Exhibit,Appendix: Pamela Goldstein, Ellyn Berk, Tony Berk, Paul Benjamin v. Houlihan/Lawrence Inc.

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                FILED:         WESTCHESTER              COUNTY         CLERK       06/30/2022             03:20        PM            INDEX    NO.   60767/2018
   NYSCEF     DOC.   NO.   1395                                                                               RECEIVED      NYSCEF:     06/30/2022




                                                      EXHIBIT                                  6
   FILED:         WESTCHESTER              COUNTY         CLERK       06/30/2022             03:20        PM            INDEX    NO.   60767/2018
   NYSCEF     DOC.   NO.   1395                                                                               RECEIVED      NYSCEF:     06/30/2022



                                                                                                                     156 E. Market Street
                                                                                                                              Suite 1200
                                                                                                                   Indianapolis, IN 46204
                                                                                                                   www.MacGillLaw.com


                  Robert D. MacGill
                  317.906.5085
                  Robert.MacGill@MacGillLaw.com

                  Via Email
                  April 6, 2022

                  Jeremy Vest
                  Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo, P.C.
                  Chrysler Center
                  666 Third Avenue
                  New York NY 10017

                  William Ohlemeyer
                  Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
                  333 Main Street
                  Armonk, NY 10504

                           RE:      Class List, Goldstein et al. v. Houlihan Lawrence, Inc.,
                                    No. 60767/2018 (N.Y. Sup. Ct., Westchester Cty.)

                  Dear Counsel,

                           Pursuant to the Fourteenth Report and Recommendation, please find enclosed the class
                  member list.

                           Transactions that met the class criteria were identified within the Company’s ERP
                  system, Profit Power, as follows:        The transaction was recorded as a residential, closed, sales
                  transaction. The close date was between 1/1/2011 and 7/14/2018.                 The address of the subject
                  property had a ZIP Code or city name within Westchester, Putnam or Dutchess counties, per data
                  from the USPS. The transaction type was recorded as “Our List and Sale.”

                           We also identified 28 data records where there were multiple records for the same subject
                  property that recorded commissions for the list side and sale (buy) side. In these instances, the
                  subject property shared either (a) the same address and MLS Number and/or (b) shared the same
                  address and close price with close dates within 30 days of the other record. We have provided
                  these records in a separate Excel workbook.

                           This list should be used in place of the prior lists, which were attached to Plaintiffs’
                  motion for class certification. As we informed you on January 28, 2019, the prior list was based
                  upon third party MLS data, which is less accurate than the Company’s ERP system, Profit
                  Power.
   FILED:         WESTCHESTER              COUNTY         CLERK       06/30/2022             03:20        PM            INDEX    NO.   60767/2018
   NYSCEF     DOC.   NO.   1395                                                                               RECEIVED      NYSCEF:     06/30/2022

                  Jeremy Vest
                  William Ohlemeyer
                  April 6, 2022
                  Page 2

                           Per your request, we asked the third-party Client Connect vendor to supply us with the
                  email addresses associated with these transactions. The data received can be found within the
                  enclosed Excel workbooks.

                           We remind you that you are prohibited from contacting absent class members and that
                  nothing in the Fourteenth Report and Recommendation has changed this restriction. Per the
                  Fourteenth Report and Recommendation, by supplying this list, Houlihan Lawrence does not
                  admit that the persons identified are appropriate members of the class, and Houlihan Lawrence
                  reserves all rights to move to remove individuals from the class and/or modify the class
                  definition. Further, Houlihan Lawrence reaffirms and incorporates by reference the Court’s so-
                  ordered Stipulation on Arbitration, NYSCEF 368.

                           Finally, we note that you have been ordered to “update the mailing addresses within the
                  Potential Class Member Data,” and to “produce any such updated address list(s) to Houlihan
                  Lawrence upon their creation.” Please provide the date upon which you will produce this list to
                  us.

                                    Best regards.


                                                                                          Very truly yours,




                                                                                          Robert D. MacGill



                  cc: Matthew Ciulla, Alfred Donnellan, Nelida Lara, Alexander Pantos