Preview
ARNOLD & PORTER KAYE SCHOLER LLP
Willis M. Wagner (SBN 310900)
Rica Santos (SBN 328826)
Three Embarcadero Center, 10th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
Telephone: 415.471.3100
Facsimile: 415.471.3400
will-wagner@arnoldporter.com
rica.santos@arnoldporter.com
Attorneys for Defendant
FEDERICI BRANDS, LLC
10
11
12
13 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
14
FOR THE COUNTY OF SANTA CRUZ
15
16 ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ADVOCATES, Case No. 23CV00293
INC,
17 Plaintiff, NOTICE OF ORDER ASSIGNING
V. COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE,
18 SETTING HEARING AND STAYING
CASES
19 FEDERICI BRANDS, LLC, et al.,
20 Defendants.
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-[--
NOTICE OF ORDER CASE NO. 23CV00293
TO THE COURT, ALL PARTIES, AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Pursuant to the Order of the Judicial Council of
June 12, 2023, the Superior Court of California, Alameda County issued an Order Assigning a
Coordination Motion Judge, setting a hearing on the Petition for Coordination, and staying this
case pending the hearing. A copy of the Order is attached hereto as Exhibit 1.
Dated: June 27, 2023 ARNOLD & PORTER KAYE SCHOLER LLP
10
By:
‘Will Wagner
Kur
11
Attorney for Defendant
12
FEDERICI BRANDS, LLC
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
2-
NOTICE OF ORDER CASE NO. 23CV00293
EXHIBIT 1
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA
TI02 POWER COMETICS CASES No. JCCP 5285
ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION
10 MOTION JUDGE, SETTING HEARING
AND STAYING CASES
1
12
a 2B
ay
SS ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE
gs On June 12, 2023, the Chair of the Judicial Council issued an Order Assigning
Coordination Motion Judge, authorizing the presiding Judge in Alameda County to appoint a
Coordination Motion Judge. (CCP 404; CRC 3.524.)
19
The superior court cases in the Judicial Council Order are listed in the attached Order.
20
The presiding Judge in Alameda County through General Directive 2022-02 designated
21
Judge Brad Seligman as Supervising Judge of Complex and delegated to the Supervising Judge
22
23 of Complex the case assignment duties set forth in CRC 10.603(b)(1)(R) and 10.603(c)(1)(D).
24 These include the case assignment duties set forth in CCP 404 and CRC 3,524(a).
25 IT IS ORDERED that Judge Brad Seligman, Department 23, is assigned as Coordination
26 Motion Judge. The Coordination Motion Judge will consider the petition and any opposition and
response thereto, hold a hearing if appropriate, and recommend whether the actions should be
coordinated. (C.C.P. 404.4; C.R.C. 3.527.) In addition, the Coordination Motion Judge may
stay the included actions. (C.C.P. 404.5.)
The Court directs counsel for petitioner to file a copy of this order in each of the cases
identified in the attached Order and to serve a copy of this order on all parties in each of the
identified cases by personal delivery, fax or next day mail upon receipt of this order. (CRC
3.510
& 3.511.)
A hearing on the Petition will be heard on July 11, 2023 at 3 pm in Department 23 of the
10 Alameda Superior Court. All cases are stayed pending this hearing.
1
12 Dated: June 15, 2023.
SL
Bred Seligman
13
Judge of the Superior Court
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
CHAIR, JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA
455 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94102-3688
Coordination Proceeding )
Special Title (Rule 3.550) )
)
)
TIO2 POWDER COSMETICS CASES ) JUDICIAL COUNCIL
) COORDINATION PROCEEDING
) NO. 5285
)
)
ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE
THE PRESIDING JUDGE of the Superior Court of California, County of
Alameda, is hereby authorized to assign this matter to a judge of the court pursuant to Code of
Civil Procedure section 404 and rule 3.524 of the California Rules of Court to sit as
coordination motion judge to determine whether the included actions listed below are
complex (rule 3.502), and if so, whether coordination of those actions is appropriate. If the
coordination motion judge grants the petition for coordination, the judge must (1) recommend
a particular superior court for the site of the coordination proceedings, pursuant to rule 3.530,
and (2) select the reviewing court having appellate jurisdiction if the actions to be coordinated
are within the jurisdiction of more than one reviewing court, pursuant to rule 3.505(a).
INCLUDED ACTIONS
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California 22CV008711 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v.
Bareminerals US Holdco Inc.,
etal.
Superior Court of California 22CV008722 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Cosnova,
Inc., et al.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California 22CV008726 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Seed
Beauty, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 22CV018926 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. The
Beauty Crop, Limited, et al.
Superior Court of California 22CV019356 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Urban
Decay Cosmetics, LLC,
etal.
Superior Court of California 22CV020982 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Maesa LLC. .
etal.
Superior Court of California 22CV23816 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. NYX
Professional Makeup LLC,
etal.
Superior Court of California 22CV023821 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Makeup
by Lilit, LLC
Superior Court of California 22CV024016 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Almay,
Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 22CV024026 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v.
Maybelline LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV025452 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Almar
Sales Co., Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV025457 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v.
Billion Dollar Beauty L.L.C.,
etal.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California 23CV025460 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Danessa
Myricks Beauty, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV025466 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. JW
Beauty LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV026134 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Ulta Salon,
Cosmetics & Fragrance,
Inc.
Superior Court of California 23CV026126 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. GLO
Skin Beauty
Superior Court of California 23CV027328 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Lurella
Cosmetics, Inc.
Superior Court of California 23CV027275 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Persona
Cosmetics Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV027280 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. EM
Cosmetics, LLC
Superior Court of California 23CV027282 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Givenchy
Corporation, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV028399 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Artist
Couture, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV029247 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Giorgio
Armani Corporation, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV030780 Environmental Health
County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Centric
Beauty LLC, etal.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California C22-01606 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v.
Revolution Beauty, Inc., et al
Superior Court of California C22-01667 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Michael
Giordano International, Inc.,
et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01669 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc, v. The
Boots Company PLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01695 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Beauty
21 Cosmetics, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01697 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Larkly,
LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01698 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Melt
Cosmetics, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01794 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Absolute
New York Beauty Supply
Warehouse, Inc.
Superior Court of California C22-01795 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Black
Opal, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01796 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Nicka K
New York, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-01932 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. BYS
Cosmetics Australia, et al.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California C22-02111 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. y. Memebox
Corporation, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02235 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Jon Davler,
etal,
Superior Court of California C22-02292 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Laura Lee
Los Angeles LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02405 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Pacifica
Beauty, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02462 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. E.L.I.
Cosmetics, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02657 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Hard
Candy, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02658 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Rare
Beauty, LLC, etal.
Superior Court of California C22-02680 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Coty Inc.,
etal.
Superior Court of California C22-02681 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. J.Cat
Beauty Enterprise LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02684 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Jacky and
Lauren Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California C22-02685 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Kat Von D. >
Inc., et al.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California C23-00153 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. AS
Beauty LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C23-00269 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Glamlite
Inc.
Superior Court of California C23-00270 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Patrick
Ta Beauty, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C23-00402 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Guerlain,
Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California C23-00451 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. THGPP
LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C23-00574 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Tom Ford
International LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California C23-00803 Environmental Health
County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Han Skin
Care Cosmetics, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-599492 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Sephora
USA, Inc.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-599495 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Profusion
Cosmetics Corp., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-599530 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Pearl
World Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-599743 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Tarte, Inc. ’
etal.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California CGC-22-600953 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Too Faced
Cosmetics LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-600957 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Physicians
Formula Cosmetics, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-602653 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Enchante
Accessories Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-602737 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Kiss
Products, Inc.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-602967 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Estee
Lauder Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-602968 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Clinique
Laboratories, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-602985 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v.
Beauty Bakerie Cosmetics
Brand, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-603487 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Laura
Mercier US Buyer LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-22-603488 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Jaclyn
Cosmetics, LLC
Superior Court of California CGC-22-603489 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Beauty
Treats International Co., Inc.,
etal.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-603899 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Karity LLC
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court ofCalifornia CGC-23-603901 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Origins
Natural Resources Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604168 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Fenty
Beauty LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604171 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. W3ll
People Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604172 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Mented
Cosmetics, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604173 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Sugarpill,
LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604176 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Jouer
Cosmetics, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604446 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Nails.Inc.
Limited, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-604457 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Lawless
Beauty Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-605174 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Parfums
Christian Dior U.S. Corp.,
etal.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-605175 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Anastasia
Beverly Hills, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California CGC-23-605662 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Gucci
America Inc., et al.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California CGC-23-605664 Environmental Health
County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Pop Beauty
Inc,, et al.
Superior Court of California 22CV399098 Environmental Health
County of Santa Clara Advocates, Inc. v. The Creme
Shop, et al.
Superior Court of California 22CV02540 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Perfume
Worldwide, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00062 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Kimchi_
Chic Beauty LLC
Superior Court of California 23CV00063 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Kingdom
Animalia, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00064 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. New
Milani Group LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00080 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Laura
Geller Beauty, LLC
Superior Court of California 23CV00188 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. HB USA
Holdings Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00189 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Glossier
Inc.
Superior Court of California 23CV00190 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Lilah
Beauty, Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00191 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Joss
Cosmetics LLC, et al.
COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE
Superior Court of California 23CV00192 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Tru
Fragrance and Beauty LLC
Superior Court of California 23CV00193 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Merle
Norman Cosmetics, Inc.
Superior Court of California 23CV00194 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. y.
Colorscience Inc., et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00293 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Federici
Brands LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00295 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Stila
Styles, LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00296 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Sacha
Cosmetics LLC
Superior Court of California 23CV00426 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Bella
Pierre Cosmetics Inc., et all
Superior Court of California 23CV00445 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. y. Make Up
For Ever LLC, et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00454 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Pixi, Inc.,
etal.
Superior Court of California 23CV00598 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Chanel, Inc.,
et al.
Superior Court of California 23CV00620 Environmental Health
County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Nikkia Joy
Cosmetics, PTY Ltd.
10
Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 404.5 and rule 3.515, pending the
determination of whether coordination is appropriate, the coordination motion judge may
stay any action being considered for, or affecting an action being considered for,
coordination.
Pursuant to rule 3.524, the clerk of each court in which an included action is
pending is directed to file this order in the included action. Also, pursuant to rule 3.524, all
documents required to be submitted to the coordination motion judge must be transmitted to
the court address designated below:
Presiding Judge of the Superior Court of California,
County of Alameda
1225 Fallon Street
Oakland, CA 94612-4278
Pursuant to rule 3.511, a copy of every notice of opposition, application for
stay order, stay order, notice of hearing on the petition, and order granting or denying
coordination must be transmitted to the Chair of the Judicial Council at the following
address:
Chair, Judicial Council of California
Attn; Appellate Court Services
(Civil Case Coordination)
455 Golden Gate Avenue, 5th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94102-3688
Petitioners are directed to serve a copy of this order on (1) all parties to the
included actions, and (2) the clerk of each court for filing in each included action.
Dated: June 12, 2023
woe
Chief Justice of California and
Chair of the Judicial Council
ll
CHAIR, JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA
PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JUDICIAL COUNCIL COORDINATION NUMBER: CASE NUMBER:
4
lam over the age of 18 and not a party to this legal action.
2. lam employed in the City and County of San Francisco and my business address is
455 Golden Gate Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94102-3688
3. On June 13, 2023, | served a copy of the following documents:
X ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE
ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION TRIAL JUDGE
ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE
AND SETTING DATE FOR HEARING
AMENDED ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE
AMENDED ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION TRIAL JUDGE
OTHER
on the interested parties listed on the attached mailing list by placing a true copy enclosed in a
sealed envelope with postage fully prepaid in the outgoing mailbox in my office, in accordance with
ordinary business practices for deposit with the United States Postal Service in San Francisco,
California. | am readily familiar with my office's business practice for collection of and processing of
correspondence for mailing, and under that practice the above document is being deposited with
the United States Postal Service this date in San Francisco, California, in the ordinary course of
business.
| declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing
Mik,
is true and correct.
(Fonbil
Date: Tuesday, June 13, 2023
C Bernadine
MAILING LIST
JUDICIAL COUNCIL COORDINATION PROCEEDING NO. 5285
Willis M. Wagner
Andrew J. Rambo
ARNOLD & PORTER KAYE SCHOLER LLP
Three Embarcadero Center, 10th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111-4024
PROOF OF SERVICE
I, the undersigned, declare:
1 am a citizen of the United States and employed in Sacramento, California. I am over the
age of eighteen years and not a party to the within-entitled action. My business address is Three
Embarcadero Center, 10" Floor, San Francisco, CA 94111. On June 27, 2023, I served a copy of
the within document(s):
NOTICE OF ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE,
SETTING HEARING AND STAYING CASES
[BY MAIL] by placing the document(s) listed above in a sealed envelope with
10 postage thereon fully prepaid, by certified or registered mail, return receipt
requested, in the United States mail at San Francisco, California addressed as set
11 forth below.
12 [BY E-MAIL] by transmitting via email the document(s) listed above to the email
XI address(es) set forth below on this date before 6:00 p.m.
13
I served the document on the following persons:
14
15 SEE ATTACHED SERVICE LIST
16 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the above is
17 true and correct. Executed on June 27, 2023, at San Francisco, California.
18
ght re O
19 Lag
7 Méfie Zambrano
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
PROOF OF SERVICE
SERVICE LIST
ATTACHMENT TO PROOF OF SERVICE — Court Clerks by US Mail; Counsel by e-mail
Date Case Name Superior Case No.
Action Court
Filed
Represents Plaintiff ENTORNO LAW, LLP
in all cases Noam Glick
Jake W. Schulte
Craig M. Nicholas
Janani Natarajan
noam@entornolaw.com
jake@entornolaw.com
craig@entornolaw.com
janani@entornolaw.com
entornoparalegals@entornolaw.com
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
ADVOCATES, INC.
March 22. Environmental Alameda 22CV008711 Will Wagner
2022 Health Advocates, Andrew J. Rambo
Ine. v. Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP
Bareminerals US Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com
Holdco Inc., andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com
Shiseido Americas
Corporation, Attorneys for Defendants
Sephora USA, Inc. BAREMINERALS US HOLDCO, INC.,
et al. SHISEIDO AMERICAS CORPORATION,
SEPHORA USA, INC., and ULTA SALON
COSMETICS & FRAGRANCE, INC.
March 22. Environmental Alameda 22CV008722 Peggy Otum
2022 Health Advocates, Christopher A. Rheinheimer
Inc. v. Cosnova Wilmer cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP
Inc., Ulta Beauty, peggy.otum@wilmerhale.com
Inc., Ulta Beauty Chris.Rheinheimer@wilmerhale.com
Credit Services
Corporation, Ulta David Greenberg
Salon Cosmetics & Davis + Gilbert LLP
Fragrance, Inc. et dgreenberg@dglaw.com
al.
Attorneys for Defendant
COSNOVA INC.
March 22. Environmental Alameda 22CV008726 Matthew Kaplan
2022 Health Advocates, Tucker Ellis
Inc. v. Seed Beauty, matthew.kaplan@tuckerellis.com
US 174103144v1
Date Case Name Superior Case No.
Action Court
Filed
LLC, Ulta Beauty
Inc. et al. Attorneys for Defendant
SEED BEAUTY, LLC
Will Wagner
Andrew J. Rambo
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP
Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com
andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com
Attorneys for Defendant
COTY INC.
May 4, Environmental San CGC-22- Rick Rothman.
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599492 Megan Suehiro
Inc. v. Sephora Morgan Lewis
USA, Inc. et al. rick.rothman@morganlewis.com
megan.suehiro@morganlewis.com
Attorneys for Defendant
SEPHORA USA INC.
May 4, Environmental San CGC-22- Greg Sperla
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599495 DLA Piper
Inc. v. Profusion greg.sperla@dlapiper.com
Cosmetics Corp.,
Ross Stores, Inc. et Attorneys for Defendant
al. PROFUSION COSMETIC CORP.
May 6, Environmental San CGC-22- Matt Cave
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599530 Kevin Kroll
Inc. v. Pearl World Kibler Fowler & Cave LLP
Inc., Ross Stores, meave@kfe.law
Inc. et al. kkroll@kfc.law
Attorneys for Defendant
PEARL WORLD INC.
May 18. Environmental San CGC-22- Ryan S. Landis
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599678 rlandis@grsm.com
Inc. v. Buth-Na- Gordon & Rees
Bodhaige, Inc. dba
“The Body Shop” Attorneys for Defendant
et al. BUTH-NA-BODHAIGE, INC. DBA THE
BODY SHOP
May 23 Environmental San CGC-22- Jonathan Sandler
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599743 Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck
US 174103144v1
Date Case Name Superior Case No.
Action Court
Filed
Inc. v. Tarte, Inc., jsandler@bhfs.com
Kose America, Inc.,
Sephora USA, Inc. Attorneys for Defendant
etal. TARTE, INC.
Rick Rothman
Megan Suehiro
Morgan Lewis
rick.rothman@morganlewis.com
megan.suehiro@morganlewis.com
Attorneys for Defendant
SEPHORA USA INC.
May 27 Environmental Santa 22CV399098 Nate Meyer
2022 Health Advocates, Clara Russ August & Kabat
Inc. v. The Créme nmeyer@raklaw.com
Shop, Inc., Urban
Outfitters, Inc. et Attorneys for Defendant
al. THE CREME SHOP, INC.
June 16, Environmental Santa 22CV400211 Rocky Tsai
2022 Health Advocates, Clara Ropes & Gray
Inc. v. Forma rocky.tsai@ropesgray.com
Brands LLC,
Jeffree Star Attorneys for Defendant
Cosmetics, Inc., FORMA BEAUTY BRANDS LLC
Amazon.com et al.
July 27, Environmental San CGC-22- Will Wagner
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 600953 Andrew J. Rambo
Inc. v. Too Faced Amold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP
Cosmetics, LLC, Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com
Sephora USA, Inc. andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com
etal.
Attorneys for Defendants
TOO FACED COSMETICS, LLC and
SEPHORA USA, INC.
July 27, Environmental San CGC-22- Will Wagner
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 600957 Andrew J. Rambo
Inc. y. Physicians Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP
Formula Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com
Cosmetics, Inc., andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com
Physicians
Formula, Inc., Attorneys for Defendants
Markwins Beauty
US 174103144v1
Date Case Name Superior Case No.
Action Court
Filed
Brands, Inc., PHYSICIANS FORMULA COSMETICS,
Target Corporation INC., PHYSICIANS FORMULA, INC.,
etal. MARKWINS BEAUTY BRANDS, INC., and
TARGET CORPORATION
August 4, Environmental Contra C22-01606 Patrick D. Goggin
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Law Office of Patrick D. Goggin
Inc. y. Revolution Pdgogginlaw@gmail.com
Beauty, Inc., Target
corporation & Larry Mishkin
Amazon.com et al. Mishkin Law
Imishkin@mishkin.law
Attorneys for Defendant
REVOLUTION BEAUTY, INC.
August 9, Environmental San CGC-22- Matthew R. Orr
2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 601187 Amin Talati Wasserman, LLP
Inc. v. Mineral matt@amintalati.com
Fusion Natural
Brands LLC, Attorneys for Defendants
Target Corporation TARGET CORPORATION and MINERAL
etal. FUSION NATURAL BRANDS, LLC
August 11, Environmental Contra C22-01667 Jamie Norman
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Litchfield Cavo
Inc. v. Michael norman@litchfieldcavo.com
Giordano
International, Inc., Attorneys for Defendant
Ross Stores, Inc. et ROSS STORES, INC. and MICHAEL
al. GIORDANO INTERNATIONAL, INC.
August 11, Environmental Contra C22-01669 Andrew Homer
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Victor Sandoval
Inc. v. The Boots Joseph Green
Company PLC, Kelley Drye & Warren, LLP
Walgreen Co. et al. ahomer@kelleydrye.com
vsandoval@kelleydrye.com
jgreen@kelleydrye.com
Attorneys for Defendant
THE BOOTS COMPANY, PLC and
WALGREEN CO.
August 15, Environmental Contra C22-01695 Jeffrey B. Margulies
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Raymond J. Muro
Inc. v. Beauty 21 Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP
Cosmetics, Inc., jeff.margulies@nortonrosefulbright.com
US 174103144v1
Date Case Name Superior Case No.
Action Court
Filed
CVS Health Raymond.muro@nortonrosefulbright.com
Corporation, CVS
Pharmacy, Inc. et Attorneys for Defendant
al. BEAUTY 21 COSMETICS, INC.
August 15, Environmental Contra C22-01697 Lauren A. Deeb
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP
Inc. v. Larkly, LLC, Lauren.deeb@nelsonmullins.com
Nordstrom Inc. et
al. Attorneys for Defendant
NORDSTROM, INC.
August 15, Environmental Contra C22-01698 Michael Fisher
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Jeremy Weitz
Inc. v. Melt Buchalter
Cosmetics, Sephora mbfisher@buchalter.com
USA, Inc. et al. jweitz@buchalter.com
Attorneys for Defendant
MELT COSMETICS and SEPHORA USA,
INC.
August 18, Environmental Contra C22-01739 John H. Shaffery
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Nader S. Sabawi
Inc. v. Skin PS Poole Shaffery
Brands, Dr. Sandra jshaffery@pooleshaffery.com
J. Lee, M.D., P.C. nsabawi@pooleshaffery.com
etal.
Attorneys for Defendant
SKIN PS BRANDS
August 26, Environmental Contra C22-01794 Stephen Holzer
2022 Health Advocates, Costa Gayane Ghandilyan
Inc. y. Absolute Lewitt Hackman Shapiro Marshall & Harlan
Preview
ARNOLD & PORTER KAYE SCHOLER LLP Willis M. Wagner (SBN 310900) Rica Santos (SBN 328826) Three Embarcadero Center, 10th Floor San Francisco, CA 94111 Telephone: 415.471.3100 Facsimile: 415.471.3400 will-wagner@arnoldporter.com rica.santos@arnoldporter.com Attorneys for Defendant FEDERICI BRANDS, LLC 10 11 12 13 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 14 FOR THE COUNTY OF SANTA CRUZ 15 16 ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ADVOCATES, Case No. 23CV00293 INC, 17 Plaintiff, NOTICE OF ORDER ASSIGNING V. COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE, 18 SETTING HEARING AND STAYING CASES 19 FEDERICI BRANDS, LLC, et al., 20 Defendants. 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 -[-- NOTICE OF ORDER CASE NO. 23CV00293 TO THE COURT, ALL PARTIES, AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Pursuant to the Order of the Judicial Council of June 12, 2023, the Superior Court of California, Alameda County issued an Order Assigning a Coordination Motion Judge, setting a hearing on the Petition for Coordination, and staying this case pending the hearing. A copy of the Order is attached hereto as Exhibit 1. Dated: June 27, 2023 ARNOLD & PORTER KAYE SCHOLER LLP 10 By: ‘Will Wagner Kur 11 Attorney for Defendant 12 FEDERICI BRANDS, LLC 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 2- NOTICE OF ORDER CASE NO. 23CV00293 EXHIBIT 1 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA TI02 POWER COMETICS CASES No. JCCP 5285 ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION 10 MOTION JUDGE, SETTING HEARING AND STAYING CASES 1 12 a 2B ay SS ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE gs On June 12, 2023, the Chair of the Judicial Council issued an Order Assigning Coordination Motion Judge, authorizing the presiding Judge in Alameda County to appoint a Coordination Motion Judge. (CCP 404; CRC 3.524.) 19 The superior court cases in the Judicial Council Order are listed in the attached Order. 20 The presiding Judge in Alameda County through General Directive 2022-02 designated 21 Judge Brad Seligman as Supervising Judge of Complex and delegated to the Supervising Judge 22 23 of Complex the case assignment duties set forth in CRC 10.603(b)(1)(R) and 10.603(c)(1)(D). 24 These include the case assignment duties set forth in CCP 404 and CRC 3,524(a). 25 IT IS ORDERED that Judge Brad Seligman, Department 23, is assigned as Coordination 26 Motion Judge. The Coordination Motion Judge will consider the petition and any opposition and response thereto, hold a hearing if appropriate, and recommend whether the actions should be coordinated. (C.C.P. 404.4; C.R.C. 3.527.) In addition, the Coordination Motion Judge may stay the included actions. (C.C.P. 404.5.) The Court directs counsel for petitioner to file a copy of this order in each of the cases identified in the attached Order and to serve a copy of this order on all parties in each of the identified cases by personal delivery, fax or next day mail upon receipt of this order. (CRC 3.510 & 3.511.) A hearing on the Petition will be heard on July 11, 2023 at 3 pm in Department 23 of the 10 Alameda Superior Court. All cases are stayed pending this hearing. 1 12 Dated: June 15, 2023. SL Bred Seligman 13 Judge of the Superior Court 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 CHAIR, JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA 455 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94102-3688 Coordination Proceeding ) Special Title (Rule 3.550) ) ) ) TIO2 POWDER COSMETICS CASES ) JUDICIAL COUNCIL ) COORDINATION PROCEEDING ) NO. 5285 ) ) ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE THE PRESIDING JUDGE of the Superior Court of California, County of Alameda, is hereby authorized to assign this matter to a judge of the court pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 404 and rule 3.524 of the California Rules of Court to sit as coordination motion judge to determine whether the included actions listed below are complex (rule 3.502), and if so, whether coordination of those actions is appropriate. If the coordination motion judge grants the petition for coordination, the judge must (1) recommend a particular superior court for the site of the coordination proceedings, pursuant to rule 3.530, and (2) select the reviewing court having appellate jurisdiction if the actions to be coordinated are within the jurisdiction of more than one reviewing court, pursuant to rule 3.505(a). INCLUDED ACTIONS COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California 22CV008711 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Bareminerals US Holdco Inc., etal. Superior Court of California 22CV008722 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Cosnova, Inc., et al. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California 22CV008726 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Seed Beauty, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 22CV018926 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. The Beauty Crop, Limited, et al. Superior Court of California 22CV019356 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Urban Decay Cosmetics, LLC, etal. Superior Court of California 22CV020982 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Maesa LLC. . etal. Superior Court of California 22CV23816 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. NYX Professional Makeup LLC, etal. Superior Court of California 22CV023821 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Makeup by Lilit, LLC Superior Court of California 22CV024016 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Almay, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 22CV024026 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Maybelline LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV025452 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Almar Sales Co., Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV025457 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Billion Dollar Beauty L.L.C., etal. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California 23CV025460 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Danessa Myricks Beauty, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV025466 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. JW Beauty LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV026134 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Ulta Salon, Cosmetics & Fragrance, Inc. Superior Court of California 23CV026126 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. GLO Skin Beauty Superior Court of California 23CV027328 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Lurella Cosmetics, Inc. Superior Court of California 23CV027275 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Persona Cosmetics Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV027280 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. EM Cosmetics, LLC Superior Court of California 23CV027282 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Givenchy Corporation, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV028399 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Artist Couture, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV029247 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Giorgio Armani Corporation, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV030780 Environmental Health County of Alameda Advocates, Inc. v. Centric Beauty LLC, etal. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California C22-01606 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Revolution Beauty, Inc., et al Superior Court of California C22-01667 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Michael Giordano International, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California C22-01669 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc, v. The Boots Company PLC, et al. Superior Court of California C22-01695 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Beauty 21 Cosmetics, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California C22-01697 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Larkly, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C22-01698 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Melt Cosmetics, et al. Superior Court of California C22-01794 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Absolute New York Beauty Supply Warehouse, Inc. Superior Court of California C22-01795 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Black Opal, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C22-01796 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Nicka K New York, et al. Superior Court of California C22-01932 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. BYS Cosmetics Australia, et al. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California C22-02111 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. y. Memebox Corporation, et al. Superior Court of California C22-02235 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Jon Davler, etal, Superior Court of California C22-02292 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Laura Lee Los Angeles LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C22-02405 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Pacifica Beauty, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C22-02462 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. E.L.I. Cosmetics, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California C22-02657 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Hard Candy, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California C22-02658 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Rare Beauty, LLC, etal. Superior Court of California C22-02680 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Coty Inc., etal. Superior Court of California C22-02681 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. J.Cat Beauty Enterprise LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C22-02684 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Jacky and Lauren Inc., et al. Superior Court of California C22-02685 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Kat Von D. > Inc., et al. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California C23-00153 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. AS Beauty LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C23-00269 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Glamlite Inc. Superior Court of California C23-00270 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Patrick Ta Beauty, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C23-00402 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Guerlain, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California C23-00451 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. THGPP LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C23-00574 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Tom Ford International LLC, et al. Superior Court of California C23-00803 Environmental Health County of Contra Costa Advocates, Inc. v. Han Skin Care Cosmetics, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-599492 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Sephora USA, Inc. Superior Court of California CGC-22-599495 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Profusion Cosmetics Corp., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-599530 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Pearl World Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-599743 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Tarte, Inc. ’ etal. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California CGC-22-600953 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Too Faced Cosmetics LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-600957 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Physicians Formula Cosmetics, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-602653 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Enchante Accessories Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-602737 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Kiss Products, Inc. Superior Court of California CGC-22-602967 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Estee Lauder Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-602968 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Clinique Laboratories, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-602985 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Beauty Bakerie Cosmetics Brand, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-603487 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Laura Mercier US Buyer LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-22-603488 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Jaclyn Cosmetics, LLC Superior Court of California CGC-22-603489 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Beauty Treats International Co., Inc., etal. Superior Court of California CGC-23-603899 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Karity LLC COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court ofCalifornia CGC-23-603901 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Origins Natural Resources Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604168 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Fenty Beauty LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604171 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. W3ll People Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604172 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Mented Cosmetics, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604173 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Sugarpill, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604176 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Jouer Cosmetics, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604446 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Nails.Inc. Limited, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-604457 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Lawless Beauty Inc., et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-605174 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Parfums Christian Dior U.S. Corp., etal. Superior Court of California CGC-23-605175 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Anastasia Beverly Hills, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California CGC-23-605662 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Gucci America Inc., et al. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California CGC-23-605664 Environmental Health County of San Francisco Advocates, Inc. v. Pop Beauty Inc,, et al. Superior Court of California 22CV399098 Environmental Health County of Santa Clara Advocates, Inc. v. The Creme Shop, et al. Superior Court of California 22CV02540 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Perfume Worldwide, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00062 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Kimchi_ Chic Beauty LLC Superior Court of California 23CV00063 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Kingdom Animalia, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00064 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. New Milani Group LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00080 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Laura Geller Beauty, LLC Superior Court of California 23CV00188 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. HB USA Holdings Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00189 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Glossier Inc. Superior Court of California 23CV00190 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Lilah Beauty, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00191 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Joss Cosmetics LLC, et al. COURT NUMBER SHORT TITLE Superior Court of California 23CV00192 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Tru Fragrance and Beauty LLC Superior Court of California 23CV00193 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Merle Norman Cosmetics, Inc. Superior Court of California 23CV00194 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. y. Colorscience Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00293 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Federici Brands LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00295 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Stila Styles, LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00296 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Sacha Cosmetics LLC Superior Court of California 23CV00426 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Bella Pierre Cosmetics Inc., et all Superior Court of California 23CV00445 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. y. Make Up For Ever LLC, et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00454 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Pixi, Inc., etal. Superior Court of California 23CV00598 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Chanel, Inc., et al. Superior Court of California 23CV00620 Environmental Health County of Santa Cruz Advocates, Inc. v. Nikkia Joy Cosmetics, PTY Ltd. 10 Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 404.5 and rule 3.515, pending the determination of whether coordination is appropriate, the coordination motion judge may stay any action being considered for, or affecting an action being considered for, coordination. Pursuant to rule 3.524, the clerk of each court in which an included action is pending is directed to file this order in the included action. Also, pursuant to rule 3.524, all documents required to be submitted to the coordination motion judge must be transmitted to the court address designated below: Presiding Judge of the Superior Court of California, County of Alameda 1225 Fallon Street Oakland, CA 94612-4278 Pursuant to rule 3.511, a copy of every notice of opposition, application for stay order, stay order, notice of hearing on the petition, and order granting or denying coordination must be transmitted to the Chair of the Judicial Council at the following address: Chair, Judicial Council of California Attn; Appellate Court Services (Civil Case Coordination) 455 Golden Gate Avenue, 5th Floor San Francisco, CA 94102-3688 Petitioners are directed to serve a copy of this order on (1) all parties to the included actions, and (2) the clerk of each court for filing in each included action. Dated: June 12, 2023 woe Chief Justice of California and Chair of the Judicial Council ll CHAIR, JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL JUDICIAL COUNCIL COORDINATION NUMBER: CASE NUMBER: 4 lam over the age of 18 and not a party to this legal action. 2. lam employed in the City and County of San Francisco and my business address is 455 Golden Gate Avenue San Francisco, CA 94102-3688 3. On June 13, 2023, | served a copy of the following documents: X ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION TRIAL JUDGE ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE AND SETTING DATE FOR HEARING AMENDED ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE AMENDED ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION TRIAL JUDGE OTHER on the interested parties listed on the attached mailing list by placing a true copy enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage fully prepaid in the outgoing mailbox in my office, in accordance with ordinary business practices for deposit with the United States Postal Service in San Francisco, California. | am readily familiar with my office's business practice for collection of and processing of correspondence for mailing, and under that practice the above document is being deposited with the United States Postal Service this date in San Francisco, California, in the ordinary course of business. | declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing Mik, is true and correct. (Fonbil Date: Tuesday, June 13, 2023 C Bernadine MAILING LIST JUDICIAL COUNCIL COORDINATION PROCEEDING NO. 5285 Willis M. Wagner Andrew J. Rambo ARNOLD & PORTER KAYE SCHOLER LLP Three Embarcadero Center, 10th Floor San Francisco, CA 94111-4024 PROOF OF SERVICE I, the undersigned, declare: 1 am a citizen of the United States and employed in Sacramento, California. I am over the age of eighteen years and not a party to the within-entitled action. My business address is Three Embarcadero Center, 10" Floor, San Francisco, CA 94111. On June 27, 2023, I served a copy of the within document(s): NOTICE OF ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE, SETTING HEARING AND STAYING CASES [BY MAIL] by placing the document(s) listed above in a sealed envelope with 10 postage thereon fully prepaid, by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, in the United States mail at San Francisco, California addressed as set 11 forth below. 12 [BY E-MAIL] by transmitting via email the document(s) listed above to the email XI address(es) set forth below on this date before 6:00 p.m. 13 I served the document on the following persons: 14 15 SEE ATTACHED SERVICE LIST 16 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the above is 17 true and correct. Executed on June 27, 2023, at San Francisco, California. 18 ght re O 19 Lag 7 Méfie Zambrano 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 PROOF OF SERVICE SERVICE LIST ATTACHMENT TO PROOF OF SERVICE — Court Clerks by US Mail; Counsel by e-mail Date Case Name Superior Case No. Action Court Filed Represents Plaintiff ENTORNO LAW, LLP in all cases Noam Glick Jake W. Schulte Craig M. Nicholas Janani Natarajan noam@entornolaw.com jake@entornolaw.com craig@entornolaw.com janani@entornolaw.com entornoparalegals@entornolaw.com Attorneys for Plaintiffs ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ADVOCATES, INC. March 22. Environmental Alameda 22CV008711 Will Wagner 2022 Health Advocates, Andrew J. Rambo Ine. v. Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP Bareminerals US Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com Holdco Inc., andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com Shiseido Americas Corporation, Attorneys for Defendants Sephora USA, Inc. BAREMINERALS US HOLDCO, INC., et al. SHISEIDO AMERICAS CORPORATION, SEPHORA USA, INC., and ULTA SALON COSMETICS & FRAGRANCE, INC. March 22. Environmental Alameda 22CV008722 Peggy Otum 2022 Health Advocates, Christopher A. Rheinheimer Inc. v. Cosnova Wilmer cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP Inc., Ulta Beauty, peggy.otum@wilmerhale.com Inc., Ulta Beauty Chris.Rheinheimer@wilmerhale.com Credit Services Corporation, Ulta David Greenberg Salon Cosmetics & Davis + Gilbert LLP Fragrance, Inc. et dgreenberg@dglaw.com al. Attorneys for Defendant COSNOVA INC. March 22. Environmental Alameda 22CV008726 Matthew Kaplan 2022 Health Advocates, Tucker Ellis Inc. v. Seed Beauty, matthew.kaplan@tuckerellis.com US 174103144v1 Date Case Name Superior Case No. Action Court Filed LLC, Ulta Beauty Inc. et al. Attorneys for Defendant SEED BEAUTY, LLC Will Wagner Andrew J. Rambo Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com Attorneys for Defendant COTY INC. May 4, Environmental San CGC-22- Rick Rothman. 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599492 Megan Suehiro Inc. v. Sephora Morgan Lewis USA, Inc. et al. rick.rothman@morganlewis.com megan.suehiro@morganlewis.com Attorneys for Defendant SEPHORA USA INC. May 4, Environmental San CGC-22- Greg Sperla 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599495 DLA Piper Inc. v. Profusion greg.sperla@dlapiper.com Cosmetics Corp., Ross Stores, Inc. et Attorneys for Defendant al. PROFUSION COSMETIC CORP. May 6, Environmental San CGC-22- Matt Cave 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599530 Kevin Kroll Inc. v. Pearl World Kibler Fowler & Cave LLP Inc., Ross Stores, meave@kfe.law Inc. et al. kkroll@kfc.law Attorneys for Defendant PEARL WORLD INC. May 18. Environmental San CGC-22- Ryan S. Landis 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599678 rlandis@grsm.com Inc. v. Buth-Na- Gordon & Rees Bodhaige, Inc. dba “The Body Shop” Attorneys for Defendant et al. BUTH-NA-BODHAIGE, INC. DBA THE BODY SHOP May 23 Environmental San CGC-22- Jonathan Sandler 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 599743 Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck US 174103144v1 Date Case Name Superior Case No. Action Court Filed Inc. v. Tarte, Inc., jsandler@bhfs.com Kose America, Inc., Sephora USA, Inc. Attorneys for Defendant etal. TARTE, INC. Rick Rothman Megan Suehiro Morgan Lewis rick.rothman@morganlewis.com megan.suehiro@morganlewis.com Attorneys for Defendant SEPHORA USA INC. May 27 Environmental Santa 22CV399098 Nate Meyer 2022 Health Advocates, Clara Russ August & Kabat Inc. v. The Créme nmeyer@raklaw.com Shop, Inc., Urban Outfitters, Inc. et Attorneys for Defendant al. THE CREME SHOP, INC. June 16, Environmental Santa 22CV400211 Rocky Tsai 2022 Health Advocates, Clara Ropes & Gray Inc. v. Forma rocky.tsai@ropesgray.com Brands LLC, Jeffree Star Attorneys for Defendant Cosmetics, Inc., FORMA BEAUTY BRANDS LLC Amazon.com et al. July 27, Environmental San CGC-22- Will Wagner 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 600953 Andrew J. Rambo Inc. v. Too Faced Amold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP Cosmetics, LLC, Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com Sephora USA, Inc. andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com etal. Attorneys for Defendants TOO FACED COSMETICS, LLC and SEPHORA USA, INC. July 27, Environmental San CGC-22- Will Wagner 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 600957 Andrew J. Rambo Inc. y. Physicians Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP Formula Will.wagner@arnoldporter.com Cosmetics, Inc., andrew.rambo@arnoldporter.com Physicians Formula, Inc., Attorneys for Defendants Markwins Beauty US 174103144v1 Date Case Name Superior Case No. Action Court Filed Brands, Inc., PHYSICIANS FORMULA COSMETICS, Target Corporation INC., PHYSICIANS FORMULA, INC., etal. MARKWINS BEAUTY BRANDS, INC., and TARGET CORPORATION August 4, Environmental Contra C22-01606 Patrick D. Goggin 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Law Office of Patrick D. Goggin Inc. y. Revolution Pdgogginlaw@gmail.com Beauty, Inc., Target corporation & Larry Mishkin Amazon.com et al. Mishkin Law Imishkin@mishkin.law Attorneys for Defendant REVOLUTION BEAUTY, INC. August 9, Environmental San CGC-22- Matthew R. Orr 2022 Health Advocates, Francisco 601187 Amin Talati Wasserman, LLP Inc. v. Mineral matt@amintalati.com Fusion Natural Brands LLC, Attorneys for Defendants Target Corporation TARGET CORPORATION and MINERAL etal. FUSION NATURAL BRANDS, LLC August 11, Environmental Contra C22-01667 Jamie Norman 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Litchfield Cavo Inc. v. Michael norman@litchfieldcavo.com Giordano International, Inc., Attorneys for Defendant Ross Stores, Inc. et ROSS STORES, INC. and MICHAEL al. GIORDANO INTERNATIONAL, INC. August 11, Environmental Contra C22-01669 Andrew Homer 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Victor Sandoval Inc. v. The Boots Joseph Green Company PLC, Kelley Drye & Warren, LLP Walgreen Co. et al. ahomer@kelleydrye.com vsandoval@kelleydrye.com jgreen@kelleydrye.com Attorneys for Defendant THE BOOTS COMPANY, PLC and WALGREEN CO. August 15, Environmental Contra C22-01695 Jeffrey B. Margulies 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Raymond J. Muro Inc. v. Beauty 21 Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP Cosmetics, Inc., jeff.margulies@nortonrosefulbright.com US 174103144v1 Date Case Name Superior Case No. Action Court Filed CVS Health Raymond.muro@nortonrosefulbright.com Corporation, CVS Pharmacy, Inc. et Attorneys for Defendant al. BEAUTY 21 COSMETICS, INC. August 15, Environmental Contra C22-01697 Lauren A. Deeb 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP Inc. v. Larkly, LLC, Lauren.deeb@nelsonmullins.com Nordstrom Inc. et al. Attorneys for Defendant NORDSTROM, INC. August 15, Environmental Contra C22-01698 Michael Fisher 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Jeremy Weitz Inc. v. Melt Buchalter Cosmetics, Sephora mbfisher@buchalter.com USA, Inc. et al. jweitz@buchalter.com Attorneys for Defendant MELT COSMETICS and SEPHORA USA, INC. August 18, Environmental Contra C22-01739 John H. Shaffery 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Nader S. Sabawi Inc. v. Skin PS Poole Shaffery Brands, Dr. Sandra jshaffery@pooleshaffery.com J. Lee, M.D., P.C. nsabawi@pooleshaffery.com etal. Attorneys for Defendant SKIN PS BRANDS August 26, Environmental Contra C22-01794 Stephen Holzer 2022 Health Advocates, Costa Gayane Ghandilyan Inc. y. Absolute Lewitt Hackman Shapiro Marshall & Harlan