On December 10, 2020 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
Patsy Young,
and
Aventis Inc.,
Avon Products, Inc.,
Block Drug Company, Inc.,
Block Drug Corporation,
Brenntag North America, Inc.,
Brenntag Specialties, Inc. F K A Mineral Pigment Solutions, Inc.,
Charles B. Chrystal Company, Inc.,
Chattem, Inc.,
Colgate-Palmolive Company,
Cyprus Amax Minerals Company,
Cyprus Mines Corporation,
Glaxosmithkline Llc (Sued Individually And As Successor-In-Interest To Block Drug Corporation, Successor-In-Interest To The Gold Bond Sterilizing Powder Company A K A The Gold Bond Company And As A Successor-In-Interest To Novartis Corporation And
Novartis Consumer Health Inc.),
Gsk Consumer Health, Inc. F K A Novartis Consumer Health Inc. F K A Ciba Self-Medication, Inc.,
Insight Pharmaceuticals Corporation, A Subsidiary Of Prestige Brands Holdings, Inc.,
Insight Pharmaceuticals Llc,
Macy'S Inc. F K A Federated Department Stores, Inc.,
Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation,
Prestige Brands Holdings, Inc.,
Prestige Consumer Healthcare Inc. F K A Prestige Brands, Inc.,
Sanofi-Aventis U.S. Llc,
Sanofi Us Services, Inc.,
Whittaker Clark & Daniels, Inc.,
for Torts - Asbestos
in the District Court of Erie County.
Preview
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023
EXHIBIT 32
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF:
P-&ab 03/03/2023
Heine J. (BBliW40) Jeauary 7, 1976
Eterman%
Birector, Division of Cosmeties Teahnalmsy
TEROUGH: Henry M. Davis, (35F-446)
Chief, Product Composition Branch
Ronald L. Yates, (377-446)
Product Compøeities Brandh
Tabulated Results of BCST5s Awaisses for Ashestes
Wearais in Levin, P5e14 activity surveillance (PAS),
Investigational and Consumer Cosmetic Tale Products.
Attached are a satise of tab%as date obtained from the
summarising
BCST analyses of eassette tale prodness for ashestes minawate.
for purposes of compariman, are pr. S. 2. Lexin's
Also ineladed,
analytical data obea4mad by x-ray diffractemetry.
Atemahmaarar
Table of Results of the Xavestigatices
a. Master table, "San=wy
of Weial Gammette Tale Prodents War Ambastes
Emehnology/'
M5marate by
S. K. 3wamin and the Bivision of commatic This
taMe contains analytical data of All the towin samples
analysed RCSL Included is Equin's data qa these samples.
by
For Asheetes
b. Table L "S*amanvy of Results of B68984 agalyses
Hinerate Sam91se Reposted by 1ýwin to conthia Tremolite
in Tale
Chrysottle." tab3a was extracted
and/or Informatten ta.this
from the master table and Itate only those mamples which Lenin
reported the presease of ashestee mimetals.
tales analysed Imin and Repersed to
e. Table IL "Cosmetic by
Chryseatie and/or Tremelina witish were met Analysed
contain
DCST Bithms BTA as Optical BCST does not
by by Nissescopy
samples listed in this table end, ther4fore, were
possese the
neable to analyse them.
ef BCSPs Amelyses of Cosmatte Tale Products
4. Table IEL "Summary
Analysis (D and 0ptf4$1N MeqSG@pyC
by Diffemmatial Thermal
This table by a.= dhat of samples DC$fe analysee
"==="*4*=",
HHS00000152
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023
e. Table TL "S*"mmary of aw & Lamis's .hmalyses of ceamarcial Geometic
Tales Fee Bifheetion,"
Tremelite and Chrysettle by X-Ray This
table swanawises, by assiber of emaples, S, L Lewife reemits
for all samples analysed.
hedest Composition Branch
HHS00000153
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023
r ..
-
54 53 52 50 42 38 37 35 29 26 14
63 62 61. 60 ,59 58 57 56 SAMPLE
#
Z
B Yves .
AvonApril Seven Quest Lewis Helen
T Macy's
Nacy's
Mennen
Riviana Desitin
Beloved Zeasorb Vaseline September Johnson's
BabySaint Baby
hnbush-Dana Winds Press1 Baby
Stowers Super bforn ·Talcum,
Scented Baby
Matchabelli Quinsana
Deadorant
Perfumed After By
Powder Intensive Powder
Unforgettable Laurent
. Dusting " Foot Apple Powder,
"Little
AND
Foods-Italian Powder
Bath Powder; Borated PRODUCF
AbsorbentRive Care Pond's
Dusting Lady" MFG. TATE
Pouler Powder NAMS
Perfumad BabyTalc; Stearin Talcum
Gauche
Powder,
Talc Medicated
Talc; Antibacterial; PEDUCTS
Powder SOM
spray DuBarry
For FOR
BY
Prince
PÁWderf Talc ·(same Pfizer
as Rice . TABLE
A5BESTOS
OF
Stiefel 130)
RESULTS
MINEBALS
(19B) (2K4) (028Q)
(9884) (I209) (H202) CODE
(1139Z) BYOF
(Fl021) (021085)
S.
TIE
3.
.
.
LENIN
S. AND
3. INVESTIGATI
THE
5% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND NO ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND OF
ND(2)
. Tremolite
Lewin's
D1VISION
(%)
OF
(DMMERCIAL
. Results O
? 7
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
. (X-Pay CO5METICS
SMETIC
Chrysotile
(%)
Diff.)
TECEINOLOGY
Optical
- - - - - - - Tracolite
- ND ND
600 200
700
36,000 ICST's
(.07%) (.06%) (.02%) Microscopy
(fiber/mg)
(3)
(3.6%)
(%) Results
? -
ND ND ND ND ND ND
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND. ND
DTA
Chrysotile
.
.
.
.
O OOO LO
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023
.
.
92 90 89 88 87 86 85 84 82 81 80 79 78 77 75 74 73 72 71 70 68 64
SAMPLE
, #
OH! AaB
Pure Jean Iady (bty
Mavis AlgayPond's Shower Touch JolieJeris
de Faberge
Yardley Max
Flamingo Cashnere Tbujours Face
Djer-Kiss
Constance BabyTo Nate Chantilly and Nedicated
Esther ,Talc,
Talcum; Dream Moi Madane
April Iondon
Talc Glow Feath
Dusting
Talcum; Shower Bouquet,
POWder, Face Flambeau
Powder
Carroll, Dusting Bath Ctmfort Flesh
Flower FaceTale; thes A
Dusting
Hypo-AllergenicBody Violets &
Vivaudou Dart AND
Powder, Powder, B "Fachel
PRODUCT
Ker)ooff Powder; Powder; Powder;
Face
Bouquet Imported Deodorant
Drug Yardley Powder, Powder,
Powder, MN.
PerfumedPowder; NAME
1ssy Talc Rachel
White Corday Spray(Airspun)
Talc
Powder Creamy
Houbigant Bachelle Balmain
Johnson ParhDavis
& Talcom Powder
Peach;
.
Povder
Johnson
. Revlon
.
-
(013D) (llF) (498)
(Ll047) (KllC) (4908) (37WBF) CODE
(5507BG)
(on.345)
. S.
7,.
5% 3% 5% 4% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 5% 3% ND ND ND ND 3% ND ND ND
NDe
Trenolite
Lewin's
(%)
. Results
? ? ? ? ? ? ?
5% 5% 5% 5% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
. ND.'
(X-Ray
Chrysota.1e
,.
(%)
Diff.)
.
, Optical
-. - c- - - Tremolite
ND ND ND NO 500 -·
7,3004,0002,9007,000 2,800
96,000 3,300
(.4%) (.7%) (.05%) Microscopy
(.73%) (.29%) (.28%)
(9.6%) (.33%) (fiber/mg)
.
(%).
? ? -
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND N0 "° ND ND ND ND ND
. . DTA
Unrytivu.n
p.
"
1 I O O r-
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023
.
99 97 96 95 94 93
149 148 145 143 138 137 136 135 134 133 131 107 102 101 100 SAMPLE
144A
#
A&B Tai Miss Asa Born ZBT
lady Coty Mavis
Softee Johnson Johnson
Johnson Johnson Johnson Tangee;
Pin-Zow Baby.
Solitaire Overton's & & & & Johnson's Ö
Johnson's Wild
Dior tander
ToscaWinds Body
Wayne
Face Muguet Blanchard's
Cake Talque; BabyBaby des Spray Powder
Face
Johnson Johnson
Johnson Johnson LilacsDusting
Johnson Dosting Dusting Pawder;
POWder Dusting Luft-Tangee
Bois Talc; and
Makeup Powler
Powder AND
Powder "High-Brown"
Shower
Shower
Shower Powder Powder Powder; PRODUCT
Perfection Avon Powder MFG.
Face to to to Medicated Medicated Roses Vivaudou
Dusting Del NNME
Beauty
Powder Shower
Shower Powder
Shower Powder Labs
POWder
Deodorant
BodyBodyBody
Body
Products,
Powder
Pauler
Powder Talc
Inc.
(2DO)
(108T)
(109T) (1171K) (B0048) CODE
(0872K) (0452K)
(C512Z)
(0709X1) (p0C1272)
.
. S.
E.
8 2 5 5
ND 5% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 10% 15% ND ND 12% 8% 2% -4%
. trace
Tremola.te
T.ewin's
. (%)
Besults
? 2 ?
ND ND ND ND ND ND 7% ND ND (D 3%
ND 10% ND ND 15% 10% 4%.
(X-Bay
Chrysot1.le
.
(%)
Diff.)
.
Optical
Tremolite
ND 400 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
300
3,000trace 1,800 8,900 trace 5,600 2,5005,100
60,000 13,000 DCST's
(6 (.03%) (.51 Microscopy
(.04%) )
(.3%) (.18%) (.89%) (.56%) (.25%)
) (filar/mg)
(1.3%)
(%) Results
- - -
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
.
i.7IA
Chrysotile
O OO LO
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF:
. 03/03/2023
169 168 167 165 164 163 160 159 150 157A156 155 154 153..152 151 SAMPLE
176A175A173A170A . #
.
"C" Dr. AvonAvonAvonNavis Rite Early
Tawny Grand Pinaud Warner Amens .
Lander
Lander Corsage
Corsage Colgate Aid Bisnoline
Mustus, Blue
Lyon's Tone Beauty Brocade Pure
Baby Bouquet Union
Lilac '1both Pure Powser, American
Inc. Clubman Lotus Imported Dasting
& Dusting Tooth Body
Baby Dust
cashmete-Beuquet Baby
Talc; BabyMedicated Old
Powder Talc
Roses Powdet Tale 'talcum
Perfumed
Powder Pculer; AND
Ponder; Powder Powder PefillPerfumed MedicatedSpice PRODUCT
From - Powder
Powder
Body Talc MEG.
Winarick,
Talc NAME
Tander
Talc Lander Talcon
Inc. Black
Co. Charisma
Powder
Heritage;
Beauty
.(2662) CODE
(101672)
(4212DX)
. 5.
L
6 2% ND 2% ND ND ND
ND ND ND ND ND ND 2% ND ND 10% ND ND ND
.
Trenellte
Lewin's
|%)
" Results
8 ? 1 ? ?
? ? ?
ND ND ND ND 8% ND ND ND ND ND
10%
trace (X-Ray
Chrysotile
(%)
Diff.)
.
Preview
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023 EXHIBIT 32 FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: P-&ab 03/03/2023 Heine J. (BBliW40) Jeauary 7, 1976 Eterman% Birector, Division of Cosmeties Teahnalmsy TEROUGH: Henry M. Davis, (35F-446) Chief, Product Composition Branch Ronald L. Yates, (377-446) Product Compøeities Brandh Tabulated Results of BCST5s Awaisses for Ashestes Wearais in Levin, P5e14 activity surveillance (PAS), Investigational and Consumer Cosmetic Tale Products. Attached are a satise of tab%as date obtained from the summarising BCST analyses of eassette tale prodness for ashestes minawate. for purposes of compariman, are pr. S. 2. Lexin's Also ineladed, analytical data obea4mad by x-ray diffractemetry. Atemahmaarar Table of Results of the Xavestigatices a. Master table, "San=wy of Weial Gammette Tale Prodents War Ambastes Emehnology/' M5marate by S. K. 3wamin and the Bivision of commatic This taMe contains analytical data of All the towin samples analysed RCSL Included is Equin's data qa these samples. by For Asheetes b. Table L "S*amanvy of Results of B68984 agalyses Hinerate Sam91se Reposted by 1ýwin to conthia Tremolite in Tale Chrysottle." tab3a was extracted and/or Informatten ta.this from the master table and Itate only those mamples which Lenin reported the presease of ashestee mimetals. tales analysed Imin and Repersed to e. Table IL "Cosmetic by Chryseatie and/or Tremelina witish were met Analysed contain DCST Bithms BTA as Optical BCST does not by by Nissescopy samples listed in this table end, ther4fore, were possese the neable to analyse them. ef BCSPs Amelyses of Cosmatte Tale Products 4. Table IEL "Summary Analysis (D and 0ptf4$1N MeqSG@pyC by Diffemmatial Thermal This table by a.= dhat of samples DC$fe analysee "==="*4*=", HHS00000152 FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023 e. Table TL "S*"mmary of aw & Lamis's .hmalyses of ceamarcial Geometic Tales Fee Bifheetion," Tremelite and Chrysettle by X-Ray This table swanawises, by assiber of emaples, S, L Lewife reemits for all samples analysed. hedest Composition Branch HHS00000153 FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023 r .. - 54 53 52 50 42 38 37 35 29 26 14 63 62 61. 60 ,59 58 57 56 SAMPLE # Z B Yves . AvonApril Seven Quest Lewis Helen T Macy's Nacy's Mennen Riviana Desitin Beloved Zeasorb Vaseline September Johnson's BabySaint Baby hnbush-Dana Winds Press1 Baby Stowers Super bforn ·Talcum, Scented Baby Matchabelli Quinsana Deadorant Perfumed After By Powder Intensive Powder Unforgettable Laurent . Dusting " Foot Apple Powder, "Little AND Foods-Italian Powder Bath Powder; Borated PRODUCF AbsorbentRive Care Pond's Dusting Lady" MFG. TATE Pouler Powder NAMS Perfumad BabyTalc; Stearin Talcum Gauche Powder, Talc Medicated Talc; Antibacterial; PEDUCTS Powder SOM spray DuBarry For FOR BY Prince PÁWderf Talc ·(same Pfizer as Rice . TABLE A5BESTOS OF Stiefel 130) RESULTS MINEBALS (19B) (2K4) (028Q) (9884) (I209) (H202) CODE (1139Z) BYOF (Fl021) (021085) S. TIE 3. . . LENIN S. AND 3. INVESTIGATI THE 5% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND NO ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND OF ND(2) . Tremolite Lewin's D1VISION (%) OF (DMMERCIAL . Results O ? 7 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND . (X-Pay CO5METICS SMETIC Chrysotile (%) Diff.) TECEINOLOGY Optical - - - - - - - Tracolite - ND ND 600 200 700 36,000 ICST's (.07%) (.06%) (.02%) Microscopy (fiber/mg) (3) (3.6%) (%) Results ? - ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND. ND DTA Chrysotile . . . . O OOO LO FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023 . . 92 90 89 88 87 86 85 84 82 81 80 79 78 77 75 74 73 72 71 70 68 64 SAMPLE , # OH! AaB Pure Jean Iady (bty Mavis AlgayPond's Shower Touch JolieJeris de Faberge Yardley Max Flamingo Cashnere Tbujours Face Djer-Kiss Constance BabyTo Nate Chantilly and Nedicated Esther ,Talc, Talcum; Dream Moi Madane April Iondon Talc Glow Feath Dusting Talcum; Shower Bouquet, POWder, Face Flambeau Powder Carroll, Dusting Bath Ctmfort Flesh Flower FaceTale; thes A Dusting Hypo-AllergenicBody Violets & Vivaudou Dart AND Powder, Powder, B "Fachel PRODUCT Ker)ooff Powder; Powder; Powder; Face Bouquet Imported Deodorant Drug Yardley Powder, Powder, Powder, MN. PerfumedPowder; NAME 1ssy Talc Rachel White Corday Spray(Airspun) Talc Powder Creamy Houbigant Bachelle Balmain Johnson ParhDavis & Talcom Powder Peach; . Povder Johnson . Revlon . - (013D) (llF) (498) (Ll047) (KllC) (4908) (37WBF) CODE (5507BG) (on.345) . S. 7,. 5% 3% 5% 4% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 5% 3% ND ND ND ND 3% ND ND ND NDe Trenolite Lewin's (%) . Results ? ? ? ? ? ? ? 5% 5% 5% 5% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND . ND.' (X-Ray Chrysota.1e ,. (%) Diff.) . , Optical -. - c- - - Tremolite ND ND ND NO 500 -· 7,3004,0002,9007,000 2,800 96,000 3,300 (.4%) (.7%) (.05%) Microscopy (.73%) (.29%) (.28%) (9.6%) (.33%) (fiber/mg) . (%). ? ? - ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND N0 "° ND ND ND ND ND . . DTA Unrytivu.n p. " 1 I O O r- FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/03/2023 . 99 97 96 95 94 93 149 148 145 143 138 137 136 135 134 133 131 107 102 101 100 SAMPLE 144A # A&B Tai Miss Asa Born ZBT lady Coty Mavis Softee Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson Tangee; Pin-Zow Baby. Solitaire Overton's & & & & Johnson's Ö Johnson's Wild Dior tander ToscaWinds Body Wayne Face Muguet Blanchard's Cake Talque; BabyBaby des Spray Powder Face Johnson Johnson Johnson Johnson LilacsDusting Johnson Dosting Dusting Pawder; POWder Dusting Luft-Tangee Bois Talc; and Makeup Powler Powder AND Powder "High-Brown" Shower Shower Shower Powder Powder Powder; PRODUCT Perfection Avon Powder MFG. Face to to to Medicated Medicated Roses Vivaudou Dusting Del NNME Beauty Powder Shower Shower Powder Shower Powder Labs POWder Deodorant BodyBodyBody Body Products, Powder Pauler Powder Talc Inc. (2DO) (108T) (109T) (1171K) (B0048) CODE (0872K) (0452K) (C512Z) (0709X1) (p0C1272) . . S. E. 8 2 5 5 ND 5% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 10% 15% ND ND 12% 8% 2% -4% . trace Tremola.te T.ewin's . (%) Besults ? 2 ? ND ND ND ND ND ND 7% ND ND (D 3% ND 10% ND ND 15% 10% 4%. (X-Bay Chrysot1.le . (%) Diff.) . Optical Tremolite ND 400 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 300 3,000trace 1,800 8,900 trace 5,600 2,5005,100 60,000 13,000 DCST's (6 (.03%) (.51 Microscopy (.04%) ) (.3%) (.18%) (.89%) (.56%) (.25%) ) (filar/mg) (1.3%) (%) Results - - - ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND . i.7IA Chrysotile O OO LO FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 03/03/2023 03:51 PM INDEX NO. 815818/2020 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 144 RECEIVED NYSCEF: . 03/03/2023 169 168 167 165 164 163 160 159 150 157A156 155 154 153..152 151 SAMPLE 176A175A173A170A . # . "C" Dr. AvonAvonAvonNavis Rite Early Tawny Grand Pinaud Warner Amens . Lander Lander Corsage Corsage Colgate Aid Bisnoline Mustus, Blue Lyon's Tone Beauty Brocade Pure Baby Bouquet Union Lilac '1both Pure Powser, American Inc. Clubman Lotus Imported Dasting & Dusting Tooth Body Baby Dust cashmete-Beuquet Baby Talc; BabyMedicated Old Powder Talc Roses Powdet Tale 'talcum Perfumed Powder Pculer; AND Ponder; Powder Powder PefillPerfumed MedicatedSpice PRODUCT From - Powder Powder Body Talc MEG. Winarick, Talc NAME Tander Talc Lander Talcon Inc. Black Co. Charisma Powder Heritage; Beauty .(2662) CODE (101672) (4212DX) . 5. L 6 2% ND 2% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 2% ND ND 10% ND ND ND . Trenellte Lewin's |%) " Results 8 ? 1 ? ? ? ? ? ND ND ND ND 8% ND ND ND ND ND 10% trace (X-Ray Chrysotile (%) Diff.) .