Preview
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 1 of 1 Trans ID: LCV20231393846
LAW OFFICES OF
SAMUEL L. DAVIS●⌂†
DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C.
800 INMAN AVENUE
MARC C. SAPERSTEIN●○☼† 375 CEDAR LANE COLONIA, NJ 07067
GARRY R. SALOMON●†
STEVEN BENVENISTI●■† TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 (732) 510-1000
───
PAUL A. GARFIELD●■† FACSIMILE: (201) 692-0444 23 ROUTE 31 NORTH, SUITE B10
ADAM LEDERMAN●○† PENNINGTON, NJ 08534
STEVEN H. COHEN●○ Email: lawinfo@dsslaw.com (609) 945-3112
───
PATRICIA Z. BOGUSLAWSKI●† (201) 907-5000 39 BROADWAY, SUITE 520
EVAN D. BAKER●○♦†
KELLY A. CONLON●† NEW YORK, NY 10006
───
(212) 608-1917
───
LUIS L. HAQUIA●○† CERTIFIED CIVIL TRIAL ATTY †
RACHAEL NASS●○ April 28, 2023 PENNSYLVANIA BAR ■
NEW JERSEY BAR ●
ANGELA CERVELLI BENNETT● NEW YORK BAR ○
DAVID A. DRESCHER●○▲ LOUISIANA BAR □
MANUEL B. SAMEIRO● FLORIDA BAR ▲
JEFFREY E. SALOMON●○ GEORGIA BAR ☼
ILLINOIS BAR ♦
ARIELLE HEO●○ D.C. BAR ⌂
DANIEL BUCHHEISTER● ───
SHERWIN TSAI●⌂†
GRACE ROBOL●† REPLY TO TEANECK
MICHAEL WACHTEL●○
JEREMIAH W.M. LARKIN, JR.●
JOHN M. PIRO ●○
ROBERT H. BAUMGARTEN ●○†
VIA● ELECTRONIC
SUSAN R. SCHRANK FILING
KATE N. CELESTINO ●
Honorable Mara Zazzali-Hogan, J.S.C.
Monmouth County Superior Court
71 Monument Park
Po Box 1266
Freehold, NJ 07728
Re: Case, Marc -v- Wang, Lijun
File No.: 33855
Docket No.: MON-L-1518-22
Dear Your Honor:
Please be advised that this office represents the plaintiff with respect to the above captioned
matter.
There is currently pending before Your Honor a Notice of Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff’s
Complaint.
Plaintiff has provided all outstanding discovery to defendant, see attached documentation as
Exhibit A with respect to same. Defense counsel has advised they would withdraw their Motion but
have yet to do so.
Therefore, it is respectfully requested that this Motion be denied.
Respectfully,
DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON P.C.
s/Evan Baker
EB/gmr/enclosure _______________________________
EVAN BAKER
Cc: Patricia Adams, Esq. For the Firm
NEW JERSEY ● NEW YORK
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 1 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846
LAW OFFICES OF
SAMUEL L. DAVIS●⌂†
DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C.
800 INMAN AVENUE
MARC C. SAPERSTEIN●○☼† 375 CEDAR LANE COLONIA, NJ 07067
GARRY R. SALOMON●†
STEVEN BENVENISTI●■† TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 (732) 510-1000
───
PAUL A. GARFIELD●■† FACSIMILE: (201) 692-0444 23 ROUTE 31 NORTH, SUITE B10
ADAM LEDERMAN●○† PENNINGTON, NJ 08534
STEVEN H. COHEN●○ Email: lawinfo@dsslaw.com (609) 945-3112
───
PATRICIA Z. BOGUSLAWSKI●† (201) 907-5000 39 BROADWAY, SUITE 520
EVAN D. BAKER●○♦†
KELLY A. CONLON●† NEW YORK, NY 10006
───
(212) 608-1917
───
LUIS L. HAQUIA●○† CERTIFIED CIVIL TRIAL ATTY †
RACHAEL NASS●○ PENNSYLVANIA BAR ■
ANGELA CERVELLI BENNETT● NEW JERSEY BAR ●
NEW YORK BAR ○
DAVID A. DRESCHER●○▲ LOUISIANA BAR □
MANUEL B. SAMEIRO● FLORIDA BAR ▲
JEFFREY E. SALOMON●○
April 27, 2023 GEORGIA BAR ☼
ILLINOIS BAR ♦
ARIELLE HEO●○ D.C. BAR ⌂
DANIEL BUCHHEISTER● ───
SHERWIN TSAI●⌂†
GRACE ROBOL●† REPLY TO TEANECK
MICHAEL WACHTEL●○
JEREMIAH W.M. LARKIN, JR.●
JOHN M. PIRO ●○
ROBERT H. BAUMGARTEN ●○†
SUSAN R. SCHRANK ●
KATE N. CELESTINO ●
Patricia B. Adams, Esq.
Campbell, Foley, Delano & Adams, LLC.
1599 Highway 34, Building E
P.O. Box 1570
Wall, NJ 07719
Re: Case, Marc -v- Wang, Lijun
File No.: 33855
Docket No.: MON-L-1518-22
Dear Counselor:
In response to your request for MSA to interrogatories, please be advised as follows:
6. Plaintiff is not in possession of the Dr. Cohen’s xrays. Plaintiff has requested same and will
provide same upon receipt of same. With regards to any and all providers, including Dr. Ratzker, plaintiff
is hereby providing all radiology films and reports in his possession.
7. With regard to treatment in Florida, please be advised that plaintiff treated with Dr. Franz
Jones. See attached records. Plaintiff has no other records with regards to this request including medical
treatment in New York.
13 and 14. See attached medical bills. Plaintiff’s medical expenses are documented below with
status of the bills. The vast majority of the bills are pending in PIP arbitration and have been consolidated
with a hearing date in October 11, 2023.
NEW JERSEY ● NEW YORK
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 2 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846
18. Attached hereto are two photos, one of Mr. Case’s surgical hardware, a photo of his
scars and the photographs were taken around May 14, 2021.
Kindly withdraw your Motion currently pending on Friday, April 28, 2023. Thank you.
Very truly yours,
DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON P.C.
s/Evan Baker
_______________________________
EVAN BAKER
For the Firm
EB/gmr
Encl.
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 3 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846
LAW OFFICES OF
SAMUEL L. DAVIS●⌂†
DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C.
800 INMAN AVENUE
MARC C. SAPERSTEIN●○☼† 375 CEDAR LANE COLONIA, NJ 07067
GARRY R. SALOMON●†
STEVEN BENVENISTI●■† TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 (732) 510-1000
───
PAUL A. GARFIELD●■† FACSIMILE: (201) 692-0444 23 ROUTE 31 NORTH, SUITE B10
ADAM LEDERMAN●○† PENNINGTON, NJ 08534
STEVEN H. COHEN●○ Email: lawinfo@dsslaw.com (609) 945-3112
───
PATRICIA Z. BOGUSLAWSKI●† (201) 907-5000 39 BROADWAY, SUITE 520
EVAN D. BAKER●○♦†
KELLY A. CONLON●† NEW YORK, NY 10006
(212) 608-1917
───
LUIS L. HAQUIA●○†
April 27, 2023 ───
CERTIFIED CIVIL TRIAL ATTY †
RACHAEL NASS●○ PENNSYLVANIA BAR ■
ANGELA CERVELLI BENNETT● NEW JERSEY BAR ●
NEW YORK BAR ○
DAVID A. DRESCHER●○▲ LOUISIANA BAR □
MANUEL B. SAMEIRO● FLORIDA BAR ▲
JEFFREY E. SALOMON●○ GEORGIA BAR ☼
ILLINOIS BAR ♦
ARIELLE HEO●○ D.C. BAR ⌂
DANIEL BUCHHEISTER● ───
SHERWIN TSAI●⌂†
GRACE ROBOL●† REPLY TO TEANECK
MICHAEL WACHTEL●○
JEREMIAH W.M. LARKIN, JR.●
JOHN M. PIRO ●○
ROBERT H. BAUMGARTEN ●○†
SUSAN R. SCHRANK ●
KATE N. CELESTINO ●
VIA EMAIL
Patricia B. Adams, Esq.
Campbell, Foley, Delano & Adams, LLC.1599 Highway 34, Building E
P.O. Box 1570
Wall, NJ 07719
Re: Case, Marc -v- Wang, Lijun
File No.: 33855
Docket No.: MON-L-1518-22
Dear Counselor:
In response to your Notice for Production of Documents, please be guided as follows:
1. See attached letter from CMS dated April 6, 2023.
Thank you for your attention in this regard.
Very truly yours,
DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C.
s/Evan Baker
____________________________________
EVAN BAKER
For the Firm
EB/gmr
NEW JERSEY ● NEW YORK
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 4 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846
CM~i
CENTERS FOR MEDICARE 8 MEDIGID SERVI~S
COBR Coordination of
Benefits and Recovery
Apri106, 2023
84 1 MB 0.531
~COPY~
For Information Only
***AUTOMIXED AADC 720 R:84 T:2 P:2 PC:1 F:2278601
DAMS SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON PC
375 CEDAR LN
TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433
o~ Apri106, 2023
0
O
O
O
O
O
O
O 84 1 MB 0.531
O
~o
J ***AUTOMIXED AADC 720 R:84 T:2 P2 PC:1 F:2278601
O
m MARC CASE
cn
MANALAPAN, NJ 07726-9568
O
Beneficiary Name: MARC CASE
Medicare ID: *****7373A
Date of Incident: January 02, 2020
Case Identification Number 202127909001625
Document Control Number: 33033023-0000392
MSP Type: Liability
Subject: Case Resolved
Dear MARC CASE:
This letter is to inform you that the case referenced above has been reviewed and the Benefits
Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC) determined that the case has been closed or deleted.
Therefore, the BCRC now considers this matter resolved.
If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact the BCRC by phone at
ML067NGHP
NGHP P.O. Bog 138832 Oklahoma City, OK 73113
Page 1 of 2
❑~ ~❑~
r~ r
~~
i r ~1~
T
~~
f
7
■ ~~_ 1 _
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 5 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846
CMS
CENTERS f0R MEDIGRE 8 ME~IGID SEAVI~
cosR Coordination of
Benefits and Recovery
7
W
Rai
w
O
1-855-798-2627 (TTY/TDD: 1-855-797-2627 for hearing/speech impaired).
Sincerely,
BCRC Case Analyst
CC: DAMS SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON PC
ML067NGHP
NGHP P.O. Bog 138832 Oklahoma Cite, Oti 73113
Page 2 of 2
Preview
MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 1 of 1 Trans ID: LCV20231393846 LAW OFFICES OF SAMUEL L. DAVIS●⌂† DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C. 800 INMAN AVENUE MARC C. SAPERSTEIN●○☼† 375 CEDAR LANE COLONIA, NJ 07067 GARRY R. SALOMON●† STEVEN BENVENISTI●■† TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 (732) 510-1000 ─── PAUL A. GARFIELD●■† FACSIMILE: (201) 692-0444 23 ROUTE 31 NORTH, SUITE B10 ADAM LEDERMAN●○† PENNINGTON, NJ 08534 STEVEN H. COHEN●○ Email: lawinfo@dsslaw.com (609) 945-3112 ─── PATRICIA Z. BOGUSLAWSKI●† (201) 907-5000 39 BROADWAY, SUITE 520 EVAN D. BAKER●○♦† KELLY A. CONLON●† NEW YORK, NY 10006 ─── (212) 608-1917 ─── LUIS L. HAQUIA●○† CERTIFIED CIVIL TRIAL ATTY † RACHAEL NASS●○ April 28, 2023 PENNSYLVANIA BAR ■ NEW JERSEY BAR ● ANGELA CERVELLI BENNETT● NEW YORK BAR ○ DAVID A. DRESCHER●○▲ LOUISIANA BAR □ MANUEL B. SAMEIRO● FLORIDA BAR ▲ JEFFREY E. SALOMON●○ GEORGIA BAR ☼ ILLINOIS BAR ♦ ARIELLE HEO●○ D.C. BAR ⌂ DANIEL BUCHHEISTER● ─── SHERWIN TSAI●⌂† GRACE ROBOL●† REPLY TO TEANECK MICHAEL WACHTEL●○ JEREMIAH W.M. LARKIN, JR.● JOHN M. PIRO ●○ ROBERT H. BAUMGARTEN ●○† VIA● ELECTRONIC SUSAN R. SCHRANK FILING KATE N. CELESTINO ● Honorable Mara Zazzali-Hogan, J.S.C. Monmouth County Superior Court 71 Monument Park Po Box 1266 Freehold, NJ 07728 Re: Case, Marc -v- Wang, Lijun File No.: 33855 Docket No.: MON-L-1518-22 Dear Your Honor: Please be advised that this office represents the plaintiff with respect to the above captioned matter. There is currently pending before Your Honor a Notice of Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Complaint. Plaintiff has provided all outstanding discovery to defendant, see attached documentation as Exhibit A with respect to same. Defense counsel has advised they would withdraw their Motion but have yet to do so. Therefore, it is respectfully requested that this Motion be denied. Respectfully, DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON P.C. s/Evan Baker EB/gmr/enclosure _______________________________ EVAN BAKER Cc: Patricia Adams, Esq. For the Firm NEW JERSEY ● NEW YORK MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 1 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846 LAW OFFICES OF SAMUEL L. DAVIS●⌂† DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C. 800 INMAN AVENUE MARC C. SAPERSTEIN●○☼† 375 CEDAR LANE COLONIA, NJ 07067 GARRY R. SALOMON●† STEVEN BENVENISTI●■† TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 (732) 510-1000 ─── PAUL A. GARFIELD●■† FACSIMILE: (201) 692-0444 23 ROUTE 31 NORTH, SUITE B10 ADAM LEDERMAN●○† PENNINGTON, NJ 08534 STEVEN H. COHEN●○ Email: lawinfo@dsslaw.com (609) 945-3112 ─── PATRICIA Z. BOGUSLAWSKI●† (201) 907-5000 39 BROADWAY, SUITE 520 EVAN D. BAKER●○♦† KELLY A. CONLON●† NEW YORK, NY 10006 ─── (212) 608-1917 ─── LUIS L. HAQUIA●○† CERTIFIED CIVIL TRIAL ATTY † RACHAEL NASS●○ PENNSYLVANIA BAR ■ ANGELA CERVELLI BENNETT● NEW JERSEY BAR ● NEW YORK BAR ○ DAVID A. DRESCHER●○▲ LOUISIANA BAR □ MANUEL B. SAMEIRO● FLORIDA BAR ▲ JEFFREY E. SALOMON●○ April 27, 2023 GEORGIA BAR ☼ ILLINOIS BAR ♦ ARIELLE HEO●○ D.C. BAR ⌂ DANIEL BUCHHEISTER● ─── SHERWIN TSAI●⌂† GRACE ROBOL●† REPLY TO TEANECK MICHAEL WACHTEL●○ JEREMIAH W.M. LARKIN, JR.● JOHN M. PIRO ●○ ROBERT H. BAUMGARTEN ●○† SUSAN R. SCHRANK ● KATE N. CELESTINO ● Patricia B. Adams, Esq. Campbell, Foley, Delano & Adams, LLC. 1599 Highway 34, Building E P.O. Box 1570 Wall, NJ 07719 Re: Case, Marc -v- Wang, Lijun File No.: 33855 Docket No.: MON-L-1518-22 Dear Counselor: In response to your request for MSA to interrogatories, please be advised as follows: 6. Plaintiff is not in possession of the Dr. Cohen’s xrays. Plaintiff has requested same and will provide same upon receipt of same. With regards to any and all providers, including Dr. Ratzker, plaintiff is hereby providing all radiology films and reports in his possession. 7. With regard to treatment in Florida, please be advised that plaintiff treated with Dr. Franz Jones. See attached records. Plaintiff has no other records with regards to this request including medical treatment in New York. 13 and 14. See attached medical bills. Plaintiff’s medical expenses are documented below with status of the bills. The vast majority of the bills are pending in PIP arbitration and have been consolidated with a hearing date in October 11, 2023. NEW JERSEY ● NEW YORK MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 2 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846 18. Attached hereto are two photos, one of Mr. Case’s surgical hardware, a photo of his scars and the photographs were taken around May 14, 2021. Kindly withdraw your Motion currently pending on Friday, April 28, 2023. Thank you. Very truly yours, DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON P.C. s/Evan Baker _______________________________ EVAN BAKER For the Firm EB/gmr Encl. MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 3 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846 LAW OFFICES OF SAMUEL L. DAVIS●⌂† DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C. 800 INMAN AVENUE MARC C. SAPERSTEIN●○☼† 375 CEDAR LANE COLONIA, NJ 07067 GARRY R. SALOMON●† STEVEN BENVENISTI●■† TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 (732) 510-1000 ─── PAUL A. GARFIELD●■† FACSIMILE: (201) 692-0444 23 ROUTE 31 NORTH, SUITE B10 ADAM LEDERMAN●○† PENNINGTON, NJ 08534 STEVEN H. COHEN●○ Email: lawinfo@dsslaw.com (609) 945-3112 ─── PATRICIA Z. BOGUSLAWSKI●† (201) 907-5000 39 BROADWAY, SUITE 520 EVAN D. BAKER●○♦† KELLY A. CONLON●† NEW YORK, NY 10006 (212) 608-1917 ─── LUIS L. HAQUIA●○† April 27, 2023 ─── CERTIFIED CIVIL TRIAL ATTY † RACHAEL NASS●○ PENNSYLVANIA BAR ■ ANGELA CERVELLI BENNETT● NEW JERSEY BAR ● NEW YORK BAR ○ DAVID A. DRESCHER●○▲ LOUISIANA BAR □ MANUEL B. SAMEIRO● FLORIDA BAR ▲ JEFFREY E. SALOMON●○ GEORGIA BAR ☼ ILLINOIS BAR ♦ ARIELLE HEO●○ D.C. BAR ⌂ DANIEL BUCHHEISTER● ─── SHERWIN TSAI●⌂† GRACE ROBOL●† REPLY TO TEANECK MICHAEL WACHTEL●○ JEREMIAH W.M. LARKIN, JR.● JOHN M. PIRO ●○ ROBERT H. BAUMGARTEN ●○† SUSAN R. SCHRANK ● KATE N. CELESTINO ● VIA EMAIL Patricia B. Adams, Esq. Campbell, Foley, Delano & Adams, LLC.1599 Highway 34, Building E P.O. Box 1570 Wall, NJ 07719 Re: Case, Marc -v- Wang, Lijun File No.: 33855 Docket No.: MON-L-1518-22 Dear Counselor: In response to your Notice for Production of Documents, please be guided as follows: 1. See attached letter from CMS dated April 6, 2023. Thank you for your attention in this regard. Very truly yours, DAVIS, SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON, P.C. s/Evan Baker ____________________________________ EVAN BAKER For the Firm EB/gmr NEW JERSEY ● NEW YORK MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 4 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846 CM~i CENTERS FOR MEDICARE 8 MEDIGID SERVI~S COBR Coordination of Benefits and Recovery Apri106, 2023 84 1 MB 0.531 ~COPY~ For Information Only ***AUTOMIXED AADC 720 R:84 T:2 P:2 PC:1 F:2278601 DAMS SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON PC 375 CEDAR LN TEANECK, NJ 07666-3433 o~ Apri106, 2023 0 O O O O O O O 84 1 MB 0.531 O ~o J ***AUTOMIXED AADC 720 R:84 T:2 P2 PC:1 F:2278601 O m MARC CASE cn MANALAPAN, NJ 07726-9568 O Beneficiary Name: MARC CASE Medicare ID: *****7373A Date of Incident: January 02, 2020 Case Identification Number 202127909001625 Document Control Number: 33033023-0000392 MSP Type: Liability Subject: Case Resolved Dear MARC CASE: This letter is to inform you that the case referenced above has been reviewed and the Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC) determined that the case has been closed or deleted. Therefore, the BCRC now considers this matter resolved. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact the BCRC by phone at ML067NGHP NGHP P.O. Bog 138832 Oklahoma City, OK 73113 Page 1 of 2 ❑~ ~❑~ r~ r ~~ i r ~1~ T ~~ f 7 ■ ~~_ 1 _ MON-L-001518-22 04/28/2023 9:24:33 AM Pg 5 of 5 Trans ID: LCV20231393846 CMS CENTERS f0R MEDIGRE 8 ME~IGID SEAVI~ cosR Coordination of Benefits and Recovery 7 W Rai w O 1-855-798-2627 (TTY/TDD: 1-855-797-2627 for hearing/speech impaired). Sincerely, BCRC Case Analyst CC: DAMS SAPERSTEIN & SALOMON PC ML067NGHP NGHP P.O. Bog 138832 Oklahoma Cite, Oti 73113 Page 2 of 2