On January 20, 2021 a
Proof of Service
was filed
involving a dispute between
Jane Doe,
and
Abigail Mensah N.P.,
Meera Shah M.D.,
Planned Parenthood Hudson Peconic, Inc.,
A New York Corporation, D B A Planned Parenthood Spring Valley Health Center, And Planned Parenhood White Plains Health Center,
for Torts - Medical, Dental, or Podiatrist Malpractice
in the District Court of Kings County.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/10/2021 04:47 PM03: 52: 51 p.m. INDEX
02-10-2021 NO. 501531/2021
1 12
15162219200 INTERBORO ATTORNY'S
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 11 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/10/2021
OF NEW YORK INDEX #: 501531/2021
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE
COUNTY OF KINGS
Date Filed: 01/2D/202.1
Attorneys: Company: RUTA 80UL!os & STRATIS LLP PH: 212-997-45D0
Address: 211 EAST43RD STREET NEW YORK, NY 10017
Client's File No: HON. ELLEN M.
SPODEY
JANE DOE
ys Plainmi
MEERA SHAH, M D., ET AL
Derendent
STATE OF NEW YORK ROCKLAND OF SERVICE
, COUNTY OF __.. SS.: AFFIDAVIT
FORREST GREEN , being duly sworn deposes and says:
Dci-ss:;- 1/29/2021 11:25 AM
is not a party herein, is over 18 years of age. On at
25 PERLMAN DR, SPRING VAt.LEY NY 10977 .
at . , deponent served the within
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE/AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT/MEMO OF LAW
on: PLANNED PARENTHOOD HUDSON PECONIC, INC., a New York Corgentice, , therein named.
#1 INDIVIDUAL By adisadñg a true copy of each to said recipient persañally; depenst knew the person served to be the person
O described as said person therein.
#2 CORPORATION By dalivadñg thereat a true copy of each to Stephanie Gonzalez . and that depcnañl knew
the person so served to be the Asdhnrivari Agent/ Manar'ar of the corporation, and authorized to
to accept service on behalf of the corporation.
#3 SUITABLE By de!!varing a true copy of each to __ a person of suitable age and discretion.
AGE PERSON Said premises is recipient's [ ] actual place of business [ ] dwelling house (usual place of abode) within the state.
#4 AFFlXING By affixing a true copy of each to the door of said premises, which is racipinnt's: [ l actual place of business
TO DOOR
[ ] dwelling house (place of abode) within the state.
O
Depeñëñt was unable, with due dilipñre to find is cipisñt or a person of suitable age and discration, having called
therest on the day of at
on the day of . at
on the day of at
on the day of at
#5 MAIL COPY On , depenent completedservice under the last two sections by depositing a copy of the
to the above address in a 1st Class
Confidential"
psepaM pro e I eddressed envelope marked "Personal and in an official depository under the exclusive
care and cus of the United States Post office in the State of
O and by Certified Mait #
#6 NON-SRVC After due search, careful inquiry and diligerit attempts, I have beenunable to effect process upon the person/entity
being served because of the fe!!owing: [ ] Unknnwn at Address I ] Evading [ ] Moved left no forwarding
[ ] Address does not exist [ ] Other
-
#7 DEsciiiPTicii A descri tion of the Defendant, or other erson served, or spo en to on behalf of t Dsfêñdsrit is as follow
Sex: F ALE Color of skin: WH1 E Color of hair B CK Age: Height:
2" *
Weight: _ 130 I RR Other Features:
#8 WIT ES SubpoenaFee Tendered in the amount of
#9 MILITARYSRVC Deponent asked person spoken to whether the recipient was presently in military service of the United States or of the State
of and was informed that recipient was not. Recipient wore ordinary civilian clothes and no rnil tary u
#10 OTHER
O
Sworn to before me on
FORREST RE
MICHELLE GENTILE
STATEOFNEWYORK.COUNTYOF ROCKL Notary Public. State of New York
No. 04GE6340565
tÛ Lý/Ct o Qualified in Rockland County s
Commission Expires April 18, 20_
NO Y PUBO.
1 of 2
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/10/2021 04:47 PM03:53:31 p.m. INDEX
02-10-2021 NO. 501531/2021
2 /2
15162219200 INTERBORO ATTORNY'S
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 11 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK INDEX#; 501531/2021
COUNTY OF KINGS
Att=-c.-ya; Company: RUTASOULIOS & STRATIS LLP PH: 212-997-4500 Date Filed: D1/2D/2021
Address:211 EAST43RD STREETNEWYORK, NY10017
Cilent's File No.:
JANE DOE
vs Plaintiff
MEERA SHAH, M D., ET AL
Defendant
STATE OF NEW YORK _ , COUNTY OF ROCKLAND SS.: AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
FORREST GREEN , being duly sworn deposes and says:
. . 1/29/2021 11:25 AM
Depañêñt is not a party herem, is over 18 years of age. On .. at
25 PERLMAN DRIVE, SPRING VALLEY NY 10977
deponent served the within
SUMMONS & VERIFIED COMPLAINT/ELECTRONIC FILING NOTICE/lNDEX# & DATE FILED
on: PLANNED PARENTHOOD HUDSON PECONIC, INC., a New York Corporation, , therein narned.
#1 INDIVIDUAL By dé|Nedñg a true copy of each to said recipient pâisanally; dapañant knew the person served to be the person
described as said person therein.
#2 CORPORATlDN By ±‰,‡.5 thereat a true copy of each to STEPHANIE GONZALEZ and that deponent knew
the person so served to be the AUTHORIZED AGENT/ MANAGER of the corporation, and authorized to
to accept service on behalf of the corporation.
#3 SUITABLE By delivering a true copy of each to . a person of suitable age and discretion.
AGE PERSON Said premises is recipient's [ ] actual place of Lüûrms [ ] dwelling house (usual place of abode) within the state.
O
#4 AFFlXING By affixing a true copy of each to the door of said premises, which is racipisñrs: [ ] actual place of business
TO DOOR
[ ] dwelling house (place of abode) within the state.
O
Depansñt was unable, with due diligence to find recipient or a person of suitable age and discretion, having called
thereat on the day of at
on the day of ___ at
on the day of at
on the , day of at--
//5 MAIL COPY On , de ponent completed
service under the last two sections by depositing a copy of the
to the above address in a 1st Class
Confidential"
postpaid properly addressed envelope marked "Persüüal and in an official depc:2tory under the exclusiva
care and custod of the United States Post Office in the State of
O and by Certified Mali# .
#6 NON.SRVC After due search, careful inquiry and diligent attempts, I have been unable to effect process upon the pemen/=aiti
being served because of the fe!!ewing: [ ] Unknown at Address [ ] Evading { ] Moved left no forwarding
[ ] Address does not exist [ ] Other
#7DESC (PTION A descr f he Defendant, or erson served, or spo n behalf of th efsñdst is as follows: 5'7"
Sex: Color of skin: Color of hair Age: Height
²ª ³l
Weight: 130 LBS Other Features:
FORREST GREEN
8 WIT ES Subpoena Fee Tendered in the amountof
#9 MlUTARYSRVC Deponent asked person spoken to whether the recipient was presently in mmtaryservice of the United States Gee===* or of the State
of and was informed that recipient was not. Recipient wore ordinary civilian clothes and no military u
#10 OTHER
Swam to before me on
P Print Narne Below Signete
STATECFNEWYGRK,COUNTYOFROCK 'D
9 cmam em SWOWT E Dia MGmS_DAY OF AffCHELLE GENTILE Job# 131634
- Notary Public, State of New York
No. 04G E6340565
o'Ts Y PUilUC Qualified in Rockland Cotmty
Commission Expires April 18, 20
2 of 2
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/10/2021 04:47 PM03: 52: 51 p.m. INDEX 02-10-2021 NO. 501531/2021 1 12 15162219200 INTERBORO ATTORNY'S NYSCEF DOC. NO. 11 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/10/2021 OF NEW YORK INDEX #: 501531/2021 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE COUNTY OF KINGS Date Filed: 01/2D/202.1 Attorneys: Company: RUTA 80UL!os & STRATIS LLP PH: 212-997-45D0 Address: 211 EAST43RD STREET NEW YORK, NY 10017 Client's File No: HON. ELLEN M. SPODEY JANE DOE ys Plainmi MEERA SHAH, M D., ET AL Derendent STATE OF NEW YORK ROCKLAND OF SERVICE , COUNTY OF __.. SS.: AFFIDAVIT FORREST GREEN , being duly sworn deposes and says: Dci-ss:;- 1/29/2021 11:25 AM is not a party herein, is over 18 years of age. On at 25 PERLMAN DR, SPRING VAt.LEY NY 10977 . at . , deponent served the within ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE/AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT/MEMO OF LAW on: PLANNED PARENTHOOD HUDSON PECONIC, INC., a New York Corgentice, , therein named. #1 INDIVIDUAL By adisadñg a true copy of each to said recipient persañally; depenst knew the person served to be the person O described as said person therein. #2 CORPORATION By dalivadñg thereat a true copy of each to Stephanie Gonzalez . and that depcnañl knew the person so served to be the Asdhnrivari Agent/ Manar'ar of the corporation, and authorized to to accept service on behalf of the corporation. #3 SUITABLE By de!!varing a true copy of each to __ a person of suitable age and discretion. AGE PERSON Said premises is recipient's [ ] actual place of business [ ] dwelling house (usual place of abode) within the state. #4 AFFlXING By affixing a true copy of each to the door of said premises, which is racipinnt's: [ l actual place of business TO DOOR [ ] dwelling house (place of abode) within the state. O Depeñëñt was unable, with due dilipñre to find is cipisñt or a person of suitable age and discration, having called therest on the day of at on the day of . at on the day of at on the day of at #5 MAIL COPY On , depenent completedservice under the last two sections by depositing a copy of the to the above address in a 1st Class Confidential" psepaM pro e I eddressed envelope marked "Personal and in an official depository under the exclusive care and cus of the United States Post office in the State of O and by Certified Mait # #6 NON-SRVC After due search, careful inquiry and diligerit attempts, I have beenunable to effect process upon the person/entity being served because of the fe!!owing: [ ] Unknnwn at Address I ] Evading [ ] Moved left no forwarding [ ] Address does not exist [ ] Other - #7 DEsciiiPTicii A descri tion of the Defendant, or other erson served, or spo en to on behalf of t Dsfêñdsrit is as follow Sex: F ALE Color of skin: WH1 E Color of hair B CK Age: Height: 2" * Weight: _ 130 I RR Other Features: #8 WIT ES SubpoenaFee Tendered in the amount of #9 MILITARYSRVC Deponent asked person spoken to whether the recipient was presently in military service of the United States or of the State of and was informed that recipient was not. Recipient wore ordinary civilian clothes and no rnil tary u #10 OTHER O Sworn to before me on FORREST RE MICHELLE GENTILE STATEOFNEWYORK.COUNTYOF ROCKL Notary Public. State of New York No. 04GE6340565 tÛ Lý/Ct o Qualified in Rockland County s Commission Expires April 18, 20_ NO Y PUBO. 1 of 2 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/10/2021 04:47 PM03:53:31 p.m. INDEX 02-10-2021 NO. 501531/2021 2 /2 15162219200 INTERBORO ATTORNY'S NYSCEF DOC. NO. 11 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/10/2021 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK INDEX#; 501531/2021 COUNTY OF KINGS Att=-c.-ya; Company: RUTASOULIOS & STRATIS LLP PH: 212-997-4500 Date Filed: D1/2D/2021 Address:211 EAST43RD STREETNEWYORK, NY10017 Cilent's File No.: JANE DOE vs Plaintiff MEERA SHAH, M D., ET AL Defendant STATE OF NEW YORK _ , COUNTY OF ROCKLAND SS.: AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FORREST GREEN , being duly sworn deposes and says: . . 1/29/2021 11:25 AM Depañêñt is not a party herem, is over 18 years of age. On .. at 25 PERLMAN DRIVE, SPRING VALLEY NY 10977 deponent served the within SUMMONS & VERIFIED COMPLAINT/ELECTRONIC FILING NOTICE/lNDEX# & DATE FILED on: PLANNED PARENTHOOD HUDSON PECONIC, INC., a New York Corporation, , therein narned. #1 INDIVIDUAL By dé|Nedñg a true copy of each to said recipient pâisanally; dapañant knew the person served to be the person described as said person therein. #2 CORPORATlDN By ±‰,‡.5 thereat a true copy of each to STEPHANIE GONZALEZ and that deponent knew the person so served to be the AUTHORIZED AGENT/ MANAGER of the corporation, and authorized to to accept service on behalf of the corporation. #3 SUITABLE By delivering a true copy of each to . a person of suitable age and discretion. AGE PERSON Said premises is recipient's [ ] actual place of Lüûrms [ ] dwelling house (usual place of abode) within the state. O #4 AFFlXING By affixing a true copy of each to the door of said premises, which is racipisñrs: [ ] actual place of business TO DOOR [ ] dwelling house (place of abode) within the state. O Depansñt was unable, with due diligence to find recipient or a person of suitable age and discretion, having called thereat on the day of at on the day of ___ at on the day of at on the , day of at-- //5 MAIL COPY On , de ponent completed service under the last two sections by depositing a copy of the to the above address in a 1st Class Confidential" postpaid properly addressed envelope marked "Persüüal and in an official depc:2tory under the exclusiva care and custod of the United States Post Office in the State of O and by Certified Mali# . #6 NON.SRVC After due search, careful inquiry and diligent attempts, I have been unable to effect process upon the pemen/=aiti being served because of the fe!!ewing: [ ] Unknown at Address [ ] Evading { ] Moved left no forwarding [ ] Address does not exist [ ] Other #7DESC (PTION A descr f he Defendant, or erson served, or spo n behalf of th efsñdst is as follows: 5'7" Sex: Color of skin: Color of hair Age: Height ²ª ³l Weight: 130 LBS Other Features: FORREST GREEN 8 WIT ES Subpoena Fee Tendered in the amountof #9 MlUTARYSRVC Deponent asked person spoken to whether the recipient was presently in mmtaryservice of the United States Gee===* or of the State of and was informed that recipient was not. Recipient wore ordinary civilian clothes and no military u #10 OTHER Swam to before me on P Print Narne Below Signete STATECFNEWYGRK,COUNTYOFROCK 'D 9 cmam em SWOWT E Dia MGmS_DAY OF AffCHELLE GENTILE Job# 131634 - Notary Public, State of New York No. 04G E6340565 o'Ts Y PUilUC Qualified in Rockland Cotmty Commission Expires April 18, 20 2 of 2