Your recipients will receive an email with this envelope shortly and will be able to access it on trellis. You can always see your envelopes by clicking the Inbox on the top right hand corner.
IAN MAULEON VS. CRUNCH HOLDINGS, LLC ET AL
On February 24, 2020 an other non exempt complaints case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of San Francisco County. Judge Samuel K. Feng presiding.
Case Details
Case Number
Filing Date
February 24, 2020
Last Refreshed
November 23, 2023
Filing Location
San Francisco County, CA
OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE
Garrett L. Wong;Category
OTHER NON EXEMPT COMPLAINTS
Status
Dismissal
OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE
Overview
Causes of Action
CAUSE OF ACTION VIOLATION OF PAGA (AGAINST ALL DEFENDANTS BY PLAINTIFF)
Number of causes of action specify
Parties
Plaintiffs
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Defendants
Attorneys for Defendants
Case Documents
ORDER STRIKING PLAINTIFFS DISMISSAL OF ENTIRE ACTION
Date: Jun 17, 2021NOTICE OF RELATED CASE (TRANSACTION ID 100106121)
Date: Jul 09, 2020NOTICE TO PLAINTIFF
Date: Feb 24, 2020Case Events
Date | Type | Description | |
---|---|---|---|
September 20, 2022 | hearing |
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
July 19, 2022 | hearing |
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
July 08, 2022 | Docket Event | ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE SET FOR JUL-19-2022 CONTINUED TO SEP-20-2022 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR FAILURE TO OBTAIN DISMISSAL ORDER IN DEPARTMENT 302. ***NOTE: REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL MUST BE MADE IN DEPARTMENT 302.*** NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
June 23, 2022 | Docket Event | DECLARATION OF DOUGLAS HAN IN SUPPORT OF ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE RE DISMISSAL (TRANSACTION ID # 67758511) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") | |
May 17, 2022 | hearing |
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
May 03, 2022 | Docket Event | ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE SET FOR MAY-17-2022 CONTINUED TO JUL-19-2022 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR FAILURE TO OBTAIN DISMISSAL ORDER IN DEPT. 302. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
April 06, 2022 | Docket Event | DECLARATION OF DOUGLAS HAN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF IAN MAULEON?S REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL (TRANSACTION ID # 67458243) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") | |
April 06, 2022 | Docket Event | PLAINTIFF IAN MAULEON?S REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL (TRANSACTION ID # 67458243) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH HOLDINGS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY DOES 1 TO 100 INCLUSIVE CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH, LLC CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC CRUNCH LA, LLC CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC | |
April 06, 2022 | Docket Event | PROOF OF SERVICE OF REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL; FORM CIV-110 REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL; DECLARATIOIN OF DOUGLAS HAN; AND PROPOSED ORDER. (TRANSACTION ID # 67458243) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED APR-06-2022, ELECTRONIC AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH HOLDINGS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY DOES 1 TO 100 INCLUSIVE CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH, LLC CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC CRUNCH LA, LLC CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC | |
March 15, 2022 | hearing |
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
February 25, 2022 | Docket Event | ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE SET FOR MAR-15-2022 CONTINUED TO MAY-17-2022 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR FAILURE TO OBTAIN ORDER OF DISMISSAL IN DEPARTMENT 302. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
January 11, 2022 | hearing |
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
December 27, 2021 | Docket Event | ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE SET FOR JAN-11-2022 CONTINUED TO MAR-15-2022 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR FAILURE TO OBTAIN ORDER OF DISMISSAL IN DEPARTMENT 302. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
December 07, 2021 | Docket Event | DECLARATION OF DOUGLAS HAN IN SUPPORT OF ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE RE DISMISSAL (TRANSACTION ID # 67150326) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") | |
November 10, 2021 | hearing |
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
October 21, 2021 | Docket Event | ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE SET FOR JAN-11-2022 IN DEPARTMENT 610 AT 10:30 AM FOR FAILURE TO OBTAIN DISMISSAL ORDER PER CRC 3.770 IN DEPARTMENT 302. THE NOV-10-2021 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE IS OFF CALENDAR. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
September 08, 2021 | hearing |
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
August 31, 2021 | Docket Event | NOTICE OF CONTINUED CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID # 100140494) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") | |
August 23, 2021 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE OF SEP-08-2021 CONTINUED TO NOV-10-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR PLAINTIFF TO OBTAIN DISMISSAL ORDER PER CRC 3.770 IN DEPARTMENT 302. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
July 07, 2021 | hearing |
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
June 17, 2021 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE OF JUL-07-2021 CONTINUED TO SEP-08-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR PLAINTIFF TO OBTAIN ORDER OF DISMISSAL PURSUANT CRC 3.770 IN DEPT. 302. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
June 17, 2021 | Docket Event | ORDER STRIKING PLAINTIFF'S DISMISSAL OF ENTIRE ACTION | |
March 03, 2021 | hearing |
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Judge: SAMUEL K. FENG |
|
February 18, 2021 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE OF MAR-03-2021 CONTINUED TO JUL-07-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR THE SUBMISSION OF CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENTS REGARDING STATUS OF SETTLEMENT. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
February 16, 2021 | Docket Event | DISMISSAL OF ENTIRE ACTION OF ALL PARTIES AND ALL CAUSES OF ACTION WITHOUT PREJUDICE (TRANSACTION ID # 100124058) | |
December 02, 2020 | hearing |
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Judge: GARRETT L. WONG |
|
November 16, 2020 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66113218) FILED BY DEFENDANT CRUNCH, LLC CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC ESTIMATED TIME FOR TRIAL: 5.0 DAYS | |
November 13, 2020 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE OF DEC-02-2020 CONTINUED TO MAR-03-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610 FOR STATUS OF SETTLEMENT. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
November 06, 2020 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 100115878) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") JURY DEMANDED, ESTIMATED TIME FOR TRIAL: 14.0 DAYS | |
September 18, 2020 | Docket Event | NOTICE OF RELATED CASE (TRANSACTION ID # 65945112) (TRANSACTION ID # 65945112) FILED BY DEFENDANT CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC | |
July 29, 2020 | hearing |
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Judge: GARRETT L. WONG |
|
July 20, 2020 | Docket Event | NOTICE OF CONTINUING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID # 100106957) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") | |
July 15, 2020 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE OF JUL-29-2020 CONTINUED TO DEC-02-2020 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT 610. NOTICE SENT BY COURT. | |
July 14, 2020 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 100106472) FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") JURY DEMANDED, ESTIMATED TIME FOR TRIAL: 14.0 DAYS | |
July 14, 2020 | Docket Event | CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 65768754) FILED BY DEFENDANT CRUNCH, LLC CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC ESTIMATED TIME FOR TRIAL: 5.0 DAYS | |
July 09, 2020 | Docket Event | NOTICE OF RELATED CASE (TRANSACTION ID # 100106121) | |
April 17, 2020 | Docket Event | AMENDED ANSWER TO COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 65584630) FILED BY DEFENDANT CRUNCH, LLC CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC CRUNCH LA, LLC CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC | |
April 16, 2020 | Docket Event | ANSWER TO COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 65582231) FILED BY DEFENDANT CRUNCH, LLC CRUNCHHOLDINGS, LLC CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC CRUNCH LA, LLC CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH HOLDINGS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
March 11, 2020 | Docket Event | SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 100099341), PROOF OF SERVICE ONLY, FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") SERVED FEB-28-2020, PERSONAL SERVICE AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH LA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY | |
February 24, 2020 | Docket Event | OTHER NON EXEMPT COMPLAINTS, COMPLAINT FILED BY PLAINTIFF MAULEON, IAN INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF AGGRIEVED EMPLOYEES PURSUANT TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ACT ("PAGA") AS TO DEFENDANT CRUNCH HOLDINGS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH JV PARTNERS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH NORCAL, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY PLACENTIA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA RIVERSIDE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH LA UPLAND, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAC HOWE, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAC ROCKLIN, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY CRUNCH SAN DIEGO, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY DOES 1 TO 100 INCLUSIVE CRUNCH ORANGE COUNTY, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY SUMMONS ISSUED, JUDICIAL COUNCIL CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET FILED CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR JUL-29-2020 PROOF OF SERVICE DUE ON APR-24-2020 CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT DUE ON JUL-06-2020 | |
February 24, 2020 | Docket Event | NOTICE TO PLAINTIFF |