Tentative Ruling: The State of California vs Vie-Del Company

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                

                      
                       
                                           

                 
                 !

                                                                                                      "
                                   $     %       %    
                                          &'())(*&

          +,       -".*/.)&(                      +,          $0       
                   1)2                                -",3   4-","5/5       
          "6         "/5                   0          

           ,    
          00                                                     0


          "     7                                       "     7      
                                                                                                                                               #
         #



          8
             00
            9




          89"   89  0:   :  4:   0 ::


              "
          8 9                    ";  <;3<;","4     89
                                                                                     % ," "4

             
0, 0
          8 9
                                   "; 4


          89% ,     89 4   89%    8
                                                                                                9<;3<;"="74

          896"     

          89"     89" 8 9  "  <; :     89  < 8 9

          8>9 ",7       ;0;7"4    0"; 7      4

         8>9 " "2?&@A 7&)&?4'@A/0"; 7                 4   ;",
         ;",       ;0;7"4

          8>9 7;76<7    "70;4

          897;70; ",4

             -",:: <B4
          8 9



             -",   :  04
          8 9

             C7;<     " ;"0D  :
           -
E%       
            9%,             0"     9; :           "
                                                                           ;        0

                       D:              D:              :                   D:           D:
          8                       8 9          8



                                                                                                        D: :
              7                            0          
          8
             
            9
                    0B       , 8
                                    8 9          94 "   <;;,   0

             
   +/
           
             %   ;,007   8 9 =",74  8
                                                                                                             =",4
                                                                                               9 "


            9 D:
          89

          8        =",7   7  "   =",
                                                                                             4
          89 ,0F74"0:/F4       89$   "
          8 970 <; &'4  89
                                                         "0     

          8>9; ", 4      7;4



          !&1)1&(
          G::: 4G
                                                           $    %      %   
  
                  @.1A                                         ",

                                          004 !
                                             "      4     EH      

                  +,             -".*/.)&(@41)2A

                  %                   %00            

                   ",

                             ,/ <;       00I        0               6 ;
                  ;     J   -" .*/  .)&(/   K   ,      ..LG2      ,    2(      ;  ;   
                  J<;7;  K,2.2L4



                  B

                            ;       0   ;"M"        4  ;M"0
                  ;6, "007           4       ;     0/ "0          
                  =7;,0                ;,";                   <   
                    ;   ;4  ;         ;  ;     ;   ;  00<07  0  
                                                                                                                               
                   =",0                   4   ;"  / ;   , 0 ;
                  00        ;;           "700=",/;00
                  < "00    "   ;    ;  0; 7     0            4
                  @474N.''41)/            "4@A@.A4A

                           +</0 7"               7 &.''41')/     "    @A M"    ;
                  <;;  77"0"                     /;0              
                   ;       ;2)     ;              64      ;0/;
                  <       6,<;;M"4

                           "   " 0 "       0 "/ " 24&2. 0  7"
                   7 ?4'@A/ 0";<   7              /;;         0; 4
                   ;",;             ",<    ;0;7"/ 7
                  ;760   ; "         7
                                                         <    "  7   0;4

                   ",
                     "C           55               L3.(&&(     4


                                    @-",I    A      @A
                    

                     
                           
    
  )% 
                                    /   
                                              &2)KK 
                                             &
                                      /0   ?2L.1))).
                                             @''?A1'L.)))
                 
               !


                                5I                  %       E                      ONPPJHPPN

           70;
                       ; 7"
                                                    ;"70;
                                              %"-".*QK/.)&(",
          <  7 7077,;;7           ;<<
          0<,""      774   0<;; 7"I
                                                                                              77077,7    ,
          7   70,4   ;   ;7    7  7077,/    
           ;7"  0"    <;;
       7<;  ,0"4



          70,     /0  ?2L.1G))).
             )L3.?3.)&(                             6/                                                            /"




              %
                                                                         "4   
             ,                                              C6%76* -    /
          &)) ";% 4                                                   '.()    41; 
           "&2))                                                             /    ?2L)1
              ,  /  ?))&.2L).


           ;-                                                         C"7C4-;   /-
          .('6                                                 ...) " /';   
             .                                                          /   ?2L.&
             /  ?2L.)




         9 6I  070%,      , 7;
          E )(  )'                                5I               %     E