We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Felina Robinson v. The Buffalo News, Inc.

On January 31, 2019 a commercial division case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of Erie County. Judge Timothy Walker presiding.

Case Details

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)   

Filing Date

January 31, 2019

Last Refreshed

October 10, 2023

Filing Location

Erie County, NY

Filing Court House

Erie County Supreme Court

Judge

Hon. Timothy Walker Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Timothy Walker   

Category

Commercial Division

Practice Area

Commercial

Matter Type

General Commercial

Overview

This is a class action against defendant The Buffalo News, Inc. (“Buffalo News”

or “Defendant”) for misclassification of Plaintiff and all similarly-situated newspaper delivery

carriers (the “Class” or the “Carriers”) who worked for Defendant since January 31, 2013 and

were misclassified as independent contractors.

Although Defendant purports to classify the Carriers as independent contractors,

they are controlled and treated like employees. The Carriers work seven days a week for

Defendant, deliver newspapers to Defendant’s customers, are subject to Defendant’s standards

for delivery including Defendant’s dictated route, and are required to complete their deliveries by

specific times. The Carriers are economically dependent on Defendant and have virtually no

opportunity for profit or loss: they are paid cents for each newspaper delivered (a rate set by

Defendant), the boundaries of their routes are set by Defendant, and the newspapers are delivered

to Defendant’s customers and thus the Carriers have little opportunity to expand their purported

business. The Carriers are trained by Defendant or its agents and are terminated at-will, like

Causes of Action

1. Unlawful Deductions in Violation of New York Labor Law Section 193

2. Common Law Misclassification

3. Unjust Enrichment

4. Violation of New York Labor Law Section 195(3)

Parties

Plaintiffs

Felina Robinson

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Kurtz, Orin R
Sanders, Harvey P

Defendants

The Buffalo News, Inc.

Attorneys for Defendants

Hickey, Michael Edward
Lafferty, Riane F.

Case Events

Type Description
hearing (Motion #002)
Part 22

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Motion Approve Settlement (Motion #003)
Decided: 10/16/2020Granted Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.
Answer demanded: No

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

hearing Adjourned (Motion #002)
Part 22

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

hearing Adjourned (Motion #002)
Part 22

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Motion (Motion #002)
Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.
Answer demanded: No

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #2)
Exemplar Invoices
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #2)
Robinson HDA Agreement
Docket Event STIPULATION - OTHER (Motion #2)
Stipulation of Fact re Class Certification
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - E (Motion #2)
Gardy & Notis Employment Resume
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - D (Motion #2)
Gardy & Notis Firm Resume
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - C (Motion #2)
New Majority Decision
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #2)
Martin v. Restaurant Associates
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #2)
Leahy v. Retriever
Docket Event AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION (Motion #2)
Affirmation of Orin Kurtz
Docket Event AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT (Motion #2)
Affidavit of Felina Robinson
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #2)
Exh A -- Proposed Class Notice
Docket Event MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT (Motion #2)
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #2)
Docket Event LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter Requesting Brief Extension To File Motion For Class Certification
hearing Held
Part 22

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Docket Event STIPULATION - CONFIDENTIALITY
Docket Event ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING
hearing Held
Part 22

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Docket Event ANSWER
Docket Event STIPULATION - SO ORDERED (Motion #1)
hearing Stipulation Filed (Motion #001)
Part 22

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Docket Event STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER ) (Motion #1)
Dismissing Second and Third Causes of Action, Dismissing Class Allegations for Fourth Cause of Actio
Docket Event RJI (AMENDED) (Motion #1)
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #1)
Motion Dismiss (Motion #001)
Decided: 05/03/2019Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.
Answer demanded: No

Judge: Walker, Hon. Timothy J.

Docket Event NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Docket Event ADDENDUM - COMMERCIAL DIVISION (840C) (Motion #1)
Docket Event RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #1)
Docket Event MEMORANDUM OF LAW (Motion #1)
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - 2 (Motion #1)
Agreement
Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - 1 (Motion #1)
Summons and Complaint
Docket Event AFFIRMATION (Motion #1)
Docket Event NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Docket Event SUMMONS + COMPLAINT

Please wait a moment while we load this page.

New Envelope

Your free document request was received.

Your request has been received. We will email you this document within 4 business hours.

You have used out of 0 document requests this month.

Continue

Document Requested

You have exceeded your document request limit for this month.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue
Docket Refresh Requested

Your docket refresh request has been received. You will receive a notification when the docket is refreshed.

Docket Refresh Requested

A refresh is already in progress.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue