Party Notice: SALVATORE MINEO INDIVIDUALLY, AND ON BEHALF OF ALL et al VS. CITY SIGHTSEEING CORPORATION, A DELAWARE et al

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                MOMMA

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

Document Scanning Lead Sheet
Nov-15-2011 4:55 pm

Case Number: CGC-10-504804
Filing Date: Nov-15-2011 1:55
Juke Box: 001 Image: 03385939
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER/NOTICE OF RULING FILED

EO INDIVIDUALLY, AND ON BEHALF OF ALL et al VS. CITY SIGHTSEEING CORPORATK

001003385939

Instructions:
Piease place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.+ FAX (415) 974-1520

LAW OFFICES OF
LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG, MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP
199 FREMONT STREET - 21°" FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA $4105

TEL (415) 957-1800

ORIGINAL

STEVEN H. BOVARNICK (State Bar # 99361)
Sbovarnick@lpslaw.com NOV 45 20n]
JENNIFER A. RISO (State Bar # 203497)

yr
“ van LE, D

UATY Of San Francisco

jriso@Ipslaw.com CLERK OF TH
LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG, av Moy Qe E COURT
MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP fae

199 Fremont Street - 21" Floor
San Francisco, California 94105
Telephone: (415) 957-1800
Facsimile: (415) 974-1520

Attorneys for City Sightseeing Ltd. s/h/a Citysightseeing Worldwide erroneously sued as
Citysightseeing Worldwide

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

SALVATORE MINEO, GINA SCHEMBARI, | ©48® No. CGC-10-504804

PHILLIP THOMAS NAILS, BENJAMIN NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER

DUAX, and DAVID HAYWARD
wg: sae GRANTING DEFENDANT CITY
individually, and on behalf of others similarly SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a

situated, CITYSIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE'S
. MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF
Plaintiffs, SUMMONS

vs.
CITYSIGHTSEEING CORPORATION, a
Delaware corporation, CITY SIGHTSEEING .

: * : Action Filed: October 22, 2010
WORLDWIDE and DOES 1-500, inclusive, Trial Date: None Set

Defendants.

{S/CITY S000 1/PLD/75 1731, DOCX} 1

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER GRANTING
DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a
CITYSIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO
QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONSFAX (415) 974-1520

LAW OFFICES OF
LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG, MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94105

199 FREMONT STREET - 215" FLOOR
TEL (416) 957-1800 -

Ce Wa DH Hk WN

YN YY YP YP YP KR NY DY Be Be ew eB Be ee ee
oa A mH FB MP KF SF 6S eI AH BF BY FS S

NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on November 15, 2011, the attached ORDER

GRANTING DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a CITYSIGHTSEEING

WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS vas entered by the Court

in the above-referenced matter, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated

herein by reference.

DATED: November 15, 2011

{S/CITYS1/0001/PLD/751731.DOCX}

LELAND, PARACHINI,
MATZGER & ME!

BERG,

Steven H. Bovarnick
Attomeys for City Sightseeing Ltd. s/h/a
Citysightseeing Worldwide erroneously sued
as Citysightseeing Worldwide

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER GRANTING
DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD, s/h/a
CITYSIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO.
QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONSEXHIBIT A+ PAX (419) 974-1520

LAW OFFICES OF

LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINSERG, MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP
199 FREMONT STREET - 215" FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94305

TEL (415) 957-7800

CS Oy KH mH BB wR HR

by om we RP YB NN NR RR SF Be Be Be oe Be ee Re
e349 A nan ££ WN = SC BRIA A F&F HK ET ES

STEVEN H. BOVARNICK (State Bar # 99361)

Sbovarnick@|pslaw.com

JENNIFER A. RISO (State Bar # 203497)

jriso@ipslaw.com

LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG,
MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP

199 Fremont Street - 21° Floor

San Francisco, California 94105

Telephone: (415) 957-1800

Faesimile: (415) 974-1520

ENDORSED
San Fenced tints D Court
NOV 15 201

CLERK OF THE COURT
BY: __GINA GONZALES
Deputy Clerk ~

Attorneys for City Sightseeing Ltd. s/h/a Citysightseeing Worldwide erroneously sued as

Citysightseeing Worldwide

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

SALVATORE MINEO, GINA SCHEMBARI,
PHILLIP THOMAS NAILS, BENJAMIN
DUAX, and DAVID HAYWARD
individually, and on behalf of others similarly
situated,

Plaintiffs,
vs.
CITYSIGHTSEEING CORPORATION, a
Delaware corporation, CITY SIGHTSEEING
WORLDWIDE and DOES 1-500, inclusive,

Defendants.

Case No. CGC-10-504804

D] ORDER GRANTING
DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD.
s/h/a CITYSIGHTSEEING
WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO QUASH
SERVICE OF SUMMONS

Date: November 15, 2011
Time: 9:30 am.

Dept.: 302

Judge: Hon. Harold Kahn

Action Filed:
Trial Date:

October 22, 2010
None Set

The motion of defendant CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD, s/h/a CITY SIGHTSEEING

WORLDWIDE, which appeared specially only, for an order quashing service of summons on it

came on regularly for hearing by the court on November 15, 2011. Appearing specially for CITY

SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a CITY SIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE for the purpose of presenting

the proposed order for signature was Steven H. Bovarnick of the law firm Leland, Parachini,

Steinberg, Matzger and Melnick. No other appearances were made.

Having considered the papers submitted in support of and in opposition to the motion and

{SYCITYSI/000 L/PLD/747311.DOCX}

1

[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT
CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a CITYSIGHTSEEING
WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF
TIMMONSSAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA $4105
+ FAX (419) 974-4520

199 FREMONT STREET - 2157 FLOOR
TEL (418) 957-1500

LAW OFFICES OF
LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG, MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP.

Ce Oe IV DH FE WHR

RB YP NY N NN KN De em Be ee
a Dn ww B Ww NM EF SF FE BE IW AA FF BY FS

nN
oe

there being no challenge to the Court's tentative ruling, and good cause appearing therefore,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the motion be, and is hereby, GRANTED. Service on the
moving defendant was defective, but, even if that service was not defective, the moving defendant
would still be entitled to quash service on it due to plaintiffs’ failure to present facts showing that
requiring the moving defendant to defend this action in California comports with due process.
Plaintiffs have not shown that the moving defendant is subject to either general or specific

jurisdiction.

NOV 15 201

DATED:
HARGL Ds KARIN
Harold E. Kahn
Judge of the Superior Court
{SYCITYSI/000L/PLD/747311. DOCK} 2

[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT
CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a CITYSIGHTSEEING
WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF
STIMMANG.SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94105
© FAX (418) 974-1520

199 FREMONT STREET - 21°” FLOOR
TEL (415) 957-1800

LAW OFFICES OF
LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG, MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP

Cem WN

10
il
12
13
4
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

PROOF OF SERVICE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

At the time of service, I was over 18 years of age and not a party to this action. [ am
employed in the County of San Francisco, State of California. My business address is 199
Fremont Street - 21st Floor, San Francisco, California 94105.

On November 15, 2011, I served true copies of the following document(s) described as
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD.
s/hia CITYSIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF
SUMMONS on the interested parties in this action as follows:

SEE ATTACHED SERVICE LIST

BY MAIL: | enclosed the document(s) in a sealed envelope or package addressed to the
persons at the addresses listed in the Service List and placed the envelope for collection and
mailing, following our ordinary business practices. [ am readily familiar with Leland, Parachini,
Steinberg, Matzger & Melnick, LLP's practice for collecting and processing correspondence for
mailing. On the same day that the correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is
deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service, in a sealed
envelope with postage fully prepaid.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
foregoing is true and correct.

Executed on November 15, 2011, at San Francisco, California.

Kim Scott

{S:/CITYSI/0001/PLD/751731.DOCX} 3

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER GRANTING
DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD, s/h/a
CITYSIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO
QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS+ FAX (415) 974-1820

189 FREMONT STREET - 215° FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94105

LAW OFFICES OF
LELAND, PARACHINI, STEINBERG, MATZGER & MELNICK, LLP
TEL (415) 957-1800

wo ec a KH nH ke RH YD

YPN YP N NY NN NR NR RY EF BF Be Be ee ee oe
oc Ty A HW RF YW MP BF SF CeO UW KR mH FE BH YY SF S

SERVICE LIST

Ashwin Ladva, Esq.

Ladva Law Firm

530 Jackson Street, 2"! Floor

San Francisco, California 94133

Tel: (415) 296-8844

Email: ladvalaw@gmail.com

Attorneys for Plaintiffs Salvatore Mineo, Gina Schembari, Phillip T. Nails, Benjamin Duax, and
David Hayward individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated

Daniel Martinez de la Vega, Esq.

Law Offices of Daniel Vega

201 Spear Street, Suite 1100

San Francisco, California 94105

Tel: (415) 287-6203

Fax: (415) 704-5067

Email: dvega@vegalawyer.com

Attorneys for Plaintiffs Salvatore Mineo, Gina Schembari, Phillip T. Nails, Benjamin Duax, and
David Hayward individually and on behalf of ail others similarly situated

Elizabeth Thompson, Esq.

Paul J. Dion, Esq.

Jones Bothwell Dion & Thompson LLP

44 Montgomery Street, Suite 610

San Francisco, California 94104

Tel: (415) 951-8900

Fax: (415) 951-8901

Attorneys for Defendant CitySightseeing Corporation

{S:CITYSI/0001/PLD/751731.DOCX} 4

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER GRANTING
DEFENDANT CITY SIGHTSEEING LTD. s/h/a
CITYSIGHTSEEING WORLDWIDE'S MOTION TO
QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS