On June 07, 2021 a
Conference
was filed
involving a dispute between
Caroline Kay Hanna,
and
Boruch Perl,
Mordechai Perl,
for Torts - Motor Vehicle
in the District Court of Orange County.
Preview
DESIGNATION AND DISCOVERY STIPULATION AND ORDER. STANDARD CASE
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COL]NTY OF ORANGE
1Y:11.::).:.1T:*:.Y.:.i::'l ,.
CAROLINE KAY HANNA,
Plaintiff (s)
-against- Index # EF003821-2021
BORUCH PERL and MORDECHAI PERL
Defendant (s)
---------x
This case has been assigned to the Hon. Catherine M. Bartlett and has been designated a
standard case. Disclosure must be completed within twelve months of the date of the filing
of the RJI.
A. DISCOVERYSCHEDULE
1/17/22
l. Insurance Coverage: Ifnot already provided, shall be fumished on or before
The following information must be provided:
Name of Primary Canier:
Amount of Coverage
Name of Excess Carrier (s):
Amount of Coverage:
Self-Insured: ( )Yes ( )No
2. Bill of Particulars:
done
(a) Demand for Bill of Particulars shall be served on or before
(within two (2) weeks).
I
(b) Bill of Particulars shall be served on or before 12/17/21 but within
thirty (30) days ofreceipt ofdemand. Defendant to serve Bill of Particulars
as to any affirmative defenses within thirty (30) days ofreceipt o a demand.
(c) A Supplemental Bill ofParticulars shall be served by
as to Items on or before
3. Authorizations: Medical, Hospital, Other:
( ) Have been furnished.
( ) Ptaintiff shall provide all necessary doctor and hospital authorizations to
defendant (s)within twenty (20) days ofthe date of this order and not later than- 12/17/21
Defendant shall request all records within fifteen (15) days ofreceipt of
authorizations, not later than
( ) Plaintiff shall provide all employment records or tax retums for
years no later than
4. Examination before Trial:
( ) Have been completed/waived.
(X ) Ordered to commence on or before 3/17/22 at the offices of
virtual deposition
( ) All partied are to be deposed.
( ) Plaintiff(s) are to be deposed.
( ) Defendant (s) are to be deposed.
Said examinations shall continue from day to day until completed. The priority of
examination shall be govemed by previously served notices, ifany.
5. Physical Examinations/Doctors Reports:
(X ) Physical and/or psychiatric examinations are to be completed no later than_ 4/17/22
(within thirty (30) days of completion of Examination before Trial) and doctor's
reports of such examinations shall be exchanged not later than forty-five (45) days
after the physical.
6. Third Party Actions/lmpleader:
Third party actions, ifany, shall be commenced not later than thirty (30) days after the
2
Examination befbre Trial or the date of this order, whichever is later.
7. Other Discovery:
(a) _Defendant shall provide to Plaintiff not later than
1/17/22 the following items:-
Responses to Plaintiff's initial discovery demands
(b) All parties, on or before shall exchange names and
addresses of all witnesses, statements of opposing parties and photographs, or, if none,
provide an affirmation to that effect.
(c) Demand for discovery and inspection shall be served by (plaintiff)/(defendant) on
or before The items sought shall be produced to the extent not objected
to, and objections, ifany, shall be stated within ten (10) days of service ofthe demand.
B. ENDDATEFORALLDISCLOSURE: .
FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER MAY RESULT
IN SANCTIONS, WHICH MAY INCLUDE COSTS INCURR.ED BY THE OTHER
PARTY, AND ANY OTHER SANCTION AUTHORIZED BY LAW, INCLUDING BUT
NOT LIMITED TO CONTEMPT, DISMISSAL, STRIKING OF PLEADINGS.
NO ADJOURNMENTS OF ANY TIME DIRECTIVE ABOVE SHALL BE HAD
WITHOUT THE PERMISSION OF THE COURT TO WHICH THIS CASE IS
ASSIGNED.
THIS ORDER SUPERSEDES THE STATUTORY STAY IN CPLR 3214 FOR
DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS MADE PURSUANT TO CPLR 321I, 3212, OR 3213. UNLESS
OTHERWISE ORDERED BY THE COURT ALL PRETRIAL DISCOVERY SHALL
CONTINUE NOTWITHSTANDING THE FILING OF A DISPOSITIVE MOTION.
Stuart W. Mosbacher, Esq.
Attomey for Plaintiff (s) Attomey for Defendant (s)
Fax# 845-343-0929 Fax# 866 421 0804
Phone # 845-343-7626
Dated: Goshen, New York
2021 SO ORDERED:
CATHEzuNE M. BARTLETT
Judge NY State Court of Claims
3 Acting Supreme Court Justice
Preview
DESIGNATION AND DISCOVERY STIPULATION AND ORDER. STANDARD CASE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COL]NTY OF ORANGE 1Y:11.::).:.1T:*:.Y.:.i::'l ,. CAROLINE KAY HANNA, Plaintiff (s) -against- Index # EF003821-2021 BORUCH PERL and MORDECHAI PERL Defendant (s) ---------x This case has been assigned to the Hon. Catherine M. Bartlett and has been designated a standard case. Disclosure must be completed within twelve months of the date of the filing of the RJI. A. DISCOVERYSCHEDULE 1/17/22 l. Insurance Coverage: Ifnot already provided, shall be fumished on or before The following information must be provided: Name of Primary Canier: Amount of Coverage Name of Excess Carrier (s): Amount of Coverage: Self-Insured: ( )Yes ( )No 2. Bill of Particulars: done (a) Demand for Bill of Particulars shall be served on or before (within two (2) weeks). I (b) Bill of Particulars shall be served on or before 12/17/21 but within thirty (30) days ofreceipt ofdemand. Defendant to serve Bill of Particulars as to any affirmative defenses within thirty (30) days ofreceipt o a demand. (c) A Supplemental Bill ofParticulars shall be served by as to Items on or before 3. Authorizations: Medical, Hospital, Other: ( ) Have been furnished. ( ) Ptaintiff shall provide all necessary doctor and hospital authorizations to defendant (s)within twenty (20) days ofthe date of this order and not later than- 12/17/21 Defendant shall request all records within fifteen (15) days ofreceipt of authorizations, not later than ( ) Plaintiff shall provide all employment records or tax retums for years no later than 4. Examination before Trial: ( ) Have been completed/waived. (X ) Ordered to commence on or before 3/17/22 at the offices of virtual deposition ( ) All partied are to be deposed. ( ) Plaintiff(s) are to be deposed. ( ) Defendant (s) are to be deposed. Said examinations shall continue from day to day until completed. The priority of examination shall be govemed by previously served notices, ifany. 5. Physical Examinations/Doctors Reports: (X ) Physical and/or psychiatric examinations are to be completed no later than_ 4/17/22 (within thirty (30) days of completion of Examination before Trial) and doctor's reports of such examinations shall be exchanged not later than forty-five (45) days after the physical. 6. Third Party Actions/lmpleader: Third party actions, ifany, shall be commenced not later than thirty (30) days after the 2 Examination befbre Trial or the date of this order, whichever is later. 7. Other Discovery: (a) _Defendant shall provide to Plaintiff not later than 1/17/22 the following items:- Responses to Plaintiff's initial discovery demands (b) All parties, on or before shall exchange names and addresses of all witnesses, statements of opposing parties and photographs, or, if none, provide an affirmation to that effect. (c) Demand for discovery and inspection shall be served by (plaintiff)/(defendant) on or before The items sought shall be produced to the extent not objected to, and objections, ifany, shall be stated within ten (10) days of service ofthe demand. B. ENDDATEFORALLDISCLOSURE: . FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER MAY RESULT IN SANCTIONS, WHICH MAY INCLUDE COSTS INCURR.ED BY THE OTHER PARTY, AND ANY OTHER SANCTION AUTHORIZED BY LAW, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO CONTEMPT, DISMISSAL, STRIKING OF PLEADINGS. NO ADJOURNMENTS OF ANY TIME DIRECTIVE ABOVE SHALL BE HAD WITHOUT THE PERMISSION OF THE COURT TO WHICH THIS CASE IS ASSIGNED. THIS ORDER SUPERSEDES THE STATUTORY STAY IN CPLR 3214 FOR DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS MADE PURSUANT TO CPLR 321I, 3212, OR 3213. UNLESS OTHERWISE ORDERED BY THE COURT ALL PRETRIAL DISCOVERY SHALL CONTINUE NOTWITHSTANDING THE FILING OF A DISPOSITIVE MOTION. Stuart W. Mosbacher, Esq. Attomey for Plaintiff (s) Attomey for Defendant (s) Fax# 845-343-0929 Fax# 866 421 0804 Phone # 845-343-7626 Dated: Goshen, New York 2021 SO ORDERED: CATHEzuNE M. BARTLETT Judge NY State Court of Claims 3 Acting Supreme Court Justice