Preview
FILED:
FILED: TOMPKINS
TOMPKINS COUNTY
COUNTY CLERK
CLERK 07/28/2020
07/27/2020 09:27
11:24 AM
AM)
INDEX
INDEX NO.
NO. EF2020-0345
EF2020-0345
NYSCEFREOWEST
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 4 FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION RECEIVED
FRE jDUTkS NYSCEF: 07/28/2020)
TKWWFOrdy:/27/202
UCS-840 (3/2011) IAS
CI2020-09465
Supreme COUNTY OF Tompkins 2020-0250-M
COURT,
JUdge ASSIgned
Index No: Date Index !ssued:
Hon. Joseph R. Cassidy
R-JTDWe--
Enterthe cüñip|sts
case caption. Do not use et al or et ano.
If morespace is
CAPTION:
attach
reauired, a captionridersheet.
7/27/2020
In theMatter of
LUX ITHACA HOLDINGS, LLC,
Plaintiff(s)/P÷?!?!
s(s)
The BOARD OF ASSESSORSandtheBOARDOF ASSESSMENT
REVIEW of the CITY AND TOWN OF ITHACA, TOMPKINS COUNTY, NEW YORK,
--' ----
De )/Respondent(s)
NATURE OF ACTION OR PROCEEDING: Check ONE box onlyand specifywhere indicated.
MATRIMONIAL | COMMERCIAL
Q Contested Q Businoco Entity corporations,
(including partnerships,
LLCs, etc.)
O uncontested O Contract
NOTE: actions
For all MatrirñGñ|â| where the partieshavechildrenunder
---'
O !nsurance(where insureris a party,
exceptarbitrâGóñ)
and attach
the ageof 18, complete theMATRIMONIAL RJI A
O UCC sales,
(including ñêgatiâb|êinstruments)
|TORTS IO Other Commercial:
(SP°°fY)
Q Asbestos
O BreastImplant NOTE: For Commercial ass|garñêñt
Division requests [22 NYCRR §
^dd=d:=
O Envircñiiiantal: comp!ete
202.70(d)], and attachtheCOMMERCIAL DIV RJi
(specify) REAL PROPERTY: How many properties does the spp!!cat!en include?
O Medical,Dental,or Podiatric
Ms|prâct!ce O Cor-mne±en
O Motor Vehicle O Foreclosure
O Products Liability: PropertyAddress:
(specify) StreetAddress City State Zip
O Other Neg!!ges.e: NOTE: For Foreclosureactions a one-
involving owner-
to four-family,
(specify) occupied,residential or an owner-occupied
property, ceñdciiiiriiürn,
' '
O Other Prefessiciial
W!p-3!ce: complete and attachtheFORECLOSURE RJI A 's.. .-..
(specify) 64·
- Section:
Tax Certiorari Block: 2 18
. Lot:
O Other Tort: O Other RealProperty:
(specify) (specify)
OTHER MATTERS SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS
Certificate
of Incorporat!en/Dissolution
[seeNOTE underCommercial] O CPLR Article
75 (Arbitraticii)
[seeNOTE under Commercial]
O Emergency MedicalTreatment O CPLR Article
78 (Body or Officer)
O Habeas Corpus O ElectionLaw
O LocalCourt Appeal O MHL Article9.60(Kendra's Law)
O Mechanic'sLien O MHL Article10 (Sex Offender Conñn:-ont
|n|t|d)
O Name Change O MHL Article10 (Sex Offender Confinement-Review)
O PistolPermitRevocation Hearing O MHL Article81 (Guardianship)
Q Sale or Financeof Re!!g!eus/Not-for-Profit
Property O Other MentalHygiene:
(SP°°fY)
Q Other:
(specify)
Û Other SpecialProceed!ng:
I (specify)
STATUS OF ACTION OR g-nuuttEJiNG: Answer YES or NO forEVERY questionAND entersdd!!!éñe!information
where indicated.
| YES | NO |
Has a summons and complaintor summeñs w/noticebeen filed? O 0 If yes,
date filed:
Is this acticñ/picceeding
beingfiledpoet-judgment? O 0 If yes, judgment
date:
1
1 of
of 3
3
FILED:
FILED: TOMPKINS
TOMPKINS COUNTY
COUNTY CLERK
CLERK 07/28/2020
07/27/2020 09:27
11:24 AM
AM INDEX
INDEX NO.
NO. EF2020-0345
EF2020-0345
NYSCEF
NYSCEF DOC.
DOC. NO.
NO. 4
3 RECEIVED
RECEIVED NYSCEF:
NYSCEF: 07/28/2020
07/27/2020
CI2020-09465 Index #: EF2020-0345
Ö Note ofss an o of Readiness
Certificate
O Notice Dental, or Podlatric
of Medical, Date Issue Joined:
O Noticeof MotIon Relief Sought: ReturnDate:
O Noticeof Petition Tax AssessmentReview
Relief Sought: ReturnDate: on submission
O Order to Show Cause Relief Sought: ReturnDate:
O Other Ex Parte Åpplication Relief Sought:
O Poor Person Application
O Request for Preliminary
Conference
O Residential
Meitgags Foreclosure
SettlementConference
O writof Habeas Corpus
O Other (Specify): __
Case Title Index/Case No. Court Judga (ifassigned) Relationship to InstantCase
Parties: AMemeys:
Un- ue
List n apdon order and c|ned h : CarrIer(s):
Providename, firm name businessaddress,phone bcr sad e-mai[
a pa s) (e defendant; address of ag attorneys
that have appearedin the case (Y/N):
LUX ITHACA HOLDINGS,LLC SPELLANE PHILIP G.
LastName LastName FirstName
HARRIS BEACH PLLC
Rrst Name FirmName
PrimaryRole: 99 GARNSEY ROAD PlTTSFORD New York 14534
Petitioner StreetAddress State
city ZIp
SecondaryRole(if any): 585-419-8800 585-419-8812 pepe!!2necharrlsbeach.com
Phone Fax e-mail
LastName LastName First Name
FirstName FirmName
PrimaryRole: New York
Respondent
StreetAddress City State Zip
NO
SecondaryRole(if any):
Phone Fax e-mail
LastName LastName FirstName
FirstName FirmName
PrimaryRole: New York
Respondent StreetAddress City State ZIP
SecondaryRole(If any): O
Phone Fax e-mall
LastName LastName FirstName
FirstName FirmName
PrimaryRole: New York
Respondent StreetAddress State
City ZIP
SecondaryRole(If any):
Phone Fax e-mall
I AFFIRM UNDER THE PENALTY OF PERJURY THAT, TO MY KNOWLEDGE, OTHER THAN AS NOTED ABOVE, THERE ARE AND
HAVE BEEN NO RELATED ACTIONS OR PROCEEDINGS, NOR HAS A REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION PREVIOUSLY BEEN
FILED IN THIS ACTION OR PROCEEDING.
Dated: Julyf 2020 L/
SIGNATURE
NYS Bar License NO. 2276087 Philip G. Sps ane, Esq.
ATTORNEY REGISTRATION NUMBER PRINT OR TYPE NAME
2
2 of
of 3
3
FILED:
FILED: TOMPKINS
TOMPKINS COUNTY
COUNTY CLERK
CLERK 07/28/2020
07/27/2020 09:27
11:24 AM
AM|
INDEX
INDEX NO.
NO. EF2020-0345
EF2020-0345
NYSCEF
NYSCEF DOC.
DOC. NO.
NO. 4
3 RECEIVED
RECEIVED NYSCEF:
NYSCEF: 07/28/2020
07/27/2020
CI2020-09465 Index #: EF2020-0345
ournam¿ COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK --- - -- -
312011
COUNTY OF TOMPKINS
_________________________¬________x Index No. _______________________________
Lux IthacaHoldings, LLC,
RJi No. (ifany) ______________________
-a ainst- Plaintiff(syPetitioner(s)
The Board of Assessors and the Board of Annessment Review of the
COMMERCIAL DIVISION
Cityand Town of Ithaca,Tompkins County, Ngw York . .
-ni(oyRespedenne Request for Judicial Intervention Addendum
COMPLETE WHERE APPLICABLE [add eddit!êñalpages If needed]:
Plaint!ff!Petitioner's cause(s) of action [check allthatapply]:
Breach of contractor fiduciary
duty, fraud,misrepicsc±at!on, busiñêss tort(e.g.unfaircompetitióñ),or statutcry
and/or common
law viciatics
where thebreach or violation
is alleged
to ariseout ofbusiness dealings (e.g.sales of assetsor securities;
corporate
restructuring;
partnership,shârshc|dcr, joint
venture, and other business agrêêmentê; trade secrets;restrictive
covenante; and
employment agrcaments not includingclaims that involve
principally allegeddiscriminatorypractices)
Transactionsgcverned by theUniform Commercie! Code (exclusiveof thoseccñceming individualcooperative or ccñdomiñ|üm
units)
Transectieneinvc|v|ñgcommerc!a! realproperty, includingYellowstone injun me and exdud;iig actionsforthe payment ofrent
only
Shareholder derivativeactions- withoutconsideration of themcñêtary thresho!d
Commercial class actions- without ccñsidsraticñof themonetary threshold
Business transactionsinvolvingor arisingout ofdealingswith commercial banks and otherfinanciä|!ñsutùUúñs
Intemalaffairs
of business organizations
Me!pmotice by accountants or actuar|ês,and legalmalpractice arisingout ofrepresentationin commercia! matters
Environmental insurance coverage
Commarie! insurance ccverags (e.g.directereand errors
officers, and omissions, and bus!±ss interruptioncaverage)
Dissc|üticnof corp~ations, peecrmpe, limited companies,
liability limited pednerships
liability and jointventures- without
considerationof themonetary threshold
App!!ceticesto stayor compel arbitiation
and affirmor disaffirmaibitraticñ
awards and related injunctive pursuant
relief toCPLR
Article
75 imfêMag any of thefcrsgc|ñg enumerated commsicial issues- without considerationof thenienetary threshold
Plaintiff/Petitioner's claim for compenestory d:==ges [exclusiveof punitive
damages, interest,costs and counselfees claimed]:
$
Plaint!"!Petitioner's claim for equitable or declaratory relief descript!en]:
[brief
Defend ent!Respondent's counterclaim(s) [brief
description,includingclaim formcñêtary relief]:
I REQUEST THAT THIS CASE BE ASSIGNED TO THE COMMERCIAL Divi5iON. I CERTIFY THAT THE CASE
MEETS THE JURISDICTIONAL REQ UIREMENTS OF THE COMMERCIAL DiviSiON SET FORTH IN 22 NYCRR §
202.70(a), (b) AND (c).
_July 2020
Dated:
I NATURE
Philip G. Spellane, Esq.
PRINT OR TYPE NAME
3
3 of
of 3
3
Preview
FILED: FILED: TOMPKINS TOMPKINS COUNTY COUNTY CLERK CLERK 07/28/2020 07/27/2020 09:27 11:24 AM AM) INDEX INDEX NO. NO. EF2020-0345 EF2020-0345 NYSCEFREOWEST NYSCEF DOC. NO. 4 FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION RECEIVED FRE jDUTkS NYSCEF: 07/28/2020) TKWWFOrdy:/27/202 UCS-840 (3/2011) IAS CI2020-09465 Supreme COUNTY OF Tompkins 2020-0250-M COURT, JUdge ASSIgned Index No: Date Index !ssued: Hon. Joseph R. Cassidy R-JTDWe-- Enterthe cüñip|sts case caption. Do not use et al or et ano. If morespace is CAPTION: attach reauired, a captionridersheet. 7/27/2020 In theMatter of LUX ITHACA HOLDINGS, LLC, Plaintiff(s)/P÷?!?! s(s) The BOARD OF ASSESSORSandtheBOARDOF ASSESSMENT REVIEW of the CITY AND TOWN OF ITHACA, TOMPKINS COUNTY, NEW YORK, --' ---- De )/Respondent(s) NATURE OF ACTION OR PROCEEDING: Check ONE box onlyand specifywhere indicated. MATRIMONIAL | COMMERCIAL Q Contested Q Businoco Entity corporations, (including partnerships, LLCs, etc.) O uncontested O Contract NOTE: actions For all MatrirñGñ|â| where the partieshavechildrenunder ---' O !nsurance(where insureris a party, exceptarbitrâGóñ) and attach the ageof 18, complete theMATRIMONIAL RJI A O UCC sales, (including ñêgatiâb|êinstruments) |TORTS IO Other Commercial: (SP°°fY) Q Asbestos O BreastImplant NOTE: For Commercial ass|garñêñt Division requests [22 NYCRR § ^dd=d:= O Envircñiiiantal: comp!ete 202.70(d)], and attachtheCOMMERCIAL DIV RJi (specify) REAL PROPERTY: How many properties does the spp!!cat!en include? O Medical,Dental,or Podiatric Ms|prâct!ce O Cor-mne±en O Motor Vehicle O Foreclosure O Products Liability: PropertyAddress: (specify) StreetAddress City State Zip O Other Neg!!ges.e: NOTE: For Foreclosureactions a one- involving owner- to four-family, (specify) occupied,residential or an owner-occupied property, ceñdciiiiriiürn, ' ' O Other Prefessiciial W!p-3!ce: complete and attachtheFORECLOSURE RJI A 's.. .-.. (specify) 64· - Section: Tax Certiorari Block: 2 18 . Lot: O Other Tort: O Other RealProperty: (specify) (specify) OTHER MATTERS SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS Certificate of Incorporat!en/Dissolution [seeNOTE underCommercial] O CPLR Article 75 (Arbitraticii) [seeNOTE under Commercial] O Emergency MedicalTreatment O CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer) O Habeas Corpus O ElectionLaw O LocalCourt Appeal O MHL Article9.60(Kendra's Law) O Mechanic'sLien O MHL Article10 (Sex Offender Conñn:-ont |n|t|d) O Name Change O MHL Article10 (Sex Offender Confinement-Review) O PistolPermitRevocation Hearing O MHL Article81 (Guardianship) Q Sale or Financeof Re!!g!eus/Not-for-Profit Property O Other MentalHygiene: (SP°°fY) Q Other: (specify) Û Other SpecialProceed!ng: I (specify) STATUS OF ACTION OR g-nuuttEJiNG: Answer YES or NO forEVERY questionAND entersdd!!!éñe!information where indicated. | YES | NO | Has a summons and complaintor summeñs w/noticebeen filed? O 0 If yes, date filed: Is this acticñ/picceeding beingfiledpoet-judgment? O 0 If yes, judgment date: 1 1 of of 3 3 FILED: FILED: TOMPKINS TOMPKINS COUNTY COUNTY CLERK CLERK 07/28/2020 07/27/2020 09:27 11:24 AM AM INDEX INDEX NO. NO. EF2020-0345 EF2020-0345 NYSCEF NYSCEF DOC. DOC. NO. NO. 4 3 RECEIVED RECEIVED NYSCEF: NYSCEF: 07/28/2020 07/27/2020 CI2020-09465 Index #: EF2020-0345 Ö Note ofss an o of Readiness Certificate O Notice Dental, or Podlatric of Medical, Date Issue Joined: O Noticeof MotIon Relief Sought: ReturnDate: O Noticeof Petition Tax AssessmentReview Relief Sought: ReturnDate: on submission O Order to Show Cause Relief Sought: ReturnDate: O Other Ex Parte Åpplication Relief Sought: O Poor Person Application O Request for Preliminary Conference O Residential Meitgags Foreclosure SettlementConference O writof Habeas Corpus O Other (Specify): __ Case Title Index/Case No. Court Judga (ifassigned) Relationship to InstantCase Parties: AMemeys: Un- ue List n apdon order and c|ned h : CarrIer(s): Providename, firm name businessaddress,phone bcr sad e-mai[ a pa s) (e defendant; address of ag attorneys that have appearedin the case (Y/N): LUX ITHACA HOLDINGS,LLC SPELLANE PHILIP G. LastName LastName FirstName HARRIS BEACH PLLC Rrst Name FirmName PrimaryRole: 99 GARNSEY ROAD PlTTSFORD New York 14534 Petitioner StreetAddress State city ZIp SecondaryRole(if any): 585-419-8800 585-419-8812 pepe!!2necharrlsbeach.com Phone Fax e-mail LastName LastName First Name FirstName FirmName PrimaryRole: New York Respondent StreetAddress City State Zip NO SecondaryRole(if any): Phone Fax e-mail LastName LastName FirstName FirstName FirmName PrimaryRole: New York Respondent StreetAddress City State ZIP SecondaryRole(If any): O Phone Fax e-mall LastName LastName FirstName FirstName FirmName PrimaryRole: New York Respondent StreetAddress State City ZIP SecondaryRole(If any): Phone Fax e-mall I AFFIRM UNDER THE PENALTY OF PERJURY THAT, TO MY KNOWLEDGE, OTHER THAN AS NOTED ABOVE, THERE ARE AND HAVE BEEN NO RELATED ACTIONS OR PROCEEDINGS, NOR HAS A REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION PREVIOUSLY BEEN FILED IN THIS ACTION OR PROCEEDING. Dated: Julyf 2020 L/ SIGNATURE NYS Bar License NO. 2276087 Philip G. Sps ane, Esq. ATTORNEY REGISTRATION NUMBER PRINT OR TYPE NAME 2 2 of of 3 3 FILED: FILED: TOMPKINS TOMPKINS COUNTY COUNTY CLERK CLERK 07/28/2020 07/27/2020 09:27 11:24 AM AM| INDEX INDEX NO. NO. EF2020-0345 EF2020-0345 NYSCEF NYSCEF DOC. DOC. NO. NO. 4 3 RECEIVED RECEIVED NYSCEF: NYSCEF: 07/28/2020 07/27/2020 CI2020-09465 Index #: EF2020-0345 ournam¿ COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK --- - -- - 312011 COUNTY OF TOMPKINS _________________________¬________x Index No. _______________________________ Lux IthacaHoldings, LLC, RJi No. (ifany) ______________________ -a ainst- Plaintiff(syPetitioner(s) The Board of Assessors and the Board of Annessment Review of the COMMERCIAL DIVISION Cityand Town of Ithaca,Tompkins County, Ngw York . . -ni(oyRespedenne Request for Judicial Intervention Addendum COMPLETE WHERE APPLICABLE [add eddit!êñalpages If needed]: Plaint!ff!Petitioner's cause(s) of action [check allthatapply]: Breach of contractor fiduciary duty, fraud,misrepicsc±at!on, busiñêss tort(e.g.unfaircompetitióñ),or statutcry and/or common law viciatics where thebreach or violation is alleged to ariseout ofbusiness dealings (e.g.sales of assetsor securities; corporate restructuring; partnership,shârshc|dcr, joint venture, and other business agrêêmentê; trade secrets;restrictive covenante; and employment agrcaments not includingclaims that involve principally allegeddiscriminatorypractices) Transactionsgcverned by theUniform Commercie! Code (exclusiveof thoseccñceming individualcooperative or ccñdomiñ|üm units) Transectieneinvc|v|ñgcommerc!a! realproperty, includingYellowstone injun me and exdud;iig actionsforthe payment ofrent only Shareholder derivativeactions- withoutconsideration of themcñêtary thresho!d Commercial class actions- without ccñsidsraticñof themonetary threshold Business transactionsinvolvingor arisingout ofdealingswith commercial banks and otherfinanciä|!ñsutùUúñs Intemalaffairs of business organizations Me!pmotice by accountants or actuar|ês,and legalmalpractice arisingout ofrepresentationin commercia! matters Environmental insurance coverage Commarie! insurance ccverags (e.g.directereand errors officers, and omissions, and bus!±ss interruptioncaverage) Dissc|üticnof corp~ations, peecrmpe, limited companies, liability limited pednerships liability and jointventures- without considerationof themonetary threshold App!!ceticesto stayor compel arbitiation and affirmor disaffirmaibitraticñ awards and related injunctive pursuant relief toCPLR Article 75 imfêMag any of thefcrsgc|ñg enumerated commsicial issues- without considerationof thenienetary threshold Plaintiff/Petitioner's claim for compenestory d:==ges [exclusiveof punitive damages, interest,costs and counselfees claimed]: $ Plaint!"!Petitioner's claim for equitable or declaratory relief descript!en]: [brief Defend ent!Respondent's counterclaim(s) [brief description,includingclaim formcñêtary relief]: I REQUEST THAT THIS CASE BE ASSIGNED TO THE COMMERCIAL Divi5iON. I CERTIFY THAT THE CASE MEETS THE JURISDICTIONAL REQ UIREMENTS OF THE COMMERCIAL DiviSiON SET FORTH IN 22 NYCRR § 202.70(a), (b) AND (c). _July 2020 Dated: I NATURE Philip G. Spellane, Esq. PRINT OR TYPE NAME 3 3 of of 3 3