Your recipients will receive an email with this envelope shortly and will be able to access it on trellis. You can always see your envelopes by clicking the Inbox on the top right hand corner.
VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ -V- NABIL KOUDSI, ET AL Print
On February 24, 2016 a medical malpractice unlimited case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of San Bernardino County. Judge Donald R. Alvarez presiding.
Case Details
Case Number
Filing Date
February 24, 2016
Last Refreshed
August 30, 2023
Filing Location
San Bernardino County, CA
Filing Court House
San Bernardino
OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE
Douglas K. Mann;Category
Complaint for Medical Malpractice
Practice Area
Torts
Matter Type
Malpractice
Status
Trial Verdict
Parties
Plaintiffs
Enriquez, Vicente Guerrero
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
David H Ricks & Associates
Defendants
Koudsi M.D., Nabil
Koudsi Medical, Inc., A California Corporation
Attorneys for Defendants
Walker & Mann, Llp
Other Parties
Conv
(Conversion Event)
Case Documents
Order for Destruction of Exhibits Signed
Date: Jul 18, 2019
Notice of Destruction of Exhibits Mailed to Parties
Date: Jan 25, 2019
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: Jun 04, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 31, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 31, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 30, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 25, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 25, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 25, 2018
Miscellaneous Document Filed
Date: May 25, 2018
Declaration Filed
Date: May 01, 2018
Certificate of Assignment Received
Date: Feb 24, 2016
Notice Imaged
Date: Feb 24, 2016
Civil Case Cover Sheet Filed
Date: Feb 24, 2016
Summons Issued and Filed
Date: Feb 24, 2016Case Events
| Date | Type | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 18, 2019 | Docket Event | ORDER FOR DESTRUCTION OF EXHIBITS SIGNED ON 07/18/19 | |
| July 18, 2019 | Docket Event |
Exhibits Destroyed Pursuant to Court Order EXHIBITS DESTROYED ON 07/18/19 PURSUANT TO COURT ORDER FILED 07/18/19. |
|
| March 21, 2019 | Docket Event |
Comment: $5048.00 REPORTER FEES REIMBURSED TO THE COURT |
|
| January 25, 2019 | Docket Event | NOTICE OF DESTRUCTION OF EXHIBITS MAILED TO PARTIES | |
| September 28, 2018 | Docket Event | JURY FEES POSTED BY DEFENDANT/NABIL KOUDSI,ET AL IN THE AMOUNT OF $376.66 180928-0232-CK JTF/ 376.66 PAYMT 180928-0232-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 3189 | |
| September 06, 2018 | Docket Event | JURY FEES POSTED BY PLAINTIFF/VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ IN THE AMOUNT OF $376.66 180906-0736-CK JTF/ 376.66 PAYMT 180906-0736-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17566 | |
| July 26, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FAX FEE, POSTAGE, EVP, CONFORMED 180726-0975-VS FFS/ 0.20 FPC/ 0.49 PAYMT 180726-0975-VS TSB/ 0.02 FAX/ 11.00 PAYMT 180726-0975-VS FCP/ 0.50 PAYMT 180726-0975-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 033-0078787554 | |
| July 25, 2018 | |||
| July 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes HEARING RE: SUBMISSION OF JUDGMENT |
|
| July 25, 2018 | Docket Event | NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT FILED. | |
| July 10, 2018 | Docket Event |
Judgment on Complaint Filed JUDGMENT ON COMPLAINT (UNLIMITED) OF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ FILED JUDGMENT ON COMPLAINT (UNLIMITED) OF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ ORDERED ENTERED 07/10/18 AND AGAINST VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD PLAINTIFF, VICENTE ENRIQUEZ, TAKE NOTHING BY WAY OF HIS COMPLAINT AGAINST DEFENDANT, NABIL KOUDSI, MD. STAGE AT DISPOSITION: ENTRY OF JUDGMENT JURY VERDICT AFTER TRIAL (CIV) DISPOSITION: ENTRY OF JUDGMENT JURY VERDICT AFTER TRIAL(CIV) |
|
| July 06, 2018 | Docket Event | EXHIBITS RECEIVED FROM COURTROOM. | |
| July 06, 2018 | Docket Event |
Exhibits List Filed EXHIBIT LIST FILED. |
|
| June 28, 2018 | Docket Event | JURY FEES POSTED BY PLAINTIFF/VICENTE ENRIQUEZ IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,515.91 180628-0098-CK JTF/ 1515.91 PAYMT 180628-0098-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17333 | |
| June 28, 2018 | Docket Event | JURY FEES POSTED BY DEFENDANT/NABIL KOUDSI, ET AL IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,515.91 180628-0071-CK JTF/ 1515.91 PAYMT 180628-0071-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 2893 | |
| June 28, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FAX, EVP, COPY 180709-0053-VS FFS/ 0.20 FPC/ 0.49 PAYMT 180709-0053-VS TSB/ 0.02 FAX/ 7.00 PAYMT 180709-0053-VS FCP/ 0.50 PAYMT 180709-0053-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 01156D | |
| June 28, 2018 | Docket Event |
Reporter's Fees Paid in the Amount of: REPORTER'S FEES IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,524.00 PAID BY PLAINTIFF/VICENTE ENRIQUEZ. 180628-0106-CK CTF/ 2524.00 PAYMT 180628-0106-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17321 |
|
| June 28, 2018 | Docket Event |
Reporter's Fees Paid in the Amount of: REPORTER'S FEES IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,524.00 PAID BY DEFENDANT/NABIL KOUDSI, ET AL. 180628-0072-CK CTF/ 2524.00 PAYMT 180628-0072-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 2894 |
|
| June 25, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Jury Instructions INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY - GIVEN - FILED. |
|
| June 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Comment: (Imaged) INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY NOT GIVEN (IMAGED) |
|
| June 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Comment: (Imaged) USED VERDICT FILED (IMAGED) |
|
| June 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 14TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:02 OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: DISCUSSIONS HELD REGARDING JURY QUESTION #2 10:04 DELIBERATION CONTINUES DEFENSE EXHIBIT(S) #59 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST). - VIDEO TRANSCRIPTS OF ARAM DEMIRIJIAN, JOHN LEE, AND JAMES RHO ARE LODGED WITH THE COURT. 10:44 REPORTER MARY ANDERSON BEGINS READBACK AT 10:44 11:36 REPORTER MARY ANDERSON FINISHES READBACK AT 11:36 12:04 COURT IN RECESS. 01:30 DELIBERATION CONTINUES 02:12 JURORS NOTIFY THE COURT THEY HAVE REACHED A VERDICT. 02:40 JURORS ARE NOW PRESENT AND SEATED. VERDICT READ BY JUDICIAL ASSISTANT VERDICT DATED 06/25/18 AND SIGNED BY THE FOREPERSON. VERDICT(S) FORM FILED. RE-READING OF VERDICT(S) WAIVED 02:44 JURY POLLED. 02:48 JURORS THANKED AND EXCUSED. - COURT FINDS: JUDGMENT ON COMPLAINT (UNLIMITED) OF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ ORDERED AS FOLLOWS: JUDGMENT FOR KOUDSI MEDICAL, INC., JUDGMENT AGAINST VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ - HEARINGS: HEARING RE:SUBMISSION OF JUDGMENT SET FOR 07/25/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. DEFENSE TO PREPARE JUDGMENT AND GIVE NOTICE. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 21, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 21, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS NOT REPORTED COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 13TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:05 DELIBERATION CONTINUES 10:50 JURY QUESTION(S) #1 12:04 COURT IN RECESS. 01:20 DELIBERATION CONTINUES 03:59 JURY QUESTION(S) #2 JURY CALLS FOR COURT REPORTER READ BACK. COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/25/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 20, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 20, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS NOT REPORTED COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 12TH DAY OF TRIAL 02:05 DELIBERATION CONTINUES 04:05 COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL (JURY DELIBERATIONS) CONTINUED TO 06/21/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 19, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 19, 2018 | Docket Event |
Comment: (Imaged) PLAINTIFF'S MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT USE OF CACI 518 (IMAGED) |
|
| June 19, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD PRESENT - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 11TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:19 COURT CONVENES COUNSEL AND COURT STAFF ARE PRESENT OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: DISCUSSIONS HELD REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS 10:45 JURORS NOW PRESENT AND SEATED COURT GIVES JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 11:13 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 11:25 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT CLOSING ARGUMENTS PRESENTED BY PLAINTIFF. 11:59 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 01:46 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT CLOSING ARGUMENTS PRESENTED BY PLAINTIFF CONTINUES. 02:25 PLAINTIFF CONCLUDES CLOSING STATEMENT CLOSING ARGUMENTS PRESENTED BY DEFENSE. 03:32 DEFENSE CONCLUDES CLOSING STATEMENT JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 03:42 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT REBUTTAL BY PLAINTIFF 04:00 PLAINTIFF CONCLUDES REBUTTAL COURT GIVES JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 04:07 COURT ATTENDANT SWORN JURY ADMONISHED AND COMMENCES DELIBERATION. 04:30 COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL (JURY DELIBERATIONS) CONTINUED TO 06/20/18 AT 02:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 18, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 18, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 10TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:11 COURT CONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT DEFENSE CONTINUES CASE IN CHIEF STEPHEN WILSON IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR DEFENSE. 11:09 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 11:21 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT DEFENSE WITNESS STEPHEN WILSON RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 11:56 WITNESS STEPHEN WILSON EXCUSED. BENCH CONFERENCE HELD OFF THE RECORD. 12:02 BENCH CONFERENCE CONCLUDES-BACK ON THE RECORD DEFENSE RESTS. JURORS ADMONISHED AND RELEASED FOR THE DAY. 01:54 COURT RECONVENES COUNSEL AND COURT STAFF ARE PRESENT OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: DISCUSSIONS HELD REGARDING EXHIBITS TO BE ADMITTED , JURY INSTRUCTIONS, AND VERDICT FORM 03:24 COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/19/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. - EXHIBITS: JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE. JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 24-30, 25-1, 25-9, 27-1, 30-9, 30-11, 45, 46 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE. JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 47, 48 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE. PLAINTIFF EXHIBIT(S) 31A, 49, 50, 51, 52, 57 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE. DEFENSE EXHIBIT(S) 53, 54, 55, 56 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST). ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 15, 2018 | Docket Event |
Comment: (Imaged) DEFENDANT TRIAL BRIEF REGARDING RES IPSA LOQUITUR JURY INSTRUCTION (IMAGED) |
|
| June 14, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 14, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER REGINA VEGA;12612 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 9TH DAY OF TRIAL 11:01 COURT CONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT JURORS VIEW VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JAMES I. RHO AS WITNESS TESTIMONY. 11:59 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 01:43 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT JURORS CONTINUE VIEWING THE VIDEO DEPOSITION OF WITNESS JAMES I. RHO. 01:52 VIDEO DEPOSITION OF JAMES I. RHO CONCLUDES PLAINTIFF RESTS. DEFENSE CASE IN CHIEF LYNN CONNOLLY IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR DEFENSE. 02:34 BENCH CONFERENCE HELD OFF THE RECORD. 02:37 BENCH CONFERENCE CONCLUDES-BACK ON THE RECORD DEFENSE WITNESS LYNN CONNOLLY RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 03:41 WITNESS LYNN CONNOLLY EXCUSED. BENCH CONFERENCE HELD OFF THE RECORD. 03:44 BENCH CONFERENCE CONCLUDES-BACK ON THE RECORD JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/18/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. - EXHIBITS: JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 37, 24-30 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST). ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 13, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 13, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER REGINA VEGA;12612 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. PLAINTIFF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ PRESENT ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD PRESENT - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 8TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:15 COURT CONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTFIFF CONTINUES CASE IN CHIEF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 11:23 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 11:37 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTIFF WITNESS VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 11:57 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 01:44 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTIFF WITNESS VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 02:09 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 02:23 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTIFF WITNESS VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 02:44 WITNESS VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ EXCUSED. RICHARD RUIZ IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 04:04 WITNESS RICHARD RUIZ EXCUSED. JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/14/18 AT 10:45 IN DEPARTMENT S23. - EXHIBITS: JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 46, 31A, 27-1, 30-11, 30-9, 25-9, 35-2, 35-3 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 35-4, 35-5, 35-6, 35-7, 35-8, 35-1, 25-1 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST). ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 13, 2018 | Docket Event |
Comment: (Imaged) DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI NTC OF LODGING OF ORIGINAL DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS FOR TRIAL (IMAGED) |
|
| June 12, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 12, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER REGINA VEGA;12612 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 7TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:16 COURT CONVENES COUNSEL AND COURT STAFF ARE PRESENT OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: DISCUSSIONS REGARDING MOTION IN LIMINE NUMBER 7 10:20 COURT IN RECESS. 10:30 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTIFF CONTINUES CASE IN CHIEF PAUL BROADUS IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 11:10 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 11:19 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTIFF WITNESS PAUL BROADUS RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 12:05 WITNESS PAUL BROADUS EXCUSED. JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 01:45 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT JONATHAN ELLIS IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 02:46 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 03:09 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT PLAINTIFF WITNESS JONATHAN ELLIS RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 03:52 WITNESS JONATHAN ELLIS EXCUSED. BENCH CONFERENCE HELD OFF THE RECORD. 03:54 BENCH CONFERENCE CONCLUDES-BACK ON THE RECORD JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/13/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. - EXHIBITS: PLAINTIFF EXHIBIT(S) 58 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST). ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 11, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 11, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER REGINA VEGA;12612 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. CERTIFIED INTERPRETER IGNACIO VILLARREAL IS PRESENT TO INTERPRET SPANISH/ENGLISH FOR PLAINTIFF WITNESS. INTERPRETER'S JUDICIAL COUNCIL BADGE NUMBER 300493 HAS BEEN VALIDATED AND IDENTIFICATION HAS BEEN VERIFIED. THE INTERPRETER OATH HAS BEEN ADMINISTERED AND PLACED ON FILE WITH THE COURT. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 6TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:02 COURT CONVENES COUNSEL AND COURT STAFF ARE PRESENT OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: DISCUSSIONS REGARDING WITNESS 10:07 COURT IN RECESS. 10:11 JURORS NOW PRESENT AND SEATED PLAINTIFF CONTINUES CASE IN CHIEF ALFONSO GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 10:36 WITNESS ALFONSO GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ EXCUSED. MARIA DE JESUS FLORES HERNANDEZ IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 10:45 WITNESS MARIA DE JESUS GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ EXCUSED. JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 11:01 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT JURORS VIEW VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JOHN GUNN LEE AS WITNESS TESTIMONY. 11:59 VIDEO DEPOSITION OF JOHN GUNN LEE CONCLUDES. JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 01:45 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT JURORS VIEW VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF ARAM N. DEMIRJIAN AS WITNESS TESTIMONY. 03:02 VIDEO DEPOSITION OF ARAM N. DEMIRJIAN CONCLUDES. JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. 03:23 COURT RECONVENES ALL NECESSARY PARTIES ARE PRESENT MARIA ISABEL BARRIOS IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 03:43 WITNESS MARIA ISABEL BARRIOS EXCUSED. BENCH CONFERENCE HELD OFF THE RECORD. 03:45 BENCH CONFERENCE CONCLUDES-BACK ON THE RECORD JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 06/12/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. - EXHIBITS: PLAINTIFF EXHIBIT(S) 57 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST). ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 11, 2018 | Docket Event |
Comment: (Imaged) PLTF'S MEMO OF P & A'S IN OPPO TO MTN IN LIMINE NUMBER 7 (IMAGED) |
|
| June 07, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 07, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: LUANN GEESINK COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID H. RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas K\. Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD PRESENT - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 10:13 COURT CONVENES WITH COUNSEL, DEFENDANT AND JURY PRESENT. WITNESS -- NABIL KOUDSI (776) IS SWORN AND EXAMINED. JOINT EXHIBIT(S) #9-PERIOPERATIVE RECORD DATED 12/26/14 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. 11:12 COURT IN RECESS. 11:32 COURT RECONVENES WITH COUNSEL/DEFENDANT PRESENT - JURY NOT PRESENT. DISCUSSIONS HELD REGARDING VIDEO TAPED DEPOSITION TESTIMONY. 11:34 JURY NOW PRESENT. TESTIMONY OF NABIL KOUDSI RESUMES. 11:53 JURY ADMONISHED AND EXCUSED FOR NOON RECESS. COURT IN RECESS. 01:39 COURT RECONVENES WITH COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT PRESENT - JURY NOT PRESENT. COURT IS ADVISED, PER STIPULATION OF COUNSEL, DEFENDANT WILL NOW BE CALLED OUT OF ORDER IN DEFENSE CASE IN CHIEF. 01:40 COURT IN RECESS. COURT RECONVENES WITH COUNSEL, DEFENDANT AND JURY PRESENT. THE JURY IS ADVISED DEFENDANT WILL BE CALLED OUT OF ORDER IN DEFENSE CASE IN CHIEF. TESTIMONY OF NABIL KOUDSI RESUMES. JOINT EXHIBIT(S) #6 - CONSENT TO SURGERY DATED 12/25/14 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. DEFENSE EXHIBIT(S) #53 - TROCAR #5 (MEDICAL INSTRUMENT) MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. DEFENSE EXHIBIT(S) #54 - TROCAR #12 (MEDICAL INSTRUMENT) MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. DEFENSE EXHIBIT(S) #55 - GRASPER (MEDICAL INSTRUMENT) MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. DEFENSE EXHIBIT(S) #56 - CLIP APPLICATOR (MEDICAL INSTRUMENT) MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. 02:47 JURY ADMONISHED AND EXCUSED FOR AFTERNOON RECESS. COURT IN RECESS. 03:09 COURT RECONVENES WITH COUNSEL, DEFENDANT AND JURY PRESENT. TESTIMONY OF NABIL KOUDSI RESUMES. JOINT EXHIBIT(S) #15 - DIAGRAM: CORRECT POST-OP CONDITION MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. 03:35 COURT AND COUNSEL CONFER OFF THE RECORD. 03:36 JURY PRESENT AND ADVISED RE TRIAL SCHEDULE. 03:38 JURY ADMONISHED AND EXCUSED FOR THE DAY. COURT ADJOURNED. - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 06/11/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 06, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 06, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: JENNIFER MEDINA COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT A MARTINEZ - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID H. RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas K\. Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD PRESENT - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 4TH DAY OF TRIAL 10:22 COURT CONVENES WITH ALL COUNSEL AND JURY PRESENT PLAINTIFF PRESENTS OPENING STATEMENT. 10:50 DEFENDANT PRESENTS OPENING STATEMENT. 11:23 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - 11:36 COURT RECONVENES WITH PARTIES, COUNSEL, AND JURY PRESENT PLAINTIFF CASE IN CHIEF MICHAEL TIM NELSON, M.D. IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES AS WITNESS FOR PLAINTIFF. 11:57 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - 01:42 COURT RECONVENES WITH ALL PARTIES, COUNSEL, AND JURY PRESENT. PLAINTIFF WITNESS MICHAEL TIM NELSON, M.D. RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. 02:49 COURT AND COUNSEL CONFER IN CHAMBERS OFF THE RECORD 02:55 BACK ON THE RECORD. PLAINTIFF WITNESS MICHAEL TIM NELSON, M.D. RESUMES TESTIMONY, STILL UNDER OATH. - 04:00 COURT AND COUNSEL CONFER IN CHAMBERS OFF THE RECORD - 04:02 BACK ON THE RECORD. WITNESS MICHAEL TIM NELSON, M.D. EXCUSED. JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - EXHIBITS: JOINT EXHIBIT(S) 3, 5, 7, 8, 10, 13, 14, 16, 17, 45, 47 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. PLAINTIFF EXHIBIT(S) 49, 50, 51, 52 MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION. EXHIBITS ARE OFFERED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION/ENTERED AS EVIDENCE (REFERENCE EXHIBIT LIST, ATTACHED HERETO AND INCORPORATED HEREIN BY REFERENCE). - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 06/07/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 05, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 05, 2018 | Docket Event |
Notice Filed Re: NOTICE OF LODGING OF ORIGINAL DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS FILED BY NABIL KOUDSI MD. |
|
| June 05, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: JENNIFER MEDINA COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT A MARTINEZ - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID H. RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas K\. Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 3RD DAY OF TRIAL 10:08 (VOIR DIRE NOT REPORTED) COURT CONVENES WITH COUNSEL AND PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED FOR CAUSE: 4 11:02 JURORS ADMONISHED. OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: DISCUSSION HELD REGARDING CHALLENGES FOR CAUSE THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED FOR CAUSE: 43 11:04 COURT IN RECESS. - 11:19 COURT RECONVENES WITH ALL COUNSEL AND PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT. TWO JURORS CALLED TO FILL EMPTY SEATS. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 11:51 PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES EXERCISED BY COUNSEL. THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED: 41 ANOTHER JUROR CALLED TO FILL EMPTY SEAT. 11:55 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - 01:42 COURT RECONVENES WITH ALL COUNSEL PRESENT. OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS ARE HELD: COURT AND COUNSEL DISCUSS SCHEDULING 01:44 RECONVENE WITH JURY PANEL JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 01:53 PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES EXERCISED BY COUNSEL. THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED: 3 ANOTHER JUROR CALLED TO FILL EMPTY SEAT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 02:01 PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES EXERCISED BY COUNSEL. COUNSEL ACCEPTS THE PANEL AS IS. JURY SWORN. - TWO ALTERNATE JURORS CALLED FOR REVIEW. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 02:29 PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES EXERCISED BY COUNSEL. THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED : 21 ANOTHER JUROR IS CALLED TO FILL EMPTY SEAT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 02:32 PURSUANT TO STIPULATION OF COUNSEL: THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED : 12 ANOTHER JUROR IS CALLED TO FILL EMPTY SEAT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 02:42 PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES EXERCISED BY COUNSEL. COUNSEL ACCEPTS THE ALTERNATES AS IS. #1 AND #2 ALTERNATE JUROR(S) SWORN. REMAINING JURY PANEL EXCUSED. - 02:47 (COURT REPORTER NOW PRESENT) COURT GIVES JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 03:03 COURT AND COUNSEL CONFER IN CHAMBERS OFF THE RECORD 03:05 COURT CONTINUES WITH JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 03:06 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 06/06/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 04, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| June 04, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed STIPULATION RE: JURY INST., VERDICT & STAY OF EXECUTION, & DISPO OF MATERIALS FILED. |
|
| June 04, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: JENNIFER MEDINA COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT A MARTINEZ - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD 2ND DAY OF TRIAL 10:19 COURT CONVENES WITH ALL COUNSEL AND PARTIES PRESENT COURT AND COUNSEL ADDRESS JOINT DOCUMENTS RECEIVED, TIME ESTIMATE, AND JURY SELECTION PROCEDURES. MOTION(S) IN LIMINE HEARD. PARTIES STIPULATE TO MIL #1. MOTION MOOT. COURT RESERVES ON RULING ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE # 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, & 7. 10:29 COURT IN RECESS. - PURSUANT TO STIPULATION OF COUNSEL: REPORTER WAIVED (FOR VOIRE DIRE) 10:50 JURY PANEL CALLED IN AND ROLL CALL TAKEN PROSPECTIVE JURY PANEL HAVING BEEN SUMMONED, IS SWORN REGARDING THEIR QUALIFICATION TO ACT AS TRIAL JURORS. 11:04 COURT GIVES A BRIEF INTRODUCTION AND STATEMENT OF THE CASE. 11:16 HARDSHIPS EXERCISED BY PROSPECTIVE JURORS. COURT EXCUSES THE FOLLOWING JURORS FOR CAUSE: 38, 52, 49, 54, 48, 14, 10, 20, 18, 34, 45, 15, 37, AND 22. 11:38 FIRST 12 PROSPECTIVE JURORS SEATED. JURY VOIR DIRE COMMENCES 11:57 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - 01:45 COURT RECONVENES WITH ALL COUNSEL AND PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 02:28 THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED FOR CAUSE: 46 . ANOTHER JUROR CALLED TO FILL EMPTY SEAT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 03:03 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT IN RECESS. - 03:19 COURT RECONVENES WITH ALL COUNSEL AND PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT. JURY VOIR DIRE RESUMES 04:02 JURORS ADMONISHED. COURT ADJOURNED. THE FOLLOWING JUROR IS EXCUSED FOR CAUSE: 29. - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL (IN PROGRESS) CONTINUED TO 06/05/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| June 01, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEFENDANT #7 FILED. | |
| May 31, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S JOINT STATEMENT OF THE CASE FILED. |
|
| May 31, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S JOINT WITNESS LIST FILED. |
|
| May 31, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S JOINT LIST OF PROPOSED EXHIBITS FOR TRIAL FILED. |
|
| May 30, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| May 30, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed STIPULATION RE: PAST MEDICAL SPECIAL DAMAGES AND LIMITING PLAINTIFFS DAMAGES FILED. |
|
| May 30, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLAINTIFF'S TRIAL BRIEF FILED. |
|
| May 30, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes HEARING RE: PRETRIAL MOTIONS/MOTIONS IN LIMINES DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS NOT REPORTED COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD BENCH CONFERENCE HELD OFF THE RECORD. - HEARINGS: JURY TRIAL SET FOR 06/04/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23A ESTIMATED DURATION OF 12-15 DAYS. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| May 29, 2018 | |||
| May 29, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH 00:00 HOURS. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S OPPO TO DEF MIL #5 FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S OPPO TO DEF'S MIL #1 FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S OPPO TO DEF'S MIL #6 FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEF'S #2 FILED. | |
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed DEF'S TRIAL BRIEF RE MICRA FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S OPPO TO DEF'S MIL #3 FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed DEF'S NOTICE OF INTENT TO OFFER VIDEO RECORDING DEPO TESTIMONEY FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEF'S #1 FILED. | |
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed DEF'S TRIAL BRIEF RE CAUSATION FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEF'S # 5 FILED. | |
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEF'S #4 FILED. | |
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S OPPO TO DEF'S MIL #4 FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLTF'S OPPO TO DEF MIL #2 FILED. |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEF'S # 3 FILED. | |
| May 25, 2018 | Docket Event | MOTION IN LIMINE RE: DEF'S #6 FILED. | |
| May 24, 2018 | |||
| May 24, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes MOTION RE: TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR ASMISSION FILED BY PLAINTIFF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ |
|
| May 24, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes READINESS CALENDAR DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY DOUGLAS SMITH PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY FOR TRIAL. ESTIMATED LENGTH OF TRIAL 10 DAY(S). - HEARINGS: VACATE JT HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 05/29/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. HEARING RE:PRETRIAL MOTIONS/MOTIONS IN LIMINES SET FOR 05/30/18 AT 01:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23A. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END === |
|
| May 14, 2018 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| May 14, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes MOTION RE: COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO RQST ADMISSIONS DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER MARY ANDERSON;10319 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY ALYSSA MORSENSEN PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD - MOTION VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ'S MOTION COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUEST ADMISSIONS IS HEARD. ARGUED BY COUNSEL AND SUBMITTED. - COURT FINDS: VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ'S MOTION COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUEST ADMISSIONS IS GRANTED. (AS TO REQUEST 6, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, AND 14) THE COURT GRANTS 5 DAYS TO RESPOND. - HEARINGS: HEARING DATE OF 05/24/18 CONFIRMED. HEARING DATE OF 05/29/18 CONFIRMED. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END === |
|
| May 09, 2018 | Docket Event |
Reply Filed REPLY TO OPPO TO MOTION RE:TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES SET FOR HEARING ON 05/14/18 FILED BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ. (IMAGED) |
|
| May 08, 2018 | Docket Event |
Opposition to Motion Filed OPPOSITION TO MOTION RE: TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO RQST FOR ADMISSIONS SET FOR HEARING ON 05/14/18, FILED BY DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD (IMAGED) |
|
| May 08, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed DEFT'S OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFF'S SEPARATE STATEMENT FILED. |
|
| May 08, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR COPIES + POSTAGE FOR MAILING 180508-0424-VS FFS/ 0.20 FPC/ 0.49 PAYMT 180508-0424-VS TSB/ 0.02 FCP/ 1.00 PAYMT 180508-0424-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 033-0066743377 | |
| May 08, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FAX FILING OF (2) OPPOSITIONS 180508-0423-VS FAX/ 32.00 PAYMT 180508-0423-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 033-0066743377 | |
| May 08, 2018 | Docket Event | CREDIT CARD TRANSACTION ID NUMBER 033-0066743377 | |
| May 02, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes EX PARTE HEARING RE: APPL FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER ALICIA LINDSEY;13895 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY ALYSSA MORTENSEN PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD EX-PARTE HEARING IS HELD. EX PARTE APPLICATION ARGUED. EX PARTE ORDERS GRANTED - HEARINGS: VACATE L&M HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 05/24/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. LAW & MOTION RE: COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO RQST ADMISSIONS SET FOR 05/14/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPT. S23. PER STIPULATION OF COUNSEL OPPOSITION WILL BE DUE MAY 7, 2018, AND A REPLY IS DUE MAY 11, 2018. ***NO FILE IN COURTROOM*** === MINUTE ORDER END === ACTION - COMPLETE |
|
| May 01, 2018 | Docket Event |
Motion Filed MOTION RE: TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQSRT FOR ADMISSIO SET FOR HEARING ON 05/24/18, FILED BY PLAINTIFF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ (IMAGED) |
|
| May 01, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ FOR MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSE 180501-0288-CK MMF/ 60.00 CRU/ 30.00 PAYMT 180501-0288-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17269 | |
| May 01, 2018 | Docket Event |
Declaration Filed DECLARATION OF YVETTE A. PATINO FILED |
|
| May 01, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed PLNTFF SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPRT OF MTN TO COMPEL FURTHER RSPNS FILED. |
|
| May 01, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ FOR EX PARTE 180501-0280-CK MMF/ 60.00 CRU/ 30.00 PAYMT 180501-0280-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17270 | |
| May 01, 2018 | Docket Event |
Ex Parte Filed EX PARTE PLTF APPL FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME FILED. |
|
| April 16, 2018 | |||
| April 16, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH 00:00 HOURS. |
|
| April 12, 2018 | |||
| April 12, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes MOTION RE: COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS |
|
| April 12, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes READINESS CALENDAR |
|
| April 12, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes MOTION RE: COMPEL RESPONSES TO PRETRIAL DEMAND FOR INSPCTN |
|
| April 11, 2018 | Docket Event |
Vacate Hearing Scheduled VACATE LM37 HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 04/12/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. |
|
| March 12, 2018 | |||
| March 12, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes MOTION RE: COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS FILED BY PLAINTIFF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ |
|
| March 12, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes MOTION RE: TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO PRETRIAL DEMAND FOR INSPCTINS AND PROD FILED BY DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD |
|
| March 09, 2018 | Docket Event |
Vacate Hearing Scheduled VACATE READI HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 04/12/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. |
|
| March 09, 2018 | Docket Event |
Vacate Hearing Scheduled VACATE JT HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 04/16/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. |
|
| March 09, 2018 | Docket Event |
Stipulation & Order filed STIPULATION AND ORDER RE: TO CONTINUE TRIAL READINESS AND TRIAL FILED. |
|
| March 09, 2018 | Docket Event |
Conformed Copies in the Attorney Bin - No Envelope Provided CONFORMED COPIES IN THE ATTORNEY BIN -- NO ENVELOPE PROVIDED |
|
| March 07, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ FOR STIP/ORDER TO CONTINUE TRIAL 180307-0037-CK RSO/ 20.00 PAYMT 180307-0037-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17158 | |
| March 01, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FAX FEES 180301-0776-VS FAX/ 7.00 PAYMT | |
| March 01, 2018 | Docket Event |
Stipulation & Order filed STIPULATION AND ORDER RE: TO CONTINUE MOTION TO COMPEL HEARINGS FILED. |
|
| March 01, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR STIP/ORDER FEES 180301-0772-VS RSO/ 20.00 PAYMT 180301-0772-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 0330056483974 | |
| March 01, 2018 | Docket Event | CREDIT CARD TRANSACTION ID NUMBER 0330056483974 | |
| March 01, 2018 | Docket Event |
Vacate Hearing Scheduled VACATE L&M HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 03/12/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. |
|
| February 16, 2018 | Docket Event | CREDIT CARD TRANSACTION ID NUMBER 033-0054994703 | |
| February 16, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FAX FILING, CC AND P&E 180221-0129-VS FFS/ 0.20 FPC/ 0.49 PAYMT 180221-0129-VS TSB/ 0.02 FAX/ 22.00 PAYMT 180221-0129-VS FCP/ 1.00 PAYMT 180221-0129-VS REFERENCE NUMBER VISA | |
| February 16, 2018 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO PRETRIAL 180221-0118-VS MMF/ 60.00 CRU/ 30.00 PAYMT 180221-0118-VS REFERENCE NUMBER VISA | |
| February 16, 2018 | Docket Event |
Motion Filed MOTION RE: TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO PRETRIAL SET FOR HEARING ON 03/12/18, FILED BY DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD (IMAGED) |
|
| February 13, 2018 | Docket Event |
Miscellaneous Document Filed SEPARATE STATEMENT FILED. |
|
| February 13, 2018 | Docket Event |
Motion Filed MOTION RE: COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION SET FOR HEARING ON 03/12/18, FILED BY PLAINTIFF VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ (IMAGED) 180213-0616-CK MMF/ 60.00 CRU/ 30.00 PAYMT 180213-0616-CK REFERENCE NUMBER 17082 |
|
| January 29, 2018 | |||
| January 29, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes JURY TRIAL -- ESTIMATED TRIAL LENGTH HOURS. |
|
| January 25, 2018 | |||
| January 25, 2018 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes READINESS CALENDAR |
|
| November 16, 2017 | Docket Event |
Stipulation & Order filed STIPULATION AND ORDER RE: TO CONTINUE TRIAL READINESS AND TRIAL FILED. |
|
| November 16, 2017 | Docket Event |
Conformed Copies in the Attorney Bin - No Envelope Provided CONFORMED COPIES IN THE ATTORNEY BIN -- NO ENVELOPE PROVIDED |
|
| November 16, 2017 | Docket Event |
Vacate Hearing Scheduled VACATE READI HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 01/25/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. |
|
| November 16, 2017 | Docket Event |
Vacate Hearing Scheduled VACATE JT HEARING SCHEDULED FOR 01/29/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23. |
|
| November 14, 2017 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ FOR STIPULATION AND ORDER TO CONTINUE 171115-0531-CK RSO/ 20.00 PAYMT | |
| April 24, 2017 | Docket Event |
Notice of Ruling Filed NOTICE OF RULING ON TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE 4/17/17 FILED. |
|
| April 17, 2017 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| April 17, 2017 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER DEENA MACIAS;9826 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY ALYSSA MORTENSEN PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY FOR TRIAL. ESTIMATED LENGTH OF TRIAL 7-10 DAY(S). - HEARINGS: SET ON TRIAL READINESS/ASSIGNMENT CALENDAR FOR 01/25/18 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23 JURY TRIAL SET FOR 01/29/18 AT 10:00 IN DEPARTMENT S23 ESTIMATED DURATION OF 7-10 DAYS. COUNSEL FOR DEFENSE TO GIVE NOTICE. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END === |
|
| April 05, 2017 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT FILED BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ. | |
| December 16, 2016 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| December 16, 2016 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER LAWANA VASQUEZ;12582 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY ERICA BERRETT PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY NAZIK HASAN PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD HEARING CONTINUED AT REQUEST OF COUNSEL. HEARING CONTINUED FOR THE PURPOSES OF DISCOVERY. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 04/17/17 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. NOTICE WAIVED. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END === |
|
| November 29, 2016 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT FILED BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ. | |
| August 24, 2016 |
Judge:
Alvarez, Donald
|
||
| August 24, 2016 | Docket Event |
Legacy Minutes TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE DONALD ALVAREZ,JUDGE CLERK: MONICA REAL-RAMOS COURT REPORTER CRAIG ANDERSON;11800 COURT ATTENDANT E ASHE - APPEARANCES: ATTORNEY DAVID RICKS PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER. ATTORNEY Douglas Mann PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT. - PROCEEDINGS: PREDISPOSITION HEARING HELD HEARING CONTINUED AT REQUEST OF PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL. - HEARINGS: CURRENT HEARING CONTINUED TO 12/16/16 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT S23. COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF TO GIVE NOTICE. ACTION - COMPLETE === MINUTE ORDER END ===
|
|
| August 02, 2016 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT FILED BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ. | |
| April 15, 2016 | Docket Event | ANSWER FILED BY NABIL KOUDSI MD; PARTY REPRESENTED BY WALKER & MANN, LLP. | |
| April 15, 2016 | Docket Event | ADVANCED JURY FEES POSTED FOR NABIL KOUDSI MD. 160422-0568-VS JFN/ 150.00 PAYMT 160422-0568-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 023-0255912236 | |
| April 15, 2016 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FAX FILING, COPY, RETURN ENVELOPE/POSTAGE 160422-0559-VS FFS/ 0.20 FPC/ 0.49 PAYMT 160422-0559-VS TSB/ 0.02 FAX/ 10.00 PAYMT 160422-0559-VS FCP/ 0.50 PAYMT 160422-0559-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 023-0255911215 | |
| April 15, 2016 | Docket Event |
Defendant First Paper Fee Paid in Full DEFENDANT NABIL KOUDSI MD FIRST PAPER FEE PAID IN FULL |
|
| April 15, 2016 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY NABIL KOUDSI MD FOR FIRST PAPER FEE 160422-0555-VS CVH/ 435.00 PAYMT 160422-0555-VS REFERENCE NUMBER 023-0255911215 | |
| April 15, 2016 | Docket Event |
Notice Filed Re: NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES FILED BY NABIL KOUDSI MD. |
|
| April 01, 2016 | Docket Event |
Proof of Service as to Clerk's Certified Mail with Costs of: PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS AND COMP/PET FILED AS TO NABIL KOUDSI MD; PARTY SERVED ON 03/15/16 WITH COSTS OF $0.00 BY CERTIFIED MAIL. |
|
| March 25, 2016 | Docket Event |
Dismissal Filed as to Defendant DISMISSAL FILED AS TO KOUDSI MEDICAL, INC.,, WITHOUT PREJUDICE |
|
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | CERTIFICATE OF ASSIGNMENT RECEIVED. | |
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | COMPLAINT AND PARTY INFORMATION ENTERED | |
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | NOTICE IMAGED | |
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | FILING FEE PAID BY VICENTE GUERRERO ENRIQUEZ FOR FIRST PAPER FEES 160224-0395-CK CVH/ 435.00 PAYMT | |
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET FILED. | |
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | CASE ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO DEPARTMENT S23 | |
| February 24, 2016 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ISSUED AND FILED |
