On April 27, 2018 a
Trial Materials
was filed
involving a dispute between
Mary Kay Inc.,
and
Xxxxxxx, Xxxxx Xxxxx,
for CNTR CNSMR COM DEBT
in the District Court of Dallas County.
Preview
FILED
DALLAS COUNTY
9/3/2019 3:32PM
FELICIA PITRE
DISTRICT CLERK
Miranda Lynch
CAUSE NO. DC-18-05560
MARY KAY, INC., § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
§
Plaintiff, §
§
v. § 116th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
§
xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxx, §
§
Defendant/ §
Counter-Plaintiff. § DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS
DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
COME NOW, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxx ("Defendant/Counter-Plaintiff’), in the above-styled
and numbered cause, and file this Trial Exhibit List:
N0. Description Produced Admitted
1 Letter from Lorelei Cronin of Mary Kay t0 xxxxx From Plaintiff, but
xxxxxxx dated 9-25-17 produced to Plaintiff
in response to 7th
RFP, Request #104
(Defendant’s Bate #’s
1828-29)
Part Of Busmess.
Independent National Sales Director Agreement along
2 Records Affidawt’
with annexes and amendments
Depo Exhibit 32
Amendment to Independent National Sales Director Part of Business
3 Agreement between Mary Kay, Inc. and xxxxx xxxxx Records Affidavit,
xxxxxxx Depo Exhibit 32
,
. . Part of Business
Mary Kay, Inc. s Famlly Securlty Program, Group III .
4 Records Affidavn’
along with addendums and amendments
Depo Exhibit 32
Exhibit 2 to
. Counterclaim;
5 Declaratlon of Jenny Chavez
Exhibit 23 t0 Chavez
Dep.
6 Second Declaration of xxxxx xxxxxxx Def’S Fil‘StAmended
DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 1
Counterclaim —
Exhibit 1; and Def’ s
Response to MSJ -
Exhibit A
. . Def s Response t0
7 Declaratlon 0f Beth Plland
MSJ _ Exhibit E
Def s First Amended
couptgqalm _
Defendant’s EEOC Charge, cover letter and facsimile
8 EXhlblt 2’ and
transmission (composite exhibit)
Exhibit 13 to xxxxxxx
Dep.
Plaintiff’ s Responses to Defendant’s Requests for Def’ s Response t0
9
Disclosure MSJ — Exhibit G
Plaintiff’ s Objections and Responses to Defendant’s Def’ s Response t0
10 First Request for Production of MSJ — Exhibit H
Documents
t0
Plaintiff s Objections and Responses to Defendant’s
11 516;}: Eiiigilllse
Third Request for Production
,
. E-filed and e-served
12 Defendant s Fourth Request for Productlon
0n 7/1 6/1 9
EXhlplt 14 t0 Vflmos
Text message exchange between xxxxx xxxxxxx and
13 Dep., and part 0f EX.
Jenny Chavez
25 to Chavez Dep.
Produced to Plaintiff
in her supplemental
Text Messages between xxxxx xxxxxxx and other Mary response to Plaintiff s
14
Kay sales personnel 5th RFP for Request
No. 79, (Defendant’s
Bate #’s 1813-1826)
Exhibit 39 t0 Beitler
15 Affidavit 0f Laura Beitler Dep.; and Exhibit 19
to xxxxxxx Dep.
Affidavit 0f Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx in Opp and Exhibit 17 t0 xxxxxxx
16
Response to Beitler Affidavit Dep.
Produced to Plaintiff
in response to 7th
RFP, Request No.
17 CEO Series podcast email with disclaimer
108 (EXhlblt A t0
Defendant’s
Responses t0
Plaintiff’ s 7th RFP);
and Exhibit 29 t0
DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 2
xxxxxxx Dep.
Produced to Plaintiff
in response t0
Plaintiff’ s 4th RFP
for Request N0. 69,
(Defendant’s Bate #’s
Declarations from various former Mary Kay 31-37 and 1780-
18
salespersons 0f no recruitment by xxxxx xxxxxxx 1784); and in her
supplemental
response t0 Plaintiff’ s
lst RFP for Request
N0. 9, (Defendant’s
Bate #’s 1788-1808)
Exhibit 38 to Beitler
Dep.; and produced
t0 Plaintiff in
19 Letter from John Monhollon, MD response to lst RFP,
Request N0. 10
(Defendant’s Bate #’s
30)
Produced to Plaintiff
in response t0 2nd
and 3rd RFP, Request
Nos. 30-33,35, 39,
and 48-49
20 Tax returns of Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx for 2016 (Defendant’s Bate #’s
13 13 - 1 3 64)
Produced to Plaintiff
in her supplemental
response t0 Plaintiff’ s
21 Tax returns of Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx for 2017 2nd RFP for Request
Nos. 3 1, 48 and 49,
(Defendant’s Bate #’s
1830- 1 870)
Exhibit 16 to xxxxxxx
22 Portion of medical records 0f Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx Dep. Defendant’s
Bate #’s 975-978)
DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 3
Defendant reserves the right to supplement this Exhibit List. Defendant’s also reserve the
right to seek t0 admit any exhibit identified 0n Plaintiff’ sExhibit List as though identified above.
Defendant reserves the right t0 introduce any exhibit identified above for purposes 0f rebuttal
and/or impeachment.
Respectfully submitted,
WILSON MCCOY, P.A.
/s/Gary D. Wilson
Gary D. Wils0n*
Florida Bar N0. 0846406
gwilson@wilsonmccoylaw.com
Point 100 Building
100 E. Sybelia Avenue, Suite 205
Maitland, Florida 32751
(407) 803-5400 (Telephone)
(407) 803-4617 (Telecopier)
*
Admitted Pro Hac Vice
And
/s/ Ryan K. Lurich
Ryan K. Lurich
State Bar No. 24013070
rlurich@fflawoffice.com
FRIEDMAN & FEIGER, LLP
5301 Spring Valley Road., Suite 200
Dallas, Texas 75254
(972) 788-1400 (Telephone)
(972) 788-2667 (Telecopier)
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
xxxxx CRUISE xxxxxxx
DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 4
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that a true and correct copy 0f this pleading has been served on
all counsel 0f record on this the
of Civil Procedure.
fl day 0f September, 2019, in accordance With the Texas Rules
Christopher J. Schwegmann, Esq.
Lynn Pinker Cox & Hurst, LLP
2100 Ross Avenue, Suite 2700
Dallas, Texas 75201
(214) 981-3800 (Telephone)
(214) 981-3839 (Telecopier)
/s/ Ryan K. Lurich
Ryan K. Lurich
DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 5
Document Filed Date
September 03, 2019
Case Filing Date
April 27, 2018
Category
CNTR CNSMR COM DEBT
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED DALLAS COUNTY 9/3/2019 3:32PM FELICIA PITRE DISTRICT CLERK Miranda Lynch CAUSE NO. DC-18-05560 MARY KAY, INC., § IN THE DISTRICT COURT § Plaintiff, § § v. § 116th JUDICIAL DISTRICT § xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxx, § § Defendant/ § Counter-Plaintiff. § DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT: COME NOW, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxx ("Defendant/Counter-Plaintiff’), in the above-styled and numbered cause, and file this Trial Exhibit List: N0. Description Produced Admitted 1 Letter from Lorelei Cronin of Mary Kay t0 xxxxx From Plaintiff, but xxxxxxx dated 9-25-17 produced to Plaintiff in response to 7th RFP, Request #104 (Defendant’s Bate #’s 1828-29) Part Of Busmess. Independent National Sales Director Agreement along 2 Records Affidawt’ with annexes and amendments Depo Exhibit 32 Amendment to Independent National Sales Director Part of Business 3 Agreement between Mary Kay, Inc. and xxxxx xxxxx Records Affidavit, xxxxxxx Depo Exhibit 32 , . . Part of Business Mary Kay, Inc. s Famlly Securlty Program, Group III . 4 Records Affidavn’ along with addendums and amendments Depo Exhibit 32 Exhibit 2 to . Counterclaim; 5 Declaratlon of Jenny Chavez Exhibit 23 t0 Chavez Dep. 6 Second Declaration of xxxxx xxxxxxx Def’S Fil‘StAmended DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 1 Counterclaim — Exhibit 1; and Def’ s Response to MSJ - Exhibit A . . Def s Response t0 7 Declaratlon 0f Beth Plland MSJ _ Exhibit E Def s First Amended couptgqalm _ Defendant’s EEOC Charge, cover letter and facsimile 8 EXhlblt 2’ and transmission (composite exhibit) Exhibit 13 to xxxxxxx Dep. Plaintiff’ s Responses to Defendant’s Requests for Def’ s Response t0 9 Disclosure MSJ — Exhibit G Plaintiff’ s Objections and Responses to Defendant’s Def’ s Response t0 10 First Request for Production of MSJ — Exhibit H Documents t0 Plaintiff s Objections and Responses to Defendant’s 11 516;}: Eiiigilllse Third Request for Production , . E-filed and e-served 12 Defendant s Fourth Request for Productlon 0n 7/1 6/1 9 EXhlplt 14 t0 Vflmos Text message exchange between xxxxx xxxxxxx and 13 Dep., and part 0f EX. Jenny Chavez 25 to Chavez Dep. Produced to Plaintiff in her supplemental Text Messages between xxxxx xxxxxxx and other Mary response to Plaintiff s 14 Kay sales personnel 5th RFP for Request No. 79, (Defendant’s Bate #’s 1813-1826) Exhibit 39 t0 Beitler 15 Affidavit 0f Laura Beitler Dep.; and Exhibit 19 to xxxxxxx Dep. Affidavit 0f Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx in Opp and Exhibit 17 t0 xxxxxxx 16 Response to Beitler Affidavit Dep. Produced to Plaintiff in response to 7th RFP, Request No. 17 CEO Series podcast email with disclaimer 108 (EXhlblt A t0 Defendant’s Responses t0 Plaintiff’ s 7th RFP); and Exhibit 29 t0 DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 2 xxxxxxx Dep. Produced to Plaintiff in response t0 Plaintiff’ s 4th RFP for Request N0. 69, (Defendant’s Bate #’s Declarations from various former Mary Kay 31-37 and 1780- 18 salespersons 0f no recruitment by xxxxx xxxxxxx 1784); and in her supplemental response t0 Plaintiff’ s lst RFP for Request N0. 9, (Defendant’s Bate #’s 1788-1808) Exhibit 38 to Beitler Dep.; and produced t0 Plaintiff in 19 Letter from John Monhollon, MD response to lst RFP, Request N0. 10 (Defendant’s Bate #’s 30) Produced to Plaintiff in response t0 2nd and 3rd RFP, Request Nos. 30-33,35, 39, and 48-49 20 Tax returns of Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx for 2016 (Defendant’s Bate #’s 13 13 - 1 3 64) Produced to Plaintiff in her supplemental response t0 Plaintiff’ s 21 Tax returns of Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx for 2017 2nd RFP for Request Nos. 3 1, 48 and 49, (Defendant’s Bate #’s 1830- 1 870) Exhibit 16 to xxxxxxx 22 Portion of medical records 0f Defendant xxxxx xxxxxxx Dep. Defendant’s Bate #’s 975-978) DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 3 Defendant reserves the right to supplement this Exhibit List. Defendant’s also reserve the right to seek t0 admit any exhibit identified 0n Plaintiff’ sExhibit List as though identified above. Defendant reserves the right t0 introduce any exhibit identified above for purposes 0f rebuttal and/or impeachment. Respectfully submitted, WILSON MCCOY, P.A. /s/Gary D. Wilson Gary D. Wils0n* Florida Bar N0. 0846406 gwilson@wilsonmccoylaw.com Point 100 Building 100 E. Sybelia Avenue, Suite 205 Maitland, Florida 32751 (407) 803-5400 (Telephone) (407) 803-4617 (Telecopier) * Admitted Pro Hac Vice And /s/ Ryan K. Lurich Ryan K. Lurich State Bar No. 24013070 rlurich@fflawoffice.com FRIEDMAN & FEIGER, LLP 5301 Spring Valley Road., Suite 200 Dallas, Texas 75254 (972) 788-1400 (Telephone) (972) 788-2667 (Telecopier) ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT xxxxx CRUISE xxxxxxx DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 4 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned certifies that a true and correct copy 0f this pleading has been served on all counsel 0f record on this the of Civil Procedure. fl day 0f September, 2019, in accordance With the Texas Rules Christopher J. Schwegmann, Esq. Lynn Pinker Cox & Hurst, LLP 2100 Ross Avenue, Suite 2700 Dallas, Texas 75201 (214) 981-3800 (Telephone) (214) 981-3839 (Telecopier) /s/ Ryan K. Lurich Ryan K. Lurich DEFENDANT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 5