Exhibit,Appendix: JOHN COYLE VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B/P)AS REFLECTED ON EXHIBITS et al

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                SCUIFF HARDIN

Oo Oo ODN OD HW BF WwW BB =

=

28

LLP

AVTORNEYS AY LAW

SAN Phancisco

SCHIFF HARDIN LLP

JEFFREY R. WILLIAMS (CSB #84156)
NEIL C. LUDMAN (CSB #104657)
One Market, Spear Street Tower
Thirty-Second Floor

San Francisco, CA 94105

Telephone: (415) 901-8700
Facsimile: (415) 901-8701

Attorneys for Defendant
WALT DISNEY WORLD CO.

ELECTRONICALLY
FILED

Superior Court of California,
County of San Francisco

OCT 13 2010

Clerk of the Court
BY: WILLIAM TRUPEK
Deputy Clerk

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

INA COYLE, as Wrongful Death Heir,
and as Successor-in-Interest to JOHN
WALTER COYLE, Deceased; and
ROBERT E. COYLE, PEGGY O'NEILL,
DANNY O. COYLE, as Legal Heirs of
JOHN WALTER COYLE, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,

Vv.

ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (8-P),

Defendants.

SF\@806817.1

Case No. CGC-08-274634

DECLARATION OF NEIL C. LUDMAN IN
SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT WALT
DISNEY WORLD CO.’S MOTION FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT

EXHIBITS 1 -3

Date:
Time:
Dept.:
Judge:

October 28, 2010
9:30 a.m.

220

Hon. Harold E. Kahn

Trial Date: November 8, 2010EXHIBIT 1. sie
tow s1Blo§4- BA",
FOR COURT USE OntY
(SOLO PARA USO OC LA CORTF)

+

SUMMONS
(CITATION JUDICIAL)
NOTICE TO DEFENDANT:
{AVISO AL DEMANDADO):
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BoP)
As Reflected on Exhibits B, B-1, C, H, |; and DOES 41-8500;
and SEE ATTACHED LIST.

YOU ARE BEING SUED BY PLAINTIFF:
(LO ESTA DEMANDANODO EL DEMANDAN: TE):

JOHN COYLE and INA COYLE

stlomey referral sefvics. If you cannot afford an attomey, you may be aligible for free legat eerviees from a nonprofit tagal corvicos
Program. You can locate these nonprofit groups at the California Legal Sarvicos Web sito {www lawhelpcalifornia.org}, the California
Sourts Ontine Sol Halp Centar (www. courtinfa.ca.gosetthalp}, of By contacting your loesl eovrt tr county bar assocfation.

‘egates gratultas de un programa do servicios legales sin fines de tucro. Puede encontrar estos grupos sin fines de lucro en af sitlo web cio
California Lagal Services, (veww jawhelpcaittomia.org), en ef Centro de Ayuda do las Cartes de California,

The name and address of the court is:

(Ef nombre y direacion de la cone es): CASE HUMBER:
SAN F CO COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT iene
400 McAllister Strect eC = 08 ~2 24634

San Francisco, CA 94102

The name, address, and telephone number of plaintifi's atiorney, or plaintiff without an attorney, is:
{El nombre, la direscién de teléfono det abogado dei demandante, o def demandante que no tien abogado, es}
DAVID R. DONADIO, ESQ., STATE BAR NO. 154436

BRAYTON?PURCELL LEP

222 Rush Landing Road, Novain, CA 94048-6169 {445} 898-1556,

DATE: Cordon Park-Li o, _ pe
DAE: apr 29 2008 otk PY NAT Paty

{Ssccotacioy
(Por proof of service Of this summons, ase Prot of Sanvice of Summons form POS-O10))
(Pare prueba de entrega de esta citation use ef formustario Proof of Service of Summons, [POS-010)),
NOTICE TO PERSON SERVED: You are served
{SEAL} L Oo as an individual defendant.
2. O as the person sued under the fictitious name of (specify):

3. Pahon neha of fopoctn: Le (I Disney World Co.

underilxd CCP 416,10 (corporation) CCP 416.60(minor}
CCP 416.20 (defunct corporation} Cleep 416.70 (conservates}
CCP 416.40 (association of partnership) O CCP 416.80 (authorized person}
other (specify): ° é
4 Df by personal delivery on (date): 5 Dp dD 3 Page tof
“FORRTaapRSE Ta May Oa ~ CET Ca PREIS RA MS
utiol GmunciofCatoma SUMMONS °

‘SUM, 100 fftev January 1, 2004}AMERICAN STANDARD, INC.

ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION
BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC.
CALAVERAS ASBESTOS, LTD.

JOHN CRANE, INC.

CRANE Co.

THE GOODYRAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY
DANA CORPORATION

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
OAKFABCO, INC, ~
“PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION
PLANT INSULATION COMPANY

SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC,

SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC.
VIACOM, INC.

WESTBURNE SUPPLY, INC.

WESTERN MacARTHUR COMPANY
MacARTHUR COMPANY

WESTLRN ASBESTOS COMPANY
ECONOMY PUMPS

COLONIAL SUGAR REFINING COMPANY
ADVOCATE MINES, LTD.

GRINNELL CORPORATION

FAMILIAN CORPORATION

KEENAN PROPERTIES, INC,

GOODRICH CORPORATION

ACH BURBHLER

SVI CORPORATION

INTERNATIONAL PIPING ACCESSORIES INC.
PMC CORPORATION

TURNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
MCGEE CONSULTING ASSOCIATES, INC.
PIERCE ENGINEBRING CO.

‘TISHMAN CONSTRUCTION CORP.

ROSCOE AIAX CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
iT. THORPE & SOW, INC.
GEORGIA-PACIFIC CONSUMER PRODUCTS LP

413) B98-1S55

P.O, Hox 6169
CALIFORNIA 94942-6159

ATTORNEYS AT LAW
322 RUSH LANDING ROAD

BRAYTON PURCELL LLP

Novato
3

| WALT DISNEY WORLD CO.
244 FORD MOTOR COMPANY
ALBERTSON'S, INC.
25) MATYEL TOYS, INC.

PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OP AMERICA
HOTEL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, INC.

HILTON HOTELS CORPORATION

UNION BANK

METROPOLITAN LIVE INSURANCE COMPANYOWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.

GATKE CORPORATION

GARLOCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC

AMERICAN CONFERENCE OF GOVERNMENTAL INDUSTRIAL HYGIENISTS, INC.
UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES, INC.

PNEUMO ABEX LLC

and DOES 1-8500,

Defendants.

Soe wy Awe wD

ighn Covte and Ina Covle vs, Asbestos Defendants (BP)

San Francisco Superior Court‘ t

CASE NUMBER: CGC-08-274634 JOHN COYLE VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B/PJAS REF
NOTICE TO PLAINTIFF ,

A Case Management Conference is set for
DATE: APR-18-2009
TIME: 4:30PM

PLACE: Department 206
400 McAllister Street
San Francisco, CA 94102-3680

All parties must appear and comply with Local Rulé 3.3 and 3.4.

CRC 212 (g)(1) requires the filing and service of a case management statement

form CM-110 no later than 15 days before the case management conference.

Plaintiff must serve a copy of this notice upon each party to this action with the
summons and complaint. Proof of service subsequently filed with this court shall
So state.

[DEFENDANTS: Attending the Case Management Conference does not take the
place of filing a written response to the complaint. You must file a written
response with the court within the time limit required by law. See Summons.}

Superior Court Alternative Dispute Resolution Coordinator
400 McAllister Street, Room 103

San Francisco, CA 94102

(415) 851-3876: i CM-OtG

ATTORNEY O8 PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY (Meets, tate bar umber, etd axtetreasy: POR COURT USE ONLY
DAVID 8 DONADIO, HSQ., STATE BAR NO. 154436
BRAYTON@PURCENE LEB ENDORSED
Novato Cabteans Se 6169 FILE D-
ovata, Cal NS vf

TELRPUONENO: (415) 898-1555 Pre" 445) 898.1287 San Francisco County Superior Court
ATTORNEY FoR (NAME Plaintifits) PR 7008
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO APR 2 9

STREET ADORESS: 400 McAllister Street GORDON PARK-LI, Clerk

MAILING ADDRESS: . PAQAM NATE.

CITY AND aif CODE: San Francisco, CA 94102 BY rene ty Chae

BRANCH NAME:
CASE NAME:

beer:

JOUN COYLE and INA COYLE ya, ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BSP)
CIVIL CASE COVER SNEET Complex Case Designation case E « 4 6 3 4
e
Bl uatimited  rimited Cl counter Cl soinder UGE 08-27 4 |
[Atmount Amount Fited with first appearance by defendant 3UDGE:
flemanded lemanded is «Cal. Rules of Court, ral 4.402)

exceeds $25,000) $25,000 or less)
Hiems 1-6 below must be completed (sea instructions on pape 2),
[i- Checkcone box below of the case type that best describes this case:

Auto Tort Contesct Provisionally Complox Civil Litigation
Auto (22) [5 treoch af comvacrrunncenty (08) ge Rules of Conrt, rules 3.400-3.403)
Lininsurod motorist (46) Cy Tate 1.740 coftentions (99) Antitrust Trade reputation (63)

Other PUEDIWD (Personal fnjury/Propenty C1] oaker Collections (09) Conshoetion defect (10)

grees’ Wrong Beaty Tort Sasurance coverage (18) =] ass tor (40)

Aahozias (04) 1 cater contmes on LL] securities tigation 3}
Product Linbility (24) Real Propasty ‘Favironinental / Tonic tart (38)
‘Medical ntalpractice (45) Eminem domalaftaverse: tnsernnce coverage clahns arising from the,

0 ote: even any condemnation (14) asbove listed provisionally complex exse type (41)

Non-PHPO/WD (Other) Tort [2 wronged evtetion 032) Enforcement of Judgment
Business peviuniais business practice (07) CT other teal propeary 26} . (1 entircement of fodgment (20)

Civil rigies 108) Unlawful Detainer Miscellaneous Civil Complaint
Defamation (13) Conmmerciat 34} rs

2 rewt tis Residential (32) a ae .

{otettectual propany (19) Dongs (38) conmlnioe (ne pec above) 42)
Prafessional neshigenco(25) Judicial Review Miscellaneous Civil Petitina
‘Other non -PHPDAWD tort (35) Astet fortetuure (5) {1 Yarmnership and corporate gavernanea (21)

Employment Petition me: arbitration award (11) Gite petition (nor specified wbove} (435
‘Wrongful cernination (36) LL) wi or mandate 02 .

O ‘Other employment (15) ‘Other judicial seview 39}

2. ‘This case L) is is not coraplex under rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court, [f the case is conipiex, mark the factors
requiring exceptional judicial management:

a. [7 Largenumber of separately represented parties & ED Large number of witnesses

b. Extensive motion practice raising difficult or novel e Coordination and related actions pending in one or more courts
issues that will be time-consuming to resolve in other countics, states or countries, or ina federal court

¢. [2 substantial amount of documentary evidence &. C1 substantial post judgment judicial supervision

=
3. Remedies sought (check alt that apply): a. BS sonewy _. C]nonmonetary; declaratory or injunctive relic «, DQ punitive
4, Number of causes of action (spncypi &

5S. This case is - isnot a class action suit.
6. are he known related cases, file and serve a notice of related case, (You form CM-OLS.)
Bate: be
eG vid R. lio _ -
(7 ¥PH OF PRINT NAMES. #SKGHATORE OF PARTY OR ATTORNEY POR PART
NOTICE
* Plaintiff must Gile this cover sheet with the first paper fited in tite action ing (except anvall claims cases or cases filed under the Probate Code,
Family Code, or Welfare ava Inatitione Cone ee ee oF Court ale an} Pace ae ‘may result ts sanctions.
1 File this cover sheet in addition te any cover sheet required by jocal court mie.

7H this cate is complex under mie 3.400 ct seq, of the California Rules of Court, you amt sorve a copy ef this cover sheet on all other parties te
dys action or proceeding.
~ Unless this i a collections case under sule 3.740 o7 2 comptes case, this cover shect shail be used for staistiont purposes only.

"Fort Adopted for Mandtary Uae CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Cts ct ene 250 15,300 9
etch Conmeftatoe, 3 nee tel sation db
‘etefee nt coremanee

eae dated Califia alt Col FootBRAYTON@PURCELL LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
222 RUSK LANDING ROAD
POBOX 6169
NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 94949-6169
(S15) g06-3555

ENDORSED

FILE
1] DAVID R. DONADIO, ESO,, $.B. #154436 Gotnty Superior Court
|| JOHN B. GOLDSTEIN, ESO, $B. #198188 San Franciaco
2 BRAYTONPURCELL LU APR 2 9 2608 chert
ttorneys at Law ARICLI, Cler
3] 222 Rush Landing Road GORDON F
|.B.0. Box 6169 = PARAM NSTT.

41) Novato, California 94948~6 1ASB MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE JABY——--—-- Banuty Clerk
(415) 898-1555
j) Attorneys for Plaintiffs APR 1 6 2009 -1pM
DEPARTMENT 206
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
Ut] JOHN COYLE and INA COYLE, ASBESTOS
i No. .
2 Plaintiffs, CG60~08-274634
13 ff vs. 3} COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY
| } AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM -
\4]| ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B¢P} ) ASBESTOS
|, As Reflected on Exhibits B, B-1, C, H, }
15 | 1, and DOES 1-8500; and SEE
ATTACHED LIST. 5

L Plaintiff JOHN COYLE was bom December 14, 1930.

2. The ©Brayton Purcell Master Complaint for Personat Injury [and Loss of
194 Consortium|- Asbestos (hereinafter “Master Compiaint") was fited January 2, 2003, in San

2t f obtained upon request from Braytoa%+Purcell, and designated portions of the Master Complaint
are incorporated by reference herein pursuant to the authority conferred by General Order No. 55,
i Plaintiffs’ claims are as set forth in said Master Complaint against defendants herein as follows:

254 7 “THIS GABE 16 BUBJEGT TO
MANDATORY ELECTRONIC FILING
PURSUANT TO AMENDED 6.0. 158

wm I
| COMP 7 AL INTUR LOSS GF CONSORTIOM - ASRESTOSBRAYTON®PURCELE LLP

ATTORNEYS AT LAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD

P.O. Box 6169

AMERICAN STANDARD, INC.

ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION
BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC.
CALAVERAS ASBESTOS, LTD.

JOHIN CRANE, INC.

CRANE CO.

THE GOODYBAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY
DANA CORPORATION

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
CAKFABCO, INC.

PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION

PLANT INSULATION COMPANY

SLAREY BROTHERS, INC.

SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC.
VIACOM, INC,

WESTBRURNE SUPPLY, INC.

WESTERN MacARTITUR COMPANY
MecARTHUR COMPANY

WESTERN ASBESTOS COMPANY.

ECONOMY PUMPS

COLONIAL SUGAR REFINING COMPANY
ADVOCATE MINES, LTD.

GRINNELL CORPORATION

FAMILIAN CORPORATION

KEENAN PROPERTIES, INC.

GOODRICH CORPORATION

ACE BUBHLER

SVE CORPORATION

INTERNATIONAL PIPING ACCESSORIES INC,
FMC CORPORATION

TURNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
MCGEE CONSULTING ASSOCIATES, INC.
PIERCE ENGINEERING CO.

‘TISUMAN CONSTRUCTION CORP.

ROSCOE AJAX CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Jf. THORPE & SON, INC.

GROROLA-PACIFIC CONSUMER PRODUCTS LP
WALT DISNEY WORLD CO,

FORD MOTOR COMPANY

ALBERTSON'S, INC.

MATTEL TOYS, INC,

PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY Of AMERICA
HOTEL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, INC.
HILTON HOTELS CORPORATION

UNION BANK

METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY:
1 OWENS-ILINOIS, INC.
GATKE CORPORATION
2], GARLOCK SuALING ECHNOLOGIES, LLC
AMERICAN CONKERENCE OF GOVERNMENTAL INDUSTRIAL HYGI ENISTS, INC.
3 |, UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES, INC.
4 PNEUMO ABEX LLC
aud DOES 1-8500,
5 Defendants.
6 ~
7
8
9
10
iL
12

John Coyle and Ins Coyle vs, Asbestos Defendants (BeP)

San Francisco Superior Court:
First (Negligence)
Second (Strict Liability)

Third (False
Representation)

Fourth (Loss of
.. Consortium)

mr
Ba Bale
Oe

XI

&
Ooogo b

Fifth (Premises Owner/
Contractor Liability)

Sixth, Seventh, Eighth a
(Unseaworthiness, Negligence .
ones Act],Maintenance and Cure)

0
Compensation Act [LHWCA]) .

Tenth, Eleventh ELA) O

Twelfth, Thirteenth (Respiratory
Safety Devices) oP

Fourteenth, Fifteenth
(Brake Shoe Grinding) OQ

Sixteenth (Concert of Action)

Misropresentattou/Con ea lp

Nineteenth (Fraud/Deceit/ .
Intentional Misrepresentation)

Twentieth (Fraud/Deceit - Kent)

“and their alternate entities as set forth in the Master Complaint or on any Exhibit.

I

O

DOrne

Oo DOD DM DA MN PR WwW NY

3. Plaintiff's asbestos-related injury, date of diagnosis, employment status, and
history of exposure to asbestos are as stated on Exhibit A. :

4, Plaintiffs were married on December 23, 1959.

5. Plaintiffs’ claims against defendant VIACOM, INC. (successor by merger to

| CBS CORPORATION which is successor-in-interest to WESTINGHOUSE BLECTRIC

CORPORATION) exchide military and federal government jobsites,

Haea: Yf2ghe BRAYTON*+PURCELL LLP

B:

y:
David R-Donadio
Attomeys for PlaintifisEXHIBIT AH 6615 &

EXUIRILA

Plaintiff's exposure to asbestos and asbestos-containing products occurred at various

locations inside the State of California, including but not limited to:

Employer

LE. Young Pipelines
Gardena, CA

Mebring & Hanson Company
6615 8th Avenue
Los Angeles, CA

Mehring & Hanson Company
6615 8th Avenue
Los Angeles, CA

Mebring & Hanson Company
| 5615 8th Avenue

Los Angeles, CA

Mcbring & Hanson Company
Avenue

| Los Angeles, CA

i Mehring & Hanson Company
| O615 BE

Avenue
Los Angeles, CA

JB Nettles & Co Inc.

‘| 755 Sansome St.

| San Francisco, CA

Kennedy Pipe & Supply Co.
#5301 So, Earemount Blvd.

{| Paramount, CA

244
|

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

263 W. Avocado Crest Rd.

| Whittier, CA

Location of
Exposure dob Title
Pipeline, Laborer

Rosecrans Avenue,
Torrance & Hawthorne, CA

Various locations Plumber
Statler Hilton Hotel, Piumber
Wilshire Blvd.
Los Angeles, CA
Marine Land, Plumber
Palos Verdes, CA
Daniel Freeman Memorial Plumber
Hospital,
Inglewood, CA
Ambassador Hotel Plumber
Los Angeles, CA.

_ Ford Mercury Plani Plumber
Pico Rivera, CA
Slauson & Vermont Plumber
Los Angeles, CA
Wilshire Terrace Plumber
Wilshire & Beverly Glen (Foreman)
Los Angeles, CA
Comstock Building Plumber
Wilshire & Comstock (Foreman)
Los Angeles, CA
Los Angeles International Plumber
Airport, . (Foreman)
Wind Tunnel Building,
Aviation Bivd.
El Segundo, CA

Exposure
Dates

GAISO-TN951
1/1951-6/1956

3/1951-1/1953;
1955

3/1953-3/1954
4/1954 - 9/1955;
1956

1956

411956-9/1 956;
AN9S7-6N957

AIL957-G/1957

9/1957-G/1958
TFA961-3/1962

9/1957-6/1958
TAL961-3/1962

4/1958 - 3/1959

EXHIBIT AEmployer

Lohman Bros. Contracting
Plumbing & Heating

300 E. Coast Hwy.
Newport Beach, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

oO NAH PB WwW Kw

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Bailey the Plumber, Inc.
c/o Irving L Bass

12 ff 16633 Ventura Blvd.
Encino, CA .

f Standard Plumbing Co.
4529 Cecelia St.
| Cudahy, CA

— 2

i ; D & D Plumbing & Heating
| 7915 Pacific Blvd.
Huntington Park, CA

f Kore Drilling, Inc.
16022 Arminta St.
| Van Nuys, CA

Dumeil Mechanical
16146 Leadwell St.
i Van Nuys, CA

|| Durneli Mechanical
23 | 16146 Leadwell St.
} Van Nuys, CA

i i
} COMPLAINT FOR Pi Al

EXHIBIT A (cont'd)

Location of
Exposure

California State Office
Building
Los Angeles, CA

Valley Maintenance Center
San Fernando Valley, CA

Pacific Employers Group
(PEG) Building,
os Angeles, CA

Lesser Towers,
Los Angeles, CA

General Motors
South Gate, CA

Broadway Department
Stores Warehouse,
Soto St,

Los Angeles, CA

Sagura Gardens
Apartments

Crenshaw & Hawthorne
Blvd., Torrance, CA

USC University Hospital,
Los Angeles, CA esp

Mattel Toys,
Hawthorne, CA

Medical Bidg.
Hawthorne Blvd.
Los Angeles, CA

VAND RTE

Exposure
Job ‘Title Dates
Plumber 144959-3/1961
Plumber 1962
(Foreman)
Plumber 1962
(Foreman)
Plumber 1962-1963
(Foreman)
Plumber 741 963-9/1963
Plumber 941963-7/1964
Plumber 11/1963-06/1964
Plumber T1965-9/1965
(i week} °
Plumber 1/1966-3/1969
Plumber 1/1966-9/1966
EXYNBIT A
~ ASBESTO:~

Employer

Durell Mechanical
16146 Leadwell St.
Van Nuys, CA

oO ND mH & Ww Ww

Durneli Mechanical
16146 Leadwell St.
Van Nuys, CA

|| © A Norris Plumbing
12 || Baldwin Park, CA.

{| Hermsen, Inc.
2331 Oceanside
i Oceanside, CA

ft Pierce Enginecring
2121 Daladier Dr.

sot
>

Pierce Engincering

2321 Daladier Dr.

Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

, Scott Company of California,
4

1717 Doolittle Dr.
San Leandro, CA

224 Scott Company of California,

INT FOR PERSON,

EXHIBIT_A (cont'd.)

Location of
Exposure

Various Lucky Markets,
including, but not limited to
the following located at:

Lucky Market,
Rosecrans & Crenshaw,
Inglewood, CA

Lacky Market,
Atlantic & Century,
Lynwood, CA

Ford Motor Plant
Aviation & Rosecrans,
El Segunda, CA.

Holiday Inn
Redondo Beach, CA

Ramada Inn
Carson, CA

Job Tite
Plumber

Piurnber

Plumber

Plumber

Alcoa Gateway Building, — Plumber

West Century City, CA

Prudential Insurance Plumber
High rise office bldg.

5900 block Wilshire Blvd.

Los Angeles, CA

Crown-Zellerbach,
Commerce, CA

Plumber

Union Bank Plumber
(paricing structure),
Angeles, CA.

AND 1 F SOR} =

Exposure
Dates

1/1967-3/1969

141967-12/1967

1/1967-12/1967
1973-9/1974

144967-12/1967
1969

1/1969-12/1969;
411972-3/1974;
411975-911977

19/1969-06/1971

LAOTI-201972

EXHIBIT A2S MWA HW mh WwW BD om

—
nm

Employer

Pierce Enginecring
2121 Daladier Dr.
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Hermsen Inc.
2391 Oceanside, Blvd.
Oceanside, CA

Pierce Engineering
2121 Daladier Dr.
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Sam P. Wallace Co. Inc.
2102 Empire Central
Dallas, TX

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miraloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA

D/K Mechanical
4420 B. Miraloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA

D/K Mechanical

4420 E. Miraioma Ave.
Anaheim, CA

Sam P. Wallace Co, inc.
2102 Empire Central
Dailas, TX

DAK Mechanical

4420 E. Miraloma Ave,
Anaheint, CA

Wt

INT FOR PE

(ALIN, AND TOSS

EXMIBIT A (cont'd)

Location of
Exposure

Broadway Plaza,
Los Angeles, CA

Job Title

Plumber

3580 Wilshire Blvd.

{office bldg.)
s Angeles, CA

Disneyland (Bonita Tower;
Disneyland Hotel; and
Disneyland Fountain),
Anaheim, CA

Ramada Ino,
Torrance, CA

Plumber

C.F. Braun & Co. Plumber
1000 S. Fremont Ave.

Alhambra, CA

Various locations Plumber

C.F, Braun Plumber

Alhambra, CA.

Anaheim Convention Plumber
Center

Anaheim, CA
Disneyland Restaurant
Disneyland

Anaheim, CA

Maxum Hote!
Palm Springs, CA

Plumber

Phimber

Santa Ana Plumber
Register
Santa Ana, CA

SORTIOM - ASBESTOS

Exposure
Dates

ANOT2-GN OTS
Sé1975-9/1976

LO/1976-12/1979

07/1974- 12/1974;
04/1975-06/1975

1980

1981;
6A1988-G/1989
198)
S#1982-5/1983
1983
AANIB4-2/1 985

FALOBS-1986

EXHIBIT AoO DN DA HH kB Bw we

Joron Mechanical
10820 Atlantic Ave,

f Lynwood, CA

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miratoma Ave.

{ Anaheim, CA.

Sam P. Wallace Co. inc.

2102 Empire Central

i Dallas, ‘T-

|| D/K Mechanical
4426 E. Miraloma Ave,

Anaheim, CA

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miraloma Ave.

| Anaheim, CA

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miraloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA.

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Mixaloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA.

EXHIBIT A (cont'd)

Location of
Exposure

North American Facilities,
Huntington Reach, CA

North American Rockwell,
Anaheim, CA *

North American Rockwell,
Newport Beach, CA

Unknown office building
and parking structure,
MacArthur Bivd.
Newport, CA

Metropolitan Detention
Center (MDC),
Los Angeles, CA

Mattel Toys
(Cafeteria),
Hawthorme, CA

Allergan Chemical
£8600 Von Karman
Irvine, CA

White Memorial Medical
Building,
East Los Angeles, CA

St. Judes Hospital,
Fullerton, CA

Job Tite

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

THGB6-12/1 987

6/1988-6/1989

S/1990-2/199 1

1/1991-6/1991

B/ALOSI-12/1991

10/4992-1/1993

Plaintiff's exposure to asbestos and asbestos-containing products caused severe and

permanent injury te the plaintiff, including, but not limited to breathing difficulties, asbestosis,
| lung and/or other cancer, mesothelioma, and/or other lung damage. Plaintiff was diagnosed

with mesothetioma on or about September 2007, and with asbestosis and asbestos-telated

pleural disease on or about August 1993.

H it

it

EXHIBIT AB. fT A {cont'd.

Plaintiff retired from his last place of emptoyment as a result of becoming disabled due
to an illness not related to asbestos, He has therefore suffered no disability from his ashestos-

EXHIBIT AEXHIBIT B2
3 || AMERICAN STANDARD, ENC,
ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED
4 || GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION
BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC.
5 | CALAVERAS ASBESTOS, LTD.
JOHN CRANE, INC.
6 || CRANE CO.
| TRE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY
7) DANA CORPORATION
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
8 j] OAKFABCO, INC.
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION =~
9 |} PLANT PNSUILATION COMPANY
9

EXUIBIT B -

WESTRURNE SUPPLY, INC.
WESTERN MacARTHUR COMPANY
MacARTHUR COMPANY
WHSTERN ASBESTOS COMPANY
ECONOMY PUMPS

COLONIAL SUGAR REFINING COMPANY
ADVOCATE MINES, LTD.
GRINNELL CORPORATION
FAMILIAN CORPORATION
KEENAN PROPERTIES, INC.
GOODRICH CORPORATION

ACE BUEHLER

SVf CORPORATION

SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC. INTERNATIONAL PIPING ACCESSORIES INC.
10 || SPRCIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC. FMC CORPORATION
1 VIACOM, INC. DOES 1-800
11k
12] ALTERNATE ENTITY

13 ! ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION

14] GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION CONVAIR

VULTEE AIRCRAFT INC.
15 CONSOLIDATED VULTEE AIRCRAFT CORPORATION
ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED

16]
BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC. BUCYRUS-ERIE
174 MARION POWER SHOVEI. COMPANY, THE
i OSGOOD COMPANY
18] GENERAL EXCAVATOR COMPANY
19] CRANE Co. CRANE COMPANY
CRANE PLUMBING & HEATING
20 CRANE PUMPS & SYSTEMS, INC.
CRANE SUPPLY
21 BURK PUMPS
MIDWEST PIPING CO.
22 MIDWEST PIPING & SUPPLY Co.
MIDWEST {NVESTMENT
23 PACIFIC STEEL BOILER CORPORATION
i PACIFIC VALVES :
24 CRANE VALVE GROUP
DEMING PUMPS
25 REPCAL BRASS MANUFACTURING CO.
i CHAPMAN VALVE COMPANY
264 JENKINS BROS.
27h Mt

EXHIBIT BPARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION

SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC.

SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC,

 WESTBURNE SUPPLY, INC.

WESTERN MacARTHUR
COMPANY

| GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION

EXHIBIT B fcont'd.)
ALTERNATE ENTITY

SACOMA-SIERRA, INC.

SACOMA MANUPACTURING COMPANY
ELS, AUTOMOTIVE CORPORATION
CONDREN CORPORATION, THE
PARKER SEAL COMPANY

DELTA PIPE & SUPPLY CO.
AVEX SUPPLY COMPANY

SPECIAL MATERIALS, INC. - WISCONSIN

CBS CORPORATION

WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORPORATION
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC AND
MANUFACTURING COMPANY

BLP. STURTEVANT

KPIX TELEVISION STATION

PARAMOUNT COMMUNICATIONS, INC.

PLE, OHAIR & CO.

AIR COLD SUPPLY, INC.

OAKLAND PLUMBING SUPPLY
WESTERN PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., LTD
LR. DETERDING CO.

SAN DIEGO PIPE & SUPPLY, CO., INC.

WESTERN ASBESTOS CO.

MAC ARTHUR COMPANY

BAY CITIES ASBESTOS COMPANY
ELK. PINNBY, INC.

NEW DEPARTURE

CHEVROLET

AC, DELCO Co.

BUICK AUTOMOTIVE CORPORATION
CADILLAC

PONTIAC

LaSALLE

OLDSMOBILE

GM GOODWRENCH

ROCHESTER PRODUCTS DIVISION
BUCLID ROAD MACHINERY CO,
FRIDGIDAIRE (for expesure pre 4/9/1979)

GRINNELL PIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS COMPANY, INC.

GRINNELL COMPANY OF THE PACIFIC

EXHIBIT B2 Om YN AH mw Nw

FAMHAIAN CORPORATION

GOODRICI! CORPORATION

SVE CORPORATION
EMG CORPORATION

ALTGRNATE ENTITY :

EAMILIAN PIPE & SUPPLY
PAMILIAN NORTHWEST
PLUMBERS SUPPLY COMPANY, INC.
INDUSTRIES SUPPLY CO.

BAY AREA PIPE & SUPPLY CO., INC.

BLP. GOODRICH CORPORATION
GARLOCK SEALING TECUNOLOCHES, LLC
COLTEC INDUSTRIES, INC,

COLT INDUSTRIES

STOCKHAM VALVES & FITFINGS, INC.

FOOD MACHINERY AND CHEMICAL CORPORATION
FOOD MACHINERY CORP.

BARIUM PRODUCTS, LTD.

EMC AUTO DIVISION

LINK-BELT CONSTRUCTION EQUIPMENT COMPANY
VAN PELT

NORTHERN PUMP COMPANY (pre- 1982)

LINK-BELT SPEEDER

LINK-BELT COMPANY

TRUMP, INC.

CHICAGO PUMP COMPANY

PEERLESS PUMP COMPANY

EXHIBIT B

4

LIND A ° SORTIOM - ASBESTO:EXHIBIT B-1DECENDANTS

TURNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

i 3EE CONSULTING ASSOCIATES, INC.
PHERCE ENGINEERING CQ.

TISHMAN CONSTRUCTION CORP.

ROSCOR AIAK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

£.T. THORPE & SON, INC.

DOES 1-800; DOES 1601-2000

LT. THORPE & SON, INC. THE THORPE COMPANY

‘THORPE PRODUCTS CO.
4.1. THORPE NORTHWEST

EXHIBIT B-}EXHIBIT C1
2

3
4
5
6
7
&

EXHIBIT C

DEFENDANTS

GEORGIA-PACIFIC CONSUMER PRODUCTS LP
WALT DISNEY WORLD CO.

FORD MOTOR COMPANY

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
ALBERTSON'S, INC,

MATTEL TOYS, INC.

TURNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
MCGEE CONSULTING ASSOCIATES, INC.
PIERCE ENGINEERING CG.

TISHMAN CONSTRUCTION CORP.
ROSCOE AJAX CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
4-7. THORPE & SON, INC.

PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF PLANT INSULATION COMPANY
AMERICA, WESTERN MacARTHUR COMPANY
HOTEL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, INC. MacARTHUR COMPANY
HILTON HOTELS CORPORATION ‘WESTERN ASBESTOS COMPANY
UNION BANK - DOES 1061-2000
ALTERNATE ENTITY
GEORGIA-PACIFIC CONSUMER FORT JAMES OPERATING COMPANY
PRODUCTS LP
FORD MOTOR COMPANY BRITISH LEYLAND MOTORS, INC.
BRITISH MOTOR CORPORATION
JAGUAR CARS, INC.
‘TRIUMPH
LINCOLN CONTINENTAL
AUSTIN HEALEY
HOTEL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, RAMADA INC.
INC. RAMADA HOTELS INC
PREMISES OWNER
DEPENDANTS LOCATION ‘TIME PERIOD -
GBORGIA-PACIFIC CONSUMER Crown-Zellerbach, Commerce, 1O/1969-62197 1
PRODUCTS LP CA
WALT DISNEY WORLD Co. Disneyland, Anaheim, CA 1O/E9TG-EB1979
Disneyland Hotel, Anaheim, CA 16/1976-§2/1979
FORD MOTOR COMPANY Ford Motor Co., Pico Rivera, CA 4/56-9/56;
4ST-IST
Ford Motor Cu., Et Segundo, CA 1/67-12/67
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION General Motors, South Gate, CA 7/63-9/63
ALBERTSON'S, INC. Lucky Store, Inglewood, CA; 67-369
Tacky Store, Lynwood, CA
ut
EXHIBIT C

ut| PREMISES OWNER
| DEFENDANTS _

| MATTEL TOYS, INC.

PRUDENTIAL (NSURANCE COMPANY
OF AMERICA

HOTEL PROPERTY INVESTMENTS,
INC,
| HILTON HOTELS CORPORATION

UNION BANK

oU em MAH BY ON

rt tat ot
we Nm

| CONTRACTOR
|| DEFENDANTS.

| TURNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

| MCORE CONSULTING ASSOCIATES,
INC,

PIERCE ENGINEERING CO.

LOCATION
Mattel Toys, Hawthorne, CA,

Procential Insurance,
Los Angeles, CA

Ramada, inn, Carson; CA

* Statler Hotel, Hollywood, CA

Union Bank, Los Angeles, CA,

Pridential Insurance,
Eos Angeles, CA.
Union Bank, Los Angeles, CA.

Broadway Plaza, Century City,
CA

3580 Wilshire Bldg, Los Angeles,
CA

White Memoriaf Bldg,
Los Angeles, CA

Kaiser Data Center, Corona, CA
Lesser Towers, Los Angetes, CA
Lesser Towers, Los Angeles, CA.
Predential Insurance,

Los Angeles, CA

Alcoa Gateway, W, Century City,
cA

‘IME PERIOD

166-369;
9790-2791

1169-1269;
ATR 14;
APIS TT

1467-12167

YS)-US3, 1955

V71-2/72.

TIME PERIOD
169-12/69;
AIT2 BIT,
AITS-9077
ULI

TLE

SETS

8791-12491

10/91-16/92
1962-1963

1962-1963
1698-12166;
4IT2-MI4,
ASTS-77

1969

EXHIBIT C-

i Snes 19
IPLAINT FOR PERSONAL TN, 7 -EXHIBIT C (cont'd)

2], CONTRACTOR
DEFENDANTS LOCATION
3]
|| PIERCE ENGINEERING CO. {cont'd} Broadway Plaxa, Ceatury City,
4 CA
s| 3580 Wilshire Bldg, Los Angeles,
Hl CA
of
4 CF Braun, Alhambra, CA
é TISHMAN CONSTRUCTION CORP. Alcoa Gateway, W. Contury City,
CA
9] ROSCOH AJAX CONSTRUCTION Lesser Towers, Los Angeles, CA
COMPANY
10
A HT. THORPE & SON, INC. Various
iff
| PLANT INSULATION COMPANY Various
124
|| WESTERN MacARTHUR Various
13] COMPANY/MacARTRUR
COMPANY/WESTERN ASBESTOS.
14] COMPANY
15]
16 |
7
18]
19]
26
21
22
234
oat
25
26
27

TIME PERIOD:
472-6473

S75

1980-1981
1969

1962-1963

Various
Various

Various

EXHIBIT C

7 ASBESTOSEXHIBIT HEXHIBIT H .

DEFENDANTS
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STUART-WESTERN, INC.
PNEUMO ABEX LLC RIVESET MANUFACTURING COMPANY _
BORGWARNER MORSE TEC, INC. ASBESTOS MANUFACTURING COMPANY
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC. (successor-in- FIBRE & METAL PRODUCTS COMPANY
interest to ALLICDSIGNAL, INC} LASCO BRAKE PRODUCTS
THE BUDD COMPANY L.. MILEY COMPANY
DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION " ROSSENDALE-RUBOIL COMPANY :
DANA CORPORATION SOUTHERN FRICTION MATERIALS COMPANY
FORD MOTOR COMPANY U.S, SPRING & BUMPER COMPANY
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION AUTO FRICTION CORPORATION
BRIDGESTONE/FIRESTONE EMSCO ASBESTOS COMPANY
NORTH AMERICAN TIRE, LLC ~ FORCEE MANUFACTURING CORPORATION
LEAR SIEGLER DIVERSIFIED HOLDINGS CORP. MOLDED INDUSTRIAL FRICTION CORPORATION
MAREMONT CORPORATION NATIONAL TRANSPORT SUPPLY, INC.
MORTON INTERNATIONAL, INC. SILVER LINE PRODUCTS, BNC.
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION STANDCO, INC.
STANDARD MOTOR PRODUCTS, INC. UNIVERSAL FRICTION MATERIALS COMPANY
GATKE CORPORATION WHEELING BRAKE BLOCK MANUFACTURING
GARLOCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC COMPANY
BRASSBESTOS BRAKE LINING COMPANY OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.
HH. KRASNE MANUFACTURING COMPANY BELL ASBESTOS MINES LTD,

AUTO SPECIALTIES MANUFACTURING COMPANY DOES5000-#000

ALTERNATE ENTITY

GARLOCK SEALING GARLOCK, INC.

TECHNOLOUIES, LLC COLTEC INDUSTRIES, INC.
FAIRBANKS-MORSE
FAIRBANKS MORSE ENGINES
BELMONT PACKING & RUBBER CO.
GARLOCK PACKING CO.
U.S. GASKET CO.
GOODRICH CORPORATION
ENPRO INDUSTRIES, INC.

EXHIBIT HEXHIBIT IEXHIBITT

3 | METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
} OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.

4] PNBUMO ABEX LLC

§ GATKE CORPORATION

5 GARLOCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIBS, LLC

6

|| UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES, INC.

DOESS000-7500

| AMERICAN CONFERENCE OF GOVERNMENTAL INDUSTRIAL HYGIENISTS, INC.

EXHIBIT 1(815) 99801553

BRAYTON PURCELL LLP
ATTORNEYS ATLAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD
POBOX 6169
NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 549¢8-6169

°
se

 :NDORSED
FILED
San Franciseo County Superior Coe
DAVID R, DONADIO, ESQ., §.B. #154436 APR 2 9 2008 *

BRAYTON*PURCELL LEP

Ee goRnON A, Ot
2 Rus! ing Ro: ee

P.O. Box 6169 Bh mmnm Deputy Gerk

Novato, California 94948-6169

{415) 898-1555

Attomeys for Plaintiffs

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

JOHN COYLE and INA COYLE, 3 ASBESTOS
lo.

Plaintiffs, “27 hb3h
vs. preriminShy Aer Sueennew

FILING/ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B“*P) )

(See Gencral Order No. 129, in Re:
Complex Asbestos Litigation)

NOTICE

TO NBW DEFENDANTS SERVED IN COMPLEX ASBESTOS LITIGATION IN THE
SUPERIOR GQURT IN AND FOR THE STATE OF CALIPORNIA, CITY AND COUNTY OF
Al

You have been served with process in an action which has been designated by the Court
as complex litigation pursuant to Standard 19 of the Standards of Judicial Administration. This
litigation bears the caption "In Re: Complex Asbestos Litigation", [San Francisco Superior

Court No. 828684]. :

‘This litigation is governed by various general orders, some of which affect the judicial
management and/or discovery obligations, including the responsibility to answer interrogatories
deemed propounded in the case. You may contact the Court or Designated Defense Counsel,

& , P.O. Box 16070, 2930 Lakeshore Avenue, Oakland, CA 94610; Telephone:
(S10) 835-8330; FAX: ($10) 835-5117, for further information and/or copies of these orders, at
your expense,
L. State the complete name and address of each person whose claimed exposure to asbestos is
the basis of this lawsuit ("exposed person"): John Coyle, 1185 Balsa Avenue, Yucea Valley,

California 92284.

Ky I
‘ACTS! E ATION2. Does plaintiff anticipate filing a motion for a preferential trial date within the next four
months? x Yes _-_.. No
[If yes, the action will be governed by General Order No. 140; if no, the action will be governed
by General Order No. 129.}
3. Date of birth of each exposed person in item one and, if applicable, date of death:
Date of Birth: 12/14/30
Date of Death: N/A
Social Security Number of ach exposed person:
556-34-9576
4, Specify the nature or type of asbestos-related disease alleged by each exposed person.
__X__ Asbestosis __X__ Mesothelioma
_X__ Pleural Thickening/Plaques ___ Other Cancer: Specify:
____ lamg Cancer Other Than Mesothelioma —_— Other: Specify:
5. For purposes of identifying the nature of exposure allegations involved in this action, please
check one or more:
_____ Shipyard —~X__ Construction _.._ Friction-Automotive
;_X__ Premises __.__. Aerospace ___.. Military

_—.... Other: Specify al! that apply:

Hf applicable, indicate which exposure allegations apply to which exposed person.

6. Identify each location alleged to be a source of an asbestos exposure, and to the extent known,
provide the beginning and ending year(s) of each such exposure. Also specify each exposed
person's employer and job title or job description during cach period of exposure. (For example:
“San Francisce Naval Shipyard - Pipefitter - 1939-1948"). Examples of locations af exposure
might be a specific shipyard, a specific railroad maintenance yard, or perkaps more generalized
descriptions such as "merchant marine" or “construction. If an exposed person claims exposure
during only a portion of a year, the answer should indicate that year as the beginning and ending
year (€.g,, 1947-1947).

“if

RAlajrectoptAm ws 2 .
PRELIMIN: Al 7S | ONLocation of Exposure
Dates

> | Bemplover Exposure Job Title
JE. Young Pipelines Pipeline, Laborer GALISO-F/195
3 Gardena, CA P Rosecrans Avenue,
4 i Torrance & Hawthome, CA
| Mohring & Hanson Company Various locations Plumber 1/1951-6/1956
54 6615 Sth Avenve
6| Los Angeles, CA .
Mehring & Hanson Company Statler Hilton Hotel, Plumber 3/1951-1/1953;
74 6615 8th Avenuc Wilshire Blvd. 1955
8 Los Angeles, CA Los Angeles, CA
Mebring & Hanson Company Marine“Land, Plumber B/1953-3/1954
9} 6615 8th Avenue Palos Verdes, CA
1 Los Angeles, CA
Mehring & Hanson Company Daniel Freeman Memorial Plumber - 4/1954 - 9/1955;
11 | 6615 8th Avenue Hospital, 1956

| Los Angeles, CA Inglewood, CA.

12
Mohring & Hanson Company Ambassador Hotel Plumber 1956
13 | 6615 8th Avenue Los Angeles, CA
14 Los Angeles, CA
JB Nettles & Co Inc. Ford Mercury Plant Plumber 4/1956-9/1956;
154 755 Sansome St. Pico Rivera, CA 4/1 957-6/1957
San Francisco, CA

f (Altach Additional Pages, If Necessary) SEE ATTACHED CONTINUATION
| 7. For each exposed person who:
a. worked in the United States or for a U.S. agency outside the teryitorial United States,

Ht attach to the copy of this fact sheet provided to Designated Defense Counset a fully exceuted
Social Security Earnings authorization (Exhibit N-4 to General Order No. 129);

b. may have had a Social Security disability award or is no longer employed and whose
last employment was not with a United States government agency, attach to the copy of this fact
{| sheet provided to Designated Defense Counsel a fully exeeuted Social Security Disability
authorization (Exhibit N-5 to General Order No. 129);

©. served at any lime in the United States military, attach to the copy of this fact sheet
provided to Designated Defense Counsel two fully executed originals of the stipulation (Exhibit
|| N-3 to General Order No. 129);

f ko 3
| PRELIMINAI TH Fl STOS LITIGATION1 <. was employed by the United States government in a civifian capacity, aitach ta the
2] copy of this fact shect provided to Designated Defense Counsel two fully executed originals of
3 the stipulation (Exhibit N-3 to Genoral Order No. 129),

6 | attach a copy of it to the copy of this fact shect provided to Designated Defense Counsel.
7 9. State the date of the filing of the initial complaint in this matter:

| April29,Zcog 6

B

ys ) .
10] Alfomey for PlaintiffsOo OW tA A KR ww

Employer

Kennedy Pipe & Supply Co.
15301 So. a

‘aramount Bivd.
Paramount, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Bovee & Crail

B&C Contractors

263 W. Avocado Crest Rd.
Whittier, CA

Lohman Bros. Contracting
Plumbing & Heating

300 E. Coast Hwy.
Newport Beach, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Gluck Co.
Canoga Park, CA

Bailey the Plumber, Inc.
c/o Irving T. Bass
16633 Ventura Blvd.
Encino, CA

Standard Piumbing Co.
4529 Cecelia St.
Cudahy, CA

. D & D Plumbing & Heating

7915 Pacific Bivd.
Huntington Park, CA

Kore Drilling, Inc.
16022 Arminta St.
Van Nuys, CA

KAbsjoretisupprenss tect

Location of
Exposure

Slauson & Vermont
Los Angeles, CA

Wilshire Terrace
Wilshire & Beverly Glen
Les Angeles, CA

Comstock Building
Wilshire & Comstock
Las Angeles, CA

Los Artgeles [ntemational

Airport,

Wind Tunnel Building,
Aviation Blvd.

El Segundo, CA

California State Office
Building .
Los Angeles, CA

Valley Maintenance Center
San Fernando Valley, CA

Pacific Emplo: Grou;
PEG) Building
s Angeles, CA

Lesser Towers,
Los Angeles, CA

Generai Motors
South Gate, CA

Broadway Departnent
Stores Warehouse,
Soto St,

Los Angeles, CA

Sagura Gardens
Apartments

Crenshaw & Hawthome
Bivd., Torrance, CA

USC University Hospital,
Los Angeles, CA oP

$

WIT) POS LITIGA

ile
Plumber

Plumber’
(Foreman)

Plumber
(Foreman)

Plumber
(Foreman}

Plumber

Phumber
(Foreman)

Plumber
{Boreman)
Plumber
(Foreman)

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Exposure
Dates

Af 957-6/1957
DAOST-6/1958

T4196 1-3/1962

S11957-6/1958
TA961-3/1962

A/YS8 - 3/1959

1/1959-3/1961

1962

1962

1962-1963

7/1963-9/1963

9/1963-7/1964

11/1963-06/1964

7N965-9/1965
(I week)Employer

Durell Mechanical
16146 Leadweit St.
Van Nuys, CA

Dumeil Mechanical
16146 Leadwell St.
Van Nuys, CA

Dumell Mechanical
16146 Leadwell St.
Van Nuys, CA

Dumelf Mechanica!
16146 Leadwell St.
Van Nuys, CA

E A Nonis Plumbing
Baldwin Park, CA

Hermson, Inc.

2331 Oceanside
Oceanside, CA

Pierce Engineering

2121 Daladier Dr.
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
Pierce Engineesin;

2121 Daladier Dr.
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Scott Company of California,

Corp.
Wy Doolittle Dr.
San Leandro, CA

Scott Company of California,
£717 Doolittic Dr.
San Leandro, CA

i

Location of

Exposure itle
Mattel Toys, Plumber
Hawthorne, CA.

Medical Bldg. Plumber
Hawthorne Bivd.

Los Angeles, CA

Various Lucky Markets,
including, but not limited to
the following located at:

Lucky Market,
Rosecrans & Crenshaw,
Inglewood, CA

Lucky Market,
Atlantic & Century,
Lynwood, CA

Ford Motor Plant
Aviation & Rosecrans,
El Segundo, CA

Holiday fan
Redondo Beach, CA

Ramada Ino
Carson, CA

Plumber

Phimber

Plumber

Plumber

Alcoa Gateway Building, Plumber

West Century City, CA

Prudcotial Insurance Plumber
High rise office bldg.
5900 block Wilshire Blvd.

Los Angeles, CA

Crown-Zellerbach,
Commerce, CA

Plumber

Union Bank Plumber
{parking structure),

js Angeles, CA

LING/ASBES

Exposure

Dates
1/1966-3/1969

1/1966-9/1 966

1/3967-3/1969

1/1967-12/1967

LA1967-12/1967
1973-0/1974

1/1967-12/1967

1969

1/1969-12/1969;
4f1972-3/1974;
41975-9977

10/1969-06/1971

11971-249721
2 fever
Pierce Engineering
3} 2121 Daladier Dr.
4 Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

sa nw

8

91} Hermsen Inc.
2391 Oceanside, Bivd.
10 |} Oceanside, CA

lif Pierce Engineering
2121 Daladier Dr.
12] Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

43 Sam P. Wallace Co. Inc.
2102 ire Central
t4¢ Dallas, T-

45 | D/K Mechanical
442Q BE. Miraloma Ave.
164] Anaheim, CA

17} D/K Mechanical
4420 E, Miraloma Ave.
18] Anaheim, CA

19 | D/K Mechanical

4420 E. Miraloma Ave.

204 Anaheim, CA

214 Sam P. Wallace Co. Inc.
2102 Empire Central

2 | Dallas, TX

234] D/K Mechanical

4420 E. Miraloma Ave.

24\| Anaheim, CA

254

264 fH

274 it

ELIMINARY FACT SHEETINES

Location of
Exposure

Broadway Plaza,
Los Angeles, CA

Jeb Title

Plumber

3580 Wilshire Blvd.
‘office bldg.)
s Angeles, CA

Disneyland (Bonita Tower,
Disneyland Lictel; and
Disneyland Fountain),
Anaheim, CA

Ramada Inn,
Torrance, CA

Plumber

C.F, Braun & Co. Plumber
1006 S. Fremont Ave.
Athambra, CA

Various locations Plumber

CF. Braun Plumber

Alhambra, CA

Anaheim Convention Phromber
Center

Anaheim, CA.

Disneyland Restaurant
Disneyland
Anaheim, CA

Plamber

Maxum Hotel Plumber

Palm Springs, CA

Sania Ana Plumber
Register

Santa Ana, CA

Exposure
Dates.

AN972-GH9T3
SAI975-9/1976

FON 976-12/1979

OW1974-1 2/1974;
04/1975-O6/1975
1980

1981,
G/988-G/1989
1981
5/1982-S/1983
1983

4f1984-2/1985

HA98S-1986

7
ASB: IGATIONEmployer

Cc © NA Mh & & Ww

10 | Sam P. Wallace Co. Inc.
2102 Empire Central

11] Dallas, T-

Jorou Mechanical
10820 Atlantic Ave.
Lynwood , CA

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miraloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA

12 | D/K Mechanical

4420. Miraloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA

D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miraloma Ave.
Anaheim, CA

| D/K Mechanical
4420 E. Miraloma Ave.
Anabcim, CA

Location of
Exposure

North American Facilities,
Huntington Beach, CA

North American Rockwell,
Anaheim, CA

North American Rockwell,
Newport Beach, CA

Unknown office building
and parking structure,
MacArthur Blvd.
Newport, CA

Metropolitan Detention
Center (MDC),
Los Angeles, CA

Mattel To:
(Cafeteria ,
Tawthome, CA

Allergan Chemical
18600 Von Karman
irvine, CA.

White Memorial Medical
Building,
East Los Angeles, CA

St. Judes Hospital,
Fullerton, CA

AS BE:

Job Title
Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Plumber

Exposure
Dates

1986

7A986-12/1987

GAL988-6/1989
S/990-2/1 991
VL991-6/1991
B/L99T-12/1991

10/1992-1/1993RECEIVED: DATE: TIME: HOW: om ome -

iF SERVED: DATE: 5/8/2008 = TIME: 9:35a.m. HOW; PERSONAL SERVICE
IF ACCEPTED: BY: Marsha Reed ON BEHALF OF; Walt Disney World Co.

SUBJECT: John Coyle and ina Coyle

Ww
Asbestos Defendants (B*P)
As Reflected on Exhibits B, B-1, C, H, 1; and Does 1-8500; and See Attached List

CASE NUMBER: | CGC-08-274634

COURT: San Francisco County Superior Court
TYPE OF Summons; Complaint for Personal Injury and Loss of Consortium - Asbestos |
DOCUMENT:

LAW FIRM OR Brayton*Purceli LLP
ATTORNEY:

ROUTED TO: Ed Nowak
DATE: §/8/08

cc:

COMMENTS: . |

Lt ___|EXHIBIT 2o ON OW HO RB WO NM =

Ny Nw NN NY NY NY YM RD we we me
Yoouk® &s & S bet soaraxs ss

28

SCHIFF HARDIN LLP
AtsORNEYS At LAW
SAN PRANCISCO

SCHIFF HARDIN LLP

JEFFREY R. WILLIAMS (CSB #84156)
NEIL C. LUDMAN (CSB #104657)
One Market, Spear Street Tower
Thirty-Second Floor

San Francisco, CA 94105

Telephone: (415) 901-8700
Facsimile: (415) 901-8701

Attomeys for Defendant
WALT DISNEY WORLD CO.

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

JOHN COYLE and INA COYLE, Case No. CGC-08-274634

Plaintiffs, ANSWER OF DEFENDANT WALT
DISNEY WORLD CO. TO PLAINTIFFS’
v. UNVERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR
PERSONAL INJURY
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B-P),

Defendants.

Defendant WALT DISNEY WORLD CO. answers Plaintiffs’ unverified Compiaint
on its own behaif and on behalf of no other defendant as follows:

Pursuant to Califomia Code of Civil Procedure Section 431.30{(d), Defendant
denies generally each and every allegation of the Complaint.

FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Neither the Complaint nor any purported cause of action alleged by the Plaintiffs

therein states facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action against Defendant.
SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

To the extent the Complaint asserts Defendant's alleged "market share" liability,
or "enterprise liability,” the Complaint fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of
action against Defendant.

(38478-0012
$F9153081.1

ANSWER OF DEFENDANT TO PLAINTIFFS’ UNVERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURYoO DN DOD OH FB WO ND nwa

=a os
Ww Ns ©

28

SCHIFF HARDIN LLP
ATTORNEYS AT Law
San Francisca

THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Neither the Complaint nor any purported cause of action alleged therein states
facts sufficient to entitle Plaintiffs to an award of punitive damages against Defendant.
FOURTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

The imposition of any punitive damages in this matter would deprive Defendant of
its property without due process of law under the California Constitution and United
States Constitution.

FIFTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

The imposition of any punitive damages in this matter would violate the United

States Constitution's prohibition against laws impairing the obligation of contracts.
SIXTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

The imposition of any punitive damages in this matter would constitute a criminal
fine or penalty and should, therefore, be remitted on the ground that the award violates
the United States Constitution.

SEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Plaintiffs’ action, and each alleged cause of action, is barred by the applicable

statute of limitations, including but not limited to California Code of Civil Procedure
Sections 338, 339, 340.2, 343, 361, and 474, California Commercial Code, Section
2725, and any applicable statute of limitation and/or statute of repose of the state of
Plaintiffs’ residence if not California.

EIGHTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Plaintiffs unreasonably delayed in bringing this action, without good cause
therefor, and thereby have prejudiced Defendant as a direct and proximate result of such
delay; accordingly, this action is barred by laches.

NINTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Plaintiffs were negligent in and about the matters alleged in the Complaint and in
each alleged cause of action; this negligence proximately caused, in whole or in part, the
damages alleged in the Complaint. In the event Plaintiffs are entitled to any damages,

35479-0012 -2-
SFIG153061.1

ANSWER OF DEFENDANT TO PLAINTIFFS’ UNVERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURYoO ON DOD OHO & BW HB aw

Ny RN HR NN RY NH Bw ww wm ow
NE een:

28

SCHIFF HARDEN LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
SAM FRANCISCO

the amount of these damages should be reduced by the comparative fault of Plaintiffs
and any person whose negligent acts or omissions are imputed to Plaintiffs.
TENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Plaintiffs knowingly, voluntarily and unreasonably undertook to encounter each of
the risks and hazards, if any, referred to in the Complaint and each alleged cause of
action, and this undertaking proximately caused and contributed to any loss, injury or
damages incurred by Plaintiffs.
ELEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Any loss, injury or damage incurred by Plaintiffs was proximately caused by the
negligent or willful acts or omissions of parties whom Defendant neither controlled nor
had the right to control, and was not proximately caused by any acts, omissions or other
conduct of Defendant.
TWELFTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
The products referred to in the Complaint were misused, abused or altered by
Plaintiffs or by others; the misuse, abuse or alteration was not reasonably foreseeable to
Defendant, and proximately caused any loss, injury or damages incurred by Plaintiffs.
THIRTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Plaintiffs failed to exercise due diligence to mitigate their loss, injury or damages;
accordingly, the amount of damages to which Plaintiffs are entitled, if any, should be
reduced by the amount of damages which would have otherwise been mitigated.
FOURTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
The Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the matters alleged in the
Complaint because the Complaint and each alleged cause of action against Defendant
is barred by the provisions of California Labor Code, Section 3601, et seq.
FIFTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Defendant alleges that at the time of the injuries alleged in the Complaint, Plaintiff
John Coyle was employed and was entitled to receive Workers' Compensation benefits
from his employer, that Plaintiff John Coyles’ employer, other than Defendant, was

35179-0012 -3-
SF9153061.4

ANSWER OF DEFENDANT TO PLAINTIFFS’ UNVERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURYoO N OO fF WN

NNN NY NNN NHN wm wom

28

SCHIFF Haroin LLP
ATTORNEYS AT Lan
Sant PRANEISCO

negligent in and about the matters referred to in said Complaint, and that such
negligence on the part of said employer proximately and concurrently contributed to the
happening of the accident and to the loss or damage complained of by Plaintiffs, if any,
and that by reason thereof Defendant is entitled to set off any such benefits to be
received by Plaintiffs against any judgment which may be rendered in favor of Plaintiffs.
SIXTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Discovery may show that at the time of the injuries alleged in the Complaint,
Plaintiff John Coyle was employed by and entitled to Workers' Compensation benefits
from Defendant; such benefits constitute Plaintiffs’ exclusive remedy pursuant to Labor
Code section 3600 et seq.
SEVENTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Defendant alleges that at the time of the injuries alleged in the Complaint, Plaintiff
John Coyle’s employers were negligent in and about the matters referred to in said
Complaint, and that such negligence on the part of said employers proximately and
concurrently contributed to any loss or damage, including non-economic damages,
complained of by Plaintiffs, if any; and that Defendant is not liable for said employers’
proportionate share of non-economic damages.
EIGHTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

Defendant alleges that at the time of the injuries alleged in the Complaint, parties
other than this Defendant were negligent in and about the matters referred to in said
Complaint, and that such negligence on the part of said parties proximately and
concurrently contributed to any loss or damage, including non-economic damages,
complained of by Plaintiffs, if any; and that Defendant h