On October 25, 2017 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
Leonard C Lewis ,
and
Alton A Ellis ,
Luther M Rufus ,
for Torts - Motor Vehicle
in the District Court of Kings County.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2018 05:48 PM INDEX NO. 520719/2017
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 10 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2018
Exhibit "B
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2018 05:48 PM INDEX NO. 520719/2017
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 10 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2018
Page1 of 4 Pages New YorkStateDepartmentof MotorVehiclen
Precinct POUCE ACCIDENT REPORT (NYC) ,g
105 MV-104AN (7/11) -
Accident
No Complaint
MV-2017-105-002156 Number
AcddentDate DayofWeek MililaryTime No.of No.li uretNo.IGIled NotInvestigated
atScene LeftScenePolicePhotos20
Month Day } Year Vehicles _..___...---.......---
__.... .
Reconstructed Yet No
4 29 |2017 SATURDAY 23:45 2 4 0 ...-
VEHICLE1 R} VEHICLE2 C|BICYCLIST¤ PEDESTRIAN¤ OTHERPEDESTRIAN
2-
VEHICLE Driver StateofLic. 2·
VEHICLE Drnr StateofLic.
2 teense DNumber 374890224 NY UcenseIDNunter979193838 NY 21
"" DriverName-exacIly Driver
Name-mactly 4
asprintedonscense
RUFUS, LUTHER, M asprintedonsi:enseELLIS,
ALTON, A
AddresstincludeNumber
& Street) Apl.No.Address &Street)
(holuteNumber Apt No.
94 LOTT STREET 145 -74 221 STREET . ..'
city orTown State 21pCode CityorTown State ZipCode 22
EROOKLYN NY 11226 QUEENS NY 11413
3 baléWBirth Sex Unlicensed No.of Public Dateof Birth Sex Unlicensed No.of Pol)Iic
*†Y°ª' 0°°"Pants Property Month De Occupants Properly
3 29 1988 M Damaged .1 1 1984 M 2 Darnaged
8 2 ,
asprinted
Name--exacuy onregistration Sex ofBirth
Date printed
Name-exacIly onregistration Sex DateofBirth
Month Day Year Mënth Day Year
AUFUS, LUTEER, M M 8 29 198s ELLIS, ALTON, A M 1 1 1944
Address(Mefude
Number
& Street) Apl No.Hat iR ased Address
(IncirdeNumber&
Sheet) AptNo. Haz. Released 23
94 LOTT STREET 145-74 221 STREET
CityorTown State ZEpCode CityorTown StateZI ode
BROOKLYN NY 1122 6 QUEENS NY 11413
PlateNumber Stateof Reg.Vehicle
Year&Make Vehicle
Type ins.CodePlateNumber taleofReg.VehicleY88r& Make
VehideType Ing.Code
HDX1220 NY 2006 BMW SEDAN 328 HMJ8131 NY 2005 NISSAN SEDAN 410
Number(s) Number(s)
Violation Violation
Secuon(s) SecGon(s)
25
Checkif involvedvehicle is• Check ifinvolved vehicleis: CircIsthediagrambelowthat describesthe accident,or draw your own | 7
6 ¤more than95 inches wide; ¤more than95 incheswide; diagramin space#9. Numberthevehicles.
1 V C]more than34 feet long; V ¤more than34 feet long; Per End LenTum RightAngle R°
Tom HeadOn
E
H
Coperatedwith an overweightpermit;
E Doperated with an overweightpermit·
Doperated with an overdimensionpermlL
¤6perated withan overdimensionpermit·
H
+
....._p., +
VEHICLE1 DAMAGE CODES I VERICLE2 DAMAGECODES sideswipa LeftTum RightTum Sideswie 26
C Box 1 - Pointo0mpact 1 2 C 1 2 (samermecson) (DPpos
7 Box 1 - Pointof Impact 2
L Box2 - MostDamage 2 2 L Box 2 - MostDamage 2 2 L -·4..-0. 4. 6. e. --
1 E E
Enter up tothree 3 5 Enter up to three 3 4 5 ACCIDENTDIAGRAM
moreDamageCodes 1 3 more DamageCodes 1 3 27
Vehicle Vehicle ByDamsaaspua comeron a tour
Bypearanaxparstcozas2ona torzz
Towed' Towed:
Toaw.:9emaxm masam asm
mmme.. To2" **= ""ª¾""Sta ×r sum
. DIAGRAM ATTACHED ON SUBSEQUENT PAGE
VEHICLEDAMAGECODING: r
1-13. SEE DIAGRAMON RIGHT. 7 HEAD ON
14. UNDERCARRIAGE 17. DEMOLISHED a E
15. TRAILER 18. NO DAMAGE · 9- 28
16. OVERTURNED 19. OTHER _,, Cost of repairs to any one veliicle will be more than $1000.
1
fa 5 Unknownfl.Inable to Detentline Yes
u n No
ReferenceMarkerCoordinates(Wavanable) Place Where Accident
Occurred: BRONX¤KINGS Q NEW YORK QUEENS DRICI-IMOND
Le±:±/Northing: 221
Roadon whichaccidentoccuned STRRET
40.659843 (RouteNumbercrSkeetName) 29
. 1
alipntersecting street SPRINGFIELD
LANE
I Longitude/Easting: (Route orSimetNamey
Number
N S
m2
-73.76002
(MileoosNgarest RopleNumber
Intersentirjq orStrealName)
AccidentDescription/Officer'sNotes AT
TPO DRIVER OF VEHICLE 1 STAT21S WAS TRAVELI N.G SCCTHBGUND ON 221 3D
STREET WHEN HE WAS STOPPED AT THE STOP SIGN AT SPRINGFIELD LANE AND VEHICLE 2 CAME AROUND 1
THE BEND MAKING A RIGHT HAND TURN AND STRUCK HIS VEHICLE HEAD ON. DRIVER OF VEHICLE 2
STATES WAS TRAVELING WESTBOUND ON SPRINGFIELD LANE WHEN HE NADE A RIGHT HAÑD TURN ONTO
NGR-iHisûURD 221 STREET AND STRUCK VEHICLE 1 WHO WAS COMING THRU THE. STOP SIGN HEAD ON.
8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 BY TO 18 NamerofalHnvoNed Date of DeathOnly
4 1 28 M 5 12 6 - - RUFUS, LUTHER, M
L a 1 3 4 1 39 R 6 12 6 - - UEWIS, LEONARD , C
I c 2 1 4 1 33 M 11 12 6 9997 7311 ELLIS, ALTON, A
D 2 3 4 1 25 M 1 12 6 - THORPE, JERIMIAH,. A
Officer'sRank Tax ID No. NCICNo. Precect Post/Sector Reviewing Date/TimeReviewed
and Po Omcer
Signature$POM 04 /30/
956342 03030 105 SGT FUNG Y 2017 07:21
PrintName
in Full CHRISTOPHE M YONICK CHEN
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2018 05:48 PM INDEX NO. 520719/2017
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 10 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2018
PERSONS KILLED OR INJURED IN ACCIDENT of persons
designation
(Letter iciled or injured must correspond
withletter designation
on front).
A LastName First M1 D LastName First M.t.
RUFUS LUTHER M THORPE JERIMIAH
Address Address
94 LOTT STREET PH BROOKLYN NY 11226 109-58 141 STREET PH QUEENS NY
Date of Birth Telephone(AreaCode)
______________ Daleof Biiti Telephone(Area Code)
Month Day Year Month Day Year
B Last Name First M1 LastName First M
LEWIS LEONARD C
Address Address
. ......
Date of Birth _____ ITelephone{AreaCode) Dateof Birtt· Telephone(AreaCode)
Month Day Year Month Day Year
c Last Name First M1
HighwayDi L at Scene? Yes¤No
ELLIS ALTON A
Name:
Address
145-74 221 STREET PH QUEENS NY 11413
Date of Birth
Month Day
_
Year
Telephone(AreaCode) Shield No.
ENTER INSURANCE POUCY NUMBER FRONI INSURANCE IDENTIFICATION CARD, EXPIRATION DATE (INALL CASES), AND WN.
Vehicle Noa 1994015-C01-32 Vehicleblo.2 RS813238517
ExpirationDate 09/01/2017 ExpirationDate.03/28/2018
WN WBANF33506Cs35600 VIN 1N4BA41E85C839994
WITNESS (Attach separate sheet,if necemry)
Name Address Phone
DUPLICATE COPY REQUIRED FOR:
Dept. of MotorVehicles Motor Transport
Division NYC Taxi & LimousineComm. Other City Agency
(if anyoneis killed/injured) (P.D. vehicle taxi or limousine
inve!ved) ( f a Licensed (Specify)
involved)
Officeof Comptroller ¤ PersonnelSafety Unit Highway Unit
(if a City
vehicleinvolved) (if a P.D. vehicle
involved)
NOTIFICATIONS: list Missing Person Squad member who
and relationship of friend or relative notified. It aided person is ±±Mhd,
(Enter name, address,
was notified. in either case, give date and time of notification.)
PROPERTY DAMAGED (otherthan vehicles) OWNER OF PROPERTY(include cityagency,where applicable)
IF NYPD VEHICLE IS INVOLVED:
PoliceVehicle LastName
-Operator'sFirst Name Rank ShieldNo. TaxtD. No. Command
Make of Vehicle Year Type ofVehicle Plate No. Dept.VehicleNo. AssignedToWhat Command
Equipmentin UseAt TimeofAccident
Hom Turret Light High-Level Warning Ughts Traffic Cones
O siren ¤ 4-Way Flasher Headlights
ACTIONS OF POLICE VEHICLE
Responding to Code Signal O Complying with Station House Directive
O Pursuing Violator O Routine Patrol
Other (Describe)
MV-104AN
(7/11) Page 2 of 4 Pages
Judge
Richard Velasquez Pt 66
Track Judge’s New Case
Document Filed Date
December 21, 2018
Case Filing Date
October 25, 2017
Category
Torts - Motor Vehicle
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2018 05:48 PM INDEX NO. 520719/2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 10 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2018 Exhibit "B FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2018 05:48 PM INDEX NO. 520719/2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 10 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2018 Page1 of 4 Pages New YorkStateDepartmentof MotorVehiclen Precinct POUCE ACCIDENT REPORT (NYC) ,g 105 MV-104AN (7/11) - Accident No Complaint MV-2017-105-002156 Number AcddentDate DayofWeek MililaryTime No.of No.li uretNo.IGIled NotInvestigated atScene LeftScenePolicePhotos20 Month Day } Year Vehicles _..___...---.......--- __.... . Reconstructed Yet No 4 29 |2017 SATURDAY 23:45 2 4 0 ...- VEHICLE1 R} VEHICLE2 C|BICYCLIST¤ PEDESTRIAN¤ OTHERPEDESTRIAN 2- VEHICLE Driver StateofLic. 2· VEHICLE Drnr StateofLic. 2 teense DNumber 374890224 NY UcenseIDNunter979193838 NY 21 "" DriverName-exacIly Driver Name-mactly 4 asprintedonscense RUFUS, LUTHER, M asprintedonsi:enseELLIS, ALTON, A AddresstincludeNumber & Street) Apl.No.Address &Street) (holuteNumber Apt No. 94 LOTT STREET 145 -74 221 STREET . ..' city orTown State 21pCode CityorTown State ZipCode 22 EROOKLYN NY 11226 QUEENS NY 11413 3 baléWBirth Sex Unlicensed No.of Public Dateof Birth Sex Unlicensed No.of Pol)Iic *†Y°ª' 0°°"Pants Property Month De Occupants Properly 3 29 1988 M Damaged .1 1 1984 M 2 Darnaged 8 2 , asprinted Name--exacuy onregistration Sex ofBirth Date printed Name-exacIly onregistration Sex DateofBirth Month Day Year Mënth Day Year AUFUS, LUTEER, M M 8 29 198s ELLIS, ALTON, A M 1 1 1944 Address(Mefude Number & Street) Apl No.Hat iR ased Address (IncirdeNumber& Sheet) AptNo. Haz. Released 23 94 LOTT STREET 145-74 221 STREET CityorTown State ZEpCode CityorTown StateZI ode BROOKLYN NY 1122 6 QUEENS NY 11413 PlateNumber Stateof Reg.Vehicle Year&Make Vehicle Type ins.CodePlateNumber taleofReg.VehicleY88r& Make VehideType Ing.Code HDX1220 NY 2006 BMW SEDAN 328 HMJ8131 NY 2005 NISSAN SEDAN 410 Number(s) Number(s) Violation Violation Secuon(s) SecGon(s) 25 Checkif involvedvehicle is• Check ifinvolved vehicleis: CircIsthediagrambelowthat describesthe accident,or draw your own | 7 6 ¤more than95 inches wide; ¤more than95 incheswide; diagramin space#9. Numberthevehicles. 1 V C]more than34 feet long; V ¤more than34 feet long; Per End LenTum RightAngle R° Tom HeadOn E H Coperatedwith an overweightpermit; E Doperated with an overweightpermit· Doperated with an overdimensionpermlL ¤6perated withan overdimensionpermit· H + ....._p., + VEHICLE1 DAMAGE CODES I VERICLE2 DAMAGECODES sideswipa LeftTum RightTum Sideswie 26 C Box 1 - Pointo0mpact 1 2 C 1 2 (samermecson) (DPpos 7 Box 1 - Pointof Impact 2 L Box2 - MostDamage 2 2 L Box 2 - MostDamage 2 2 L -·4..-0. 4. 6. e. -- 1 E E Enter up tothree 3 5 Enter up to three 3 4 5 ACCIDENTDIAGRAM moreDamageCodes 1 3 more DamageCodes 1 3 27 Vehicle Vehicle ByDamsaaspua comeron a tour Bypearanaxparstcozas2ona torzz Towed' Towed: Toaw.:9emaxm masam asm mmme.. To2" **= ""ª¾""Sta ×r sum . DIAGRAM ATTACHED ON SUBSEQUENT PAGE VEHICLEDAMAGECODING: r 1-13. SEE DIAGRAMON RIGHT. 7 HEAD ON 14. UNDERCARRIAGE 17. DEMOLISHED a E 15. TRAILER 18. NO DAMAGE · 9- 28 16. OVERTURNED 19. OTHER _,, Cost of repairs to any one veliicle will be more than $1000. 1 fa 5 Unknownfl.Inable to Detentline Yes u n No ReferenceMarkerCoordinates(Wavanable) Place Where Accident Occurred: BRONX¤KINGS Q NEW YORK QUEENS DRICI-IMOND Le±:±/Northing: 221 Roadon whichaccidentoccuned STRRET 40.659843 (RouteNumbercrSkeetName) 29 . 1 alipntersecting street SPRINGFIELD LANE I Longitude/Easting: (Route orSimetNamey Number N S m2 -73.76002 (MileoosNgarest RopleNumber Intersentirjq orStrealName) AccidentDescription/Officer'sNotes AT TPO DRIVER OF VEHICLE 1 STAT21S WAS TRAVELI N.G SCCTHBGUND ON 221 3D STREET WHEN HE WAS STOPPED AT THE STOP SIGN AT SPRINGFIELD LANE AND VEHICLE 2 CAME AROUND 1 THE BEND MAKING A RIGHT HAND TURN AND STRUCK HIS VEHICLE HEAD ON. DRIVER OF VEHICLE 2 STATES WAS TRAVELING WESTBOUND ON SPRINGFIELD LANE WHEN HE NADE A RIGHT HAÑD TURN ONTO NGR-iHisûURD 221 STREET AND STRUCK VEHICLE 1 WHO WAS COMING THRU THE. STOP SIGN HEAD ON. 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 BY TO 18 NamerofalHnvoNed Date of DeathOnly 4 1 28 M 5 12 6 - - RUFUS, LUTHER, M L a 1 3 4 1 39 R 6 12 6 - - UEWIS, LEONARD , C I c 2 1 4 1 33 M 11 12 6 9997 7311 ELLIS, ALTON, A D 2 3 4 1 25 M 1 12 6 - THORPE, JERIMIAH,. A Officer'sRank Tax ID No. NCICNo. Precect Post/Sector Reviewing Date/TimeReviewed and Po Omcer Signature$POM 04 /30/ 956342 03030 105 SGT FUNG Y 2017 07:21 PrintName in Full CHRISTOPHE M YONICK CHEN FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2018 05:48 PM INDEX NO. 520719/2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 10 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2018 PERSONS KILLED OR INJURED IN ACCIDENT of persons designation (Letter iciled or injured must correspond withletter designation on front). A LastName First M1 D LastName First M.t. RUFUS LUTHER M THORPE JERIMIAH Address Address 94 LOTT STREET PH BROOKLYN NY 11226 109-58 141 STREET PH QUEENS NY Date of Birth Telephone(AreaCode) ______________ Daleof Biiti Telephone(Area Code) Month Day Year Month Day Year B Last Name First M1 LastName First M LEWIS LEONARD C Address Address . ...... Date of Birth _____ ITelephone{AreaCode) Dateof Birtt· Telephone(AreaCode) Month Day Year Month Day Year c Last Name First M1 HighwayDi L at Scene? Yes¤No ELLIS ALTON A Name: Address 145-74 221 STREET PH QUEENS NY 11413 Date of Birth Month Day _ Year Telephone(AreaCode) Shield No. ENTER INSURANCE POUCY NUMBER FRONI INSURANCE IDENTIFICATION CARD, EXPIRATION DATE (INALL CASES), AND WN. Vehicle Noa 1994015-C01-32 Vehicleblo.2 RS813238517 ExpirationDate 09/01/2017 ExpirationDate.03/28/2018 WN WBANF33506Cs35600 VIN 1N4BA41E85C839994 WITNESS (Attach separate sheet,if necemry) Name Address Phone DUPLICATE COPY REQUIRED FOR: Dept. of MotorVehicles Motor Transport Division NYC Taxi & LimousineComm. Other City Agency (if anyoneis killed/injured) (P.D. vehicle taxi or limousine inve!ved) ( f a Licensed (Specify) involved) Officeof Comptroller ¤ PersonnelSafety Unit Highway Unit (if a City vehicleinvolved) (if a P.D. vehicle involved) NOTIFICATIONS: list Missing Person Squad member who and relationship of friend or relative notified. It aided person is ±±Mhd, (Enter name, address, was notified. in either case, give date and time of notification.) PROPERTY DAMAGED (otherthan vehicles) OWNER OF PROPERTY(include cityagency,where applicable) IF NYPD VEHICLE IS INVOLVED: PoliceVehicle LastName -Operator'sFirst Name Rank ShieldNo. TaxtD. No. Command Make of Vehicle Year Type ofVehicle Plate No. Dept.VehicleNo. AssignedToWhat Command Equipmentin UseAt TimeofAccident Hom Turret Light High-Level Warning Ughts Traffic Cones O siren ¤ 4-Way Flasher Headlights ACTIONS OF POLICE VEHICLE Responding to Code Signal O Complying with Station House Directive O Pursuing Violator O Routine Patrol Other (Describe) MV-104AN (7/11) Page 2 of 4 Pages