On June 25, 2019 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
326 21St Street Llc,
and
328 21 St Llc,
Nyb Builders Inc.,
Regal Reconstruction Corp,
Zumbas Builders Inc,
for Torts - Other Negligence (Property Damage)
in the District Court of Kings County.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2023 03:53 PM INDEX NO. 514069/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 224 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2023
Alfred P. VigoritoCharles K. Faillace ± Of Counsel
Danielle Bennett Δ
John W. Barker Danielle M. Hansen Theresa A. Bohm Patricia M. Comblo ⁙ ±
Anna Hock
Gary W. Patterson, Jr.* Angela R. Bonica *
Josie M. Conelley
Thomas Jaffa
Jeffrey R. Nichols* Julia Combs † Brian DiPentima*
Mamie Gemma Kenney ***
Stathatos-Fulgieri Christine Crane *Tricia M. Criscito
Scott A. Singer Ruth Bogatyrow Kraft Michael P. Diven * ** ⁙
Roseann V. Driscoll
Gregg D. Weinstock*** ■ ⁙
Douglas Langholz Tyler M. FiorilloWilliam Gagas ±
Jason Lavery *
Kiki Chrisomallides** Lauren P. Ingvoldstad†
Rani B. Kulkarni
Dylan Braverman Megan A. Lawless‡ Jillian Kuper † Nicole E. Martone
Adam S. Covitt Guy A. Lawrence Christian McCarthy
Joseph P. Muscarella
Timothy P. Lewis – John O’Brien Seema Palmerson
Kevin D. Porter Jennifer M. Lobaito * Daniel O’Connell * ■
Nicole C. Salerno *
Susan Vari Neil Mascolo, Jr. Kara Ognibene † Valerie L. Siragusa
Adonaid Medina* Emily Phillips Diana V. Solla
Brian Andrews Ralph Vincent Morales Alesha Powell Paul Varriale
Margaret Antonino* ■
Vincent Nagler ** Kathleen M. Thompson
Karolina Wiaderna
Edward J. Arevalo Carolyn Rankin Paul Toscano
Robert Boccio Miles S. Reiner Claudine Travers * Also Admitted to Practice in NJ
Bruce Brady * Bhalinder L. Rikhye Tyler Weingarten †
** Also Admitted to Practice in CT
*** Also Admitted to Practice in NJ, CT, DC
Thomas Brennan ■ Lori Shapiro Samuel Youssof
-- Admitted to Practice in Florida
Dawn Bristol Tammy A. Trees Alexandra Zerrillo * ** ⁙
■ Also Admitted to Practice in FL
‡ Also Admitted to Practice in NJ and PA
Kenneth J. BurfordNicole M. Varisco * ± Also Admitted to Practice in MA
Gilbert H. Choi Julia F. Wilcox ⁙ Δ Also Admitted to Practice in Ohio
Joshua R. Cohen Arthur I. Yankowitz** ⁙ Admitted to Practice in CO
† Admission Pending
December 27, 2022
Via email: mark.labe@libertymutual.com
Law Offices Of Correla, King,
McGinnis & Liferiedge
455 Tarrytown Road, No. 1183
White Plains, New York 10607
Attn: Mark Labe, Esq.
Re: The First Liberty Insurance Corporation a/s/o Jessica Blue v. 328 21 ST, LLC, et al.
Index No: 519528/2021
File No: 0311-011
Dear Mr. Labe:
As you are aware, my office represents the defendant, 328 21st St., LLC in the above referenced
matter.
On May 18, 2022, my office served the following discovery demands on the plaintiff, The First
Liberty Insurance Corporation:
• Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars;
• Request for Production of Documents for MMSEA Information;
• Demand for Specified Damage Information; and
• Demand Pursuant to CPLR 4545;
420 Lexington Avenue • Suite 219 • New York, New York 10170 • Phone: (929) 955-4500 • Fax: (929) 232-2041
Office Locations in
LONG ISLAND WESTCHESTER NEW JERSEY CONNECTICUT FLORIDA COLORADO
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2023 03:53 PM INDEX NO. 514069/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 224 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2023
Per these demands, plaintiff’s responses to were due within twenty (20) days of the date of service.
It has now been six months since these demands were served. As such, plaintiff’s responses are now long
overdue. On November 18, 2022, my office sent a good faith letter to plaintiff again requesting this
discovery. Plaintiff has not responded.
Please accept this as our good faith effort to confer regarding outstanding discovery in this
action. If you fail to provide the aforementioned discovery responses within 10 days of the date of this
letter, we will be required to seek judicial intervention.
Very truly yours,
Jason J. Lavery
Jason J. Lavery
JJL/jw
Encl.
cc: London Fischer, LLP
59 Maiden Lane
New York, New York 10038
bkalman@londonfischer.com
amaldonado@londonfischer.com
Ahmuty Demers & McManus
200 I.U. Willets Road
Albertson, NY 11507
Susan.mauro@admlaw.com
Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz,
Edelman & Dicker, LLP
150 East 42nd Street
New York, New York 10017
patricia.wik@wilsonelser.com
2
Document Filed Date
January 12, 2023
Case Filing Date
June 25, 2019
Category
Torts - Other Negligence (Property Damage)
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2023 03:53 PM INDEX NO. 514069/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 224 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2023 Alfred P. VigoritoCharles K. Faillace ± Of Counsel Danielle Bennett Δ John W. Barker Danielle M. Hansen Theresa A. Bohm Patricia M. Comblo ⁙ ± Anna Hock Gary W. Patterson, Jr.* Angela R. Bonica * Josie M. Conelley Thomas Jaffa Jeffrey R. Nichols* Julia Combs † Brian DiPentima* Mamie Gemma Kenney *** Stathatos-Fulgieri Christine Crane *Tricia M. Criscito Scott A. Singer Ruth Bogatyrow Kraft Michael P. Diven * ** ⁙ Roseann V. Driscoll Gregg D. Weinstock*** ■ ⁙ Douglas Langholz Tyler M. FiorilloWilliam Gagas ± Jason Lavery * Kiki Chrisomallides** Lauren P. Ingvoldstad† Rani B. Kulkarni Dylan Braverman Megan A. Lawless‡ Jillian Kuper † Nicole E. Martone Adam S. Covitt Guy A. Lawrence Christian McCarthy Joseph P. Muscarella Timothy P. Lewis – John O’Brien Seema Palmerson Kevin D. Porter Jennifer M. Lobaito * Daniel O’Connell * ■ Nicole C. Salerno * Susan Vari Neil Mascolo, Jr. Kara Ognibene † Valerie L. Siragusa Adonaid Medina* Emily Phillips Diana V. Solla Brian Andrews Ralph Vincent Morales Alesha Powell Paul Varriale Margaret Antonino* ■ Vincent Nagler ** Kathleen M. Thompson Karolina Wiaderna Edward J. Arevalo Carolyn Rankin Paul Toscano Robert Boccio Miles S. Reiner Claudine Travers * Also Admitted to Practice in NJ Bruce Brady * Bhalinder L. Rikhye Tyler Weingarten † ** Also Admitted to Practice in CT *** Also Admitted to Practice in NJ, CT, DC Thomas Brennan ■ Lori Shapiro Samuel Youssof -- Admitted to Practice in Florida Dawn Bristol Tammy A. Trees Alexandra Zerrillo * ** ⁙ ■ Also Admitted to Practice in FL ‡ Also Admitted to Practice in NJ and PA Kenneth J. BurfordNicole M. Varisco * ± Also Admitted to Practice in MA Gilbert H. Choi Julia F. Wilcox ⁙ Δ Also Admitted to Practice in Ohio Joshua R. Cohen Arthur I. Yankowitz** ⁙ Admitted to Practice in CO † Admission Pending December 27, 2022 Via email: mark.labe@libertymutual.com Law Offices Of Correla, King, McGinnis & Liferiedge 455 Tarrytown Road, No. 1183 White Plains, New York 10607 Attn: Mark Labe, Esq. Re: The First Liberty Insurance Corporation a/s/o Jessica Blue v. 328 21 ST, LLC, et al. Index No: 519528/2021 File No: 0311-011 Dear Mr. Labe: As you are aware, my office represents the defendant, 328 21st St., LLC in the above referenced matter. On May 18, 2022, my office served the following discovery demands on the plaintiff, The First Liberty Insurance Corporation: • Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars; • Request for Production of Documents for MMSEA Information; • Demand for Specified Damage Information; and • Demand Pursuant to CPLR 4545; 420 Lexington Avenue • Suite 219 • New York, New York 10170 • Phone: (929) 955-4500 • Fax: (929) 232-2041 Office Locations in LONG ISLAND WESTCHESTER NEW JERSEY CONNECTICUT FLORIDA COLORADO FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 01/12/2023 03:53 PM INDEX NO. 514069/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 224 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/12/2023 Per these demands, plaintiff’s responses to were due within twenty (20) days of the date of service. It has now been six months since these demands were served. As such, plaintiff’s responses are now long overdue. On November 18, 2022, my office sent a good faith letter to plaintiff again requesting this discovery. Plaintiff has not responded. Please accept this as our good faith effort to confer regarding outstanding discovery in this action. If you fail to provide the aforementioned discovery responses within 10 days of the date of this letter, we will be required to seek judicial intervention. Very truly yours, Jason J. Lavery Jason J. Lavery JJL/jw Encl. cc: London Fischer, LLP 59 Maiden Lane New York, New York 10038 bkalman@londonfischer.com amaldonado@londonfischer.com Ahmuty Demers & McManus 200 I.U. Willets Road Albertson, NY 11507 Susan.mauro@admlaw.com Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz, Edelman & Dicker, LLP 150 East 42nd Street New York, New York 10017 patricia.wik@wilsonelser.com 2