On September 12, 2013 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
Kevin Mcgonigal,
and
Baring Industries, Inc.,
Nyy Steak Manhattan, Llc,
Plaza Construction Corp.,
for Tort
in the District Court of New York County.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
Exhibit D
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
a
m
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
MINIMEMTRADiu:ATEGottIES
L 5aperimendent are:=twcompic
top,tars edastheenes
orcarh work d:ty '"S" 'Wairr -fabrrhah.
PLAZA SUPERINTENDENT'S
DAILY REPORT oranlaw,than the ortheimrkthe·following normatunrkdar. * '' 'B'd'l-'''d '- -'mW"* &'' """' '"l''N S' ''
cal3T 6.%'trN
nuesv*|4 •nis a t; l'lilen fI.it·er"bli
-W,72. 1m tg*ge
5prink 'rTi.'.f
PF.RATt
JR
E: F AM
2.Thework uiescripilms
stu,uldbeconcheand donotgenerahre.
specific. -Lemme
Carpeialern thnso..La ,,· Paiwr. Taeri, Shreinma trvAC
I mg
PROJECT: DATE: 3. the-knecnpy kinherarwarded testic Manager
Project inhowin "''"" Er«mruw-sy-.n- Itwsm-So H Paci•=tWemmmA TdkiI'ana'ur.,n
revitu andInrmardIntheSenior FrojectManager
andProjecu Eucusite. C*** seamr- -n-twr ess, N.- cs.II,--o .ra
sicern
wtien applicasicand
uise. ow u,wn,ec. e.con·,-.c re--
NO.:
PROJECT DA C ' ' n-n ... e..or,mmu.ng nw wm- c.mm WF:AMR AM
L Thecarbon iskepE recurds
slfewiththesuperirHer.denF'i
;ttghe '' ,,, 74,, _y.
Italitthen copy tliitit.
CI*fnpf n - en
CUMULATIVE 5. Atthecontplcuegs
ortheproject willforward
tothesuperintc1ident all t Ar '
1 Tb
DAYS: nailytonRoolo.tothePrnject Manager rarhackup
archhiing.
CONTRACTOR TRADE
TRADE NUMBER PEHFORMEl)
WORK CONTRACTORS GENERALFORCE
PERSONNEL
FIRLD
.. .te stufs,
PanyChief NAME IIOIIRS
I htMrumentMan
RodMan """I
gd-
Operators
|Elevator
Mechanics
Master
Maintenance
Men
(T- (r Foreman
Laborer
Laborers
(
Other
TOTM.
TEMPORARYSERVICES
-
( d t rd tNuwLqL w 4Ar S (Ar Wrvo Rrr . exiLM ..... __.. w-
Finers
Steam
ShecamemI
tryW3iler
IbrnpomrvElectricians
Oncrator
I Flevator -
VIStTORS-
RUBBISH
nolloffs
.. .. CONTROLLEDINSPECTION couumrs
N.ofla-p.
Loncrete
Structural
Stect
S.O.EP.
Reinfineement
Sicel
__ Cturtainwall ..
Firestopping GTIIER:
Geotech(Subgrade)
Other ..
TOTAL
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
MINIMUMTRADECATEGORIES
PLAZA SUPERINTENDENTSDAILYREPORT I- superinteadcau
lae*=re coher•'utPh•Imds.•enCerrach mudday GI
4 ThOhni femh ricoA Hwd me -Ihdhimg• Mc.mr
Fan.tW-fr¾
ornoInstrthanthestart arthe*•urk
thefedowinestormost
work stan. LtH×n; Critemr Hrnw.ers Nanrem
cDitETainr t *DN u .whk -Warpm.r-itre
f,,"cru .ter NsrINic .Brdgedrdsmd£ thraSrnmUer. TEMl-T
Smeam RNTUk! AM
a 2.Thework descriptionshouldberemchr donotgenerali
andspecH1c. c. C enC rm ueen.wa. I.m.-.e Niren -Tw. sfmmcui. HVAC
umtimr .-
PROJEC'l: ·. .1.Thewhitecopy itinbeforwardnt mght.PmjeriWnager nbuwilt hieom-Spm f%merrr>. Sprn wies
N.GngShectmeral
Fire U:in
e
reviewand forwardIntheSenior Project
ManagerandPrulwl Ewculhv. L'.ns-wNIwt h-wr Butve Nmtwn SWm-pi 1.«umwMrmmw
whatsppilenbleand file. CW:"f ,on,.CW l'hmhm •Cu
urer> Ltmu
I ROJECTNO.: - , DAY: w~ ,4,.,,. .w,, c..,
4.Thecarten copyIskepimithesiic.
wirb rtennis
tiresut'erinicarica'½ EGT a M .rvDie '*• 4
unn1thejob complebon. .._ TA·
CUMULATIVF i AttheCUmpletion oftheprojecututh ups.ringesident
willrurnarit
an M 1MHr
DAYS: DailyI.ngIlooks
totheProjeo Managerfurhatkuparchiving. c· meang_2.:3.-re set e. f-une.n Will Siemn IWen.undramnes
rnADE
CONTRÁt'TOtt TNADE MlMHER WORK
PERFORMFm CONTRACTORS GENERAI.FORCE
1Et.0
I'ERSONNEI.
PartyChief NWE Itotus
Instrumeng
Man a---
RajMan
ElevatorOperamrs wn
-. floistEngineers
MusictMechanics
M:ñmenanceMen
$ Lv-U- 2- Laborer
Foreman
..__..... h
1 Laboress
b F 1 7 luntfc . ! Other
Â,,. (so } .d) . (4. TOTAL
6 NSurnt-nW ( a ur..- Wt..-5 \/M{ M 60t4WTe Nvt- tWhvvy vtaem s ; h LnnM 0) r bYL ¾ noaMan
Oper:nors
()
PM4-¾W WfrvT %¶½A iGM @ 7vaO Elev;nor
IloistEneinects .
& \f t4G \ () Lashp 7 b 5 N WfrÅ 6) 4,L 2~
TD TL L Aw /4 usa Mechames
I AA- .) '¶71 My if\d } MannenanceMen
. Forenmn
Laborer
OW --- th1 Ov &T
r£¾v]W
f bytWvtWW W Y TOTAL
81th' p ---
b L . N %'LAM ')\‰Ç (tyQ ¾Qy) Q .6L
Av(a n+*s er us v stv« c o TEMPORARYSERVICES
Finers
Sleam
Shectmetal . --
Plumlwr
.. . ..- ... .. ... -. Tempomy Water
. Electricians
iTemporary
VISITORS:
R( THISH
RollOff.s
CONTROLLEDINSPECTION COMMMTN:
K BN a c c & u Conc e
Stee
Reinforcemem
Cunainwall
---- OTHElt:
Other
TOTAL
mm
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
H
b
m m
p ; m
m
z
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
MINIMrM TR.WF.GTEGORIES
L Sa inicodnu m IninopletedMh owlofachwork f'- 4' C T'
" Wehrt
PLAZA SUPERINTENDENT'S
DAILYREPORT day
TIO,4
CN .5 nu Wng ....a_+ O- T + 52Um 181PEltATURE. P AM
. . 2.Thework ..tmidhemutivamispreific.
descripthm ilo,mu
pocrnlim c n . n ow.c
(b Cm.M.:fw n:s..-thic
C.«pers ecr-. h .,il
P!..-t .Kn
$hNMce
PROJECT: DATE: 3. nonwropyim wthi-
r-nia nowP «swer am«m "C" -o ra e-
review
andforward
to Senior Projeti
Mamner:mdProint
hecuthe.
PROJECT
NO.: DAY: " ..o w3- c Tme M
4.Theourimn itWµtatthe& withitwsuper!nte,nitnCs
mpy rect.rds . a.x.g.
untilthejob
cu1nplenism. Cr -n -. a.u 16. rakta .r
CUMULATIVE a o
DAYS stoare
Pro«t Maneroro
TRADECON-TRACTONTHADE NUMHER WORK
PERF0H11EU GENERALFORCE
CONTRACTORS
nEw PEHsonia.
PanyChief NAME HOU
hununem M:m .
| votsj?- i*T L( 7 0% fjL Kit _ NL{¾¶Ÿyodpan 1
( W¬ VV4t ( AhW W\RR c .. ........... . . . . .. .- -............. Ele orOpgalor
Ma e Mechmna - - - --
. r Ù (T- T . & LiborerForenmn
0:her
. & LL CbÅ'/ y d TEMPORARYSERVICES
Steam
Fmers
IStTOR
RURRISH
7 CONTROLLEDINSPECTION -----
y oMMENTS-
ncrete
Reinforcemem
Steel ___-.-
......... Cunainwan
., .... Fireepping OTHER:
4., .. , -- .. Geolech
(Subpadc)
TOTAL
TOTAL SUt"T:
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019
3!!NMt M IRADECATEGORIES
PLAZA DAHX REPORT
SUPERINTENDENT'S 1.suPc ahecmnplded
at¹herudCwh d "
( ON2I( IfcTaDN -. -/.r...- r..9..rnM . r- TF.MPf'RATlif4E 1-
2.Thewnrk
rescrip
innshould
becrmcisc
andspwilic.
dono encrfr. "
PROJEO DATE: 3.The tecopyismtwfurwardedtotheProject who
Manm:rr wH
-- review
and
rorwardtotheSenior M;magr
Project and Pro.K·a
Endhe.
NO..-
PROJECT DAY no wrxrn
attheýffMthgl...
J. Therarhmc,y3i kepg wprdnwrtmn
mrpre .
CUMULATIVE 5. Mghecontpledon
oftheproject
mthemperitttmdent
wiHfrarward
DAYS tw nooks
Dany mtheProjeamnantrorb×kuparthNna
TRADE
CONTRACroR TRA
DE NiJMBER
] WORK PERFORMEo GENERALFORCE
CONTRACTORS
nEmPr.nso .
-
wMJi b ½ L Dy RodMan
. . .. . 9 k1 ') l / t Labomr m
Forem
TOTAL
W TEWORARY SERVICES
No-wmmSMm
..... . ., umber
Document Filed Date
April 16, 2019
Case Filing Date
September 12, 2013
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 Exhibit D FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 a m FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 MINIMEMTRADiu:ATEGottIES L 5aperimendent are:=twcompic top,tars edastheenes orcarh work d:ty '"S" 'Wairr -fabrrhah. PLAZA SUPERINTENDENT'S DAILY REPORT oranlaw,than the ortheimrkthe·following normatunrkdar. * '' 'B'd'l-'''d '- -'mW"* &'' """' '"l''N S' '' cal3T 6.%'trN nuesv*|4 •nis a t; l'lilen fI.it·er"bli -W,72. 1m tg*ge 5prink 'rTi.'.f PF.RATt JR E: F AM 2.Thework uiescripilms stu,uldbeconcheand donotgenerahre. specific. -Lemme Carpeialern thnso..La ,,· Paiwr. Taeri, Shreinma trvAC I mg PROJECT: DATE: 3. the-knecnpy kinherarwarded testic Manager Project inhowin "''"" Er«mruw-sy-.n- Itwsm-So H Paci•=tWemmmA TdkiI'ana'ur.,n revitu andInrmardIntheSenior FrojectManager andProjecu Eucusite. C*** seamr- -n-twr ess, N.- cs.II,--o .ra sicern wtien applicasicand uise. ow u,wn,ec. e.con·,-.c re-- NO.: PROJECT DA C ' ' n-n ... e..or,mmu.ng nw wm- c.mm WF:AMR AM L Thecarbon iskepE recurds slfewiththesuperirHer.denF'i ;ttghe '' ,,, 74,, _y. Italitthen copy tliitit. CI*fnpf n - en CUMULATIVE 5. Atthecontplcuegs ortheproject willforward tothesuperintc1ident all t Ar ' 1 Tb DAYS: nailytonRoolo.tothePrnject Manager rarhackup archhiing. CONTRACTOR TRADE TRADE NUMBER PEHFORMEl) WORK CONTRACTORS GENERALFORCE PERSONNEL FIRLD .. .te stufs, PanyChief NAME IIOIIRS I htMrumentMan RodMan """I gd- Operators |Elevator Mechanics Master Maintenance Men (T- (r Foreman Laborer Laborers ( Other TOTM. TEMPORARYSERVICES - ( d t rd tNuwLqL w 4Ar S (Ar Wrvo Rrr . exiLM ..... __.. w- Finers Steam ShecamemI tryW3iler IbrnpomrvElectricians Oncrator I Flevator - VIStTORS- RUBBISH nolloffs .. .. CONTROLLEDINSPECTION couumrs N.ofla-p. Loncrete Structural Stect S.O.EP. Reinfineement Sicel __ Cturtainwall .. Firestopping GTIIER: Geotech(Subgrade) Other .. TOTAL FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 MINIMUMTRADECATEGORIES PLAZA SUPERINTENDENTSDAILYREPORT I- superinteadcau lae*=re coher•'utPh•Imds.•enCerrach mudday GI 4 ThOhni femh ricoA Hwd me -Ihdhimg• Mc.mr Fan.tW-fr¾ ornoInstrthanthestart arthe*•urk thefedowinestormost work stan. LtH×n; Critemr Hrnw.ers Nanrem cDitETainr t *DN u .whk -Warpm.r-itre f,,"cru .ter NsrINic .Brdgedrdsmd£ thraSrnmUer. TEMl-T Smeam RNTUk! AM a 2.Thework descriptionshouldberemchr donotgenerali andspecH1c. c. C enC rm ueen.wa. I.m.-.e Niren -Tw. sfmmcui. HVAC umtimr .- PROJEC'l: ·. .1.Thewhitecopy itinbeforwardnt mght.PmjeriWnager nbuwilt hieom-Spm f%merrr>. Sprn wies N.GngShectmeral Fire U:in e reviewand forwardIntheSenior Project ManagerandPrulwl Ewculhv. L'.ns-wNIwt h-wr Butve Nmtwn SWm-pi 1.«umwMrmmw whatsppilenbleand file. CW:"f ,on,.CW l'hmhm •Cu urer> Ltmu I ROJECTNO.: - , DAY: w~ ,4,.,,. .w,, c.., 4.Thecarten copyIskepimithesiic. wirb rtennis tiresut'erinicarica'½ EGT a M .rvDie '*• 4 unn1thejob complebon. .._ TA· CUMULATIVF i AttheCUmpletion oftheprojecututh ups.ringesident willrurnarit an M 1MHr DAYS: DailyI.ngIlooks totheProjeo Managerfurhatkuparchiving. c· meang_2.:3.-re set e. f-une.n Will Siemn IWen.undramnes rnADE CONTRÁt'TOtt TNADE MlMHER WORK PERFORMFm CONTRACTORS GENERAI.FORCE 1Et.0 I'ERSONNEI. PartyChief NWE Itotus Instrumeng Man a--- RajMan ElevatorOperamrs wn -. floistEngineers MusictMechanics M:ñmenanceMen $ Lv-U- 2- Laborer Foreman ..__..... h 1 Laboress b F 1 7 luntfc . ! Other Â,,. (so } .d) . (4. TOTAL 6 NSurnt-nW ( a ur..- Wt..-5 \/M{ M 60t4WTe Nvt- tWhvvy vtaem s ; h LnnM 0) r bYL ¾ noaMan Oper:nors () PM4-¾W WfrvT %¶½A iGM @ 7vaO Elev;nor IloistEneinects . & \f t4G \ () Lashp 7 b 5 N WfrÅ 6) 4,L 2~ TD TL L Aw /4 usa Mechames I AA- .) '¶71 My if\d } MannenanceMen . Forenmn Laborer OW --- th1 Ov &T r£¾v]W f bytWvtWW W Y TOTAL 81th' p --- b L . N %'LAM ')\‰Ç (tyQ ¾Qy) Q .6L Av(a n+*s er us v stv« c o TEMPORARYSERVICES Finers Sleam Shectmetal . -- Plumlwr .. . ..- ... .. ... -. Tempomy Water . Electricians iTemporary VISITORS: R( THISH RollOff.s CONTROLLEDINSPECTION COMMMTN: K BN a c c & u Conc e Stee Reinforcemem Cunainwall ---- OTHElt: Other TOTAL mm FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 H b m m p ; m m z FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 MINIMrM TR.WF.GTEGORIES L Sa inicodnu m IninopletedMh owlofachwork f'- 4' C T' " Wehrt PLAZA SUPERINTENDENT'S DAILYREPORT day TIO,4 CN .5 nu Wng ....a_+ O- T + 52Um 181PEltATURE. P AM . . 2.Thework ..tmidhemutivamispreific. descripthm ilo,mu pocrnlim c n . n ow.c (b Cm.M.:fw n:s..-thic C.«pers ecr-. h .,il P!..-t .Kn $hNMce PROJECT: DATE: 3. nonwropyim wthi- r-nia nowP «swer am«m "C" -o ra e- review andforward to Senior Projeti Mamner:mdProint hecuthe. PROJECT NO.: DAY: " ..o w3- c Tme M 4.Theourimn itWµtatthe& withitwsuper!nte,nitnCs mpy rect.rds . a.x.g. untilthejob cu1nplenism. Cr -n -. a.u 16. rakta .r CUMULATIVE a o DAYS stoare Pro«t Maneroro TRADECON-TRACTONTHADE NUMHER WORK PERF0H11EU GENERALFORCE CONTRACTORS nEw PEHsonia. PanyChief NAME HOU hununem M:m . | votsj?- i*T L( 7 0% fjL Kit _ NL{¾¶Ÿyodpan 1 ( W¬ VV4t ( AhW W\RR c .. ........... . . . . .. .- -............. Ele orOpgalor Ma e Mechmna - - - -- . r Ù (T- T . & LiborerForenmn 0:her . & LL CbÅ'/ y d TEMPORARYSERVICES Steam Fmers IStTOR RURRISH 7 CONTROLLEDINSPECTION ----- y oMMENTS- ncrete Reinforcemem Steel ___-.- ......... Cunainwan ., .... Fireepping OTHER: 4., .. , -- .. Geolech (Subpadc) TOTAL TOTAL SUt"T: FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/16/2019 03:55 PM INDEX NO. 158327/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 269 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/16/2019 3!!NMt M IRADECATEGORIES PLAZA DAHX REPORT SUPERINTENDENT'S 1.suPc ahecmnplded at¹herudCwh d " ( ON2I( IfcTaDN -. -/.r...- r..9..rnM . r- TF.MPf'RATlif4E 1- 2.Thewnrk rescrip innshould becrmcisc andspwilic. dono encrfr. " PROJEO DATE: 3.The tecopyismtwfurwardedtotheProject who Manm:rr wH -- review and rorwardtotheSenior M;magr Project and Pro.K·a Endhe. NO..- PROJECT DAY no wrxrn attheýffMthgl... J. Therarhmc,y3i kepg wprdnwrtmn mrpre . CUMULATIVE 5. Mghecontpledon oftheproject mthemperitttmdent wiHfrarward DAYS tw nooks Dany mtheProjeamnantrorb×kuparthNna TRADE CONTRACroR TRA DE NiJMBER ] WORK PERFORMEo GENERALFORCE CONTRACTORS nEmPr.nso . - wMJi b ½ L Dy RodMan . . .. . 9 k1 ') l / t Labomr m Forem TOTAL W TEWORARY SERVICES No-wmmSMm ..... . ., umber