Preview
Filing # 129860175 E-Filed 06/30/2021 07:02:48 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND
FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CIVIL DIVISION
JOHN HUGHES, III, as receiver of Flicker
Construction, Inc., an inactive Florida
corporation, CASE NO. 2019-CA-003916
Plaintiff,
vs.
ROMAN FLICKER and MID-CONTINENT
CASUALTY COMPANY,
Defendants.
/
MID-CONTINENT CASUALTY COMPANY’S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF’S
EXHIBIT LIST
Pursuant to the Court’s December 13, 2019 Uniform Order Setting Cause for Jury Trial,
Mediation, and Pre-Trial Instructions and the Court’s September 12, 2020 Order Resetting Trial,
Mid-Continent Casualty Company submits the following Objections to Plaintiff’s Exhibit List
filed June 4, 2021:
OBJECTION KEY
Symbol Description
R Document or portions thereof are irrelevant and hence inadmissible pursuant to §§
90.401-90.402, Fla. Stat.
403 The probative value of the document, if any, is substantially outweighed by the danger
of unfair prejudice, confusion of issues, misleading the jury, or needless presentation
of cumulative evidence and is hence inadmissible pursuant to § 90.403, Fla. Stat.
H Document contains inadmissible hearsay pursuant to §§ 90.801-90.803, Fla. Stat.
E Plaintiff should be estopped from using the document
A Plaintiff has not be its burden of establishing the document is authentic
NP Not provided, as required by Northup v. Acken, 865 So. 2d 1267 (Fla. 2004)
CA Improper catch-all
0979020\308479236.v1
Exhibit Objection
Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit
Mid-Continent Casualty Company’s Insurance Policy
issued to Flicker Construction
1 Effective: 03/12/10 through 03/12/11
Bates: Doc.1-9
Permit Application and Permit (Flicker Construction)
2 Date: 02/24/10
Bates: MBD-001-02
Permit Application and Permit (Taylor Plumbing & R, 403, H (as to MBD-103)
Remodeling, Inc)
3 Date: 03/25/10
Bates: MBD-103-04
Permit Application and Permit (Taylor Plumbing & R, 403, H (as to MBD-106)
Remodeling, Inc)
4 Date: 03/25/10
Bates: MBD-106-07
Permit Application and Permit (M&D Electrical R, 403, H (as to MBD-109)
Service, Inc)
5 Date: 04/22/10
Bates: MBD-109-10
Permit Application and Permit (Alfresco Air, Inc.) R, 403, H (as to MBD-112)
6 Date: 05/04/10
Bates: MBD-112-13
Permit Application and Permit (NY Electrical) R, 403, H (as to MBD-129)
7 Date: 05/28/10
Bates: MBD-129-30
Permit Application and Permit (Security Fire R, 403, H (as to MBD-132)
Prevention)
8 Date: 06/14/10
Bates: MBD-132-33
Security Fire Prevention, Inc. File R, 403, H (as to SPF 1 and
9 Date: Various 3)
Bates: SFP1-4
Permit Application and Permit (Lucto Fire Sprinkler R, 403, H (as to MBD-139)
Corp)
10 Date: 08/02/10
Bates: MBD-139-40
Permit Application and Permit (Lucto Fire Sprinkler R, 403, H
Corp)
11 Date: 08/16/10
Bates: MBD-152-53
0979020\308479236.v1
Exhibit Objection
Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit
Lutco Fire Sprinkler Corporation File R, 403, H
12 Date: Various
Bates: LFS1-9
Permit Application and Permit (Siemens Building R, 403, H (as to MBD-156)
13 Technologies, Inc) Date: 10/01/10
Bates: MBD-156-57
Siemens Building Technology File R, 403, H
14 Date: Various
Bates: SIE1-11
Universal Hood Tech, Inc. File R, 403, H (as to UH 004,
15 Date: Various UH 005, UH 008-UH 013)
Bates: UH1-14
Fire Penetration Affidavit
16 Date: 01/18/11
Bates: MBD-003
Certification Request Form and Building Certificate R, 403, H (as to MBD-163)
Date: 01/24/11 (typographical error on document stating
17 01/24/10)
Bates: MBD-162-63
Complaint from the underlying Perea v. Flicker R, 403, H, E
18 Construction lawsuit
Date: 11/03/10
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC and Envelope R, 403, H, E
19 Date: 07/15/11
Bates: MCC 000001-3
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC with R, 403, H, E
attachment and Envelope
20 Date: 07/19/11
Bates: MCC 000111-14
Email between Michael Moore and Roman Flicker R, 403, H, E
21 Date: 07/21/11
Bates: MCC 000004
Email between Michael Moore and H. Joshua Diamond R, 403, H, E
22 Date: 07/21/11
Bates: MCC 000005 and Diamond-439
Email Chains between Michael Moore and H. Joshua R, 403, H, E
Diamond
23 Date: 07/22/11
Bates: MCC 000007-110
0979020\308479236.v1
Exhibit Objection
Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit
Letter from MCC to Flicker Construction and Envelope R, 403, H, E
24 Date: 07/27/11
Bates: MCC 000143-49
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC R, 403, H, E
25 Date: 08/01/11
Bates: MCC 000137-42
Letter from MCC to Flicker Construction and Envelope R, 403, H, E
26 Date: 08/01/11
Bates: MCC 000150-56
Letter from MCC to Manuel Perea R, 403, H, E
27 Date: 08/10/11
Bates: Diamond-427-32
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC R, 403, H, E
28 Date: 08/17/11
Bates: MCC 000157-58
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC R, 403, H, E
29 Date: 08/29/11
Bates: MCC 000166-68 and 169-171
Letter from MCC to Roman Flicker and Envelope R, 403, H, E
30 Date: 09/01/11
Bates: MCC 000179-85
Letter from MCC to H. Joshua Diamond R, 403, H, E
Date: 09/01/11
31 Bates: Diamond-476
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC and Envelope R, 403, H, E
32 Date: 12/03/12
Bates: MCC 000186–90
Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC and Envelope R, 403, H, E
33 Date: 03/06/13
Bates: MCC 000191-95
Verdict in the Perea v. Flicker Construction lawsuit R, 403, H, E
34 Date: 06/25/13
Bates: Diamond-064
Final Judgment against Flicker Construction in the R, 403, H, E
Perea v. Flicker Construction lawsuit
35 Date: 07/10/13
Bates: Diamond-053
0979020\308479236.v1
Exhibit Objection
Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit
Order Granting Taxable Costs in the Perea v. Flicker R, 403, H, E
Construction lawsuit
36 Date: 07/18/13
Bates: Diamond-052
Order Appointing Receiver R, 403, H, E
37 Date: 02/11/15
Bates: Diamond-004-06
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that on June 30, 2021, the foregoing was filed via the Florida Courts eFiling
Portal which generates a copy to all counsel of record.
Respectfully submitted,
s/ Edward T. Sylvester
Edward T. Sylvester
Florida Bar No. 0051612
2525 Ponce de Leon Boulevard, 4th Floor
Coral Gables, Florida 33134
Telephone: 305-358-7747
Facsimile: 305-577-1063
esylvester@hinshawlaw.com
lleon@hinshawlaw.com;
Counsel for Mid-Continent Cas. Co.
0979020\308479236.v1
Preview
Filing # 129860175 E-Filed 06/30/2021 07:02:48 PM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA CIVIL DIVISION JOHN HUGHES, III, as receiver of Flicker Construction, Inc., an inactive Florida corporation, CASE NO. 2019-CA-003916 Plaintiff, vs. ROMAN FLICKER and MID-CONTINENT CASUALTY COMPANY, Defendants. / MID-CONTINENT CASUALTY COMPANY’S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT LIST Pursuant to the Court’s December 13, 2019 Uniform Order Setting Cause for Jury Trial, Mediation, and Pre-Trial Instructions and the Court’s September 12, 2020 Order Resetting Trial, Mid-Continent Casualty Company submits the following Objections to Plaintiff’s Exhibit List filed June 4, 2021: OBJECTION KEY Symbol Description R Document or portions thereof are irrelevant and hence inadmissible pursuant to §§ 90.401-90.402, Fla. Stat. 403 The probative value of the document, if any, is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of issues, misleading the jury, or needless presentation of cumulative evidence and is hence inadmissible pursuant to § 90.403, Fla. Stat. H Document contains inadmissible hearsay pursuant to §§ 90.801-90.803, Fla. Stat. E Plaintiff should be estopped from using the document A Plaintiff has not be its burden of establishing the document is authentic NP Not provided, as required by Northup v. Acken, 865 So. 2d 1267 (Fla. 2004) CA Improper catch-all 0979020\308479236.v1 Exhibit Objection Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit Mid-Continent Casualty Company’s Insurance Policy issued to Flicker Construction 1 Effective: 03/12/10 through 03/12/11 Bates: Doc.1-9 Permit Application and Permit (Flicker Construction) 2 Date: 02/24/10 Bates: MBD-001-02 Permit Application and Permit (Taylor Plumbing & R, 403, H (as to MBD-103) Remodeling, Inc) 3 Date: 03/25/10 Bates: MBD-103-04 Permit Application and Permit (Taylor Plumbing & R, 403, H (as to MBD-106) Remodeling, Inc) 4 Date: 03/25/10 Bates: MBD-106-07 Permit Application and Permit (M&D Electrical R, 403, H (as to MBD-109) Service, Inc) 5 Date: 04/22/10 Bates: MBD-109-10 Permit Application and Permit (Alfresco Air, Inc.) R, 403, H (as to MBD-112) 6 Date: 05/04/10 Bates: MBD-112-13 Permit Application and Permit (NY Electrical) R, 403, H (as to MBD-129) 7 Date: 05/28/10 Bates: MBD-129-30 Permit Application and Permit (Security Fire R, 403, H (as to MBD-132) Prevention) 8 Date: 06/14/10 Bates: MBD-132-33 Security Fire Prevention, Inc. File R, 403, H (as to SPF 1 and 9 Date: Various 3) Bates: SFP1-4 Permit Application and Permit (Lucto Fire Sprinkler R, 403, H (as to MBD-139) Corp) 10 Date: 08/02/10 Bates: MBD-139-40 Permit Application and Permit (Lucto Fire Sprinkler R, 403, H Corp) 11 Date: 08/16/10 Bates: MBD-152-53 0979020\308479236.v1 Exhibit Objection Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit Lutco Fire Sprinkler Corporation File R, 403, H 12 Date: Various Bates: LFS1-9 Permit Application and Permit (Siemens Building R, 403, H (as to MBD-156) 13 Technologies, Inc) Date: 10/01/10 Bates: MBD-156-57 Siemens Building Technology File R, 403, H 14 Date: Various Bates: SIE1-11 Universal Hood Tech, Inc. File R, 403, H (as to UH 004, 15 Date: Various UH 005, UH 008-UH 013) Bates: UH1-14 Fire Penetration Affidavit 16 Date: 01/18/11 Bates: MBD-003 Certification Request Form and Building Certificate R, 403, H (as to MBD-163) Date: 01/24/11 (typographical error on document stating 17 01/24/10) Bates: MBD-162-63 Complaint from the underlying Perea v. Flicker R, 403, H, E 18 Construction lawsuit Date: 11/03/10 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC and Envelope R, 403, H, E 19 Date: 07/15/11 Bates: MCC 000001-3 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC with R, 403, H, E attachment and Envelope 20 Date: 07/19/11 Bates: MCC 000111-14 Email between Michael Moore and Roman Flicker R, 403, H, E 21 Date: 07/21/11 Bates: MCC 000004 Email between Michael Moore and H. Joshua Diamond R, 403, H, E 22 Date: 07/21/11 Bates: MCC 000005 and Diamond-439 Email Chains between Michael Moore and H. Joshua R, 403, H, E Diamond 23 Date: 07/22/11 Bates: MCC 000007-110 0979020\308479236.v1 Exhibit Objection Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit Letter from MCC to Flicker Construction and Envelope R, 403, H, E 24 Date: 07/27/11 Bates: MCC 000143-49 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC R, 403, H, E 25 Date: 08/01/11 Bates: MCC 000137-42 Letter from MCC to Flicker Construction and Envelope R, 403, H, E 26 Date: 08/01/11 Bates: MCC 000150-56 Letter from MCC to Manuel Perea R, 403, H, E 27 Date: 08/10/11 Bates: Diamond-427-32 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC R, 403, H, E 28 Date: 08/17/11 Bates: MCC 000157-58 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC R, 403, H, E 29 Date: 08/29/11 Bates: MCC 000166-68 and 169-171 Letter from MCC to Roman Flicker and Envelope R, 403, H, E 30 Date: 09/01/11 Bates: MCC 000179-85 Letter from MCC to H. Joshua Diamond R, 403, H, E Date: 09/01/11 31 Bates: Diamond-476 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC and Envelope R, 403, H, E 32 Date: 12/03/12 Bates: MCC 000186–90 Letter from H. Joshua Diamond to MCC and Envelope R, 403, H, E 33 Date: 03/06/13 Bates: MCC 000191-95 Verdict in the Perea v. Flicker Construction lawsuit R, 403, H, E 34 Date: 06/25/13 Bates: Diamond-064 Final Judgment against Flicker Construction in the R, 403, H, E Perea v. Flicker Construction lawsuit 35 Date: 07/10/13 Bates: Diamond-053 0979020\308479236.v1 Exhibit Objection Number Description of Plaintiff’s Exhibit Order Granting Taxable Costs in the Perea v. Flicker R, 403, H, E Construction lawsuit 36 Date: 07/18/13 Bates: Diamond-052 Order Appointing Receiver R, 403, H, E 37 Date: 02/11/15 Bates: Diamond-004-06 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I certify that on June 30, 2021, the foregoing was filed via the Florida Courts eFiling Portal which generates a copy to all counsel of record. Respectfully submitted, s/ Edward T. Sylvester Edward T. Sylvester Florida Bar No. 0051612 2525 Ponce de Leon Boulevard, 4th Floor Coral Gables, Florida 33134 Telephone: 305-358-7747 Facsimile: 305-577-1063 esylvester@hinshawlaw.com lleon@hinshawlaw.com; Counsel for Mid-Continent Cas. Co. 0979020\308479236.v1