Motion-Secondary: SAUL LOPEZ ET AL VS SHANT ARIS NAZARYAN ET AL

• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                Electronically FILED b} buperior Court of California, County of Los Angeles on 11/15/2019 04:47 PM Sherri R. Carter, Executive Officer/Clerk of Court, by L. Coreas,Deputy Clerk



                        SIAMAK VAZIRI, ESQ. [SBN 242447]
                        MATTHEW M. TAYLOR, ESQ. [SBN 252556]
                        AARON G. MILLER, ESQ. [SBN 279126]
                        VAZIRI LAW GROUP, APC
                        5757 Wilshire Blvd., Ste. 670
                        Los Angeles, CA 90036
                        Telephone:             (310) 777-7540
                        Facsimile:             (310) 777-0373
                        Attorneys for Plaintiffs, SAUL LOPEZ and ADELA                                    LOPEZ,

                                                   SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
                                                                FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

                10
                        SAUL LOPEZ and ADELA LOPEZ,                                               Case No.: BC678211
                11
                                               Plaintiffs,                                       PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO
                12
                                                                                                 DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE
                                   vs.                                                           NO. FIVE TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE THAT]
                Lo
                                                                                                 DEFENDANTS FAILED TO PRESERVE
                14     SHANT ARIS NAZARYAN; RAZMIK                                               EVIDENCE; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS
                       NAZARYAN. and DOES | to 25 Inclusive,                                     AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF
               15
                                                                                                 MATTHEW TAYLOR
               16
                                               Defendants.
                                                                                                 Filed: October 2, 2017
               17                                                                                Trial: November 19, 2019
               18

               19

               20
                       TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR COUNSEL                                            OF RECORD:
               21.
                                  PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Plaintiffs SAUL LOPEZ and ADELA LOPEZ (hereinafter
               22
                       “PLAINTIFFS”) hereby submit the following Opposition to DEFENDANTS’                                                      Motion in Limine
               23
                      No. Five to exclude evidence that Defendants failed to preserve, destroyed, and/or spoiled
               24
                      evidence.
               25
                                  Defendants argument is that Plaintiff should be precluded from offering any testimony or
              26
                      evidence that their insurance carrier, Progressive, spoiled, destroyed and/or did not preserve
              27
                      evidence (i.e., the Event Data Recorder (“EDR”, or “black box”) that came standard in
              28




                               OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’                                 ae              IN LIMINE NO. 5 RE SPOLIATION