Preview
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
EXHIBIT E
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
STATE OF NEW YORK
SUPREME COURT COUNTY OF ONONDAGA
COSTELLO, COONEY & FEARON, PLLC, Index No. 003917/2021
Plaintiff,
PRIVILEGE LOG
-vs-
MELINDA BURDICK BOWE,
Defendant.
Beginning Subject Date Author Recipient(s) CC(s) Reason
Bates No.
CCF 0000046- E-mail re: Melinda B. Bowe 04/23/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000057 Michael D. Foti Attorney Work-Product
John R. Langey, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000060 E-mail re: Melinda B. Bowe 04/08/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000070- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000071 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0000161- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000165 Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000194- E-mail re: Distributions/ Capital 04/19/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Daniel R. Rose, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000195 Accounts Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000217- E-mail re: Melinda B. Bowe 04/23/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Michael D. Foti N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000228 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000234- E-mail re: Today's Meeting 04/08/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. Attorney-Client
CCF 0000235 Michael D. Foti Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000238- E-mail re: Email to Katie 04/19/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. Michael D. Foti Attorney-Client
CCF 0000239 Centolella Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000245- E-mail re: CCF — Revisions Per 03/26/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000247 Today's Meeting Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
2
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0000329- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/28/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000331 John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Daniel R. Rose, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000374- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/28/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000376 Daniel R. Rose, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
John R. Langey, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000433- E-mail re: email to Katie 04/19/2021 Michael D. Foti Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000435 Centolella John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000453- E-mail re: Distributions 04/08/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. David Ayoub Michael D. Foto Attorney-Client
CCF 0000454 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Gregory M. Jarvis Attorney Work-Product
John R. Langey, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000535- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/28/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Daniel R. Rose, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. Attorney-Client
CCF 0000537 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000587- E-mail re: Melinda B. Bowe 04/23/2021 Michael D. Foti Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000596 Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
3
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0000615- E-mail re: Capital Accounts 04/03/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. David Ayoub N/A Attorney Work-Product
CCF 0000616 Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000642- E-mail re: Melinda B. Bowe 04/22/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Michael D. Foti N/A Attorney Work-Product
CCF 0000650 Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000679- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000683 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000702- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000704 John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000775- E-mail re: Melinda B. Bowe 04/23/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Michael D. Foti N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000785 John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000786- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/28/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Daniel R. Rose, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000788 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
John R. Langey, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
4
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0000805- E-mail re: email to Katie 04/19/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Michael D. Foti N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000807 Centolella John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000841- E-mail re: Distributions 05/12/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Michael D. Foti N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0000842 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Robert J. Smith, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0000871- E-mail re: worksheets 06/23/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0000872 John R. Langey, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001009- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001012 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001058- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001062 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001115- E-mail re: Past Distributions 04/14/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney Work-Product
CCF 0001118 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Material Prepared in
Michael D. Foti Anticipation of
Litigation
5
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0001132 Town Board Emergency Employee N/A Town of Salina N/A N/A Attorney-Client
Pay Leave Policy — COVID-19 Confidential Client
Information
CCF 0001133 Town of Salina Memorandum N/A Town of Salina N/A N/A Attorney-Client
Confidential Client
Information
CCF 0001134 E-mail re: Distributions/ Capital 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Melinda B. Bowe, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney-Client
Accounts Paul G. Ferrara, Esq.
CCF 0001147- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney Work-Product
CCF 0001151 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001223- E-mail re: Revisions Per Today's 03/26/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
CCF 0001226 Meeting Material Prepared in
Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001255- E-mail re: Cash Receipts 01/27/2020 N/A Michael D. Foti N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001258
6
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0001273- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001274 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001280- E-mail re: Revisions Per Today's 03/26/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001282 Meeting Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001300- Report re: Labor and Employment, 04/08/2020 Melinda B. Bowe, Esq. N/A N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001303 Education Law Practice Groups
CCF 0001311- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001313 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001317- E-mail re: Revisions Per Today's 03/26/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001319 Meeting Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001340- E-mail re: School Construction 03/28/2020 Melinda B. Bowe, Esq. Karl Seckner N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001341 Projects Chris Byrne
7
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0001366- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001368 John R. Langey, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001431- E-mail re: Revisions Per Today's 03/26/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Material Prepared in
CCF 0001434 Meeting Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001452- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001454 John R. Langey, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001460- E-mail re: Capital Accounts 04/03/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001461 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Anticipation of
Michael D. Foti Litigation
CCF 0001462- E-mail re: Cash Receipts 03/11/2020 N/A Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001464
CCF 0001465- E-mail re: Cash Receipts 03/11/2020 N/A Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001467
8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 05/11/2022 04:40 PM INDEX NO. 003917/2021
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 56 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/11/2022
CCF 0001515- E-mail re: PPP Closing Package 04/18/2020 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Michael D. Foti Attorney-Client
CCF 0001523 for Empire Archives John R. Langey, Esq.
CCF 0001524- E-mail re: 2020 Distributions 04/01/2021 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001526 John R. Langey, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001545- E-mail re: Revisions Per Today's 03/26/2021 John R. Langey, Esq. Robert J. Smith, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001547 Meeting Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001548- E-mail re: Follow Up 04/01/2021 Paul G. Ferrara, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Material Prepared in
CCF 0001549 Robert J. Smith, Esq. Anticipation of
Litigation
CCF 0001569- E-mail re: Move 11/13/2020 Melinda B. Bowe, Esq. John R. Langey, Esq. N/A Attorney-Client
CCF 0001570 Robert J. Smith, Esq.
Christopher M. Militello,
Esq.
CCF _0001573 E-mail re: Meeting/Transition 11/05/2020 Melinda B. Bowe, Esq. Christopher M. Militello, John R. Langey, Esq. Attorney Work-Product
Esq. Attorney-Client
9