Exhibit,Appendix: Joan Gray v. Smbc Capital Markets, Inc.

On August 27, 2020 a Exhibit,Appendix was filed involving a dispute between Joan Gray, and Smbc Capital Markets, Inc., for Torts - Other (Employment Discrimination) in the District Court of New York County.
						
                                Preview
                                iD:            YORK         PK           WV          INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
                               OUN          0:0
NYSCEF     BOC.   NO.   68                             RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023




                                     Exhibit U
INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
FILED:         NEW         YORK      COUNTY        CLERK        05/03/2023           10:03       AM
NYSCEF     DOC.     NO.    68                                                                              RECEIVED     NYSCEF:    05/03/2023
    Message
    From:                 Nancy Erika Smith [nsmith@smithmullin.com]
    Sent:                 3/8/2023 4:38:07 PM
    To:                   Kappelman, Lynn [/o=Seyfarth/ou=First Administrative Group/cn=Recipients/cn=LKappelman]
    cc:                   DiNapoli, John [/o=Seyfarth/ou=First Administrative Group/cn=Recipients/cn=JDiNapoli]; Ravi Sattiraju
                          [rsattiraju@s-tlawfirm.com]; Dawn Opizzi [dopizzi@smithmullin.com]; Virginia Pallotto [vpallotto@smithmullin.com]
    Subject:              RE: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates




         This Message Is From an External Sender
         This message came from outside your organization.



    Okay. Please provide dates for the other noticed witnesses and the other information requested so
    we can continue to schedule.

                  NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                  SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                  240 Claremont Ave.
                  Montclair, NJ 07042
                  Ph — (973) 783-7607
                  Fx — (973) 783 -9894
                  https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A_www.smithmullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_84JbrNh2g&r=FS4kRE2gMMnJQh_iNjV-
     c2QAXsSEIfHS3N6RkcVSyLWw&m=HDAiJgep7dylO878cbd9rJOxl34eXW91 0mjilUAxx5QZt4n06zXlO
    W9IGkHf_gn_&s=opP6lzI-97qfhgF30pUhZg4od00OUfWEZ0Gsu_ycuXc&e=

    Follow me on Twitter!
           @NancyErikaSmith


    conn    Original Message -----
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Wednesday,               March    8, 2023 10:57 AM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Ce: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    Okay | know John is working hard on that so let’s hold April 4 for Ms. Gray.


    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490



    Lynn A. Kappelman | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP
    Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 | Boston, Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360
    Labor & Employment Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015
    Ikappelman@seyfarth.com | http://www.seyfarth.com
    [Read Seyfarth's Twitter Feed]
INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
FILED:       NEW        YORK   COUNTY   CLERK   05/03/2023       10:03     AM
NYSCEF   DOC.     NO.   68                                                        RECEIVED   NYSCEF:    05/03/2023


    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


    On Mar 8, 2023, at 10:35 AM, Nancy Erika Smith  wrote:


    Yes, if we get the discovery next week. NANCY ERIKA SMITH SMITH MULLIN, P.C. 240 Claremont
    Ave. Montclair, NJ 07042 Ph — (973) 783-7607 Fx — (973) 783 -9894
    https: //urldefense. proofpoint. com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin. com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=YuzaOjNoJitwSvCLFzk2k_vUG4iT_COwHdvRBOqC-
    JDsbQDK7MRmPAh4XUdQ8QCt&s=XwAoAVaMWUCWFPQoNXLSBHJOT3ZWluMVAnBqQWa-
    jTU&e=

    Yes, if we get the discovery next week.

                NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                240 Claremont Ave.
                Montclair, NJ 07042
                Ph — (973) 783-7607
          Fx — (973) 783 -9894
          https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwilGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=YuzaOjNoJitwSvCLFzk2k                 vUG4iT    COwHdvRBOgC-
    JDsbQDK7MRmPAh4XUdQ8QCt&s=XwAoA9IaMWUCWFPQoNXLSBHJOT3ZWluMVAnBqQWa-
    jTU&e=

    Followme on Twitter!
            @NancyErikaSmith


    imei Original Message fescue
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Wednesday, March 8, 2023 9:53 AM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Ce: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    Can we do Ms. Gray’s deposition by zoom on April 4 if we start at 9:30?
INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
FILED:       NEW      YORK   COUNTY    CLERK     05/03/2023        10:03    AM
NYSCEF   DOC.   NO.   68                                                            RECEIVED   NYSCEF      05/03/2023



    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490




    Lynn A. Kappelman | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP
    Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 | Boston, Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360
    Labor & Employment Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015
    Ikappelman@seyfarth.com | http://www.seyfarth.com
    [Read Seyfarth's Twitter Feed]

    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING:            This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


    On Mar 8, 2023, at 9:51 AM, Kappelman, Lynn  wrote:



    Some of the dates we proposed for depositions are dates which John had available and | did not.              |
    am likely taking Ms. Gray's deposition but we need to get it done so let’s please just pick a date and
    we will cover it. Let me get you a couple of options when | am available and we can see if that works.



    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490



    Lynn A. Kappelman | Partner
    Boston | Ext: 724888 (+1-617-946-4888) | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490
    Ikappelman@seyfarth.com

    On Mar 8, 2023, at 9:48 AM, Nancy Erika Smith  wrote:


    Lynn, | want to move forward with all of these depositions as soon as possible, but, as | made clear
    below, we need the requested discovery in order to do so. If you get us the discovery by March 15th, |
    can produce Ms. Gray on March 30th (a


    Lynn,
            | want to move forward with all of these depositions as soon as possible, but, as | made     clear
    below, we need the requested discovery in order to do so. If you get us the discovery by March 15th, |
INDEX     NO.   156852/2020
FILED:        NEW     YORK     COUNTY    CLERK     05/03/2023        10:03    AM
NYSCEF   DOC.   NO.   68                                                              RECEIVED    NYSCEF:   05/03/2023

    can produce Ms. Gray on March 30th (a date you proposed for depositions). But none of these
    depositions will go forward if we have to move to compel the outstanding discovery. Please let us
    know right away, because if we have to file a motion, we want to do so immediately.

        Also, please provide the information repeatedly requested regarding the witnesses we noticed
    who are not on your list below.

    Thanks.
    Nancy

    none Original Message. anna
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Tuesday, March 7, 2023 8:20 PM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Ce: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    Let’s hold the depositions of Paul Stolbof on April 18 and Robin Milberg on April 25th by zoom absent
    objection by anyone? John please confirm that date with Robin ASAP. Are there dates after that for
    Gus Moore that you want us to check on?         Are you going to produce Joan Gray for her deposition?


    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490




    Lynn A. Kappelman | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 |
    Boston,     Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360 Labor               & Employment
    Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015 Ikappelman@seyfarth.com | http:/Avww.seyfarth.com [Read
    Seyfarth's Twitter Feed]

    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


    On Mar 7, 2023, at 4:06 PM, Nancy Erika Smith  wrote:


    Okay. Thanks.          NANCY   ERIKA SMITH   SMITH   MULLIN,   P.C. 240 Claremont Ave. Montclair, NJ
    07042 Ph — (973) 783-7607 Fx — (973) 783 -9894 https: //urldefense. proofpoint. com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfinGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=kxHc0oUfJoMmBewKapSZqu2uvaJ9zfF 2d38pNmz18K1Sw-
    iwp8lOA2kz6QS|OpJJ&s=_HAnxBaPCUVU8VpEFBvMHKTKOU_gtlwXyaed3n-fsxY
                                                                  &e=
INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
FILED:      NEW         YORK   COUNTY     CLERK   05/03/2023    10:03     AM
NYSCEF   DOC.     NO.   68                                                       RECEIVED   NYSCEF    05/03/2023


    Okay. Thanks.

                NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                240 Claremont Ave.
                Montclair, NJ 07042
                Ph — (973) 783-7607
                Fx - (973) 783 -9894
          https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=kxHc0oUfJoMmBewKapSZqu2uvaJ9zfF2d38pNmz18K1Sw-
    iwp8lIOA2kz6QS|OpJJ&s=             HAnxBaPCUVU8VpEFBvMHKTKOU_gtlwXyaed3n-fsxY
                                                                               &e=

    Followmesme>onTwitter!
          @NancyErikaSmith


    esta Original Message essicace
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Tuesday, March 7, 2023 4:05 PM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Ce: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    We gave it to you for Gus Moore whom John is defending....but | will check to see if Paul is available.


    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490
INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
FILED:        NEW       YORK   COUNTY     CLERK    05/03/2023       10:03   AM
NYSCEF   DOC.     NO.   68                                                           RECEIVED     NYSCEF:    05/03/2023


    Lynn A. Kappelman | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 |
    Boston,      Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360 Labor & Employment
    Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015 Ikappelman@seyfarth.com | http://www.seyfarth.com [Read
    Seyfarth's Twitter Feed]

    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


    On   Mar 7, 2023, at 4:04 PM,       Nancy Erika Smith     wrote:



    The 18th is a date you gave us. But how about March 30th or 31st? NANCY          ERIKA SMITH SMITH
    MULLIN, P.C. 240 Claremont Ave. Montclair, NJ 07042 Ph — (973) 783-7607 Fx — (973) 783 -9894
    https: //urldefense. proofpoint. com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin. com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=7M6TVEsKkOeekmrRq-X_UK4ylkwpSfRrC7qFGephFhQ-
    sSRSGKZtWSMKH2DH6Qr3&s=sZINr6spwjuiNyRZOsh2T-22UskB638hQZIWVdorohk&e=


    The 18th is a date you gave us. But how about March 30th or 31st?

                NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                240 Claremont Ave.
                Montclair, NJ 07042
                Ph — (973) 783-7607
                Fx — (973) 783 -9894
                https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=7M6TVEsKkOeekmrRq-X_Uk4ylkwpSfRrC7qgF GephFhQ-
    sSRSGKZtWSMKH2DH6Qr3&s=sZINr6spwijuiNyRZOsh2T-22UskB638hQZIWVdorohk&e=

    Eollowmesme>onshttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A___www.smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=7M6TVEsKkOeekmrRg-X_Uk4ylkwpSfRrC7gF GephFhQ-
    sSRSGKZtWSMKH2DH6Qr3&s=sZINr6spwiuiNyRZOsh2T-22UskB638hQZIWVdorohk&e=

    Eollowmeme>on>Twitter!
           @NancyErikaSmith


    reine Original Message-----
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Tuesday, March 7, 2023 4:01 PM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Ce: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    Well | do not know that either Stolbof or | are available on 4/18.   We will check but if not, do you want
    to give us a few options. We have busy schedules and have been waiting for you to respond about
    these dates.


    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490
INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
FILED:        NEW       YORK   COUNTY     CLERK    05/03/2023       10:03    AM
NYSCEF   DOC.     NO.   68                                                           RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023




    Lynn A. Kappelman          | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 |
    Boston,      Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360 Labor & Employment
    Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015 Ikappelman@seyfarth.com | http://www.seyfarth.com [Read
    Seyfarth's Twitter Feed]

    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


    On Mar 7, 2023, at 3:54 PM, Nancy Erika Smith  wrote:


    | don't want two main witnesses back to back. | can do Stolbof on the 18 or 19th. Milberg on the 25th
    or 26th. And we can look at dates after that for Moore etc. NANCY ERIKA SMITH SMITH MULLIN,
    P.C. 240 Claremont Ave. Montclair, NJ 07042 Ph


    | don't want two main witnesses back to back. | can do Stolbof on the 18 or 19th. Milberg on the 25th
    or 26th. And we can look at dates after that for Moore etc.

                NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                240 Claremont Ave.
                Montclair, NJ 07042
                Ph — (973) 783-7607
                Fx — (973) 783 -9894
                https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-
    ZUIAXOrKY 6TigMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=if[33FqXVvnUkJwB                     SueXEDHTyMzDMODJQ
    9ZV36Q1eM&e=

    Eollowmesullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEG
    Follow>YGDxv-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNY CRaNizdjHvmqWw-ZUiAXOrkKY6TigM
(FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/03/72023                     10:03   AM           INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
NYSCEF   DOC.   NO.   68                                                     RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023


    Follow>meullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEG
    Follow>YGDxv-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNY CRaNizdjHvmqW-ZUiIAXOrkKY6TigM
    Follow>JVYfem7DkgoHcezjKM5j9ZD64 gm&s=iff33FqXVvnUkJwB_SueXEDHTyMzDMODJQ9Z
    Follow>V36Q1eM&e=

    Eollowme>onshttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqWw-
    ZUIAXOrKY6TiqMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=iff33FqXVvnUkJwB_SueXEDHTyMzDMODJQ
    9ZV36Q1eM&e=

    Followmeshttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__www.smithm
    Follow>ullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_ 84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEG
    Follow>Y GDxv-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqWw-ZUiAXOrKY6TigM
    Follow>JVYfcm7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=iff33FqXVvnUkJwB_SueXEDHTyMzDMODJQ9Z
    Follow>V36Q1eM&e=

    Eollowme>on>Twitter!>        @NancyErikaSmith


    ni   Original Message-----
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Tuesday, March 7, 2023 3:51 PM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Cc: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates
INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
FILED:           NEW         YORK   COUNTY    CLERK     05/03/2023      10:03   AM
NYSCEF        DOC.     NO.   68                                                      RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023


    So can we nail down the dates for each? | think this was what we proposed but forgive me if | am
    mistaken.

    1. Paul Stolbof (April 25, 26)
         2.    Gus Moore (April 18, 19, 24)
         3. Robin Milberg (April 25, 26)
         4.    Chrissy Cutrona (March 30, 31; April 6, 13, 21)

    Based on your desire for a different order, how about Stobof April 25, Milberg April 26, and we go
    back to the drawing board for Moore for a date after Milberg?


    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490



    Lynn A. Kappelman | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 |
    Boston, Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360 Labor & Employment
    Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015 Ikappelman@seyfarth.com | http://www.seyfarth.com [Read
    Seyfarth's Twitter Feed]

    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


    On Mar 7, 2023, at 3:45 PM, Nancy Erika Smith  wrote:


    | said the dates you proposed are fine. [See below] NANCY ERIKA SMITH SMITH MULLIN, P.C. 240
    Claremont Ave. Montclair, NJ 07042 Ph — (973) 783-7607 Fx — (973) 783 -9894
    www. smithmullin.com [smithmullin.com] Follow me on Twitter! @NancyErikaSmith


    | said the dates you proposed are fine. [See below]

                     NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                     SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                     240 Claremont Ave.
                     Montclair, NJ 07042
                     Ph — (973) 783-7607
                     Fx — (973) 783 -9894
                     https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A_www.smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-


                                                                                                                   10
INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
FILED:        NEW       YORK   COUNTY     CLERK    05/03/2023       10:03     AM
NYSCEF     DOC.   NO.   68                                                              RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023

    3A__smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_ 84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-
    ZUIAXOrKY6TiqMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=JOwXJivgZsUhTBQWNZSR7CgMQWOeE08
    Lidz      BBnQQT4&e=]

    Follows

    Follow>men.com&d=Dw|lGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_              84JbrNh2g&r=V0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDx
    Follow>    @NancyErikaSmith


    noneOriginal Message-----
    From: Kappelman, Lynn 
    Sent: Tuesday, March 7, 2023 3:44 PM
    To: Nancy Erika Smith 
    Ce: DiNapoli, John ; Ravi Sattiraju ; Dawn
    Opizzi ; Virginia Pallotto 
    Subject: Re: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    That is quite a speech. Can you at least give us the dates attached to your proposed deposition for
    each individual below so we can see if they, and we , are even available on the dates you now
    propose?


    Lynn A. Kappelman; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; work 617-946-4888; cell 617-699-3490




    Lynn A. Kappelman          | Partner | Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seaport East | Two Seaport Lane, Suite 1200 |
    Boston, Massachusetts 02210-2028
    Direct: +1-617-946-4888 | Mobile: +1-617-699-3490 | Fax: +1-617-790-5360 Labor & Employment
    Team of the Year - Chambers USA 2015
    lkappelman@seyfarth.com               |
    http://www.seyfarth.com [Read Seyfarth's Twitter
    Feed]

    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth_Logo_Signature.png]


    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is
    for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this
    communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the
    sender immediately and delete it from your system.


                                                                                                                      11
INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
FILED:      NEW         YORK   COUNTY    CLERK     05/03/2023      10:03   AM
NYSCEF   DOC.     NO.   68                                                        RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023




    On   Mar 7, 2023, at 3:35 PM, Nancy Erika Smith
    > wrote:


    Counsel, You have not even bothered to respond to the email below, and you did not produce any
    further discovery, not even the discovery you agreed to produce. We agreed to exchange written
    discovery before depositions, yet you have withheld

    Counsel,
               You have not even bothered to respond to the email below, and you did not produce any
    further discovery, not even the discovery you agreed to produce. We agreed to exchange written
    discovery before depositions, yet you have withheld some of the most significant written discovery.
              You have also refused, for weeks now, to provide the names of the persons noticed for
    deposition who you will not represent at depositions or to provide the last known addresses of the
    former employees who you will not represent at depositions. You also have not moved for a
    protective order regarding the depositions of current employees (if any — since you refuse to tell us
    who is who).
              Finally, we will depose the witnesses we noticed in the order noticed, not in your preferred
    order. The dates you provided are fine. We will take them in this order: Stolbof, Milberg, Moore,
    Friedlander (absent a protective order), Diamond (absent a protective order) and continuing in the
    order noticed.
              We will be filing a motion to compel the long-outstanding discovery and to compel the
    depositions of persons you refuse to produce as well as for the addresses of those who you will not
    represent and who are no longer employed.
    Nancy

                NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                240 Claremont Ave.
                Montclair, NJ 07042
                Ph — (973) 783-7607
                Fx — (973) 783 -9894
                https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-
    ZUIAXOrKY 6TigMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=if[33FqXVvnUkJwB_SueXEDHTyMzDMODJQ
    9ZV36Q1eM&e=Jhttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_84JbrNh2g&r=VO0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-
    ZUIAXOrKY6TigMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=JOwXJfvgZsUhTBQWNZSR7CgMQWOeE08
    Lidz_ BBnQQT4&e=]shttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwMGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=hmSV_iRJL8X_QwFtBitITTtOwrOyZYRI7zicOi8fmEfs2eRfIBcCGWJE7pe
    1P0acR&s=a5J1VibWP-DOJy-
    BxLT0jqguQZMWmBQryEYsDSd0BeOo&e=>/hittps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-



                                                                                                                12
INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
(FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/03/72023                        10:03    AM
NYSCEF   DOC.   NO.   68                                                               RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023

    3A__www.smithmullin.com_&d=DwMGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=kEY Ot9Kr9nLm3atVoMIQmRLgOdgVi5f3OEl-
    J9ZOLEKBV2Yu9fPTtO1Fcv32Q1dxX&s=xvGLejm 1sW5ubFzaUzObnkKxcW2RvX0d5AkSiIK4RxU9c&e=
    e>
    
    
    Follow>meshttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A _smithmulli
    Follow>n.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_84JbrNh2g&r=V0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDx
    Follow>v-dF yOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNY CRaNizdjHvmqW-ZUiIAXOrKY6TiqgMJVYF
    Follow>cm7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=JOwXJfvgZsUhTBQWNZSR7CgMQWOeE08L1dz_ BBnQ
    Follow>QT4&e=]mullin.com&d=DwQGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=V0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGE
    Follow>GYGDxv-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=hmSV_iRJL8X_9wFtBitITTtOwrOyZYRI7zicO
    Follow>i8fmEfs2eRfIBcGWJE7pe1P0acR&s=IAvkbDoL3HF3X-f5T82ZdzHpx-vOgn9F84F
    Follow>P5f4aH8U&e=>] _www.smithmullin.com_&d=DwMGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzL
    Follow>cyfPLOWfnGEGY GDxv-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=kEYOt9kKr9nLm3atVoMIQmRLgOd
    Follow>qVi5f30EI-J9ZOL6KBV2Yu9fPTtO1Fev32Q1dX&s=xvGLejm1sW5ubFzaUzObnkxe
    Follow>W2RvX0d5AkSiK4RxU9c&e=>
    
    
    Follow]
    
    simage005.jpg>
    Follow>me>onshttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A        _www.smi
    Follow>me>thmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwb>
    @NancyErikaSmith


    From: Nancy Erika Smith
    Sent: Thursday, March 2, 2023 3:00 PM
    To: 'DiNapoli, John' >;             Ravi Sattiraju
    >
    Cc: Kappelman, Lynn >; Dawn
    Opizzi >; Virginia Pallotto
    >
    Subject: RE: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    John,
                Will you be producing the discovery requested months ago, and limited in our recent
    correspondence (without prejudice to our continuing to seek the discovery we put on hold) in order to
    receive it in time to prepare for plaintiff's deposition?


                                                                                                                     13
(FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/03/72023                          10:03   AM         INDEX   NO.    156852/2020
NYSCEF   DOC.     NO.   68                                                      RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023

    Nancy

                NANCY ERIKA SMITH
                SMITH MULLIN, P.C.
                240 Claremont Ave.
                Montclair, NJ 07042
                Ph — (973) 783-7607
                Fx - (973) 783 -9894
                https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-
    ZUiIAXOrKY6TiqMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=iff33FqXVvnUkJwB_SueXEDHTyMzDMODJQ
    9ZV36Q1eMé&e=Jhttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A___smithmullin.com&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_84JbrNh2g&r=VO0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqw-
    ZUIAXOrKY6TiqMJVY fom7DkgoHczjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=JOwXJivgZsUhTBQWNZSR7CgMQWOeE08
    L1dz_ BBnQQT4&e=]shttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__www.smithmullin.com&d=DwMGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-
    K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=hmSV_iRJL8X_9wFtBitITTtOwrOyZYRI7zicOi8fmEfs2eRfIBCGWJE7pe
    1P0acR&s=a5J1VibWP-DOJy-
    BxLTOjqguQZMWmBQryEYsDSd0BeOo&e=>/hittps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A___smithmullin.com&d=DwilGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_84JbrNh2g&r=VOlpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqWw-
    ZUiIAXOrKY6TiqMJVYfcem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=JOwXJfvqZsUhTBQWNZSR7CgMQWOeE08
    L1dz_ BBnQQT4&e=Jhttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-
    3A__smithmullin.ccom&d=DwlGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=VO0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDxv-
    dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=AHQJzyGyNYCRaNizdjHvmqW-
    ZUiIAXOrKY6TiqMJVYfem7DkgoHezjKM5j9ZD64gm&s=JOwXJfvqZsUhTBQWNZSR7CgMQWOeE08
    Lidz    BBnQQT4&e=]]
    
    
    Follow]
    
    Follow>me>onme>thmullin.com&d=DwiGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwb>
    @NancyErikaSmith


    From:   DiNapoli, John
    >>
    Sent: Thursday, March 2, 2023 2:09 PM
    To: Ravi Sattiraju >>
    Cc: Kappelman, Lynn
    >>; Nancy Erika Smith
    >>; Dawn Opizzi
    >>; Virginia Pallotto
    >>
    Subject: RE: Gray v. SMBC - Deposition Dates

    Ravi & Nancy,
    Gus Moore is no longer available the week of April 10, but is available April 18, 19, and 24.
    Please advise whether these depositions will be in-person or remote. Also, please let us know on
    which dates you are available to depose the below witnesses, as our calendars are filling up, and
    whether you will be producing Ms. Gray for her remote deposition on March 15. Lastly, we note that
    Plaintiff has not filed her discovery extension request yet.


    John DiNapoli (he/him/his) | Counsel | Seyfarth Shaw LLP
    620 Eighth Avenue | New York, New York 10018-1405
    Direct: +1-212-218-3355 | Fax: +1-917-344-1187
    jdinapoli@seyfarth.com> | http://www.seyfarth.com>
    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth       Logo   Signature.png]



    CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING:>This=http://http-3A   _www.seyfarth.com-253Chttp-3A  _www.seyfarth.com
    CONFIDENTIALITY>&d=DwMGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K_84JbrNh2g&r=VO0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEG
    CONFIDENTIALITY>YGDxv-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=hmSV_iRJL8X_ QwFtBitITTtOwrOyZ
    CONFIDENTIALITY>YRI7zicOi8fmEfs2eRflBcGWJE7pe1 P0acR&s=3fe6NBull0g2XCTUJ7
    CONFIDENTIALITY>OIGMkC9Ppr3GfQW DPdMU0ld7A&e=>>
    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth   Logo   Signature.png]



    CONFIDENTIALITY >
    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth   Logo   Signature.png]



    CONFIDENTIALITY>WARNING:-3A__www.seyfarth.com-253Chttp-3A       _www.seyfarth.com&d=Dw
    CONFIDENTIALITY>MGaQ&c=fMwtGtbwbi-K 84JbrNh2g&r=VO0lpEzLcyfPLOWfnGEGYGDx
    CONFIDENTIALITY>-dFyOWZvGNejKaECSv8&m=hmSV_iRJL8X_9QwFtBItITTtOwrOyZYRI7z
    CONFIDENTIALITY >icOi8fmEfs2eRflBcGWJE7pe1 P0acR&s=3fe6NBull0g2XCTUJ7OI6Mk
    CONFIDENTIALITY>C9Ppr3GfQWDPdMUOId7A&e=>>
     https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth Logo Signature.png


    CONFIDENTIALITY >
    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth   Logo   Signature.png]



    CONFIDENTIALITY>WARNING:>This>email>
    [https://www.seyfarth.com/dir_docs/publications/Seyfarth   Logo   Signature.png]

                        >containprivileged or confidential information and is for the sole use of the
    intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this communication is prohibited. If you
    believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete it
    from your system.

    From: DiNapoli, John
    Sent: Friday, February 24, 2023 1:06 PM




                                                                                                                16
INDEX   NO.   156852/2020
FILED:          NEW       YORK   COUNTY      CLERK      05/03/2023   10:03   AM
NYSCEF       DOC.   NO.   68                                                      RECEIVED   NYSCEF:   05/03/2023

    To: 'Ravi Sattiraju' >>
    Cc: Kappelman, Lynn
     >>; Nancy Erika Smith
    >>; Dawn Opizzi
    >>; Virginia Pallotto
    >>
    Subject: Gray v. SMBC          - Deposition Dates

    Ravi,
    The availability of the individuals to be deposed, discussed in our prior correspondence, is below.

         1    Paul Stolbof (April 25, 26)
         2    Gus Moore (April 11, 12, 14, 24)
         3    Robin Milberg (April 25, 26)
         4    Chrissy Cutrona (March 30, 31; April 6, 13, 21)




                                                                                                                17
Case Info

Judge
Paul A. Goetz Track Judge’s New Case
Case No.
(Subscribe to View)
Document Filed Date
May 03, 2023
Case Filing Date
August 27, 2020
County
Parties

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.