Preview
Filing# 147043600 E-Filed 04/05/2022 09:41:19 AM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT,
IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO.: CACE21016237
DIVISION: 23
JUDGE: Phillips,Carol-Lisa (25)
Patricia Jenkins
Plaintiff(s)
/ Petitioner(s)
UNIFORM TRIAL ORDER
Seventeenth Judicial Circuit
ORDER FOR MANDATORY
CALENDAR CALL
V
Columna Inc
Defendant(s)/ Respondent (s).
i
UNIFORM TRIAL ORDER
THE UNIFORM TRIAL DATE LISTED HEREIN IS A FIRM TRIAL DATE AND DEADLINES
WILL BE STRICTLY ENFORCED BY THE COURT. STRICT COMPLIANCE MEANS NO
CONTINUANCES OR EXTENSIONS WILL BE GRANTED WITHOUT COURT ORDER UPON
WRITTEN MOTION SETTING FORTH GOOD CAUSE, PURSUANT TO AOSC20-23,
AMENDMENT 13 (May 6,2021), AND FLA. R. GEN. PRAC. & JUD. ADMIN. 2.545(e).
FAILURE TO ATTEND CALENDAR CALL MAY RESULT IN EITHER THIS CASE
BEING DISMISSED OR A DEFAULT BEING ENTERED.
TRIAL PERIOD COMMENCING: 09-06-2022 to 09-30-2022. This is a(4 )week
calendar.
CALENDAR CALL:
09-01-2022 at 10:00 AM
[1]
DAYS
[]
JURY
[X ]
NON-JURY
Page 1 of 7
*** FILED: BROWARD COUNTY, FL BRENDA D. FORMAN, CLERK 04/05/2022 09:41:19 AM.****
Case Number: CACE21016237
I. ORDER OF TRIALS:
The order of trials set duringthis Trial Period will be determined at Calendar Call. Parties are
subjectto being called to commence trial duringany portionof the above noted Trial Period.
II. TRIAL DATE:
The Court has determined this case is ready for trial pursuant to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure
1.440. This case is set for trial before the undersigned Judge in Courtroom
15175 or Zoom:
https://17thlkourts.zoom.us/j/975531891
Broward
,
County Courthouse, 201 S.E. 6th Street,
Fort Lauderdale, Florida,33301, as stated above. The trial date is a firm trial date pursuant to
AOSC20-23, Amendment 13 (May 6, 2021).
III. CIVIL TRIAL POOL:
Parties are advised that this case may be placedinto the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Court's
"Civil Trial Pool" and is subjectto being called for trial before any judge. If placedin the Civil
Trial Pool, parties must be prepared to proceed to trial if called. Only the Division Judge or
the Administrative Judge of the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Court's Civil Division may grant a
continuance of any case placedin the Civil Trial Pool.
IV. WITNESS LISTS:
A. NO LATER THAN ONE HUNDRED & TWENTY (120) DAYS PRIOR TO
CALENDAR CALL:
Fact Witnesses: Parties must file and serve a list of names and addresses of all fact witnesses
who are expectedto testifyat trial. Each party'sfact witness listmust include a brief
description
ofthe substance and scope ofthe testimonyto be elicited from such witness.
Both sides must cooperate in the schedulingof such witness depositions.
B. NO LATER THAN NINETY (90)DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
Expert Witnesses:
i. At the time of disclosure of all expert witnesses,the partiesshall file and serve
the names and addresses of all expert witnesses to be called at trial,
including
their complete and updated curriculum vitae,and all information regarding
expert testimony that is requiredby Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.28(b)(5).
Parties shall
furnish opposing counsel with two (2)alternative dates of availability
of all
expert witnesses for the purpose of takingtheir deposition.
Both partiesshall
cooperate in the schedulingof expert depositions.
ii. The partiesshall also provide answers to standard form expert interrogatories
pursuant to Fla.R.Civ.P. 1.280(b)(5).
All reports or other data compiled by each
disclosed expert which is intended to be used by the expert and/or referred to
duringhis/her depositiontestimonyshall be provided electronically
to the
opposing party at least 72 hours priorto the date of the scheduled deposition.
C. NO LATER THAN SIXTY (60)DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
Page 2 of 7
Case Number: CACE21016237
Rebuttal Witnesses: Parties must file and serve a list of names and addresses of any rebuttal
witnesses within sixty(60)days.
V. COMPULSORY MEDICAL EVALUATIONS rG?
('CME"):
A. NO LATER THAN NINETY (90)DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
All CME and other examinations pursuant to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.360 must be
completed no later than ninety (90) days priorto Calendar Call.
VI. DISCOVERY DEADLINES:
A. NO LATER THAN SIXTY-FIVE (65)DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
All final discoverymust have been initiated at least sixty-five
(65)days priorto Calendar
Call.
B. NO LATER THAN THIRTY (30) DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
Parties must complete all discovery,includingexpert discoveryin accordance with Florida
Rule of Civil Procedure 1.280(b)(5),
at least thirty(30)days priorto Calendar Call.
Discovery conducted after this time periodis stronglydisfavored and will only be permitted
by order of the Court under exceptionalcircumstances.
C. ELECTRONICALLY STORED INFORMATION (ESI) DISCOVERY: ESI discovery
proceduresare governed by Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Administrative Order 2021-20-
Gen, a copy of which is available on the Circuit's webpage (www. 17th.flcourts.org).
VII. MOTIONS:
A. NO LATER THAN SEVENTY-FIVE (75) DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
1.
Motions to add a party or partiesor to amend pleadingsshall be filed and set for hearing
no later than seventy-five(75)days before Calendar Call absent good cause shown. The
deadline shall not conflict with Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.190(e),and the motion
may be denied if there has been undue delay,bad faith,prejudiceto the opposing side,
dilatorymotive on the part of the moving party or when the amendment would be futile.
B. NO LATER THAN FORTY-FIVE (45) DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
1. DispositiveMotions : must be filed and heard no later than forty-five
(45)days before
Calendar Call.
2. DepositionObjections:objectionsraised in depositionsexpectedto be introduced at trial
must be filed and heard no later than forty-five
(45)days before Calendar Call. ..,
3. Expert Challenges: motions challengingan expert witness ("ExpertChallenges"),must
be filed and heard no later than forty-five
(45)days before Calendar Call.
C. NO LATER THAN THIRTY (30)DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
1. Motions in Limine : must be filed and heard no later than thirty(30)days priorto
Calendar Call.
2. All motions, other than motions in limine,not heard before Calendar Call will be
deemed abandoned.
D. PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
1. Motions for Summary Judgment
: must be filed and heard priorto Calendar Call.
Motions for summary judgment will not be heard at Calendar Call.
VIII. JOINT PRETRIAL STIPULATION:
A. NO LATER THAN TEN (10)DAYS PRIOR TO CALENDAR CALL:
1. The Joint Pretrial Stipulation
contemplatesa singledocument that must be filed and
served,with a courtesy copy served on the undersigned judge
no later than ten
,
(10)
Page 3 of 7
Case Number: CACE21016237
days priorto Calendar Call.
2. The Joint Pretrial Stipulation
requiresthat all agreed matters be fullyidentified and any
disputedmatters be specifically
delineated with respect to each party.
3. At the time of the above noticed Calendar Call,all partiesmust be preparedto discuss all
items set forth in Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.200(b).
B. The Joint Pretrial Stipulation must contain the following in separately numbered
paragraphs:
1. Statement ofthe Facts: A concise,impartialstatement ofthe facts ofthe case.
2. StipulatedFacts: A list of those facts that can be stipulated
and requireno proof at trial.
3. Statement of DisputedLaw & Fact A concise,impartial
statement of those issues o f law
and fact that are to be tried.
4. Exhibit Lists: Each party must separatelylist all exhibits they intend to introduce into
evidence. Each item must be listed by number and descriptionon a separate schedule
attached to the Joint Pretrial Stipulation.Each exhibit must be specifically
described. Generic descriptionsof exhibits are subjectto being stricken. If any party
objectsto the introduction of any such exhibit,such objection
must be stated in the
Joint Pretrial Stipulation,settingforth the grounds with specificity.
All exhibits must
have been made available to all partiesfor examination. Parties must initial each other's
exhibit lists and exhibits.
At trial,only those exhibits properly listed and initialed
may be offered into evidence.
5. Demonstrative Exhibits: all demonstrative exhibits (e.g.,
charts,graphs,enlargementsof
exhibits,etc.)intended to be used at a jurytrial must be displayedto all partiesat least
ten (10) days before trial.
6. Witness Lists: Parties must furnish a written list containingthe names and addresses of
all witnesses intended to be called at trial in alphabetical
order. Such list must designate
the type of witness ("expert,"
"rebuttal,""impeachment," or otherwise)and must be
attached to the Joint Pretrial Stipulation.All fact witness lists must include a brief
descriptionof the substance and scope of the testimony
to be elicited from such
witness. All expert witness lists must designate the expert's specialties If
.
any party
objectsto any witness,such objectionmust be stated in the Joint Pretrial Stipulation,
settingforth the grounds with specificity.
At trial,only those witnesses properly and
timely disclosed will be permitted to testify.
7. Jury Instructions : Ifthe trial is a jurytrial,
the partiesmust identifyall agreedupon
standard instructions and all specialinstructions. Copies of all agreed upon jury
instructions and disputedjury instructions must be attached to the Joint Pretrial
Stipulation
identifying
the party that proposed the instruction,along with copiesof
supportingstatutory citations and/or case law.
8. Verdict Forms : If the trial is a jurytrial,
the jury verdict form must be designatedas
"agreed to" or "disputed"and must be attached to the Joint Pretrial Stipulation.
9. Peremptory Challenges:If the trial is a jury trial,
the number ofperemptory challenges
for each party must be stated and attached to the Joint Pretrial Stipulation.
10. Pending Motions : Parties must set forth a listof all pending motions with copies
attached to the Joint Pretrial Stipulation.
11. Trial Estimate: Each party must provide an estimate of the number of trial days required
for presentingits side of the case.
12. Expert Challenges : All expert related issues involvingany requests for hearingson
related evidence must be noticed and heard-or agreedto by the parties-no later than
forty-five
(45)days priorto Calendar Call. FAILURE TO DO SO MAY CONSTITUTE
Page 4 of 7
Case Number: CACE21016237
A WAIVER OF ANY EXPERT RELATED EVIDENCE ISSUE(S). It is within the
discretion of the Court to remove any case with pending expert issues.
IX. COURT POLICIES:
A. Parties must do all thingsreasonable and necessary to assure the availability
of witnesses for
the entire Trial Period or to otherwise preserve witness testimony for trial as provided by the
Florida Rules of Civil Procedure.
See Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.300 & 1.460; see also Fla. R. Gen.
Prac. & Jud. Admin. 2.545.
B. The requirementsof this Uniform Trial Order cannot be waived by stipulationabsent prior
approval from the Court pursuant to written agreement between the parties.
C. This Uniform Trial Order may be tailored by the assignedDivision Judge to conform to the
particular
requirements ofthe residential foreclosure and complex litigation
divisions.
D. At trial,there will only be one (1)official record transcribed by one (1)court reporter.
Plaintiff is responsiblefor arrangingfor a court reporter unless otherwise agreed.If a
conflict exists,the partiesmust resolve it among themselves priorto Calendar Call.
X. CONTINUANCES:
No continuances will be granted without Court Order upon written motion settingforth
good cause pursuant to AOSC20-23, Amendment 13 (May 6, 2021), and Fla. R. Gen. Prac.
& Jud. Admin. 2.545(e).All motions seeking a continuance must comply with Fla. R. Civ.
P.1.460 and Fla. R. Gen. Prac. & Jud. Adm. 2.545. Continuances requested for reasons
relatingto failure to follow this Order will not be granted.
A. CONTINUANCES will only be considered upon written motion filed with the Clerk of
Court and served on the undersignedjudge priorto the above noticed Calendar Call.
B. NO CONTINUANCES will be grantedfor reasons that should have been readily
apparent to the parties
when this Uniform Trial Order was issued.
C. NO CONTINUANCES will be grantedif expert witnesses are unavailable because
testimony may be preservedby deposition.
D. NO CONTINUANCES will be granted for reasons relatingto the failure to follow this
Uniform Trial Order.
XI. MANDATORY MEDIATION:
Mediation must commence no later than sixty(60)days priorto Calendar Call. The parties
must comply with Florida Rules of Civil Procedure 1.700, 1.710, 1.720, and 1.730 as to the
conduct of mediation. Plaintiff's counsel is appointedlead counsel to facilitate and schedule the
settlement conference with the mediator and all parties.The Court appoints:
WHOMEVER THE PARTIES AGREE UPON
as Mediator, unless,within thirty(30)days of this Uniform Trial Order, the partieschoose a
different Mediator, and file notice of that choice and the name of the substitute mediator with
the Clerk of Court. Failure to attend mediation may result in sanctions.
XII. SANCTIONS:
A. All partiesshould be familiar with Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.380 entitled "Failure to
Make Discovery;Sanctions" and section 57.105, Florida Statutes,entitled "Attorney's fee;
sanctions for raisingunsupportedclaims or defenses;exceptions;service ofmotions;
Page 5 of 7
Case Number: CACE21016237
..
damages for delay of litigation.'
B. FAILURE TO APPEAR, FAILURE TO FOLLOW TIME REQUIREMENTS, OR
FAILURE TO FILE DOCUMENTS REQUIRED BY THIS COURT MAY RESULT IN
THE DISMISSAL OF THE ACTION OR THE IMPOSITION OF SANCTIONS
INCLUDING THE STRIKING OF PLEADINGS.
XIII. SETTLEMENT NOTIFICATION:
Parties must immediately notifythe Court in the event of settlement and submit a stipulation
for
an Order of Dismissal. Parties shall also cancel any and all pending hearingsas a result of the
settlement.
Pursuant to Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.516(h)(1),counsel
must file this Uniform Trial Order with the Clerk of Court, serve any self-representedparties
with this Uniform Trial Order, and file a "Certificate of Service" with the Clerk of Court, in
compliance with Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.516(f),
certifyingthe self-representedparty was served with this Uniform Trial Order.
DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida on 04-04-
2022.
-,3:49 Plv[
CACE21016237 04-04-2022 3:49 PM
Circuit Court Judge
If you are a person with a disabilitywho needs any accommodation in order to
participatein this proceeding, you are entitled,at no cost to you, to the provision
of certain assistance. Please contact the ADA Coordinator, Room 20140, 201
S.E. Sixth Street,Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301, 954-831-7721 at least 7 days
before your scheduled court appearance, or immediately upon receivingthis
notification if the time before the scheduled appearance is less than 7 days. If
you have a hearing or voice disabilityyou can contact the court through the
Florida Relay Service by calling711.
Page 6 of 7
Case Number: CACE21016237
CC
Mark J Miller, Email: Mark@millerandjacobs.com
Mark J Miller, Email: Litigation@millerandjacobs.com
Mark J Miller, Email: hr@millerandjacobs.com
Sanford R Topkin, Email : stopkin@topkinlaw.com
Sanford R Topkin, Email : epopper@topkinlaw.com
Sanford R Topkin, Email : chansen@topkinlaw.com
Page 7 of 7