On June 15, 2020 a
Motion,Ex Parte
was filed
involving a dispute between
Gonzalez, Irene,
and
Atj & Bllc,
Carl'S Jr. Restaurant, Llc,
Chino Spectrum Marketplace, Llca California Corporation,
City Of Chino A Public Entity,
County Of San Bernardino A Public Entity,
Does 6-25,
Estes Family Llc,
Majestic-Mapa Properties, Llc,
San Bernardino County,
for Personal Injury Non-Motor Vehicle Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
V
[Exempt From Filing Fee
Government Code § 6103]
ALESHIRE & WYNDER, LLP
FRED GALANTE, State Bar No. 178421
fgalante@awatt0rneys. com
G. ROSS TRINDLE, III, State Bar No. 228654
gtrindle@awattorneys. com SUPERIORchuL ED
COUNTV «r.
JAMIE TRAXLER,
..
Bar No. 328537
.
State
SAN {4: Rn
jtraxler@awattorneys. com
3880 Lemon Street, Suite 520
Riverside, California 92501
Telephone: (95 1) 241-7338
Facsimile: (95 1) 300-0985
,l'
-L -Jbur Mi.
4...“ uEr Ury
Attorneys for Defendant, CITY OF CHINO
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO, SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT
10
11 IRENE GONZALEZ, an individual, Case No. CIVD82012361
CITY OF CHINO’S SEPARATE
.i‘},
12 Plaintiff,
STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED
E 13 v. MATERIAL FACTS IN SUPPORT OF
I
U) W‘ENPER
MOTION AND MOTION FOR
14 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO, a public SUMMARY JUDGMENT
3 CITY OF CHINO, a public entity;
entity;
< 15 CHINO SPECTRUM MARKETPLACE, [Filed Concurrently with Notice ofMotion and
LLC, a California corporation, Motionfor Summary Judgment; Compendium
16 ofExhibits; Declaration ofCity Clerk, Angela
Defendants. Robles; Declaration ofChristopher
17 Magdosku; Declaration ofFrancisco
Sotomayor; Declaration 0f Tina Lopez;
18 Declaration ofJamie L. Traxler; and
[Proposed] Order]
19
Date: June 3, 2021
20 Time: 9:00 a.m.
Dept: S30
21
22 Assigned for All Purposes to:
Hon. Brian S. McCarville, Dept. S30
23
Action Filed: June 15, 2020
24 Trial Date: TBA
25
26 TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD HEREIN:
27 Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 437c(b)(1) and California Rules of Court,
28 Rule 3.1350, Plaintiff CITY OF CHINO (the “City”) hereby submits this Separate Statement Of
01225.0050/689826‘1 jt
-1-
CITY OF CHINO’S SEPARATE STATEMENT ISO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
1 Undisputed Material Facts and supporting evidence in support of its Motion for Summary Judgment
2 (the “Motion”) against Plaintiff, IRENE GONZALEZ.
3 THERE IS N0 TRIABLE ISSUE 0F MATERIAL FACT 0N PLAINTIFF’S SOLE
4 CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST THE CITY FOR DANGEROUS CONDITION OF
5 PUBLIC PROPERTY
O\
ISSUE NUMBER ONE: Plaintiff Cannot Establish That The Alleged Dangerous Condition
fl Existed On Property Owned Or Controlled By The City At The Time Of The Incident,
Pursuant To Government Code Sections 830 And 835
9 Moving Party‘s Undisputed Material Facts Opposing Party's Response and
and Supporting Evidence: Supporting Evidence:
10 At all times herein, the City of Chino is and
1.
11 of
was a public entity within the State
L5 g
12
m
Lil
M
f'
California.
Hm (-
Q
:1:
:7
’
1 3
m 2
14
(Declaration of Jamie Traxler (“Traxler Dec.”),
B§_
< .
15
2) (City’s Compendium of Exhibits filed
m
16 CITY-
concurrently herewith (“Exh.”), 4; p.
17
0063)
18
2. On or about May 10, 2019 Plaintiff ate at
19
Carl’s Jr., located at 3880 Grand Avenue,
20
Chino, California 91710.
21
22
(Declaration of Angela Robles (“Robles Dec.”),
23
m5; Traxler Dec., 1m 2, 5(c), 6(a)) (Exh. 1, 4, 1 1,
24
15; pp. CITY-OOOS, 0066, 0161, 0221—0222)
25
3. At approximately 5:00 p.m., Plaintiff
26
finished eating at Carl’s Jr. and lefi the
27
restaurant.
28
01225.0050/689826.1 jt
-2-
CITY OF CHINO’S SEPARATE STATEMENT ISO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Preview
V [Exempt From Filing Fee Government Code § 6103] ALESHIRE & WYNDER, LLP FRED GALANTE, State Bar No. 178421 fgalante@awatt0rneys. com G. ROSS TRINDLE, III, State Bar No. 228654 gtrindle@awattorneys. com SUPERIORchuL ED COUNTV «r. JAMIE TRAXLER, .. Bar No. 328537 . State SAN {4: Rn jtraxler@awattorneys. com 3880 Lemon Street, Suite 520 Riverside, California 92501 Telephone: (95 1) 241-7338 Facsimile: (95 1) 300-0985 ,l' -L -Jbur Mi. 4...“ uEr Ury Attorneys for Defendant, CITY OF CHINO SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO, SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT 10 11 IRENE GONZALEZ, an individual, Case No. CIVD82012361 CITY OF CHINO’S SEPARATE .i‘}, 12 Plaintiff, STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED E 13 v. MATERIAL FACTS IN SUPPORT OF I U) W‘ENPER MOTION AND MOTION FOR 14 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO, a public SUMMARY JUDGMENT 3 CITY OF CHINO, a public entity; entity; < 15 CHINO SPECTRUM MARKETPLACE, [Filed Concurrently with Notice ofMotion and LLC, a California corporation, Motionfor Summary Judgment; Compendium 16 ofExhibits; Declaration ofCity Clerk, Angela Defendants. Robles; Declaration ofChristopher 17 Magdosku; Declaration ofFrancisco Sotomayor; Declaration 0f Tina Lopez; 18 Declaration ofJamie L. Traxler; and [Proposed] Order] 19 Date: June 3, 2021 20 Time: 9:00 a.m. Dept: S30 21 22 Assigned for All Purposes to: Hon. Brian S. McCarville, Dept. S30 23 Action Filed: June 15, 2020 24 Trial Date: TBA 25 26 TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD HEREIN: 27 Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 437c(b)(1) and California Rules of Court, 28 Rule 3.1350, Plaintiff CITY OF CHINO (the “City”) hereby submits this Separate Statement Of 01225.0050/689826‘1 jt -1- CITY OF CHINO’S SEPARATE STATEMENT ISO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 1 Undisputed Material Facts and supporting evidence in support of its Motion for Summary Judgment 2 (the “Motion”) against Plaintiff, IRENE GONZALEZ. 3 THERE IS N0 TRIABLE ISSUE 0F MATERIAL FACT 0N PLAINTIFF’S SOLE 4 CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST THE CITY FOR DANGEROUS CONDITION OF 5 PUBLIC PROPERTY O\ ISSUE NUMBER ONE: Plaintiff Cannot Establish That The Alleged Dangerous Condition fl Existed On Property Owned Or Controlled By The City At The Time Of The Incident, Pursuant To Government Code Sections 830 And 835 9 Moving Party‘s Undisputed Material Facts Opposing Party's Response and and Supporting Evidence: Supporting Evidence: 10 At all times herein, the City of Chino is and 1. 11 of was a public entity within the State L5 g 12 m Lil M f' California. Hm (- Q :1: :7 ’ 1 3 m 2 14 (Declaration of Jamie Traxler (“Traxler Dec.”), B§_ < . 15 2) (City’s Compendium of Exhibits filed m 16 CITY- concurrently herewith (“Exh.”), 4; p. 17 0063) 18 2. On or about May 10, 2019 Plaintiff ate at 19 Carl’s Jr., located at 3880 Grand Avenue, 20 Chino, California 91710. 21 22 (Declaration of Angela Robles (“Robles Dec.”), 23 m5; Traxler Dec., 1m 2, 5(c), 6(a)) (Exh. 1, 4, 1 1, 24 15; pp. CITY-OOOS, 0066, 0161, 0221—0222) 25 3. At approximately 5:00 p.m., Plaintiff 26 finished eating at Carl’s Jr. and lefi the 27 restaurant. 28 01225.0050/689826.1 jt -2- CITY OF CHINO’S SEPARATE STATEMENT ISO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT