and
Stevenson (Stevenson)
Stevenson
Stevenson
under T.RIC.P.
(chen) under
and
against
against Defendant Ocwen
Defendant hen Loan
Loan
and in
166(a) and support of
of that
files
would
motion would
that motion
this
files this
c her motion for
her motion full
for full
Servicing, LLC
LLC (Ocwen) T.R.C.P. 166(a) in support
Servicing,
this Honorable
show this
show Honorable Court as follows:
Court as follows:
Srutuincnr
Smtcmcnr ufwt’
\ Fatcrs
Facts
rorimtllv in 2011. She
in 20D. She \‘i1l_uigml
engaged a 1ml\li«’ adjuster, Ron
pllNic .ik.Ak1tl|\1$)
Adams (Adams) t0 rm lmiitllc
h(mdh‘ rho rho in.~L1r.mcu
insurxuu'c claim claim \\irl\
\Virh NI\l'll\I1\\
\‘(H'iwnv Me
lk1\' lnnmumcv
lII.\lll'.lI\(\‘ k 10, (Lu.
}V<\\'H\\‘I1\' fur
fur rlxv
rhon rcccixrd UH
rho
Nariomxidc) whn
N.1rim\\\'lLlt') who thcn i'ct‘ci\'cd 0n In-lull
behalf ml‘
ut' l\i.~
his \h\'l1I Styx wnson pax'nwnr
climr .\:T\’\\'lI\\\l)
L'l1\‘\L>
In‘ srrugruru lass inin flu‘ approximate nmnunr
rhc .1pp1'n>;'II11;ltc .\m<»lim nt ml $*)?3',C‘00
$98,000 \\ir|\ with mid .~'.1itl chcpks
casualty m- .\Tl'llLITL|I‘C loss
c:t.pcrl\, cndm‘scd lwy
prupcrly \‘I‘l\l\\l'.<(‘\1 Src\'vn.\‘III\‘l\l’ hut
cndorscmonr lmr nv\‘t-I‘ mrurncd In
ncwr 1‘cILI1‘nul Adams .md/nr
In .A\kl}ll1\.\'
Slum‘ neither .‘\LLll]\.\ ur Sn-\\-n~uii umltl sm'nru
.<\'k'\I\'\'
c or Srm'vnsnn («711M .1
m*itl1v1' Akhms
.\
U-ultl 1w
mmhl lw prupcrly
pi'npt~1‘ly rc\\.ii1‘ul.
rqmircd‘ Smu‘
quit rho
{ruin Ocwen After
[luv
rvturn mt
return rho payment
0f rhc checks {rum
p;1\,‘m-cnr cl1ucl<.~‘ hcn
atrci‘ mid sulmnxxinn Adams
said .\'Lll‘I1II\~I\\I1 _-\gl.1m.< quit
nu i'vpt1ir .lnd/(vr cniixplt-tml
.it‘cn11\pli
appeals r‘mt rlmr k\‘\\t-n purikn‘mm‘l
(\M‘mn |‘k‘ll‘\\l'l1\L‘kl Wu» (Z)
rwu (Z) llxm1mm
Cmiilu
Cumin: t'L11'rlIo1‘,
further, ir it tixldiri‘l lwinu
1min}; \‘\VHk‘
dune in
in 2008
.igrcuincnr.< re
imvdit‘ic.\tilm ngrccmcnrs
modification tho Stcvcnsun
anJ rho
.mtl rho .~’m'ui1d
smtund being lwinu tlnnu
Juno in in 2014.
2014. Basal
l‘w;1.~'ctl on
on Thu
the I*1l\'l)1x‘l\I' ln.i'\'
pnymcnr hisrury 1w Sru\'t‘1i.~‘on
flu’ Srcvcnson
ru rlu-
l‘\¥l(~»l(~—l-‘II, a
No l‘k'nM'HvHZ;
:\'.~ v
mmvn \\ \‘ctxpn
\‘i:~\*rii~u-.i x\’~.\tn \um
1I AIJH St-nu mg H
Svn'inng I I I
( ',,
t, ct, .il; 11w
:‘r. .31; I‘I llw w
ah
11w llhvll IIMKLH
lllt!ltlII’1':‘l.~lI’ltl
501.4ka I
'k UllI'lnl1\IIH.I~
uml \ Kvuznx-,
ul I‘JHM \Xumuz
TX.
TX; .\1\‘[‘\‘nl\‘r<‘]‘”“‘l‘r\
Riomxn lorSumman lutl«_-imni.
Imlguwm. l’.i-_~c
l’Ag'c
loan with
[man \\'lI’l1 (\iwon rho
(\\\'u1i rhc loan
1mm \|\(l1l1k‘ haw
\lwuhl [wen mmHy
1ll|\'L‘ l\'k'I1 ixml tail
Inl.ill\‘ mid UH m 3014 hm
Ill 2014 K\’\\«‘1i,
lint Omvn,
kmm‘lcduu
\Virhuur |'1\\‘l(l1l\\’\l\'\lL’L’
\\'ll'l\Ul|I’ rhc .i11tl,'ui'
Jnd/m‘ nmwm
uiiiscltr ml‘
u?- .\ru\'vii~nli
Srmwnmn litltlml
.nMr-J .im»t’ux|iii,irt>l\f
ApprnximJn‘ly 370,000
$70000
tn rlw 1mm
mi r110 lmm Minna lur mmc
l‘.ll‘.ll1L1' fur LInkn«~\\n rmmn
\Ull1U unknown l'L'«l\'U|l m,1» I'mnlt ml rhc
l’t‘\llll (x17 T11! mu lmkmm’n
.1
‘L imLnn\\’n m mu In
lkhlli nwdifimriom which lmtl
Sit-\L‘1i.‘
HIV ll1l\ tl.1I'c
duly \’\lI\'ll
\x'lwn in
in Irivf
llu'r lmsul
l7:l.\k‘\‘ «in
m1 llk‘
tlw Jm‘
tltlrt‘
U‘. the nrigiml
«th rhc ‘O warts
nri<_'1n.1l 730 SfC\\‘ll>Hll lmm
\\':lrl.‘ Srcwnwn llnm \\ir11
\\iIl1L\'\\c1i
Ucwun rho lmiii should
ilic 1mm \l]«VLlltl [MW l\.l\'k' bum in
I‘\'\‘l) in
ttur Tumlly
fact rntflillt tmitl
paid rift
ufih
The facts
T110 A11‘
tkzlcrs arc .itltl1cn1ic.iictl
Aurhcmfiuucd 1w by the .lHl\l.l\'ll' 01'
r110 affidavit (1LIrhumimmm/writimrixm m,
U1‘ atirlwnrit.lrit»n,»’\'vi'i1itxriinil Hmmw
ml Ht-.lri"itt~
St'v\'o1\.~nn
Srcwnsun almlclwdlll'Y21\']t\‘kI livivrts
hcrvm um] ll1(Ul']N!l1lTL\l 1x3
lit-ix-\\irl1 mmrlmmrcd
.lll\l hcruwith |*ctrn mp
lit rch‘n Iwr all
llkL' IM' (Ill purpmb
]‘l|l’11l¥.\k‘\
untl the
and t‘ui'tlici' [Lf‘i‘igLn'ir
tlic {Ul‘thm‘ ml Rmn
.xt‘l>itl,1\'ir lll‘>ltl[1rlllrk'$ .1n\l/Kai"
sulusmmian-s and/ur summrrs . pdymcm
«ml, chums (In-t‘l<.~
[V.l\'lH\'l1r dunks
irmn N2lYl\\l1\\'lLl\‘
{rum Nuriumx'idc trnni ll\.\L|t\‘l‘
from NtlTlUl\\\'l\l\‘
insurer Narimm'idc p1*upci‘l\ unlurnml
prwlwrh k‘ll\lK'l'.\A'kl Iwy Pulwlit AJjusrvr
l\\' Public .-\tl_iu.~im‘
Run Admm
Ron Atlanta and and Claimant 5ru\c1i.~un bur
Llltiiniant Srcwnson lmt ncwr
nu\ui' rcmmcnl
l'L‘l'lll'|1\'tl In Srcwnwn
In .iml/mi‘
$lt‘\t‘ll\Ivl\ Aml/m‘
Atlziins for
Adams for purpnsvs
[‘Lll‘|MI.\‘\‘.\' Hf‘ 17l‘L‘ll1l.\'k‘\'
uf' premises rvpuir us
repair rm rurlmdn
as to rm'ii.uli» \‘tlIll2lUK‘(\)
J‘unuucfi) r0 the $it~\t~1i~li|i
tn Ihc Stu mmm
l1ui1ic.~'tv-ml sm'fbrml
humcstczul Sfo\‘cii.\vv\ \
\ Utxxrii
Ucm‘u 11 mm .\l:\'rtm:-.
wan Suvzumg I
I llK
I l m
tl fl
,ll ;
;
[vi
1w my
\m llm-ll. “d.g‘v",
110M] il\‘4\‘.4V‘. [‘Nm'
l mi
‘l-‘ii '~tmm vl
v! [X \ium~.
whwnmy
l\,il‘.,i\\
IV,
TX, Mnrmn mr Smmmn ’mdgnww: l‘nfm 2
\1\lll«Vl\lI\l<\lll\ll\.ll\lllAl‘Jlll\’lil’:1‘i'Jt
2
damages for
damages pain and
for pain suffering suffered
and suffering as aa result
suffered as result of these unlawful
of these "add ons“
unlawful "add to the
ons“ to the
Stevenson mortgage balance.
Stevenson mortgage balance,
sues for
also sues
Plaintiff also
Plaintiff court determination
a court
for a determination that the actions
that the of Ocwen are
actions of unlawful
are unlawful
Stevenson
between Stevenson
c
hen
andlor
and c
constitute a
and/or constitute
and Ocwen under
henunder the
breach of
a breach
the Texas
and Remedies
contractual loan
the contractual
of the
Texas Declaratory
Declaratory Judgments
Code or CPRC) for
agreement(s) between
loan agreement(s)
Judgments Act
Act (( ch. 37 in
ch. 37
Stevenson requests
which Stevenson
Texas Civil
the Texas
in the
requests in
Civil
a
Practice and
Practice
declaration by
declaration
attorneys fees
attorneys
by
Remedies Code
the
the court
court
under the
fees under
or CPRC)
confirming
confirming
the Act
said
said
for which
Ocwen
as determined
Act as determined to
wrongdoing,
wrongdoing,
be appropriate
to be appropriate by
costs,
costs, c
hen
addition to
in addition
expenses,
expenses,
to a
and/or
andlor
Honorable Court.
this Honorable
by this Court.
also
Plaintiff sue for
also sue
Plaintiff for exemplary damages under
exemplary damages under CPRC Sec.
CPRC Sec. 41.003 as determined
41 .003 as determined just
just
and/or appropriate
andlor by
appropriate by this
this Honorable
Honorable Court.
Court.
Wherefore, premises
Wherefore, premises considered, Movant Stevenson
considered, Movant Stevenson requests
requests relief from Ocwen as
relief from
summary judgment
judgment against
as c
hen
noted and/or
noted
Defendant
appropriate by
appropriate by this
this
c
explained in
andlor explained
Defendant Ocwen plushen
in this Stevenson motion
this Stevenson
such other
plus such
Honorable
Honorable
motion for
and/or further
other andlor
Court.
Court.
for full
full summary
further relief may be
as may
relief as deemed just
be deemed
against
and/or
just andlor
Rosmm'ully
l‘\L‘.<[VL‘tlll|ll\
Srmun
~ 1?
R. l’ir:nvr.
1,1 w mitt
listi.
l(\0‘3’>00O
liar? 16033900
1hr?
l070l Lam
(ilt~i1u;i«_'lt~.\lt1iit~
10701 Ulcnuaqlvs
l‘\u\\
Rn“ lcri,
lat, TX
TX 7§03‘l
7508‘)
4205037
(4(\‘)l 426—3037
(469)
(tax)
(fax) ‘J73-47§—Z7C‘4
072747 $3704
(mnuil) \I'[7l‘l:llL‘1‘(IU\'.ll\L\<
(t'«ni.iil) ~rpirzncrflflmhmmum \.u« illl
‘.ci‘1il'it.In‘
((fcrriifliL nil’
ntc Uf- Svrx
Scn in‘
ice
The undersigned
The iimlL*r.~i§_'nctl «ll'T\\1’l‘lL‘\'l1L‘\'k‘\\'lTl1
zlrrorncy L\‘l'llllk‘>
hm‘uwirh xivrriflm rlmr
Ihm 21 mm
11ml turrcti
.1ii‘litumtl mrrcu tum
mm «ll
«x17 Hm
llllx dnmmcm
tluciiint-111
Tvxas
was SL‘l’\'k‘kl
served
\x'.1.~‘
rLilt~.~'.
rules.
(
< 1.1ll
1 (1U L‘
r llifi‘
lns‘ «if r 'k'0l'(l
mfrcmrd rliis
this
“m
_ tl.iy wff‘xuuusr,
day 30 3,
mt’ Aliutisr, 30 lll1\lL'l’l'l1L‘
5‘ umh‘r rhc l
l Toxm C'lllk'
c—f’ilc
Arruriwcxj
Armrncy K :L‘l”\’ll\'ll\L'
(,Icrritymg
.\u1‘\3|{~—lIi~-HZ,Sitxtiisuiix
f\«\ I‘Kllfllih-MS. \‘Irwnwn Umm
\\‘\\t'l1l\i.\‘i‘
CYNTHIA MARIE
CYNTHIA
My
PEREZ
MARIE PEREZ
l0 33130872279
Notary 10 130872279
~~~
My Notaty $1
Expires October
Ewues October 21,
21, 2020
2020
Affidavit of
Affidavi‘ of Run
116th Judicial
116th
Adams: Stevenson
Ron Adams;
District
Judicial District
Stevenson v.
Court
Court of
of
c
V. Ocwen Loan
hcn
Dallas
Dallas
Loan Servicing,
County,
County,TX
TX
LLC, el.
Servicing, LLC, et. al.:
3].: Cause No.
Cause DC-16-16442; ln
No. DC-lfi—lé-Ml;
Page 22
Page
In the
the
oft
offi