Preview
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant
Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez
5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
Telephone #(610) 276-4728
Our File #193862653-002
_____________________________________
Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas
: Delaware County
v. :
:
Juana F. Fernandez :
_________ :
Jannine Templeman : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131
:
v.
Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington
ORDER
AND NOW, this ______ day of _________________, 20____, it is hereby ORDERED
and DECREED that Defendant's Motion is GRANTED and State Farm Mutual Automobile
Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company is to respond to Defendant's
Subpoena within twenty (20) days of the date of this Order or risk sanctions as may be
appropriate
BY THE COURT:
______________________________
J.
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant
Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez
5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
Telephone #(610) 276-4728
Our File #193862653-002
_____________________________________
Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas
: Delaware County
v. :
:
Juana F. Fernandez :
_________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131
Jannine Templeman :
v.
Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington
DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL PLAINTIFF, ARSENA R. WASHINGTON’S,
RECORDS FROM STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
A/K/A STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY
1. This is an action for personal injury arising out of an automobile accident.
2. On October 4, 2022 Defendant's counsel requested, by Subpoena, documents and
things relating to Plaintiff, Arsena R. Washington, from State Farm Mutual Automobile
Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company. See Correspondence
Attached as Exhibit “A”.
3. To date, State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire
and Casualty Company has not responded to Defendant's Subpoena, nor have they sought a
Protective Order.
4. Copies of these documents are required in order to obtain important information
and permit Defendant to prepare for trial in this matter. Furthermore, Defendant will be
prejudiced if full and complete responses to this Subpoena are not forwarded.
5. The failure of State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State
Farm Fire and Casualty Company to respond to Defendant's Subpoena is in violation of the
applicable Rules of Civil Procedure.
WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court enter an Order against
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty
Company in the form attached hereto.
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: ________________________________
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant
Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez
5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
Telephone #(610) 276-4728
Our File #193862653-002
_____________________________________
Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas
: Delaware County
v. :
:
Juana F. Fernandez :
_________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131
Jannine Templeman :
v.
Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington
DEFENDANT'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL
PLAINTIFF’S RECORDS
1. Matter before the Court: Before the Court is Defendant's Motion to Compel
Discovery in the form of a Motion to Compel Records from State Farm Mutual Automobile
Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company.
2. Statement of Question Involved: Is Defendant entitled to an Order compelling
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty
Company to respond to Defendant's Subpoena for Production of Documents pertaining to Plaintiff,
Arsena R. Washington, served more than thirty (30) days ago by the time this motion is heard and is
now overdue?
Suggested answer: Yes.
3. Facts: On October 4, 2022, Defendant's counsel forwarded to State Farm Mutual
Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company a Subpoena for
Production of Documents for records on Plaintiff, Arsena R. Washington. More than thirty (30) days
will have elapsed by the time this motion is heard and they have failed to respond to the Subpoena. On
October 27, 2022, Defendant's counsel sent a request to them to forward records on Plaintiff, Arsena R.
Washington, within five (5) days.
4. Argument: Pa. R. C. P. 4009.21, titled, Written Interrogatories to a Party permits a
party seeking production from a person not a party to the action to request production of documents
after providing a twenty day notice to all parties of the intent to serve such subpoena.
On October 4, 2022 , Defendant filed a Notice of Intent to Serve Subpoena upon State Farm
Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, which was
served on all parties via first class mail. On October 4, 2022, the Subpoena was served on State Farm
Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company.
Thirty days will now elapsed by the time this motion is heard since Defendant served such
Subpoena and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty
Company has failed to respond or otherwise object to the Subpoena.
6. Relief: Wherefore, Defendant respectfully requests this Court grant the Motion
and issue an Order compelling State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State
Farm Fire and Casualty Company to respond to Defendant's subpoena within twenty (20) days.
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: ________________________________
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant
Attorney ID # 312643 Juana F. Fernandez
5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
Telephone #(610) 276-4728
Our File #193862653-002
_____________________________________
Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas
: Delaware County
v. :
:
Juana F. Fernandez :
_________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131
Jannine Templeman :
v.
Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Fredric A. Bibbo, attorney for Defendant, hereby certify that I caused a true and correct
copy of Defendant's Motion to Compel Records to be served on this date to the following:
Via First Class Mail:
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company
c/o CSC
2595 Interstate Dr., Ste. 103
Harrisburg, PA 17110
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company
One State Farm Plaza
Bloomington, IL 61710
Via Electronic Filing:
Mark Brownstein, Esquire
Brownstein, Pearlman, Weizer, Newman
3 North 2nd Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106
(215) 627-0100/(215) 627-1749 (F)
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: ________________________________
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
Date: November 1, 2022
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant,
Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez
5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
Telephone #(610) 276-4728
Our File #193862653-002
_____________________________________
Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas
: Delaware County
v. :
:
Juana F. Fernandez :
_________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131
Jannine Templeman :
v.
Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE
I, Fredric A. Bibbo, attorney for Defendant, Juana F. Fernandez, hereby certify that this
filing complies with the provisions of the Public Access Policy of the Unified Judicial System of
Pennsylvania: Case Records of the Appellate and Trial Courts that require filing confidential
information and documents differently than non-confidential information and documents.
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert
By: ________________________________
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
VERIFICATION
I, Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire, aver that I am the attorney for the Defendant in this case,
and I aver that the averments contained in the foregoing pleadings are true and correct to the best
of my knowledge, information and belief; and that the statements therein are made subject to the
penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
________________________________
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF DELAWARE,
FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL TRIAL DIVISION
Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas
: Delaware County
v. :
:
Juana F. Fernandez :
_________ :
Jannine Templeman : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131
:
v.
Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington
ATTORNEY CERTIFICATION OF GOOD FAITH
The undersigned for movant hereby certifies and attests that:
X a) Defense counsel has had the contacts described below with State Farm
Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company regarding
the discovery matter contained in the foregoing discovery motion in an effort to resolve the
specific discovery dispute(s) at issue and, further, that despite all counsel’s good faith attempts to
resolve the dispute(s), counsel has been unable to do so.
Description: On October 25, 2022, counsel for Defendant sent a message via electronic
mail to State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty
Company requesting the status of the records. On October 27, 2022, counsel for Defendant sent a
letter to State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty
Company requesting the records be produced within five days or a motion would be filed. State
Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company has
not responded to the Subpoena.
___ b) Defense counsel has made a good faith but unsuccessful efforts described
below to contact opposing counsel in an effort to resolve the discovery dispute.
Description:
By: ________________________________
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
“Note: The signature of respondent’s counsel is not required”
EXHIBIT “A”
HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT
Not a ”Min No! a Comomuon
WED EMPLOYERS 0' PROGRESS“ I!
CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY
ms CAMPUS DRIVE. SUITE 200
PLYMOUTH MEETING PA 19462
Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquim Adm Assistanl Tush- DeMedio
Facsimile #866) 842 1482 Direct“ 610276-4993
me n dcmedio@pmgrcssivc com
October 4 2022
VII Certified Mail-RRR ”1'45‘1 DMD E11127 532‘! 113115 ll:
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company Stale Farm Fm: and Casually Company
c/o CSC Attentwn Subpoena Unit
2595 Interstatc Dr St: 103 One State Farm Plaza
Harrisburg PA 17110 Bloomington IL 61710
RE Washington v Panama; Tcmplcman v Permndez and Wasan
Delaware County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320/CV 2021
007131
File No 193862653002
Your Policy No “16646738
Dan Sir/Madam
Enclosed is a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for Dimoch directing you to pmduoc
the records idcnfified 111mm penaining lo Argent R Washington, You Policy ‘10 “16646738
Please proctuoc all of the rcquwtcd records to me by October 25, 2022
If possible please provide the records electronically via fax to Tasha DeMedio at fax #(866)
842 1482 or via email to sustain a demetllo®progresdve com If you require a twomble fee to
cover the cost of producing the requested documents, please fg an invoice to Tag QcMgglio at $8661
842 14 t and a check will be sent to you
If you have my questions rcyudnng this request, please call Tasha DcMcdio at tclcphonc #610
276-4993 Thank you for your time and attention to this matter
Very truly yams
Tasha DeMedio Admmmr' ' alive Assistanl to
Fredric A Bibbo Esquire
mama ‘
Enclosure
0c (via efiling) Mark Brownsmin1 Esquixe and Michael E Cook, Esquire
Sud correspondence to
5165 Campus Dr Suite 20.
Plymouth Meeting Pa 19462
COMMONWEAL'H'I OF PENNSYLVANIA
mm .L W...” comm! or DELAWARE
Ln- I‘ Fund"
had“ Temptin-
u CV 2021W(\ um
Jun F Fcnudnud M1.- ll. Vuflfll‘fl Cw“ No llfllll
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009 22
to State Farm Fire and Chunky Company (Name of Person or Entity]
wnhin twentv(20) days after service of this subpoena you are ordered to produce
the lollowing W u“ in. holiday but «a flaw mm: m dcdc- toms and dedrltim me tar
munm-m tar pulley holller mu mm. PERTMNING 1‘0 ARSLNA n. WASHINGTON
00! W2 um
a 5165 Campus Dave Suite 200 Plymomh Mecflng’A |M62 ‘Address)
If you fail to produce the documents or things required by this NOVICE T0 PRODUCE you
may be subject to the sanctions authorized by Rule 234 5 of the PA Rules of Crvil Procedure
This subpoena was issued at the request of the following person
Mane W Important Note
ALI. QU ESTIONS
Address» 5165 Cams 0"“ 9"" 7”" REGARDING THIS
Plymouth Mums. PA 19m 5"”05'“ MU“ 35
ADDRESSED TO THE
PERSON NAMED AT THE
LEFT WHO REQUESTED THAT
ITBE ISSUED NOT TOTHE
OFFICE OF JUDIQ; §Qgflfl
TE'eP’Wne M
Supreme Court m 31m;
Attorney for Defendant BY TH URT M
DATE E I % I lg;
SEA]. OF E CO T DIRECTOR ALK ESQUIRE
OFFICE OF J I SUPPORT
HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT
Not a hmmmMpt Not 1 Convention
mi!) EWMI'RDGM‘IIVE
CASUAL" INSUIASCECDMPANY
516$ CAMPUS DRIVE. SUITE 200
PLYMOUTH MEEHNG PA 19462
Fredric A Bibbo. Enquire
Admin Amman Tasha Medic
Facsimile £866) 842 1482
Directil 610-276-4993
min :1 dunedio@pmgzmive com
October 4 2022
Vin Certified mm 006‘] 0010 0027 1:329 16205 33
Stat: Farm Mutual Automobile Immnoc Stat: Pam: Mutual Automobile Insurance
Company
010 CSC
Company
Attention Subpoena Unit
2595 Interstate Dr Ste 103 One State Farm Plaza
Hanisburg. PA 17110 Bloomington. IL 61710
RE Washington v Pcmandcz Templcman v Fernandez and Washington
Delawm County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320
/CV 2021
007131
File No 193862653 002
Your Policy No “16646738
Dear Sir/Madam
Enclosed is a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for Discove
ry directing you to produce
the records Identified therein pertaining to Arum: R. Washington,
Your Policy No “16646738
Please produce all of tho requested records to me by October 25, 2022
If possible, please provide the records electronically via fax to Tasha
DcModio at In: “866)
842-1482 or via email to summit! n dmcmpmgl‘aave com
Ifyou require a reasonable fee to
cover the cost of producing the requested documents, please
fax an mxms‘glo—Tasmmnm
842 1532 including your Ty [mgfigngn unruly: and a check
will be sent to you
If you have any quesnons regarding this request, please call Tasha
DcModio at telephone #610
276-4993 Thank you for your time and attenuon to £1115 mutter
Very truly yours
Ammo.
Tuba DcMedio, Administtativc Assistant to
Fredric A Bibbo Esquire
FAmad
Enclosure
cc (vm cfiling) Marl: Brownstcin. Esquitc and Michael P Cook, Esquine
Send correspondence to
5165 Campus Dr.1 Sum 200
Plymouth Meeting Pl 19462
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
A a. mama» COUNTV OF DELAWARE
Lun- I Fernanda
land.- Tum”:
, cv Mlmmcv ml
Juan I Fernanda Ind AM. It -un CW". NO ”3‘ II
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUM EN'I'S OR THNGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009 12
To Sum Furl! Metal Amount)»: Insulate Cmummy“e of Person or Entity)
Within twenty (20) days aha: serwcc at this subpoena, you are ordeted to produce
the following W“
”W
pair} IAIWG‘HS: for punk; holder runny mourn. mt I'AIMNG I0 usuu n. wasmwmrs
m
nonwzmm
3t SIIS Cillflll nun. SI“! 2”. I‘lynoutll Meiinl.‘ PA I946? (Addrcu)
Ifyou fall to produce the documents or flung; required by this NOIICE 10 PRODUCE you
may be saline! to the sanctions authorized by Rule 234 5 of the PA Rules of Civil Procedure
This Subpoena was issued at the req nest of the following person
Name ' U!" Important Note
m ALL QUESTIONS
Address ““0”“ ”m" 9"" REGARDING THIS
Pinion“: Mating. PA mo: SUBPOENA MUST BE
ADDRESSED TO THE
PERSON NAMED AT THE
LEFT WHO REQUESTED THAT
IT BE ISSUED NOT T9 THE
OFFICE OF QQIQAL SUPPORT
Telephone (61") 216-47’9
Supreme Court sow 3m“
Attorney for “mm" BY Try a URT
DATE 4
I
A
SEAL or E coo DIRECTOR W I ALK saunas
omc: OF 1 I I SUPPORT
Anastasia N Demedio
_
From Anastasia N Demedio
Sent Tuesday October 25 2022 10 36 AM
To statefarmclaims@statefarm com
Subject Your Policy #416646738 Washington v Fernandez (LEAD CASE) 193862653 002
Attachments State Farm pdf
Good morning,
Please advise the status of the attached records pertaining to your policy #416646738
Thank you,
Tasha DeMedio, Administrative Assistant
Law Offices of
HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN, KOLB 65 SCHWEHKERT"
5165 Campus Drive Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting PA 19462
(610)276 4993 (Office)
(866)842 1482 (Fax)
E Mail Anastasia N DemedigdProgressive com
‘Salaned employees of Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
Not a partnership Not a Corporation
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE
The information contained in this e mail is confidential and/or privileged This e mail is intended to be reviewed only by the
individual“) or organization named above If you are not the intended recipient you are hereby notified that any review
dissemination or copying of this 6 mail and its attachments if any or the information contained herein is prohibited If you have
received this e mail in error, please immediately notify the sender by retum e mail and delete this 6 mail from your system
Hours M F80021m 430pm
HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT
Not a Partnership Not a Corporation
SALAthD EMPL()Y1:1:S Ol- PROGRESSIVE:
CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY
5165 CAMPUS DRIVE SUITE 200
PLYMOUTH MEETING PA 19462
Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire Admin Assistant Tasha DeMedio
Facsimile #(866) 842 1482 Direct#610 276-4993
anastasia n demedio@progressive com
October 27 2022
Via Electronic Mail and First Class Mail
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company State Farm Fire and Casualty Company
c/o CSC Attention Subpoena Unit
2595 Interstate Dr Ste 103 One State Farm Plaza
Harrisburg PA 17110 Bloomington IL 61710
RE Washington v Fernandez Templeman v Fernandez and Washington
Delaware County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320/CV 2021
007131
File No 193862653 002
Your Policy# 416646738
Dear Sir/Madam
On October 4, 2022, I served you with a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for
Discovery in regard to Your Policy# 416646738 To date 1 have not received the requested
records nor have I received an invoice for your copy fees This request is overdue
Unless I receive the requested records within five (5) days, I will be filing a Motion
to Compel with Court
If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact Tasha DeMedio, at
telephone #610 276-4993 Please note that you may fax the records to Tasha DeMedio at fax
#(866) 842 1482 Thank you for your time and attention to this matter
Very truly yours
JMNQMWD
Tasha DeMedio Administrative Assistant to
Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire
FAB/and
Send correspondence to
5165 Campus Dr , Suite 200
Plymouth Meetmg, Pa 19462
HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT
Not a Partnership, Not a Corporation
SALARllzD EMPLOYEES OP PROGRhSSlVl:
CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY
5165 CAMPUS DRIVE SUITE 200
PLYMOUTH MEETING PA 19462
Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire Admin Assistant Tasha DeMedio
Facsimile #(866) 842 1482 Direct#610 276—4993
anastasia n demedio@progressive com
October 27 2022
Via Electronic Mail and First Class Mail
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance
Company Company
c/o CSC Attention Subpoena Unit
2595 Interstate Dr Ste 103 One State Farm Plaza
Harrisburg PA 17110 Bloomington IL 61710
RE Washington v Fernandez; Templeman v Fernandez and Washington
Delaware County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320/CV 2021
007131
File No 193862653 002
Your Policy# 416646738
Dear Sir/Madam
On October 4, 2022, I served you with a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for
Discovery in regard to Your Policy# 416646738 To date, I have not received the requested
records nor have I received an invoice for your copy fees This request is overdue
Unless I receive the requested records within five (5) days, I will be filing a Motion
to Compel with Court
If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact Tasha DeMedio, at
telephone #610 276-4993 Please note that you may fax the records to Tasha DeMedio at fax
#(866) 842 1482 Thank you for your time and attention to this matter
Very truly yours
MGM!»
Tasha DeMedio, Administrative Assistant to
Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire
FAB/and
Send correspondence to
5165 Campus Dr , Suite 200
Plymouth Meeting, Pa 19462
Preview
Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez 5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462 Telephone #(610) 276-4728 Our File #193862653-002 _____________________________________ Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas : Delaware County v. : : Juana F. Fernandez : _________ : Jannine Templeman : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131 : v. Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington ORDER AND NOW, this ______ day of _________________, 20____, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Defendant's Motion is GRANTED and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company is to respond to Defendant's Subpoena within twenty (20) days of the date of this Order or risk sanctions as may be appropriate BY THE COURT: ______________________________ J. Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez 5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462 Telephone #(610) 276-4728 Our File #193862653-002 _____________________________________ Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas : Delaware County v. : : Juana F. Fernandez : _________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131 Jannine Templeman : v. Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL PLAINTIFF, ARSENA R. WASHINGTON’S, RECORDS FROM STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY A/K/A STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY 1. This is an action for personal injury arising out of an automobile accident. 2. On October 4, 2022 Defendant's counsel requested, by Subpoena, documents and things relating to Plaintiff, Arsena R. Washington, from State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company. See Correspondence Attached as Exhibit “A”. 3. To date, State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company has not responded to Defendant's Subpoena, nor have they sought a Protective Order. 4. Copies of these documents are required in order to obtain important information and permit Defendant to prepare for trial in this matter. Furthermore, Defendant will be prejudiced if full and complete responses to this Subpoena are not forwarded. 5. The failure of State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company to respond to Defendant's Subpoena is in violation of the applicable Rules of Civil Procedure. WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court enter an Order against State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company in the form attached hereto. Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: ________________________________ Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez 5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462 Telephone #(610) 276-4728 Our File #193862653-002 _____________________________________ Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas : Delaware County v. : : Juana F. Fernandez : _________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131 Jannine Templeman : v. Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington DEFENDANT'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL PLAINTIFF’S RECORDS 1. Matter before the Court: Before the Court is Defendant's Motion to Compel Discovery in the form of a Motion to Compel Records from State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company. 2. Statement of Question Involved: Is Defendant entitled to an Order compelling State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company to respond to Defendant's Subpoena for Production of Documents pertaining to Plaintiff, Arsena R. Washington, served more than thirty (30) days ago by the time this motion is heard and is now overdue? Suggested answer: Yes. 3. Facts: On October 4, 2022, Defendant's counsel forwarded to State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company a Subpoena for Production of Documents for records on Plaintiff, Arsena R. Washington. More than thirty (30) days will have elapsed by the time this motion is heard and they have failed to respond to the Subpoena. On October 27, 2022, Defendant's counsel sent a request to them to forward records on Plaintiff, Arsena R. Washington, within five (5) days. 4. Argument: Pa. R. C. P. 4009.21, titled, Written Interrogatories to a Party permits a party seeking production from a person not a party to the action to request production of documents after providing a twenty day notice to all parties of the intent to serve such subpoena. On October 4, 2022 , Defendant filed a Notice of Intent to Serve Subpoena upon State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, which was served on all parties via first class mail. On October 4, 2022, the Subpoena was served on State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company. Thirty days will now elapsed by the time this motion is heard since Defendant served such Subpoena and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company has failed to respond or otherwise object to the Subpoena. 6. Relief: Wherefore, Defendant respectfully requests this Court grant the Motion and issue an Order compelling State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company to respond to Defendant's subpoena within twenty (20) days. Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: ________________________________ Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Attorney ID # 312643 Juana F. Fernandez 5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462 Telephone #(610) 276-4728 Our File #193862653-002 _____________________________________ Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas : Delaware County v. : : Juana F. Fernandez : _________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131 Jannine Templeman : v. Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Fredric A. Bibbo, attorney for Defendant, hereby certify that I caused a true and correct copy of Defendant's Motion to Compel Records to be served on this date to the following: Via First Class Mail: State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company c/o CSC 2595 Interstate Dr., Ste. 103 Harrisburg, PA 17110 State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company One State Farm Plaza Bloomington, IL 61710 Via Electronic Filing: Mark Brownstein, Esquire Brownstein, Pearlman, Weizer, Newman 3 North 2nd Street Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 627-0100/(215) 627-1749 (F) Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: ________________________________ Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Date: November 1, 2022 Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant, Attorney ID #312643 Juana F. Fernandez 5165 Campus Drive, Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462 Telephone #(610) 276-4728 Our File #193862653-002 _____________________________________ Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas : Delaware County v. : : Juana F. Fernandez : _________ : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131 Jannine Templeman : v. Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE I, Fredric A. Bibbo, attorney for Defendant, Juana F. Fernandez, hereby certify that this filing complies with the provisions of the Public Access Policy of the Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania: Case Records of the Appellate and Trial Courts that require filing confidential information and documents differently than non-confidential information and documents. Hubshman, Flood, Dorn, Kolb & Schweikert By: ________________________________ Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant VERIFICATION I, Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire, aver that I am the attorney for the Defendant in this case, and I aver that the averments contained in the foregoing pleadings are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief; and that the statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. ________________________________ Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF DELAWARE, FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL TRIAL DIVISION Arsena R. Washington : Court of Common Pleas : Delaware County v. : : Juana F. Fernandez : _________ : Jannine Templeman : CV-2021-006320/CV-2021-007131 : v. Juana F. Fernandez and Arsena R. Washington ATTORNEY CERTIFICATION OF GOOD FAITH The undersigned for movant hereby certifies and attests that: X a) Defense counsel has had the contacts described below with State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company regarding the discovery matter contained in the foregoing discovery motion in an effort to resolve the specific discovery dispute(s) at issue and, further, that despite all counsel’s good faith attempts to resolve the dispute(s), counsel has been unable to do so. Description: On October 25, 2022, counsel for Defendant sent a message via electronic mail to State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company requesting the status of the records. On October 27, 2022, counsel for Defendant sent a letter to State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company requesting the records be produced within five days or a motion would be filed. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company a/k/a State Farm Fire and Casualty Company has not responded to the Subpoena. ___ b) Defense counsel has made a good faith but unsuccessful efforts described below to contact opposing counsel in an effort to resolve the discovery dispute. Description: By: ________________________________ Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquire Attorney for Defendant “Note: The signature of respondent’s counsel is not required” EXHIBIT “A” HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT Not a ”Min No! a Comomuon WED EMPLOYERS 0' PROGRESS“ I! CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY ms CAMPUS DRIVE. SUITE 200 PLYMOUTH MEETING PA 19462 Fredric A. Bibbo, Esquim Adm Assistanl Tush- DeMedio Facsimile #866) 842 1482 Direct“ 610276-4993 me n dcmedio@pmgrcssivc com October 4 2022 VII Certified Mail-RRR ”1'45‘1 DMD E11127 532‘! 113115 ll: State Farm Fire and Casualty Company Stale Farm Fm: and Casually Company c/o CSC Attentwn Subpoena Unit 2595 Interstatc Dr St: 103 One State Farm Plaza Harrisburg PA 17110 Bloomington IL 61710 RE Washington v Panama; Tcmplcman v Permndez and Wasan Delaware County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320/CV 2021 007131 File No 193862653002 Your Policy No “16646738 Dan Sir/Madam Enclosed is a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for Dimoch directing you to pmduoc the records idcnfified 111mm penaining lo Argent R Washington, You Policy ‘10 “16646738 Please proctuoc all of the rcquwtcd records to me by October 25, 2022 If possible please provide the records electronically via fax to Tasha DeMedio at fax #(866) 842 1482 or via email to sustain a demetllo®progresdve com If you require a twomble fee to cover the cost of producing the requested documents, please fg an invoice to Tag QcMgglio at $8661 842 14 t and a check will be sent to you If you have my questions rcyudnng this request, please call Tasha DcMcdio at tclcphonc #610 276-4993 Thank you for your time and attention to this matter Very truly yams Tasha DeMedio Admmmr' ' alive Assistanl to Fredric A Bibbo Esquire mama ‘ Enclosure 0c (via efiling) Mark Brownsmin1 Esquixe and Michael E Cook, Esquire Sud correspondence to 5165 Campus Dr Suite 20. Plymouth Meeting Pa 19462 COMMONWEAL'H'I OF PENNSYLVANIA mm .L W...” comm! or DELAWARE Ln- I‘ Fund" had“ Temptin- u CV 2021W(\ um Jun F Fcnudnud M1.- ll. Vuflfll‘fl Cw“ No llfllll SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009 22 to State Farm Fire and Chunky Company (Name of Person or Entity] wnhin twentv(20) days after service of this subpoena you are ordered to produce the lollowing W u“ in. holiday but «a flaw mm: m dcdc- toms and dedrltim me tar munm-m tar pulley holller mu mm. PERTMNING 1‘0 ARSLNA n. WASHINGTON 00! W2 um a 5165 Campus Dave Suite 200 Plymomh Mecflng’A |M62 ‘Address) If you fail to produce the documents or things required by this NOVICE T0 PRODUCE you may be subject to the sanctions authorized by Rule 234 5 of the PA Rules of Crvil Procedure This subpoena was issued at the request of the following person Mane W Important Note ALI. QU ESTIONS Address» 5165 Cams 0"“ 9"" 7”" REGARDING THIS Plymouth Mums. PA 19m 5"”05'“ MU“ 35 ADDRESSED TO THE PERSON NAMED AT THE LEFT WHO REQUESTED THAT ITBE ISSUED NOT TOTHE OFFICE OF JUDIQ; §Qgflfl TE'eP’Wne M Supreme Court m 31m; Attorney for Defendant BY TH URT M DATE E I % I lg; SEA]. OF E CO T DIRECTOR ALK ESQUIRE OFFICE OF J I SUPPORT HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT Not a hmmmMpt Not 1 Convention mi!) EWMI'RDGM‘IIVE CASUAL" INSUIASCECDMPANY 516$ CAMPUS DRIVE. SUITE 200 PLYMOUTH MEEHNG PA 19462 Fredric A Bibbo. Enquire Admin Amman Tasha Medic Facsimile £866) 842 1482 Directil 610-276-4993 min :1 dunedio@pmgzmive com October 4 2022 Vin Certified mm 006‘] 0010 0027 1:329 16205 33 Stat: Farm Mutual Automobile Immnoc Stat: Pam: Mutual Automobile Insurance Company 010 CSC Company Attention Subpoena Unit 2595 Interstate Dr Ste 103 One State Farm Plaza Hanisburg. PA 17110 Bloomington. IL 61710 RE Washington v Pcmandcz Templcman v Fernandez and Washington Delawm County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320 /CV 2021 007131 File No 193862653 002 Your Policy No “16646738 Dear Sir/Madam Enclosed is a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for Discove ry directing you to produce the records Identified therein pertaining to Arum: R. Washington, Your Policy No “16646738 Please produce all of tho requested records to me by October 25, 2022 If possible, please provide the records electronically via fax to Tasha DcModio at In: “866) 842-1482 or via email to summit! n dmcmpmgl‘aave com Ifyou require a reasonable fee to cover the cost of producing the requested documents, please fax an mxms‘glo—Tasmmnm 842 1532 including your Ty [mgfigngn unruly: and a check will be sent to you If you have any quesnons regarding this request, please call Tasha DcModio at telephone #610 276-4993 Thank you for your time and attenuon to £1115 mutter Very truly yours Ammo. Tuba DcMedio, Administtativc Assistant to Fredric A Bibbo Esquire FAmad Enclosure cc (vm cfiling) Marl: Brownstcin. Esquitc and Michael P Cook, Esquine Send correspondence to 5165 Campus Dr.1 Sum 200 Plymouth Meeting Pl 19462 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA A a. mama» COUNTV OF DELAWARE Lun- I Fernanda land.- Tum”: , cv Mlmmcv ml Juan I Fernanda Ind AM. It -un CW". NO ”3‘ II SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUM EN'I'S OR THNGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009 12 To Sum Furl! Metal Amount)»: Insulate Cmummy“e of Person or Entity) Within twenty (20) days aha: serwcc at this subpoena, you are ordeted to produce the following W“ ”W pair} IAIWG‘HS: for punk; holder runny mourn. mt I'AIMNG I0 usuu n. wasmwmrs m nonwzmm 3t SIIS Cillflll nun. SI“! 2”. I‘lynoutll Meiinl.‘ PA I946? (Addrcu) Ifyou fall to produce the documents or flung; required by this NOIICE 10 PRODUCE you may be saline! to the sanctions authorized by Rule 234 5 of the PA Rules of Civil Procedure This Subpoena was issued at the req nest of the following person Name ' U!" Important Note m ALL QUESTIONS Address ““0”“ ”m" 9"" REGARDING THIS Pinion“: Mating. PA mo: SUBPOENA MUST BE ADDRESSED TO THE PERSON NAMED AT THE LEFT WHO REQUESTED THAT IT BE ISSUED NOT T9 THE OFFICE OF QQIQAL SUPPORT Telephone (61") 216-47’9 Supreme Court sow 3m“ Attorney for “mm" BY Try a URT DATE 4 I A SEAL or E coo DIRECTOR W I ALK saunas omc: OF 1 I I SUPPORT Anastasia N Demedio _ From Anastasia N Demedio Sent Tuesday October 25 2022 10 36 AM To statefarmclaims@statefarm com Subject Your Policy #416646738 Washington v Fernandez (LEAD CASE) 193862653 002 Attachments State Farm pdf Good morning, Please advise the status of the attached records pertaining to your policy #416646738 Thank you, Tasha DeMedio, Administrative Assistant Law Offices of HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN, KOLB 65 SCHWEHKERT" 5165 Campus Drive Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting PA 19462 (610)276 4993 (Office) (866)842 1482 (Fax) E Mail Anastasia N DemedigdProgressive com ‘Salaned employees of Progressive Casualty Insurance Company Not a partnership Not a Corporation CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The information contained in this e mail is confidential and/or privileged This e mail is intended to be reviewed only by the individual“) or organization named above If you are not the intended recipient you are hereby notified that any review dissemination or copying of this 6 mail and its attachments if any or the information contained herein is prohibited If you have received this e mail in error, please immediately notify the sender by retum e mail and delete this 6 mail from your system Hours M F80021m 430pm HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT Not a Partnership Not a Corporation SALAthD EMPL()Y1:1:S Ol- PROGRESSIVE: CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 5165 CAMPUS DRIVE SUITE 200 PLYMOUTH MEETING PA 19462 Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire Admin Assistant Tasha DeMedio Facsimile #(866) 842 1482 Direct#610 276-4993 anastasia n demedio@progressive com October 27 2022 Via Electronic Mail and First Class Mail State Farm Fire and Casualty Company State Farm Fire and Casualty Company c/o CSC Attention Subpoena Unit 2595 Interstate Dr Ste 103 One State Farm Plaza Harrisburg PA 17110 Bloomington IL 61710 RE Washington v Fernandez Templeman v Fernandez and Washington Delaware County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320/CV 2021 007131 File No 193862653 002 Your Policy# 416646738 Dear Sir/Madam On October 4, 2022, I served you with a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for Discovery in regard to Your Policy# 416646738 To date 1 have not received the requested records nor have I received an invoice for your copy fees This request is overdue Unless I receive the requested records within five (5) days, I will be filing a Motion to Compel with Court If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact Tasha DeMedio, at telephone #610 276-4993 Please note that you may fax the records to Tasha DeMedio at fax #(866) 842 1482 Thank you for your time and attention to this matter Very truly yours JMNQMWD Tasha DeMedio Administrative Assistant to Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire FAB/and Send correspondence to 5165 Campus Dr , Suite 200 Plymouth Meetmg, Pa 19462 HUBSHMAN FLOOD BORN KOLB & SCHWEIKERT Not a Partnership, Not a Corporation SALARllzD EMPLOYEES OP PROGRhSSlVl: CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 5165 CAMPUS DRIVE SUITE 200 PLYMOUTH MEETING PA 19462 Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire Admin Assistant Tasha DeMedio Facsimile #(866) 842 1482 Direct#610 276—4993 anastasia n demedio@progressive com October 27 2022 Via Electronic Mail and First Class Mail State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company Company c/o CSC Attention Subpoena Unit 2595 Interstate Dr Ste 103 One State Farm Plaza Harrisburg PA 17110 Bloomington IL 61710 RE Washington v Fernandez; Templeman v Fernandez and Washington Delaware County Court of Common Pleas No CV 2021 006320/CV 2021 007131 File No 193862653 002 Your Policy# 416646738 Dear Sir/Madam On October 4, 2022, I served you with a Subpoena to Produce Documents or Things for Discovery in regard to Your Policy# 416646738 To date, I have not received the requested records nor have I received an invoice for your copy fees This request is overdue Unless I receive the requested records within five (5) days, I will be filing a Motion to Compel with Court If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact Tasha DeMedio, at telephone #610 276-4993 Please note that you may fax the records to Tasha DeMedio at fax #(866) 842 1482 Thank you for your time and attention to this matter Very truly yours MGM!» Tasha DeMedio, Administrative Assistant to Fredric A Bibbo, Esquire FAB/and Send correspondence to 5165 Campus Dr , Suite 200 Plymouth Meeting, Pa 19462