Motion for Attorneys’ Fees
Rulings on Objections
Respondent’s objections to evidence are ruled on as follows: The objection to statements set forth in the Benumof declaration at p. 5:17-21, and the objection to statements in the Skidmore declaration, are sustained. The remaining objections are overruled. Ruling on Motion
Petitioner Miner’s Camp filed a petition for writ of mandate and complaint for declaratory relief and restitution, challenging the water rate structure adopted by respondent Foresthill Public Utility District (“the District”) on June 25, 2014. Petitioner sought a declaration that the District’s water rate structure violated Proposition 218, California Constitution, Article XIIID, restitution of all fees and charges collected in violation of Proposition 218, a permanent injunction prohibiting the billing and collection of water charges or fees which were imposed in violation of Proposition 218, and a writ of mandate ordering the District to abandon its current rate stru