On October 15, 2007 a
MINUTES FOR MAY-26-2011 9:00 AM FOR DEPT 318
was filed
involving a dispute between
Ingram, Alba,
and
Does 1 To 40,
Ryder Truck Rental, Inc.,
Sifuentesbenites, Jorge Pedro,
Silva, Reynaldo Antonio,
The Henry Wine Group,
for PERSONAL INJURY/PROPERTY DAMAGE - VEHICLE RELATED
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
MINUTES
Thursday, May 26, 2011
ALBA INGRAM
PLAINTIFF
vs
THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
DEFENDANT
Present:
DONALD SULLIVAN
Sherry Sawyer CSR 5976
Judge
Reporter:
Appearing for Plaintiff (s)
Steven J. Brady, Esq.
BRADY LAW GROUP
1015 Irwin Street, Suite A
San Rafael, CA 94901
415-459-7300
Atty for Plaintiff Alba Ingram
Department 318
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Nature of Cause:
Jury Trial-Day 2
Jury Day 2
Nature of Cause: JURY TRIAL
Personal Injury — Vehicle Related
Clerk VICKI MACK
Bailiff:
Appearing for Defendant(s):
Brian Har, Esq.
NARAYAN & HUDSON
101 —2™ Street, Suite A
San Francisco, CA 94101
415-227-2300
Atty for Defendant The Henry Wine Group
09:32am The trial continues from Wednesday, May 25, 2011. The court, counsel as above
indicated, the plaintiff and 39 prospective jurors are present in open court. Mr. Brady resumes
follow-up voir dire with the 30 seated panel members.
09:35am On peremptory, plaintiff excuses the following jurors:
JANEAN WONG; JOHNPAUL WISHNIA; SCOTT GRAINGER; ROMEO PALENCIA;
CAITLIN GALANG and CORINA TROELTZSCH.
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
Date: May 26, 2011
Form: C01006On peremptory, defendant excuses the following jurors
SANDRA WOOD; CAROL RIVES; TOM ABELES and KEVIN STARR.
09:50am The following twelve jurors and three alternates are sworn to try the cause
1. BRIAN INGRAM 2. JOHN GREENWOOD 3. MARGARET PEARCE
4. GREGORY THAYER 5. TIMOTHY BREY 6. SONNY GARCIA
7. WYNNE KWAN 8. JILL WHELCHEL 9. FRANCISCO DEPANTE
10. ALLYSE GRAY 11. REBECCA SHERMAN 12. KRISTEN HAVILAND
13. JESSIE DUNCAN - Alternate no. 1
14. BEVIN DANIELS - Alternate no. 2
15. JOHANNA HOADLEY - Alternated no. 3
09:52am The court delivers its preliminary instructions to the jury, on the record.
10:15am Mr. Brady presents plaintiff's opening statement.
10:45am The court declares a morning recess.
11:02am All are present in open court, on the record. Mr. Brady resumes presentation of
plaintiff's opening statement.
12:02pm The court declares a lunch recess.
01:33pm _ All are present in open court, on the record. Mr. Har presents defendant’s opening
statement
01:39pm Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY is called to testify on behalf of plaintiff. The clerk
administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Brady commences
Plaintiff identifies the following exhibits:
Exh. no. 15 - Medical records from Pain & Rehabilitative Consultants Med Group
These records were identified as Exh. 16 on the record
Exh. no. 16 - Medical billing from Pain & Rehabilitative Consultants Med Group
These records were identified as Exh. 17 on the record
02:50pm Cross examination of Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY by Mr. Har commences
03:00pm The court declares a recess.
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
-2- Date: May 26, 2011
Form: C0100603:17pm All are present in open court, on the record. Cross examination of Dr. BRENDAN
MORLEY by Mr. Har resumes.
Defendant identifies the following exhibit:
Exh. no. 11 - Medical billing from Emeryville Open MRI
03:34pm Redirect commences.
03:38pm Recross commences
03:40pm The witness, Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY, is excused.
03:42pm STEPHANIE SANSONE is called to testify on behalf of plaintiff. The clerk
administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Brady commences
03:51pm Cross examination commences
03:52pm Redirect commences. The witness is, STEPHANIE SANSONE, is excused.
03:54pm SARA MANCINI is called to testify on behalf of plaintiff. The clerk administers the
oath. Direct examination by Mr. Brady commences.
04:02pm Cross examination commences
04:06pm The witness, SARA MANCINTL, is excused. Sidebar held
04:10pm The court excuses the jury for 15 minutes to discuss the issue of court reporter
unavailability for tomorrow, May 27, 2011. Mr. Brady suggests calling a private court reporter,
without objection by the court.
04:20pm Outside the presence of the others jury, the court, with counsel present, conducts voir
dire of alternate no. 2, Ms. Daniels, regarding her recognition of a name containing in an exhibit
used by plaintiff's counsel during opening statements.
Discussions held regarding modification of certain jury instructions. The court directs counsel to
state the stipulation to have all joint exhibits admitted into evidence.
04:28pm The jury reenters the courtroom and the court orders each of them to return on Friday,
May 27, 2011 at 9:30am in Dept. 318. Court stands in recess.
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
-3- Date: May 26, 2011
Form: C01006
Document Filed Date
May 26, 2011
Case Filing Date
October 15, 2007
Category
PERSONAL INJURY/PROPERTY DAMAGE - VEHICLE RELATED
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO MINUTES Thursday, May 26, 2011 ALBA INGRAM PLAINTIFF vs THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al DEFENDANT Present: DONALD SULLIVAN Sherry Sawyer CSR 5976 Judge Reporter: Appearing for Plaintiff (s) Steven J. Brady, Esq. BRADY LAW GROUP 1015 Irwin Street, Suite A San Rafael, CA 94901 415-459-7300 Atty for Plaintiff Alba Ingram Department 318 Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Nature of Cause: Jury Trial-Day 2 Jury Day 2 Nature of Cause: JURY TRIAL Personal Injury — Vehicle Related Clerk VICKI MACK Bailiff: Appearing for Defendant(s): Brian Har, Esq. NARAYAN & HUDSON 101 —2™ Street, Suite A San Francisco, CA 94101 415-227-2300 Atty for Defendant The Henry Wine Group 09:32am The trial continues from Wednesday, May 25, 2011. The court, counsel as above indicated, the plaintiff and 39 prospective jurors are present in open court. Mr. Brady resumes follow-up voir dire with the 30 seated panel members. 09:35am On peremptory, plaintiff excuses the following jurors: JANEAN WONG; JOHNPAUL WISHNIA; SCOTT GRAINGER; ROMEO PALENCIA; CAITLIN GALANG and CORINA TROELTZSCH. Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al Date: May 26, 2011 Form: C01006On peremptory, defendant excuses the following jurors SANDRA WOOD; CAROL RIVES; TOM ABELES and KEVIN STARR. 09:50am The following twelve jurors and three alternates are sworn to try the cause 1. BRIAN INGRAM 2. JOHN GREENWOOD 3. MARGARET PEARCE 4. GREGORY THAYER 5. TIMOTHY BREY 6. SONNY GARCIA 7. WYNNE KWAN 8. JILL WHELCHEL 9. FRANCISCO DEPANTE 10. ALLYSE GRAY 11. REBECCA SHERMAN 12. KRISTEN HAVILAND 13. JESSIE DUNCAN - Alternate no. 1 14. BEVIN DANIELS - Alternate no. 2 15. JOHANNA HOADLEY - Alternated no. 3 09:52am The court delivers its preliminary instructions to the jury, on the record. 10:15am Mr. Brady presents plaintiff's opening statement. 10:45am The court declares a morning recess. 11:02am All are present in open court, on the record. Mr. Brady resumes presentation of plaintiff's opening statement. 12:02pm The court declares a lunch recess. 01:33pm _ All are present in open court, on the record. Mr. Har presents defendant’s opening statement 01:39pm Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY is called to testify on behalf of plaintiff. The clerk administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Brady commences Plaintiff identifies the following exhibits: Exh. no. 15 - Medical records from Pain & Rehabilitative Consultants Med Group These records were identified as Exh. 16 on the record Exh. no. 16 - Medical billing from Pain & Rehabilitative Consultants Med Group These records were identified as Exh. 17 on the record 02:50pm Cross examination of Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY by Mr. Har commences 03:00pm The court declares a recess. Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al -2- Date: May 26, 2011 Form: C0100603:17pm All are present in open court, on the record. Cross examination of Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY by Mr. Har resumes. Defendant identifies the following exhibit: Exh. no. 11 - Medical billing from Emeryville Open MRI 03:34pm Redirect commences. 03:38pm Recross commences 03:40pm The witness, Dr. BRENDAN MORLEY, is excused. 03:42pm STEPHANIE SANSONE is called to testify on behalf of plaintiff. The clerk administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Brady commences 03:51pm Cross examination commences 03:52pm Redirect commences. The witness is, STEPHANIE SANSONE, is excused. 03:54pm SARA MANCINI is called to testify on behalf of plaintiff. The clerk administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Brady commences. 04:02pm Cross examination commences 04:06pm The witness, SARA MANCINTL, is excused. Sidebar held 04:10pm The court excuses the jury for 15 minutes to discuss the issue of court reporter unavailability for tomorrow, May 27, 2011. Mr. Brady suggests calling a private court reporter, without objection by the court. 04:20pm Outside the presence of the others jury, the court, with counsel present, conducts voir dire of alternate no. 2, Ms. Daniels, regarding her recognition of a name containing in an exhibit used by plaintiff's counsel during opening statements. Discussions held regarding modification of certain jury instructions. The court directs counsel to state the stipulation to have all joint exhibits admitted into evidence. 04:28pm The jury reenters the courtroom and the court orders each of them to return on Friday, May 27, 2011 at 9:30am in Dept. 318. Court stands in recess. Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al -3- Date: May 26, 2011 Form: C01006