Preview
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/22/2021
EXHIBIT
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF:
P.005 01/22/2021
RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35
14 s 3 7 FAX @005/ 010
TUE
L 2 / 2 2 / 20 20
NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report)
Agency Name: Div/Pct: Case #: Incident#:
MADISON COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPT 7263 480918
Type
Incident Location Date Reported: Occuned From: OccurredTo:
2*
NOlSE-NOlSE COMPLAINT SULLIVAN / TOWN / 12/12/2020 20:55 12/12/20202O:55 12/12/202021:15
Associated Persons Information
DOB Name Address
PERSONNOT (YET) INTI 04/10/1979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL J 2565 ROUTE 5E
APT 4
SULLIVAN, NEW Y ORK
IncidentNarratives
Date of Date
Action Written Narrative
12/12/2020 12/12/2020 NOISE COMPLAINT, TOWN OF SULLIVAN:
On 12/l2/2020 I was workingthe 2 shift,
assignedto zone 2 in marked
patrolunit#437. At 2057
hours,ID64 and I respond-dto 2565Route 5 B #4 for a reported
noise complaint
involving
MICHAEL CARPENTER. Upon I did not hear any loud
arrival, musicor disturb==e.I attempted
to
make contactwith MICHAEL, but he refused
to answerhis doorfor an interview.
No further
action
taken.
End ofreport,
ReportingOfficer:JOSHUA SEYMORE
IncidentStatustCLOSED BY INVESTlGATION Status Date:12/12/2020
PageI or I 12/I8/202017:02:50
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 13:35
RECEIVED NYSCEF:P.006 01/22/2021
RX Date/Time 12/22/2020
TUE
12 / 22 / 20 20 1 4 t 37 F AX 20 0 6 / 010
NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report)
Agency Name: Div/Pet: Case #: Incident#: _..
MADISON COUNTY SNERiFFS DEFr 7263 480707
Incident
Type Location Date Reported: Occurred From: OccurredTo:
2'
NOISE-NOISE COMPLAINT SULLIVAN / TOWN / 12/07/202021:34 12/07/2020 21:34
Associated Persons !=fo-nation
Type DOB Name Address
PERSON NOT (YET) INT)04/i0/1979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL 3 2565 ROUTE 5E
APT 4
SULL1VAN, NEW Y ORK
PERSON INTERVIEWED 05/24/1956 ROSS, TERESA D QUARRY ROAD
BLDO 6587 APT 4
CHITTENANOO, NEW YORK
PageI of2 12/t8/202017:03:27
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF:
P,007 01/22/2021
AX Oate/Tiioe 12/22/2020 13:35
I007/810
12/22/2020 208 14i 38 Pnx
Incident
T Location Date Re oned. Occurred Prom: Occurred Tc:
/2'
NOISE-NOISE COMPLAINT SULLIVA'N /TOWN l2/07/2020 21.'34 l2/07/2020 21:34
IncidentNarratives
Date of Date
Action Written Narrative
12/07/2020 12/07/2020 ASS!ST:
I was dispatched and stood by in the area for officer
to this complaint safety DEPUTY
until FLUNO
advisedthat be was ail set.
12/0'//2020 12/07/2020 LOVDNOISE COMPLAINT: TOWN QF SULLIVAN
On 12/7/2020 at 2134hours,whileassigned to marked
patrolunit442 and covering the 2
sone 2 for
shiA,Iresponded to2565 route5 B.intheTown ofSullivaninregardsto aloudnoisecomplaint.
Unit 428 DeputyKOPEC also responded.Prior I spoke
to arrival, to TERESA ROSS, the reporting
persoll.
While speakingwith ROSS, she stated that she has been receiving
severalc";..p! 0!."s from
her
tenants0;gar!;.8 MICIIAEL CARPENTER. ROSS stared that she has been advised by her tenants
that CARPENTER his music
has been playing it was penerrating
so loud that thmugh the walls
"!st-"!".the tenants.ROSS stated that CARPENTER was asked multiple
times to turn his music
down ROSS stated that she would
but refused. police
like to speak with
CARPENTER and ask him
I CARPENTER'
thc music
to turn down. While on scene, I did not hear the music
coming from S
apartment to speak to him
but I attempted anyway but didnot receive it must
an answer at the door,
be noted recent ""
that there have been several .."!i.".h regarding
CARPENTER and ROSS would
like evicted
to get him but dueto the current
covid-19 re.~ ROSS also stated
shc is unable to.
":i=..:,
to keep calling
that she is going to keep the paper trail
going.
At this have no further
time,! information.
Code 01
12/07/2020 12/07/2020 ASSIST, ROUTE 5, TOWN OF SULLlVAN:
On Monday, December 7th, 2020,I reported
to work at the Madison
County SherN'sOlsce far s
"2" 1800 to 0600 hours,
and was assigned patrolUnit all
s~! «d!ed shiA, to marked 428 covering
Rones.
At 2132 I advised
the Madison 91 1 Center that
I wouldbe ~s~n~ "," to 2565 Route
hours, County
SE in the Townof Sullivan
alongwith Unit, 442, Deputy
GERALD FLUNO, for e noise "".—..p!"!.".t
known
due to the suspect being to be uncooperative
with law enforcement,
Upon 1stood
arrival, scene security.
by for
Code 10.
ReportingOfficer:GERALD FLUNQ
IncidentStatus,CLOSED BY INVEST!GATION Status Date:12/07/2020
Foeo2ofs 17.'03:27
i 2/t srt020
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF:P.OOB
01/22/2021
RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35
TUE
1 2 / 22 / 20 2 0 14t 3S F AX 0 0 8 / 0 10
NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report)
Apency Name; Div/Pet: Case #: Incident#:
MADISON COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPT 7263 480320
IncidentType Location Date Reported: Occuned Prom: OccurredTo:
2"
CIVIL-LANDLORD TENANT TR SULLIV AN / TOWN / 11/27/202018:06 11/27/2020 18i06
Associated Persons Informatiort
Type DOB Name Address
PERSON NOT(YET) INTI 04/10/1979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL J 2565 ROUTE 5 E
APT 4
SULLIVAN, NEW YORK
PERSON INTERVIEWED 05/24/1956 ROSS. TERESA D QUARRY ROAD
BLDG 6587 APT 4
CHITTENANGO, NEW YORK
Incident Narratives
Date of Date
Action Written Narrative
11/27/2020 11/27/2020 LANDLORD/rENANT: TOWN OF SULLIV AN
On I1/27/2020 at 1806 hours,
while assignedto markedpatrolunit zone 2 for the 2
442 and covering
shift,1
responded to 2565route 5 E. in the Town
of Sullivan
in regards
to a landlord
having a dispute
witha tenant spot,
over a parking Unit425 Deputy DURANT also responded.
Priorto arrival,
we
spoke to TERESA ROSS, the reporting
person.ROSS agreed to meet at a parking
lot down the road,
away from the dispatched
residence.
While speakingwith MICHAEL
ROSS, she stated that her tenant, CARPENTBR, had a guest at his
apartmentwho parked forthe other tenants.
in an area that was an Incenvenience ROSS stated that
she wentto CARPENTER'S apartmentto advise himthat his guest will her ear and
have to relocate
CAPENTER ROSS told
became irate. CARPENTER that she was going At that
to call the police.
point,ROSS stated that CARPENTER's the apartment
guest exited and lenthe area.
ROSS stated
that due to the problem
beingsolvedfor the time
being,she wouldjustlike
thisincident
documented.
ROSS advised me that she wants
to get CARPENTER but due to the covid-19
evicted problems,she
ROSS also stated that she does not live
to do so at this time.
is unable in the same building
as
CARPENTER and does notfeel as if he is a problem.
At 1 have no further
this time, information.
Code 01
I1/27/2020 I1/27/2020 ASSIST, TOWN OF SULL1V AN:
On Friday, while
I 1/27/2020, assigned to all zones in marked
unit425 ror the 2-shift
tourof duty,
1
respondedto this complaint
withDep. FLUNO. We met withthe reporting
parkinglot due to officer
safetyconcernswithMICHAEL CARPENTER.
PageI of 2 12/I8/102o 1103:55
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/22/2021
RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35 P,009
12/22/20 20 TUE 141 39 FAX 009/010
NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report)
Agency Name: Div/Pct: Case #: Incident#:
MADISON COUNTY SHERiFFS DEPT X 479000
Incident
Type Location Date Reported: OccurredFrom: moud To:
/2"
DIST'JRB.-DISORDERLY COND SULLIVAN / TOWN 11/01/2020 12:23 11/01/2020 12:23 11/01/2020 13:00
Associated Persons Information
Type DOB Name Address
PERSON INTERVIEWED 04/10/l979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL J 256S STATE ROUTE 5
APT UP
CHI7TENANOO, NEW YORK 13037
PERSON INTERVIEWED 07/22/1967 TUFFLEY, MAUDE J 2505 CREEK RD
APT UP
CHITTENANGO, NEW YORK 13037
PERSON INTERViEWED 04/27/1971 KINNEY, PATRICK C 6802 CREBK RD
APT UP
CHITTENANGO, NEW YORK 13037
PageI of2 12/18/202017:04:56
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF:
P,010 01/22/2021
Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35
RX @010 / 010
TUE
12 / 22 / 20 20 14: 39 FAX
Incident
Type Location Date Reported: Occurred From: OccurredTo:
2"
DISTURB.-DISORDERLY COND SULLIVAN / TOWN / I1/01/2020 12:23 11/01/2020 12:23 11/01/202013:00
IncidentNarratives
Date of Date
Action Written Narrative
11/01/2020 11/01/2020 DISPUTE: TOWN OF SULLIVAN
On 11/01/2020 1was assignedto markedpatrolunit439 covering I shift. At
all zones for the
approximately 1223 hoursIreceiveda phone call
fromDep: Ladd in regards to him
receivinga
phone callfrom PATRICK KINNEY. KINNEY stated that he was not home but someone had shown
up to his house wanting
to fight
him. KINNEY stated that his girlflriend
was home at the time,
KINNEY'S girlfriend
was able to get a license plate
number as the vehicle
was drivingaway of
HVH8020.
1 contacted
KINNEY and he stated that when
he was out running Blazer
errands a blue Chevy Trail
showed up to his house at 6802 Creek
Rd. in the Town
of Then a unknown
Sullivan. male got out
yellingforKINNEY him.
to fight KINNEY drovearound and found lot of the
the male in the parking
car washin the Village
of Chittenango
where they had a verbal
argument. Bothparties argued for a
few minutesthen theyboth droveaway,KINNEY justwants alone as he stated
this male to leave him
up to his house in the past.
that this guy has shown
plate number
I ran the license and It came back to a MICHAEL CARPENTER, DEPUTY WOODEN
and I bothrespondedto CARPENTER'S address to speak with
hlm. and located the
We both arrived
describedvehicleat 2565Seneca Tumpike in the Townof Sullivan.
A femalein a silver
Ford truck
pulledup to talk female
to us. The identified
herselfas MAUDE TUFFLEY. MAUDE stated that the
by and saw PATRICK
she was driving KINNEY and MICHAEL CARPENTER at the car
arguing
wash. MAUDE stated that she has known
CARPENTER fora longtimeand knows he has mental
healthissues. MAUDE then stated CARPENTER was probablyarguingwithKinney because she had
toldCARPENTER that she received
a phone call
from a enknoum male and that she
Inte last night
cigarette
had been getting buttsin her mailbox
and she thinks
KINNEY mighthave done it.
CARPENTER stated that he did go to his house to try and fight
him but KINNEY was not there.
CARPENTER then wentto wash his car where
Kinneylocatedhim and theyboth had a verbal
argument.After arguingboth parties
separated. I advised
CARPENTER from
to stay away his
propertyand if there is an issue to call
91l.No father actionat this time.
Code 1.
ReportingOfficer:ROBERT MARRIOTT
IncidentStatus:CLOSED BY INVESTIOATION Status Date:I1/01/2020
Page2 or2 12/l8/2020 It04:56
Preview
FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/22/2021 EXHIBIT FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: P.005 01/22/2021 RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35 14 s 3 7 FAX @005/ 010 TUE L 2 / 2 2 / 20 20 NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report) Agency Name: Div/Pct: Case #: Incident#: MADISON COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPT 7263 480918 Type Incident Location Date Reported: Occuned From: OccurredTo: 2* NOlSE-NOlSE COMPLAINT SULLIVAN / TOWN / 12/12/2020 20:55 12/12/20202O:55 12/12/202021:15 Associated Persons Information DOB Name Address PERSONNOT (YET) INTI 04/10/1979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL J 2565 ROUTE 5E APT 4 SULLIVAN, NEW Y ORK IncidentNarratives Date of Date Action Written Narrative 12/12/2020 12/12/2020 NOISE COMPLAINT, TOWN OF SULLIVAN: On 12/l2/2020 I was workingthe 2 shift, assignedto zone 2 in marked patrolunit#437. At 2057 hours,ID64 and I respond-dto 2565Route 5 B #4 for a reported noise complaint involving MICHAEL CARPENTER. Upon I did not hear any loud arrival, musicor disturb==e.I attempted to make contactwith MICHAEL, but he refused to answerhis doorfor an interview. No further action taken. End ofreport, ReportingOfficer:JOSHUA SEYMORE IncidentStatustCLOSED BY INVESTlGATION Status Date:12/12/2020 PageI or I 12/I8/202017:02:50 FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 13:35 RECEIVED NYSCEF:P.006 01/22/2021 RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 TUE 12 / 22 / 20 20 1 4 t 37 F AX 20 0 6 / 010 NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report) Agency Name: Div/Pet: Case #: Incident#: _.. MADISON COUNTY SNERiFFS DEFr 7263 480707 Incident Type Location Date Reported: Occurred From: OccurredTo: 2' NOISE-NOISE COMPLAINT SULLIVAN / TOWN / 12/07/202021:34 12/07/2020 21:34 Associated Persons !=fo-nation Type DOB Name Address PERSON NOT (YET) INT)04/i0/1979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL 3 2565 ROUTE 5E APT 4 SULL1VAN, NEW Y ORK PERSON INTERVIEWED 05/24/1956 ROSS, TERESA D QUARRY ROAD BLDO 6587 APT 4 CHITTENANOO, NEW YORK PageI of2 12/t8/202017:03:27 FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: P,007 01/22/2021 AX Oate/Tiioe 12/22/2020 13:35 I007/810 12/22/2020 208 14i 38 Pnx Incident T Location Date Re oned. Occurred Prom: Occurred Tc: /2' NOISE-NOISE COMPLAINT SULLIVA'N /TOWN l2/07/2020 21.'34 l2/07/2020 21:34 IncidentNarratives Date of Date Action Written Narrative 12/07/2020 12/07/2020 ASS!ST: I was dispatched and stood by in the area for officer to this complaint safety DEPUTY until FLUNO advisedthat be was ail set. 12/0'//2020 12/07/2020 LOVDNOISE COMPLAINT: TOWN QF SULLIVAN On 12/7/2020 at 2134hours,whileassigned to marked patrolunit442 and covering the 2 sone 2 for shiA,Iresponded to2565 route5 B.intheTown ofSullivaninregardsto aloudnoisecomplaint. Unit 428 DeputyKOPEC also responded.Prior I spoke to arrival, to TERESA ROSS, the reporting persoll. While speakingwith ROSS, she stated that she has been receiving severalc";..p! 0!."s from her tenants0;gar!;.8 MICIIAEL CARPENTER. ROSS stared that she has been advised by her tenants that CARPENTER his music has been playing it was penerrating so loud that thmugh the walls "!st-"!".the tenants.ROSS stated that CARPENTER was asked multiple times to turn his music down ROSS stated that she would but refused. police like to speak with CARPENTER and ask him I CARPENTER' thc music to turn down. While on scene, I did not hear the music coming from S apartment to speak to him but I attempted anyway but didnot receive it must an answer at the door, be noted recent "" that there have been several .."!i.".h regarding CARPENTER and ROSS would like evicted to get him but dueto the current covid-19 re.~ ROSS also stated shc is unable to. ":i=..:, to keep calling that she is going to keep the paper trail going. At this have no further time,! information. Code 01 12/07/2020 12/07/2020 ASSIST, ROUTE 5, TOWN OF SULLlVAN: On Monday, December 7th, 2020,I reported to work at the Madison County SherN'sOlsce far s "2" 1800 to 0600 hours, and was assigned patrolUnit all s~! «d!ed shiA, to marked 428 covering Rones. At 2132 I advised the Madison 91 1 Center that I wouldbe ~s~n~ "," to 2565 Route hours, County SE in the Townof Sullivan alongwith Unit, 442, Deputy GERALD FLUNO, for e noise "".—..p!"!.".t known due to the suspect being to be uncooperative with law enforcement, Upon 1stood arrival, scene security. by for Code 10. ReportingOfficer:GERALD FLUNQ IncidentStatus,CLOSED BY INVEST!GATION Status Date:12/07/2020 Foeo2ofs 17.'03:27 i 2/t srt020 FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF:P.OOB 01/22/2021 RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35 TUE 1 2 / 22 / 20 2 0 14t 3S F AX 0 0 8 / 0 10 NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report) Apency Name; Div/Pet: Case #: Incident#: MADISON COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPT 7263 480320 IncidentType Location Date Reported: Occuned Prom: OccurredTo: 2" CIVIL-LANDLORD TENANT TR SULLIV AN / TOWN / 11/27/202018:06 11/27/2020 18i06 Associated Persons Informatiort Type DOB Name Address PERSON NOT(YET) INTI 04/10/1979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL J 2565 ROUTE 5 E APT 4 SULLIVAN, NEW YORK PERSON INTERVIEWED 05/24/1956 ROSS. TERESA D QUARRY ROAD BLDG 6587 APT 4 CHITTENANGO, NEW YORK Incident Narratives Date of Date Action Written Narrative 11/27/2020 11/27/2020 LANDLORD/rENANT: TOWN OF SULLIV AN On I1/27/2020 at 1806 hours, while assignedto markedpatrolunit zone 2 for the 2 442 and covering shift,1 responded to 2565route 5 E. in the Town of Sullivan in regards to a landlord having a dispute witha tenant spot, over a parking Unit425 Deputy DURANT also responded. Priorto arrival, we spoke to TERESA ROSS, the reporting person.ROSS agreed to meet at a parking lot down the road, away from the dispatched residence. While speakingwith MICHAEL ROSS, she stated that her tenant, CARPENTBR, had a guest at his apartmentwho parked forthe other tenants. in an area that was an Incenvenience ROSS stated that she wentto CARPENTER'S apartmentto advise himthat his guest will her ear and have to relocate CAPENTER ROSS told became irate. CARPENTER that she was going At that to call the police. point,ROSS stated that CARPENTER's the apartment guest exited and lenthe area. ROSS stated that due to the problem beingsolvedfor the time being,she wouldjustlike thisincident documented. ROSS advised me that she wants to get CARPENTER but due to the covid-19 evicted problems,she ROSS also stated that she does not live to do so at this time. is unable in the same building as CARPENTER and does notfeel as if he is a problem. At 1 have no further this time, information. Code 01 I1/27/2020 I1/27/2020 ASSIST, TOWN OF SULL1V AN: On Friday, while I 1/27/2020, assigned to all zones in marked unit425 ror the 2-shift tourof duty, 1 respondedto this complaint withDep. FLUNO. We met withthe reporting parkinglot due to officer safetyconcernswithMICHAEL CARPENTER. PageI of 2 12/I8/102o 1103:55 FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/22/2021 RX Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35 P,009 12/22/20 20 TUE 141 39 FAX 009/010 NEW YORK STATE INCIDENT REPORT (Short Form Report) Agency Name: Div/Pct: Case #: Incident#: MADISON COUNTY SHERiFFS DEPT X 479000 Incident Type Location Date Reported: OccurredFrom: moud To: /2" DIST'JRB.-DISORDERLY COND SULLIVAN / TOWN 11/01/2020 12:23 11/01/2020 12:23 11/01/2020 13:00 Associated Persons Information Type DOB Name Address PERSON INTERVIEWED 04/10/l979 CARPENTER, MICHAEL J 256S STATE ROUTE 5 APT UP CHI7TENANOO, NEW YORK 13037 PERSON INTERVIEWED 07/22/1967 TUFFLEY, MAUDE J 2505 CREEK RD APT UP CHITTENANGO, NEW YORK 13037 PERSON INTERViEWED 04/27/1971 KINNEY, PATRICK C 6802 CREBK RD APT UP CHITTENANGO, NEW YORK 13037 PageI of2 12/18/202017:04:56 FILED: MADISON COUNTY CLERK 01/22/2021 10:50 AM INDEX NO. EF2021-1053 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: P,010 01/22/2021 Date/Time 12/22/2020 13:35 RX @010 / 010 TUE 12 / 22 / 20 20 14: 39 FAX Incident Type Location Date Reported: Occurred From: OccurredTo: 2" DISTURB.-DISORDERLY COND SULLIVAN / TOWN / I1/01/2020 12:23 11/01/2020 12:23 11/01/202013:00 IncidentNarratives Date of Date Action Written Narrative 11/01/2020 11/01/2020 DISPUTE: TOWN OF SULLIVAN On 11/01/2020 1was assignedto markedpatrolunit439 covering I shift. At all zones for the approximately 1223 hoursIreceiveda phone call fromDep: Ladd in regards to him receivinga phone callfrom PATRICK KINNEY. KINNEY stated that he was not home but someone had shown up to his house wanting to fight him. KINNEY stated that his girlflriend was home at the time, KINNEY'S girlfriend was able to get a license plate number as the vehicle was drivingaway of HVH8020. 1 contacted KINNEY and he stated that when he was out running Blazer errands a blue Chevy Trail showed up to his house at 6802 Creek Rd. in the Town of Then a unknown Sullivan. male got out yellingforKINNEY him. to fight KINNEY drovearound and found lot of the the male in the parking car washin the Village of Chittenango where they had a verbal argument. Bothparties argued for a few minutesthen theyboth droveaway,KINNEY justwants alone as he stated this male to leave him up to his house in the past. that this guy has shown plate number I ran the license and It came back to a MICHAEL CARPENTER, DEPUTY WOODEN and I bothrespondedto CARPENTER'S address to speak with hlm. and located the We both arrived describedvehicleat 2565Seneca Tumpike in the Townof Sullivan. A femalein a silver Ford truck pulledup to talk female to us. The identified herselfas MAUDE TUFFLEY. MAUDE stated that the by and saw PATRICK she was driving KINNEY and MICHAEL CARPENTER at the car arguing wash. MAUDE stated that she has known CARPENTER fora longtimeand knows he has mental healthissues. MAUDE then stated CARPENTER was probablyarguingwithKinney because she had toldCARPENTER that she received a phone call from a enknoum male and that she Inte last night cigarette had been getting buttsin her mailbox and she thinks KINNEY mighthave done it. CARPENTER stated that he did go to his house to try and fight him but KINNEY was not there. CARPENTER then wentto wash his car where Kinneylocatedhim and theyboth had a verbal argument.After arguingboth parties separated. I advised CARPENTER from to stay away his propertyand if there is an issue to call 91l.No father actionat this time. Code 1. ReportingOfficer:ROBERT MARRIOTT IncidentStatus:CLOSED BY INVESTIOATION Status Date:I1/01/2020 Page2 or2 12/l8/2020 It04:56