On January 11, 2023 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
Louann Associates Llc
And All Other Plaintiffs Similarly Situated Identified In The Annexed Exhibit A Affecting The Parcels Listed Therein By Section, Block, And Lot Description,
and
Albertson Fire Company,,
Albertson Water District,,
Amityville School District,,
Baldwin School District,,
Barnum Island Fire District,,
Bay Park Fire District,,
Bayville Fire Company No. 1,,
Belgrave Water Pollution Control District,,
Bellerose Fire District,,
Bellerose Terrace Fire Department,,
Bellmore School District,,
Bethpage Water District,,
Bruce A. Blakeman,
In His Official Capacity As Nassau County Executive,,
Carle Place Water District,,
Cathedral Gardens Water District,,
City Of Glen Cove,,
City Of Long Beach,,
City Of Long Beach Public Works Division Of Sewer Maintenance,,
County Of Nassau,,
David Y. Chiang,
In His Official Capacity As Nassau County Treasurer,,
East Williston Fire District,,
Elmont Fire District,,
Farmingdale School District,,
Floral Park-Bellerose Fire District,,
Flower Hill Hose Company No. 1,,
Franklin Square-Munson Fire District,,
Freeport School District,,
Freeport Village,
Garden City School District,,
Garden City Water And Sewer Department,,
Glen Cove School District,,
Glen Cove Water Department,,
Glenwood Landing Fire Department,,
Glenwood Water District,,
Greater Atlantic Beach Water Reclamation District,,
Great Neck Water Pollution Control District,,
Hempstead School District,,
Herricks School District,,
Hewlett Fire District,,
Hewlett-Woodmere School District,,
Hicksville Water District,,
Incorporated Village Of Bayville School District,,
Incorporated Village Of Williston Park Water Department,,
Inwood Fire District,,
Island Trees School District,,
Jericho Water District,,
Lake Success Village,
Lakeview School District,,
Lawrence-Cedarhurst Fire District,,
Lawrence Union Free School District,,
Levittown School District,,
Locust Valley Water District,,
Long Beach School District,,
Lynbrook Water District,,
Malverne School District,,
Manhasset-Lakeville Water District,,
Manhasset School District,,
Manorhaven Village,
Massapequa Water District,,
Matthew R. Cronin,
In His Official Capacity As Assessor Of The County Of Nassau,,
Meadowmere Park Fire District,,
Merrick Union Free School District,,
Mineola School District,,
Mineola Village,
Nassau County Department Of Assessment,,
Nassau County Department Of Public Works,,
Nassau County Legislature,,
Nassau County Police Department,,
New Hyde Park-Garden City Park School District,,
New Hyde Park-Garden City Ufsd,,
New York American Water-Merrick,,
New York American Water-Sea Cliff,,
North Shore School District,,
Oceanside School District,,
Oyster Bay-East Norwich Central School District,,
Plainedge Public Schools,,
Plainview-Old Bethpage School District,,
Plainview Water District,,
Plandome Fire Department,,
Point Lookout-Lido Fire District,,
Port Washington Water Pollution Control District,,
Rockville Centre School District,,
Rockville Centre Village,
Roosevelt School District,,
Roslyn Village,
Roslyn Water District,,
Sanitary District 6,,
Sanitary District No. 2,,
Sea Cliff Fire District,,
Seaford School District,,
South Floral Park Fire Department,,
South Hempstead Fire District,,
Stewart Manor Fire District,,
Syosset School District,
Town Of Hempstead,,
Town Of Hempstead Water Department,,
Town Of North Hempstead,,
Town Of Oyster Bay,,
Uniondale School District,,
Valley Stream Fire District,,
Valley Stream School District 13,,
Valley Stream School District 24,,
Valley Stream School District 30,,
Village Of Hempstead Water Department,,
Village Of Mineola Water Department,,
Village Of Old Westbury Water Department,,
Village Of Rockville Centre Water Department,,
Village Of Sands Point Water Department,,
Wantagh School District,,
Water Authority Of Great Neck North,,
Westbury Water District,,
West Hempstead Water District,,
Williston Park Fire District,,
Woodbury Fire Company No. 1,,
Woodmere Fire District,,
for Real Property - Tax Certiorari
in the District Court of Nassau County.
Preview
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
EXHIBIT A
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NASSAU
----_____________---------________--Ç
In the Matter of the Application of:
LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC,
and all other Plaintiffs similarly situated identified
"A" SUMMONS
in the annexed Exhibit affecting the parcels listed
therein by Section, Block, and Lot description, Index No.: ( O0100 /2D23
Plaintiffs,
-against-
BRUCE A. BLAKEMAÑ, in his official capacity as
NASSAU COUNTY EXECUTIVE,
MATTHEW R. CRONIN, in his official capacity as
ASSESSOR OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU,
DAVID Y. CHIANG, in his official capacity as
NASSAU COUNTY TREASURER,
NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT,
NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATURE, COUNTY
OF NASSAU, ALBERTSON FIRE COMPANY,
ALBERTSON WATER DISTRICT,
AMITYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BALDWIN FIRE DISTRICT,
BALDWIN SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BARNUM ISLAND FIRE DISTRICT,
BAY PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
BAYVILLE FIRE COMPANY NO. 1,
BELGRAVE WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL DISTRICT,
BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT,
BELLEROSE TERRACE FIRE DEPARTMENT,
BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT,
BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BETHPAGE FIRE DISTRICT,
BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BETHPAGE WATER DISTRICT,
CARLE PLACE FIRE DISTRICT,
CARLE PLACE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
CARLE PLACE WATER DISTRICT,
CATHEDRAL GARDENS WATER DISTRICT,
CITY OF GLEN COVE,
CITY OF LONG BEACH,
CITY OF LONG BEACH PUBLIC WORKS
{003145052 } ...
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
DIVISION OF SEWER MAINTENANCE,
EAST MEADOW FIRE DISTRICT,
EAST MEADOW SCHOOL DISTRICT,
EAST NORWICH FIRE DISTRICT,
EAST ROCKAWAY FIRE DISTRICT,
EAST ROCKAWAY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
EAST WILLISTON SCHOOL DISTRICT,
EAST WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT,
ELMONT SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ELMONT FIRE DISTRICT,
FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT
FARMINGDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT
FLOWER HILL HOSE COMPANY NO. 1,
FRANKLIN SQUARE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FRANKLIN SQUARE WATER DISTRICT,
FRANKLIN SQUARE-MUNSON FIRE DISTRICT,
FREEPORT FIRE DISTRICT,
FREEPORT SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FREEPORT VILLAGE
(SÈWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
OARDEN CITY FIRE DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY PARK WATER DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY WATER AND SEWER DEPARTMENT,
GLEN COVE FIRE DISTRICT,
GLEN COVE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
GLEN COVE WATER DEPARTMENT,
GLENWOOD FIRE DISTRICT,
GLENWOOD LANDING FIRE DEPARTMENT,
GLENWOOD WATER DISTRICT,
GREAT NECK FIRE DISTRICT,
GREAT NECK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
GREAT NECK WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL DISTRICT,
GREATER ATLANTIC BEACH WATER
RECLAMATION DISTRICT,
HEMPSTEAD CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT,
HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT,
HERRICKS SCHOOL DISTRICT,
{00314505
2} 2
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
HEWLETT FIRE DISTRICT,
HEWLETT-WOODMERE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
HICKSVILLE FIRE DISTRICT,
HICKSVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
HICKSVILLE WATER DISTRICT,
INCORPORA'“ED VILLAGE OF
BAYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
BAYVILLE WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
EAST WILLISTON WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
FARMINGDALE WATER DEPARTMENT,
1NCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
FREEPORT WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
PLANDOME WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
WILLISTON PARK WATER DEPARTMENT,
INWOOD FIRE DISTRICT,
ISLAND PARK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ISLAND PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT-
SECOND BATTALION FIRE DISTRICT,
ISLAND TREES SCHOOL DISTRICT,
JERICHO FIRE DISTRICT,
JERICHO SCHOOL DISTRICT,
JERICHO WATER DISTRICT,
LAKE SUCCESS VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
LAKEVIEW FIRE DISTRICT,
LAKEVIEW SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LAWRENCE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LAWRENCE-CEDARHURST FIRE DISTRICT,
LEVITTOWN FIRE DISTRICT,
LEVITTOWN SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LOCUST VALLEY FIRE DISTRICT,
LOCUST VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LOCUST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT,
LONG BEACH FIRE DISTRICT,
LONG BEACH SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LYNBROOK FIRE DISTRICT,
LYNBROOK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LYNBROOK WATER DISTRICT,
MALVERNE CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
MALVERNE FIRE DISTRICT,
(003)4505
2}
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
MALVERNE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MANHASSET SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE FIRE DISTRICT,
MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE WATER DISTRICT,
MANORHAVEN VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT,
MASSAPEQUA SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MASSAPEQUA WATER DISTRICT, ..
MEADOWMERE PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT,
MERRICK UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MINEOLA FIRE DISTRICT,
MINEOLA SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MINEOLA VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT
OF PUBLIC WORKS,
NASSAU COUNTY POLICE DEPARTMENT,
NEW HYDE PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY UFSD,
NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY PARK
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER -
MERRICK,
NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER- SEA CLIFF,
NORTH BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT,
NORTH BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
NORTH MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT,
NORTH MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT,
NORTH MERRICK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
NORTH SHORE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
OCEANSIDE FIRE DISTRICT,
OCEANSIDE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY COMPANY 1 FIRE DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY SEWER DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY WATER DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY-EAST NORWICH CENTRAL,
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
PLAINEDGE PUBLIC SCHOOLS,
PLAINVIEW FIRE DISTRICT,
PLAINVIEW WATER DISTRICT,
PLAINVIEW-OLD BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
PLANDOME FIRE DEPARTMENT,
POINT LOOKOUT-LIDO FIRE DISTRICT,
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
PORT WASHINGTON FIRE DISTRICT,
PORT WASHINGTON SCHOOL DISTRICT,
PORT WASHINGTON WATER DISTRICT,
PORT WASHINGTON WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL DISTRICT,
ROCKVILLE.CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
ROCKVILLE CENTRE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ROCKVILLE CENTRE VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
ROOSEVELT FIRE DISTRICT,
ROOSEVELT SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ROSLYN FIRE DISTRICT,
ROSLYN SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ROSLYN WATER DISTRICT,
ROSLYN VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
SANITARY DISTRICT 6,
SANITARY DISTRICT NO. 2,
SEA CLIFF FIRE DISTRICT,
SEAFORD FIRE DISTRICT,
SEAFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT,
SOUTH FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT,
SOUTH FARMINGDALE WATER DISTRICT,
SOUTH FLORAL PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT,
SOUTH HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT,
STEWART MANOR FIRE DISTRICT,
SYOSSET CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,
SYOSSET FIRE DISTRICT,
SYOSSET SCHOOL DISTRICT (LOCUST GROVE),
TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD,
TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT,
TOWN OF NORTH HEMPSTEAD,
TOWN OF OYSTER BAY,
UNIONDALE FIRE DISTRICT,
UNIONDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 13,
VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 24,
VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 30,
VALLEY STREAM FIRE DISTRICT,
VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF M1NEOLA WATER DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF OLD WESTBURY WATER DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF ROCKVILLE CENTRE WATER DEPARTMENT,
2}
{00314505 5
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
VILLAGE OF SANDS POINT WATER DEPARTMENT,
WANTAGH FIRE DISTRICT,
WANTAGH SCHOOL DISTRICT,
WATER AUTHORITY OF GREAT NECK NORTH,
WEST HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT,
WEST HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT,
WEST HEMPSTEAD WATER DISTRICT,
WESTBURY CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
WESTBURY FIRE DISTRICT,
WESTBURY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
WESTBURY WATER DISTRICT,
WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT,
WILLISTON PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
WOODBURY FIRE COMPANY NO. 1,
WOODMERE FIRE DISTRICT,
Defendants.
-----------------------------------------------------------X
Plaintiffs'
YOU ARE HEREBY SUMMONED and required to serve upon attorneys an
answer to the Complaint of Jacquelyn L. Mascetti, Esq., attorney for the Plaintiffs LOUANN
ASSOCIATES LLC., et al., sworn to on December 29, 2022, together with the Exhibits annexed
thereto, within twenty (20) days after the service of this Summons, exclusive of the day of
service (or within thirty (30) days after the service is complete if this summons is not personally
delivered to you within the State of New York), and in the case of your failure to appear or
answer, judgment will be taken against you by default for the relief demanded in the Complaint.
Dated: Melville, New York
January 11, 2023
HERMAN KATZ CANGEMI WILKES & CLYNE, LLP
JA UEL L. MASCE , ESQ.
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
538 Broadhollow Road, Suite 307
Melville, New York 11747
p. (631) 501-5011
f. (631) 501-5012
(003l45052 } 6
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NASSAU
__-___________________________________..___________________Ç
In the Matter of the Application of:
COMPLAINT
LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC,
and all other Plaintiffs similarly situated identified
"A"
in the annexed Exhibit affecting the parcels listed Index No.: (pD0·lD0 2.02.3
therein by Section, Block, and Lot description,
Plaintiffs,
-against-
BRUCE A. BLAKEMAN, in his official capacity as
NASSAU COUNTY EXECUTIVE,
MATTHEW R. CRONIN, in his official capacity as
ASSESSOR OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU,
DAVID Y. CHIANG, in his official capacity as
NASSAU COUNTY TREASURER,
NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT,
NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATURE, COUNTY
OF NASSAU, ALBERTSON FIRE COMPANY,
ALBERTSON WATER DISTRICT,
AMITYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BALDWIN FIRE DISTRICT,
BALDWIN SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BARNUM ISLAND FIRE DISTRICT,
BAY PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
BAYVILLE FIRE COMPANY NO. 1,
BELGRAVE WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL DISTRICT,
BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT,
BELLEROSE TERRACE FIRE DEPARTMENT,
BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT,
BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BETHPAGE FIRE DISTRICT,
BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
BETHPAGE WATER DISTRICT,
CARLE PLACE FIRE DISTRICT,
CARLE PLACE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
CARLE PLACE WATER DISTRICT,
CATHEDRAL GARDENS WATER DISTRICT,
CITY OF GLEN COVE,
CITY OF LONG BEACH,
CITY OF LONG BEACH PUBLIC WORKS
{00314505
2} 7
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
DIVISION OF SEWER MAINTENANCE,
EAST MEADOW FIRE DISTRICT,
EAST MEADOW SCHOOL DISTRICT,
EAST NORWICH FIRE DISTRICT,
EAST ROCKAWAY FIRE DISTRICT,
EAST ROCKAWAY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
EAST WILLISTON SCHOOL DISTRICT,
.EAST WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT,
ELMONT SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ELMONT FIRE DISTRICT,
FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT,
FARMINGDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT,
FLOWER HILL HOSE COMPANY NO. 1,
FRANKLIN SQUARE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FRANKLIN SQUARE WATER DISTRICT,
FRANKLIN SQUARE-MUNSON FIRE DISTRICT,
FREEPORT FIRE DISTRICT,
FREEPORT SCHOOL DISTRICT,
FREEPORT VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
GARDEN CITY FIRE DISTRICT, .
GARDEN CITY PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY PARK WATER DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
GARDEN CITY WATER AND SEWER DEPARTMENT,
GLEN COVE FIRE DISTRICT,
GLEN COVE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
GLEN COVE WATER DEPARTMENT,
GLENWOOD FIRE DISTRICT,
GLENWOOD LANDING FIRE DEPARTMENT,
GLENWOOD WATER DISTRICT,
GREAT NECK FIRE DISTRICT,
GREAT NECK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
GREAT NECK WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL DISTRICT,
GREATER ATLANTIC BEACH WATER
RECLAMATION DISTRICT,
HEMPSTEAD CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT,
HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT,
HERRICKS SCHOOL DISTRICT,
{003l45052 } ...
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
HEWLETT FIRE DISTRICT,
HEWLETT-WOODMERE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
HICKSVILLE FIRE DISTRICT,
HICKSVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
HICKSVILLE WATER DISTRICT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
BAYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
BAYVILLE WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
EAST WILLISTON WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
FARMINGDALE WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
FREEPORT WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
PLANDOME WATER DEPARTMENT,
INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF
WILLISTON PARK WATER DEPARTMENT,
INWOOD FIRE DISTRICT,
ISLAND PARK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ISLAND PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT -
SECOND BATTALION FIRE DISTRICT,
ISLAND TREES SCHOOL DISTRICT,
JERICHO FIRE DISTRICT,
JERICHO SCHOOL DISTRICT,
JERICHO WATER DISTRICT,
LAKE SUCCESS VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
LAKEVIEW FIRE DISTRICT,
LAKEVIEW SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LAWRENCE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LAWRENCE-CEDARHURST FIRE DISTRICT,
LEVITTOWN FIRE DISTRICT,
LEVITTOWN SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LOCUST VALLEY FIRE DISTRICT,
LOCUST VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LOCUST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT,
LONG BEACH FIRE DISTRICT,
LONG BEACH SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LYNBROOK FIRE DISTRICT,
LYNBROOK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
LYNBROOK WATER DISTRICT,
MALVERNE CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
MALVERNE FIRE DISTRICT,
(00314505
23 9 ...
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
MALVERNE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MANHASSET SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE FIRE DISTRICT,
MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE WATER DISTRICT,
MANORHAVEN VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT,
MASSAPEQUA SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MASSAPEQUA WATER DISTRICT,
MEADOWMERE PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT,
MERRICK UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MINEOLA FIRE DISTRICT,
MINEOLA SCHOOL DISTRICT,
MINEOLA VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), .
NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT
OF PUBLIC WORKS,
NASSAU COUNTY POLICE DEPARTMENT,
NEW HYDE PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY UFSD,
NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY PARK
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER- MERRICK,
NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER - SEA
CLIFF,
NORTH BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT,
NORTH BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
NORTH MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT,
NORTH MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT,
NORTH MERRICK SCHOOL DISTRICT,
NORTH SHORE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
OCEANSIDE FIRE DISTRICT,
OCEANSIDE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY COMPANY 1 FIRE DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY SEWER DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY WATER DISTRICT,
OYSTER BAY-EAST NORWICH CENTRAL,
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
PLAINEDGE PUBLIC SCHOOLS,
PLAINVIEW FIRE DISTRICT,
PLAINVIEW WATER DISTRICT,
PLAINVIEW-OLD BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
PLANDOME FIRE DEPARTMENT,
POINT LOOKOUT-LIDO FIRE DISTRICT,
2)
(o0314505 10
....
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
. .
PORT WASHINGTON FIRE DISTRICT,
PORT WASHINGTON SCHOOL DISTRICT,
PORT WASHINGTON WATER DISTRICT,
PORT WASHINGTON WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL DISTRICT,
ROCKVILLE CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
ROCKVILLE CENTRE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ROCKVILLE CENTRE VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
ROOSEVELT FIRE DISTRICT,
ROOSEVELT SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ROSLYN FIRE DISTRICT,
ROSLYN SCHOOL DISTRICT,
ROSLYN WATER DISTRICT,
ROSLYN VILLAGE
(SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT),
SANITARY DISTRICT 6,
SANITARY DISTRICT NO. 2,
SEA CLIFF FIRE DISTRICT,
SEAFORD FIRE DISTRICT,
SEAFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT,
SOUTH FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT,
SOUTH FARMINGDALE WATER DISTRICT,
SOUTH FLORAL PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT,
SOUTH HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT,
STEWART MANOR FIRE DISTRICT,
SYOSSET CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,
SYOSSET FIRE DISTRICT,
SYOSSET SCHOOL DISTRICT (LOCUST GROVE),
TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD,
TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT,
TOWN OF NORTH HEMPSTEAD,
TOWN OF OYSTER BAY,
UNIONDALE FIRE DISTRICT,
UNIONDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT,
VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 13,
VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 24,
VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 30,
VALLEY STREAM FIRE DISTRICT,
VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF MINEOLA WATER DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF OLD WESTBURY WATER DEPARTMENT,
VILLAGE OF ROCKVILLE CENTRE WATER DEPARTMENT,
{00314505
2} ...
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
VILLAGE OF SANDS POINT WATER DEPARTMENT,
WANTAGH FIRE DISTRICT,
WANTAGH SCHOOL DISTRICT,
WATER AUTHORITY OF GREAT NECK NORTH,
WEST HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT,
WEST HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT,
€EST HEMPSTEAD WATER DISTRICT,
WESTBURY CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT,
WESTBURY FIRE DISTRICT,
WESTBURY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
WESTBURY WATER DISTRICT,
WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT,
WILLISTON PARK FIRE DISTRICT,
WOODBURY FIRE COMPANY NO. 1,
WOODMERE FIRE DISTRICT,
Defendants.
---------------------------------------------------------------------X
Plaintiffs, LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC., et al., by their attorneys, HERMAN KATZ
CANGEMI WILKES & CLYNE, LLP, as and for their Complaint in the above-captioned
proceeding, respectfully allege and petition the Court as follows:
1. As attorney for the Plaintiffs, I am fully familiar with all the facts herein.
2. Plaintiffs, LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC., and all other similarly situated
Plaintiffs identified in the annexed Exhibit A (hereinafter "Plaintiffs"), were at all relevant
times, the owners, net lessees, and/or aggrieved parties, and/or payers of taxes of certain real
property located within the County of Nassau, designated on the tax maps as set forth in the
annexed list, and incorporated herein. S List, attached hereto as Exhibit "A".
3. Defendant, BRUCE A. BLAKEMAN, in his official capacity as the NASSAU
COUNTY EXECUTIVE, is the duly elected Nassau County Executive, having his principal
office at 1550 Franklin Avenue, Mineola, New York 11501 (the "County Executive"). From
January 1, 2018, to December 31, 2022, Laura Curran was the County Executive. Prior to
January 1, 2018, Edward P. Mangano was the County Executive for all other relevant periods.
2}
(00314305 12 ...
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023
4. Defendant, MATTHEW R. CRONIN, in his official capacity as the ASSESSOR
OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU, is the County Assessor for the County of Nassau, having his
principal office at 240 Old Country Road, Mineola, New York 11501 (the "Assessor"). From
June 20 18 to January 2021, David Moog served as the Acting Assessor. From January 2021 to
May 2022, Robin Laveman served as the Acting Assessor. Prior to June 2018, James E. Davis
served as the Acting Assessor of Nassau County for all other relevant periods,
5. Defendant, DAVID Y. CHIANG, in his official capacity as the TREASURER OF
THE COUNTY OF NASSAU, is the County Treasurer for the County of Nassau, having his
principal office at 1 West Street, Mineola, New York 11501 (the "Treasurer"). Prior to February
2022, Beaumont Jefferson served as the Treasurer of the County of Nassau for all relevant
periods.
6. Defendant, NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATURE, is the legislative body of the
County of Nassau, comprised of nineteen (19) duly elected legislators from single member
districts having its principal offices at 1550 Franklin Avenue, Mineola, New York 11501 (the
Legislature"
"Nassau County or the "Legislature").
7. Defendant, COUNTY OF NASSAU, is a municipal corporation duly organized
and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of New York, operates pursuant to the
Nassau County Charter, and having its principal offices at 1550 Franklin Avenue, Mineola, New
York 11501 ("the County").
8. Defendant, ALBERTSON FIRE COMPANY, is a municipal corporation
organized and existing under
Preview
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 EXHIBIT A FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NASSAU ----_____________---------________--Ç In the Matter of the Application of: LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC, and all other Plaintiffs similarly situated identified "A" SUMMONS in the annexed Exhibit affecting the parcels listed therein by Section, Block, and Lot description, Index No.: ( O0100 /2D23 Plaintiffs, -against- BRUCE A. BLAKEMAÑ, in his official capacity as NASSAU COUNTY EXECUTIVE, MATTHEW R. CRONIN, in his official capacity as ASSESSOR OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU, DAVID Y. CHIANG, in his official capacity as NASSAU COUNTY TREASURER, NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT, NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATURE, COUNTY OF NASSAU, ALBERTSON FIRE COMPANY, ALBERTSON WATER DISTRICT, AMITYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT, BALDWIN FIRE DISTRICT, BALDWIN SCHOOL DISTRICT, BARNUM ISLAND FIRE DISTRICT, BAY PARK FIRE DISTRICT, BAYVILLE FIRE COMPANY NO. 1, BELGRAVE WATER POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT, BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT, BELLEROSE TERRACE FIRE DEPARTMENT, BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT, BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT, BETHPAGE FIRE DISTRICT, BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT, BETHPAGE WATER DISTRICT, CARLE PLACE FIRE DISTRICT, CARLE PLACE SCHOOL DISTRICT, CARLE PLACE WATER DISTRICT, CATHEDRAL GARDENS WATER DISTRICT, CITY OF GLEN COVE, CITY OF LONG BEACH, CITY OF LONG BEACH PUBLIC WORKS {003145052 } ... FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 DIVISION OF SEWER MAINTENANCE, EAST MEADOW FIRE DISTRICT, EAST MEADOW SCHOOL DISTRICT, EAST NORWICH FIRE DISTRICT, EAST ROCKAWAY FIRE DISTRICT, EAST ROCKAWAY SCHOOL DISTRICT, EAST WILLISTON SCHOOL DISTRICT, EAST WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT, ELMONT SCHOOL DISTRICT, ELMONT FIRE DISTRICT, FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT FARMINGDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK FIRE DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE SCHOOL DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT FLOWER HILL HOSE COMPANY NO. 1, FRANKLIN SQUARE SCHOOL DISTRICT, FRANKLIN SQUARE WATER DISTRICT, FRANKLIN SQUARE-MUNSON FIRE DISTRICT, FREEPORT FIRE DISTRICT, FREEPORT SCHOOL DISTRICT, FREEPORT VILLAGE (SÈWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), OARDEN CITY FIRE DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY PARK FIRE DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY PARK WATER DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY WATER AND SEWER DEPARTMENT, GLEN COVE FIRE DISTRICT, GLEN COVE SCHOOL DISTRICT, GLEN COVE WATER DEPARTMENT, GLENWOOD FIRE DISTRICT, GLENWOOD LANDING FIRE DEPARTMENT, GLENWOOD WATER DISTRICT, GREAT NECK FIRE DISTRICT, GREAT NECK SCHOOL DISTRICT, GREAT NECK WATER POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT, GREATER ATLANTIC BEACH WATER RECLAMATION DISTRICT, HEMPSTEAD CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT, HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT, HERRICKS SCHOOL DISTRICT, {00314505 2} 2 FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 HEWLETT FIRE DISTRICT, HEWLETT-WOODMERE SCHOOL DISTRICT, HICKSVILLE FIRE DISTRICT, HICKSVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT, HICKSVILLE WATER DISTRICT, INCORPORA'“ED VILLAGE OF BAYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF BAYVILLE WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF EAST WILLISTON WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF FARMINGDALE WATER DEPARTMENT, 1NCORPORATED VILLAGE OF FREEPORT WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF PLANDOME WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF WILLISTON PARK WATER DEPARTMENT, INWOOD FIRE DISTRICT, ISLAND PARK SCHOOL DISTRICT, ISLAND PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT- SECOND BATTALION FIRE DISTRICT, ISLAND TREES SCHOOL DISTRICT, JERICHO FIRE DISTRICT, JERICHO SCHOOL DISTRICT, JERICHO WATER DISTRICT, LAKE SUCCESS VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), LAKEVIEW FIRE DISTRICT, LAKEVIEW SCHOOL DISTRICT, LAWRENCE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT, LAWRENCE-CEDARHURST FIRE DISTRICT, LEVITTOWN FIRE DISTRICT, LEVITTOWN SCHOOL DISTRICT, LOCUST VALLEY FIRE DISTRICT, LOCUST VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT, LOCUST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT, LONG BEACH FIRE DISTRICT, LONG BEACH SCHOOL DISTRICT, LYNBROOK FIRE DISTRICT, LYNBROOK SCHOOL DISTRICT, LYNBROOK WATER DISTRICT, MALVERNE CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, MALVERNE FIRE DISTRICT, (003)4505 2} FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 MALVERNE SCHOOL DISTRICT, MANHASSET SCHOOL DISTRICT, MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE FIRE DISTRICT, MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE PARK FIRE DISTRICT, MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE WATER DISTRICT, MANORHAVEN VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT, MASSAPEQUA SCHOOL DISTRICT, MASSAPEQUA WATER DISTRICT, .. MEADOWMERE PARK FIRE DISTRICT, MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT, MERRICK UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT, MINEOLA FIRE DISTRICT, MINEOLA SCHOOL DISTRICT, MINEOLA VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS, NASSAU COUNTY POLICE DEPARTMENT, NEW HYDE PARK FIRE DISTRICT, NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY UFSD, NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY PARK SCHOOL DISTRICT, NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER - MERRICK, NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER- SEA CLIFF, NORTH BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT, NORTH BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT, NORTH MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT, NORTH MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT, NORTH MERRICK SCHOOL DISTRICT, NORTH SHORE SCHOOL DISTRICT, OCEANSIDE FIRE DISTRICT, OCEANSIDE SCHOOL DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY COMPANY 1 FIRE DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY SEWER DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY WATER DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY-EAST NORWICH CENTRAL, SCHOOL DISTRICT, PLAINEDGE PUBLIC SCHOOLS, PLAINVIEW FIRE DISTRICT, PLAINVIEW WATER DISTRICT, PLAINVIEW-OLD BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT, PLANDOME FIRE DEPARTMENT, POINT LOOKOUT-LIDO FIRE DISTRICT, FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 PORT WASHINGTON FIRE DISTRICT, PORT WASHINGTON SCHOOL DISTRICT, PORT WASHINGTON WATER DISTRICT, PORT WASHINGTON WATER POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT, ROCKVILLE.CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, ROCKVILLE CENTRE SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROCKVILLE CENTRE VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), ROOSEVELT FIRE DISTRICT, ROOSEVELT SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROSLYN FIRE DISTRICT, ROSLYN SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROSLYN WATER DISTRICT, ROSLYN VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), SANITARY DISTRICT 6, SANITARY DISTRICT NO. 2, SEA CLIFF FIRE DISTRICT, SEAFORD FIRE DISTRICT, SEAFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT, SOUTH FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT, SOUTH FARMINGDALE WATER DISTRICT, SOUTH FLORAL PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT, SOUTH HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT, STEWART MANOR FIRE DISTRICT, SYOSSET CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, SYOSSET FIRE DISTRICT, SYOSSET SCHOOL DISTRICT (LOCUST GROVE), TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD, TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT, TOWN OF NORTH HEMPSTEAD, TOWN OF OYSTER BAY, UNIONDALE FIRE DISTRICT, UNIONDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT, VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 13, VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 24, VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 30, VALLEY STREAM FIRE DISTRICT, VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF M1NEOLA WATER DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF OLD WESTBURY WATER DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF ROCKVILLE CENTRE WATER DEPARTMENT, 2} {00314505 5 FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 VILLAGE OF SANDS POINT WATER DEPARTMENT, WANTAGH FIRE DISTRICT, WANTAGH SCHOOL DISTRICT, WATER AUTHORITY OF GREAT NECK NORTH, WEST HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT, WEST HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT, WEST HEMPSTEAD WATER DISTRICT, WESTBURY CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, WESTBURY FIRE DISTRICT, WESTBURY SCHOOL DISTRICT, WESTBURY WATER DISTRICT, WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT, WILLISTON PARK FIRE DISTRICT, WOODBURY FIRE COMPANY NO. 1, WOODMERE FIRE DISTRICT, Defendants. -----------------------------------------------------------X Plaintiffs' YOU ARE HEREBY SUMMONED and required to serve upon attorneys an answer to the Complaint of Jacquelyn L. Mascetti, Esq., attorney for the Plaintiffs LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC., et al., sworn to on December 29, 2022, together with the Exhibits annexed thereto, within twenty (20) days after the service of this Summons, exclusive of the day of service (or within thirty (30) days after the service is complete if this summons is not personally delivered to you within the State of New York), and in the case of your failure to appear or answer, judgment will be taken against you by default for the relief demanded in the Complaint. Dated: Melville, New York January 11, 2023 HERMAN KATZ CANGEMI WILKES & CLYNE, LLP JA UEL L. MASCE , ESQ. Attorneys for Plaintiffs 538 Broadhollow Road, Suite 307 Melville, New York 11747 p. (631) 501-5011 f. (631) 501-5012 (003l45052 } 6 FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NASSAU __-___________________________________..___________________Ç In the Matter of the Application of: COMPLAINT LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC, and all other Plaintiffs similarly situated identified "A" in the annexed Exhibit affecting the parcels listed Index No.: (pD0·lD0 2.02.3 therein by Section, Block, and Lot description, Plaintiffs, -against- BRUCE A. BLAKEMAN, in his official capacity as NASSAU COUNTY EXECUTIVE, MATTHEW R. CRONIN, in his official capacity as ASSESSOR OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU, DAVID Y. CHIANG, in his official capacity as NASSAU COUNTY TREASURER, NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT, NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATURE, COUNTY OF NASSAU, ALBERTSON FIRE COMPANY, ALBERTSON WATER DISTRICT, AMITYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT, BALDWIN FIRE DISTRICT, BALDWIN SCHOOL DISTRICT, BARNUM ISLAND FIRE DISTRICT, BAY PARK FIRE DISTRICT, BAYVILLE FIRE COMPANY NO. 1, BELGRAVE WATER POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT, BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT, BELLEROSE TERRACE FIRE DEPARTMENT, BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT, BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT, BETHPAGE FIRE DISTRICT, BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT, BETHPAGE WATER DISTRICT, CARLE PLACE FIRE DISTRICT, CARLE PLACE SCHOOL DISTRICT, CARLE PLACE WATER DISTRICT, CATHEDRAL GARDENS WATER DISTRICT, CITY OF GLEN COVE, CITY OF LONG BEACH, CITY OF LONG BEACH PUBLIC WORKS {00314505 2} 7 FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 DIVISION OF SEWER MAINTENANCE, EAST MEADOW FIRE DISTRICT, EAST MEADOW SCHOOL DISTRICT, EAST NORWICH FIRE DISTRICT, EAST ROCKAWAY FIRE DISTRICT, EAST ROCKAWAY SCHOOL DISTRICT, EAST WILLISTON SCHOOL DISTRICT, .EAST WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT, ELMONT SCHOOL DISTRICT, ELMONT FIRE DISTRICT, FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT, FARMINGDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK FIRE DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE SCHOOL DISTRICT, FLORAL PARK-BELLEROSE FIRE DISTRICT, FLOWER HILL HOSE COMPANY NO. 1, FRANKLIN SQUARE SCHOOL DISTRICT, FRANKLIN SQUARE WATER DISTRICT, FRANKLIN SQUARE-MUNSON FIRE DISTRICT, FREEPORT FIRE DISTRICT, FREEPORT SCHOOL DISTRICT, FREEPORT VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), GARDEN CITY FIRE DISTRICT, . GARDEN CITY PARK FIRE DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY PARK WATER DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, GARDEN CITY WATER AND SEWER DEPARTMENT, GLEN COVE FIRE DISTRICT, GLEN COVE SCHOOL DISTRICT, GLEN COVE WATER DEPARTMENT, GLENWOOD FIRE DISTRICT, GLENWOOD LANDING FIRE DEPARTMENT, GLENWOOD WATER DISTRICT, GREAT NECK FIRE DISTRICT, GREAT NECK SCHOOL DISTRICT, GREAT NECK WATER POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT, GREATER ATLANTIC BEACH WATER RECLAMATION DISTRICT, HEMPSTEAD CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT, HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT, HERRICKS SCHOOL DISTRICT, {003l45052 } ... FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 HEWLETT FIRE DISTRICT, HEWLETT-WOODMERE SCHOOL DISTRICT, HICKSVILLE FIRE DISTRICT, HICKSVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT, HICKSVILLE WATER DISTRICT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF BAYVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF BAYVILLE WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF EAST WILLISTON WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF FARMINGDALE WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF FREEPORT WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF PLANDOME WATER DEPARTMENT, INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF WILLISTON PARK WATER DEPARTMENT, INWOOD FIRE DISTRICT, ISLAND PARK SCHOOL DISTRICT, ISLAND PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT - SECOND BATTALION FIRE DISTRICT, ISLAND TREES SCHOOL DISTRICT, JERICHO FIRE DISTRICT, JERICHO SCHOOL DISTRICT, JERICHO WATER DISTRICT, LAKE SUCCESS VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), LAKEVIEW FIRE DISTRICT, LAKEVIEW SCHOOL DISTRICT, LAWRENCE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT, LAWRENCE-CEDARHURST FIRE DISTRICT, LEVITTOWN FIRE DISTRICT, LEVITTOWN SCHOOL DISTRICT, LOCUST VALLEY FIRE DISTRICT, LOCUST VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT, LOCUST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT, LONG BEACH FIRE DISTRICT, LONG BEACH SCHOOL DISTRICT, LYNBROOK FIRE DISTRICT, LYNBROOK SCHOOL DISTRICT, LYNBROOK WATER DISTRICT, MALVERNE CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, MALVERNE FIRE DISTRICT, (00314505 23 9 ... FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 MALVERNE SCHOOL DISTRICT, MANHASSET SCHOOL DISTRICT, MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE FIRE DISTRICT, MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE PARK FIRE DISTRICT, MANHASSET-LAKEVILLE WATER DISTRICT, MANORHAVEN VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT, MASSAPEQUA SCHOOL DISTRICT, MASSAPEQUA WATER DISTRICT, MEADOWMERE PARK FIRE DISTRICT, MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT, MERRICK UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT, MINEOLA FIRE DISTRICT, MINEOLA SCHOOL DISTRICT, MINEOLA VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), . NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS, NASSAU COUNTY POLICE DEPARTMENT, NEW HYDE PARK FIRE DISTRICT, NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY UFSD, NEW HYDE PARK-GARDEN CITY PARK SCHOOL DISTRICT, NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER- MERRICK, NEW YORK AMERICAN WATER - SEA CLIFF, NORTH BELLMORE FIRE DISTRICT, NORTH BELLMORE SCHOOL DISTRICT, NORTH MASSAPEQUA FIRE DISTRICT, NORTH MERRICK FIRE DISTRICT, NORTH MERRICK SCHOOL DISTRICT, NORTH SHORE SCHOOL DISTRICT, OCEANSIDE FIRE DISTRICT, OCEANSIDE SCHOOL DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY COMPANY 1 FIRE DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY SEWER DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY WATER DISTRICT, OYSTER BAY-EAST NORWICH CENTRAL, SCHOOL DISTRICT, PLAINEDGE PUBLIC SCHOOLS, PLAINVIEW FIRE DISTRICT, PLAINVIEW WATER DISTRICT, PLAINVIEW-OLD BETHPAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT, PLANDOME FIRE DEPARTMENT, POINT LOOKOUT-LIDO FIRE DISTRICT, 2) (o0314505 10 .... FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 . . PORT WASHINGTON FIRE DISTRICT, PORT WASHINGTON SCHOOL DISTRICT, PORT WASHINGTON WATER DISTRICT, PORT WASHINGTON WATER POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT, ROCKVILLE CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, ROCKVILLE CENTRE SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROCKVILLE CENTRE VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), ROOSEVELT FIRE DISTRICT, ROOSEVELT SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROSLYN FIRE DISTRICT, ROSLYN SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROSLYN WATER DISTRICT, ROSLYN VILLAGE (SEWER COLLECTION DISTRICT), SANITARY DISTRICT 6, SANITARY DISTRICT NO. 2, SEA CLIFF FIRE DISTRICT, SEAFORD FIRE DISTRICT, SEAFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT, SOUTH FARMINGDALE FIRE DISTRICT, SOUTH FARMINGDALE WATER DISTRICT, SOUTH FLORAL PARK FIRE DEPARTMENT, SOUTH HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT, STEWART MANOR FIRE DISTRICT, SYOSSET CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, SYOSSET FIRE DISTRICT, SYOSSET SCHOOL DISTRICT (LOCUST GROVE), TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD, TOWN OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT, TOWN OF NORTH HEMPSTEAD, TOWN OF OYSTER BAY, UNIONDALE FIRE DISTRICT, UNIONDALE SCHOOL DISTRICT, VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 13, VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 24, VALLEY STREAM SCHOOL DISTRICT 30, VALLEY STREAM FIRE DISTRICT, VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF HEMPSTEAD WATER DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF MINEOLA WATER DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF OLD WESTBURY WATER DEPARTMENT, VILLAGE OF ROCKVILLE CENTRE WATER DEPARTMENT, {00314505 2} ... FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 VILLAGE OF SANDS POINT WATER DEPARTMENT, WANTAGH FIRE DISTRICT, WANTAGH SCHOOL DISTRICT, WATER AUTHORITY OF GREAT NECK NORTH, WEST HEMPSTEAD FIRE DISTRICT, WEST HEMPSTEAD SCHOOL DISTRICT, €EST HEMPSTEAD WATER DISTRICT, WESTBURY CENTRE FIRE DISTRICT, WESTBURY FIRE DISTRICT, WESTBURY SCHOOL DISTRICT, WESTBURY WATER DISTRICT, WILLISTON FIRE DISTRICT, WILLISTON PARK FIRE DISTRICT, WOODBURY FIRE COMPANY NO. 1, WOODMERE FIRE DISTRICT, Defendants. ---------------------------------------------------------------------X Plaintiffs, LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC., et al., by their attorneys, HERMAN KATZ CANGEMI WILKES & CLYNE, LLP, as and for their Complaint in the above-captioned proceeding, respectfully allege and petition the Court as follows: 1. As attorney for the Plaintiffs, I am fully familiar with all the facts herein. 2. Plaintiffs, LOUANN ASSOCIATES LLC., and all other similarly situated Plaintiffs identified in the annexed Exhibit A (hereinafter "Plaintiffs"), were at all relevant times, the owners, net lessees, and/or aggrieved parties, and/or payers of taxes of certain real property located within the County of Nassau, designated on the tax maps as set forth in the annexed list, and incorporated herein. S List, attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 3. Defendant, BRUCE A. BLAKEMAN, in his official capacity as the NASSAU COUNTY EXECUTIVE, is the duly elected Nassau County Executive, having his principal office at 1550 Franklin Avenue, Mineola, New York 11501 (the "County Executive"). From January 1, 2018, to December 31, 2022, Laura Curran was the County Executive. Prior to January 1, 2018, Edward P. Mangano was the County Executive for all other relevant periods. 2} (00314305 12 ... FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 05/09/2023 02:12 AM INDEX NO. 600700/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 140 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/09/2023 4. Defendant, MATTHEW R. CRONIN, in his official capacity as the ASSESSOR OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU, is the County Assessor for the County of Nassau, having his principal office at 240 Old Country Road, Mineola, New York 11501 (the "Assessor"). From June 20 18 to January 2021, David Moog served as the Acting Assessor. From January 2021 to May 2022, Robin Laveman served as the Acting Assessor. Prior to June 2018, James E. Davis served as the Acting Assessor of Nassau County for all other relevant periods, 5. Defendant, DAVID Y. CHIANG, in his official capacity as the TREASURER OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU, is the County Treasurer for the County of Nassau, having his principal office at 1 West Street, Mineola, New York 11501 (the "Treasurer"). Prior to February 2022, Beaumont Jefferson served as the Treasurer of the County of Nassau for all relevant periods. 6. Defendant, NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATURE, is the legislative body of the County of Nassau, comprised of nineteen (19) duly elected legislators from single member districts having its principal offices at 1550 Franklin Avenue, Mineola, New York 11501 (the Legislature" "Nassau County or the "Legislature"). 7. Defendant, COUNTY OF NASSAU, is a municipal corporation duly organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of New York, operates pursuant to the Nassau County Charter, and having its principal offices at 1550 Franklin Avenue, Mineola, New York 11501 ("the County"). 8. Defendant, ALBERTSON FIRE COMPANY, is a municipal corporation organized and existing under