On June 21, 2019 a
Peremptory Challenge Under CCP 170.6 Filed - PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE UNDER CCP 170.6 AS TO DONALD ALVAREZ.
was filed
involving a dispute between
Harco National Insurance Company A Corporation,
and
Wall, Kelsey,
for Insurance Coverage/Subrogation
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
08 09r19 04 24PM 6198145738 2 7
1 i3mbe ly S Oberreaht CSB No 190794
Brian T Chang C SB No 274688
Z ORTON O X C K PATRICK MART 1
l0I W Broadway Suite OO
3 San Diego California 92101
SUp
RroR Cp E D
571 COUN7 OF VRT BpF CAUF
619 232 8 14 dCS1i111 C
SANBERNARD NO CN RNARpjN
I
D1ViSlpN
AUG 2
5 Attorneys for 17af ndant T T SE t UV A Lx 2019
6
ICq
D
1Y
8 SYJP X a COTJJxtt O THE STATE OF CA II OZZNIEI
g YN AND rOR THE COUN xX O S AI I B R AYtnTN
10 HARCO NATZ NAS NS NCE CASE NO CXVAS X9 8312
COMFANX a C0 7AratiOn
1 I A YI AN X S Y WAL 55
Plainti I Y Q tY C A Y E1 iC
I2
vs
1 AcCian Filed rucae 21 2QI9
KELSEY VV A Y L n indi viduial an dD S 1 Tria1 l at None Set
i4 tkurou 10
T7ept S23
15 Defendants
16
I7 TO E I ONORA T E Jdk N P VANDER FEER R SZD1 G J CxE O T TE A 0V
1 LNTITLF 1 CQURT
19 T efendant KELSEY WAL in tlae above entifled mstter hereby moves tl at the tri
l or
20 heari tg vvXuel involv s a contc sted issue of ler var ftet and wk icb as been assigned to the
21 onorable Donald Alvare Judge o the abova entitled Court be reassigaed fiom that Jt dge and
22 l a o matt rs h reinatter arising in this cas be heard or assigt ed to the Ionorable Donald
TCE S Y VVAT in this
23 A lvarez oz the ground that said udge is prejudiced ag inst the Defendant
4 action and or the 1 xz n of o o be recht YCirkpatrick MarCh Gowasel d record for
25 Defendant TC LSEY WALL Defendant IC ELS Y I iTALL daes notbelieve they cat have a faix and
2b impaxtia trial orh aring for the judicial xcex
27
28 J
PEkLEN1 TaR S C TA ENGE
Ci 1CL1ENTS160421Petemptory CbAqengc
wpd
08 0 19 04 24PM 6198145738 3 7
1 This challenge is basad oztthe matters contained herein on Code ofCivi Pxoceduxe 17Q
2 and on the supporCing Declaratipn o Brian T Chang att ched hereto rid filed herewith
3 y E p bef ndant TCE SE Y VALL prays tl at e relie herein requ sted be
4 granted
5
7 Dated August 9 2019 O txON OBERR CHT I IIt ATRxCX
MARTHA
Y
ur erl S Oberxeab t
1Q B T Chsng
t ttomeys fox D dantK S X WA
11
2
I3
I4
15
I6
I7
1
19
20
21
22
23
24
2S
26
27
28
PER MPTO tY CT AT G
G CLIEtI S16d421Fanmptary Challenge
pd
2
Document Filed Date
August 12, 2019
Case Filing Date
June 21, 2019
Category
Insurance Coverage/Subrogation
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
08 09r19 04 24PM 6198145738 2 7 1 i3mbe ly S Oberreaht CSB No 190794 Brian T Chang C SB No 274688 Z ORTON O X C K PATRICK MART 1 l0I W Broadway Suite OO 3 San Diego California 92101 SUp RroR Cp E D 571 COUN7 OF VRT BpF CAUF 619 232 8 14 dCS1i111 C SANBERNARD NO CN RNARpjN I D1ViSlpN AUG 2 5 Attorneys for 17af ndant T T SE t UV A Lx 2019 6 ICq D 1Y 8 SYJP X a COTJJxtt O THE STATE OF CA II OZZNIEI g YN AND rOR THE COUN xX O S AI I B R AYtnTN 10 HARCO NATZ NAS NS NCE CASE NO CXVAS X9 8312 COMFANX a C0 7AratiOn 1 I A YI AN X S Y WAL 55 Plainti I Y Q tY C A Y E1 iC I2 vs 1 AcCian Filed rucae 21 2QI9 KELSEY VV A Y L n indi viduial an dD S 1 Tria1 l at None Set i4 tkurou 10 T7ept S23 15 Defendants 16 I7 TO E I ONORA T E Jdk N P VANDER FEER R SZD1 G J CxE O T TE A 0V 1 LNTITLF 1 CQURT 19 T efendant KELSEY WAL in tlae above entifled mstter hereby moves tl at the tri l or 20 heari tg vvXuel involv s a contc sted issue of ler var ftet and wk icb as been assigned to the 21 onorable Donald Alvare Judge o the abova entitled Court be reassigaed fiom that Jt dge and 22 l a o matt rs h reinatter arising in this cas be heard or assigt ed to the Ionorable Donald TCE S Y VVAT in this 23 A lvarez oz the ground that said udge is prejudiced ag inst the Defendant 4 action and or the 1 xz n of o o be recht YCirkpatrick MarCh Gowasel d record for 25 Defendant TC LSEY WALL Defendant IC ELS Y I iTALL daes notbelieve they cat have a faix and 2b impaxtia trial orh aring for the judicial xcex 27 28 J PEkLEN1 TaR S C TA ENGE Ci 1CL1ENTS160421Petemptory CbAqengc wpd 08 0 19 04 24PM 6198145738 3 7 1 This challenge is basad oztthe matters contained herein on Code ofCivi Pxoceduxe 17Q 2 and on the supporCing Declaratipn o Brian T Chang att ched hereto rid filed herewith 3 y E p bef ndant TCE SE Y VALL prays tl at e relie herein requ sted be 4 granted 5 7 Dated August 9 2019 O txON OBERR CHT I IIt ATRxCX MARTHA Y ur erl S Oberxeab t 1Q B T Chsng t ttomeys fox D dantK S X WA 11 2 I3 I4 15 I6 I7 1 19 20 21 22 23 24 2S 26 27 28 PER MPTO tY CT AT G G CLIEtI S16d421Fanmptary Challenge pd 2