On October 15, 2007 a
MINUTES FOR JUN-02-2011 9:30 AM FOR DEPT 318
was filed
involving a dispute between
Ingram, Alba,
and
Does 1 To 40,
Ryder Truck Rental, Inc.,
Sifuentesbenites, Jorge Pedro,
Silva, Reynaldo Antonio,
The Henry Wine Group,
for PERSONAL INJURY/PROPERTY DAMAGE - VEHICLE RELATED
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
MINUTES
Thursday, June 02, 2011
ALBA INGRAM
PLAINTIFF
vs
THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
DEFENDANT
Present:
DONALD SULLIVAN
Sherry Sawyer CSR 5976
Judge
Reporter:
Appearing for Plaintiff (s)
Steven J. Brady, Esq.
Stuart Blecher, Esq. present
BRADY LAW GROUP
1015 Irwin Street, Suite A
San Rafael, CA 94901
415-459-7300
Atty for Plaintiff Alba Ingram
Department 318
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Nature of Cause:
Jury Trial-Day 6
Jury Day 6
Nature of Cause: JURY TRIAL
Personal Injury — Vehicle Related
Clerk VICKI MACK
Bailiff: Deputy Joanne Gomez
Appearing for Defendant(s):
Brian Har, Esq. present
NARAYAN & HUDSON
101 —2™ Street, Suite A
San Francisco, CA 94101
415-227-2300
Atty for Defendant The Henry Wine Group
09:30am The trial continues from June 1, 2011 for jury deliberations. Counsel as above noted
and the plaintiff are present in open court. The twelve jurors assemble outside the courtroom and
the bailiff escorts each of them to the deliberation room.
The court reporter reads back the agreed upon trial testimony of Dr. Light relating to the cost of
surgery as requested in juror note no. 1 received June 1, 2011
10:22am The bailiff delivers written juror request no. 2. The court and counsel confer.
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
Date: June 02, 2011
Form: C0100610:32am The court responds in writing and attaches a copy of jury instruction CACI 3964,
Additional copies of jury instruction CACI 3964 for each member of the jury.
11:20am The bailiff delivers written juror request no. 3. The court and counsel confer.
11:32am The court responds to request no. 3 in writing.
12:00pm The court declares a lunch recess. The jurors take a lunch recess from 12:00-1:00pm.
01:30pm Counsel and the plaintiff return to the courtroom.
01:56pm The court and counsel as above indicated are present as the twelve jurors enter the
courtroom. After review by the court, the clerk reads the Special Verdict, on the record
As to question no. 1 “ was defendant The Henry Wine Group’s admitted negligence a substantial
factor in causing plaintiff's injuries and damages?” the jury answered “Yes”
As to question no. 2 “what are plaintiff Alba Ingram’s injuries and damages?”
a. Past Medical Expenses $ 51,833.83
b. Future Medical Expenses $200,000.00
c. Past Lost Earnings $ 17,401.60
d. Non-Economic losses including physical pain, impairment, inconvenience, grief, anxiety and
emotional distress $750,000.00
Total: $1,019,235.43
The Special Verdict form is signed and dated by the Presiding Juror, John Greenwood. The
jurors are polled and respond as follows:
Question no. 1 — 12 jurors affirm
Question no. 2a - 12 jurors affirm
Question no. 2b - 12 jurors affirm
Question no. 2c - 12 jurors affirm
Question no. 2d - 9 jurors affirm; 3 jurors deny
The reading of the Special Verdict as recorded is waived. The jurors are thanked and excused.
The court grants counsel brief leave to interview the jurors inside the courtroom.
02:34pm On the record, the court signs an order to return deposition transcripts and trial
exhibits. Offset motions may be filed regarding the $32,000.00 paid to workman’s compensation
by defendant. Plaintiff shall submit a proposed Judgment approved as to form. Court is
adjourned.
Case Number: CGC-07-468175
Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al
-2- Date: June 02, 2011
Form: C01006
Document Filed Date
June 02, 2011
Case Filing Date
October 15, 2007
Category
PERSONAL INJURY/PROPERTY DAMAGE - VEHICLE RELATED
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO MINUTES Thursday, June 02, 2011 ALBA INGRAM PLAINTIFF vs THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al DEFENDANT Present: DONALD SULLIVAN Sherry Sawyer CSR 5976 Judge Reporter: Appearing for Plaintiff (s) Steven J. Brady, Esq. Stuart Blecher, Esq. present BRADY LAW GROUP 1015 Irwin Street, Suite A San Rafael, CA 94901 415-459-7300 Atty for Plaintiff Alba Ingram Department 318 Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Nature of Cause: Jury Trial-Day 6 Jury Day 6 Nature of Cause: JURY TRIAL Personal Injury — Vehicle Related Clerk VICKI MACK Bailiff: Deputy Joanne Gomez Appearing for Defendant(s): Brian Har, Esq. present NARAYAN & HUDSON 101 —2™ Street, Suite A San Francisco, CA 94101 415-227-2300 Atty for Defendant The Henry Wine Group 09:30am The trial continues from June 1, 2011 for jury deliberations. Counsel as above noted and the plaintiff are present in open court. The twelve jurors assemble outside the courtroom and the bailiff escorts each of them to the deliberation room. The court reporter reads back the agreed upon trial testimony of Dr. Light relating to the cost of surgery as requested in juror note no. 1 received June 1, 2011 10:22am The bailiff delivers written juror request no. 2. The court and counsel confer. Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al Date: June 02, 2011 Form: C0100610:32am The court responds in writing and attaches a copy of jury instruction CACI 3964, Additional copies of jury instruction CACI 3964 for each member of the jury. 11:20am The bailiff delivers written juror request no. 3. The court and counsel confer. 11:32am The court responds to request no. 3 in writing. 12:00pm The court declares a lunch recess. The jurors take a lunch recess from 12:00-1:00pm. 01:30pm Counsel and the plaintiff return to the courtroom. 01:56pm The court and counsel as above indicated are present as the twelve jurors enter the courtroom. After review by the court, the clerk reads the Special Verdict, on the record As to question no. 1 “ was defendant The Henry Wine Group’s admitted negligence a substantial factor in causing plaintiff's injuries and damages?” the jury answered “Yes” As to question no. 2 “what are plaintiff Alba Ingram’s injuries and damages?” a. Past Medical Expenses $ 51,833.83 b. Future Medical Expenses $200,000.00 c. Past Lost Earnings $ 17,401.60 d. Non-Economic losses including physical pain, impairment, inconvenience, grief, anxiety and emotional distress $750,000.00 Total: $1,019,235.43 The Special Verdict form is signed and dated by the Presiding Juror, John Greenwood. The jurors are polled and respond as follows: Question no. 1 — 12 jurors affirm Question no. 2a - 12 jurors affirm Question no. 2b - 12 jurors affirm Question no. 2c - 12 jurors affirm Question no. 2d - 9 jurors affirm; 3 jurors deny The reading of the Special Verdict as recorded is waived. The jurors are thanked and excused. The court grants counsel brief leave to interview the jurors inside the courtroom. 02:34pm On the record, the court signs an order to return deposition transcripts and trial exhibits. Offset motions may be filed regarding the $32,000.00 paid to workman’s compensation by defendant. Plaintiff shall submit a proposed Judgment approved as to form. Court is adjourned. Case Number: CGC-07-468175 Case Title: ALBA INGRAM VS. THE HENRY WINE GROUP et al -2- Date: June 02, 2011 Form: C01006