Preview
MARK C. MOLUMPHY (168009)
FILEB
'
mmolumphy@cp_mlegal.com
ALEXANDRA P. SUMMER (266485)
asunnner@cpmlegal.com SAN MATEO COUNTY
COTCHE'IT, PITRE & MCCARTHY, LLP
San Francisco Airport Office Center OCT 1 9 2015
840 Malcolm Road, Suite 200
\OOOQGMAUJNu—n
Burlingame, California 94010
Telephone: (650) 697-6000
Facsimile: (650) 697-0577
Attorneys fbr Plaintifis Kerrigan Capital LLC and Ryan J: Kerrigan,
,as Trustee for the
Kerrigan Family Trust
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN MATEO
KERRIGAN CAPITAL LLC and RYAN J. ) Case No. CIV534431
KERRIGAN, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE )
KERRIGAN FAMILY TRUST, individually CLASS ACTION
and on behalf of all others similarly situated, 3
) NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER RE:
Plaintiffs, ) STIPULATION AND ORDER TO MODIFY
) CLASS CERTIFICATION SCHEDULE
vs. )
‘
) Complaint Filed: June 26, 2015
DAVID STROHM, TOM PATTERSON, )
CARL PASCARELLA, AIDA ALVAREZ, )
NNNNNNNND—‘D—ll—lt—Ot-fiI-dF—IHHH
RAUL VAZQUEZ, DAVE TOMLINSON, ) fl FAX _
GREYLOCK XII L.P., GREYLOCK XII-A ) {EN
\IONMALDNHOOOOVOXUI-wi-‘C
L.P., GREYLOCK XII PRINCIPALS LLC, )
MAPACI-IE INVESTMENTS L.P. FUND V,)
MADRONE PARTNERS, LP. and DOES )
1-20, inclusive, )
%~
)
Defendants. )
’/
{ cwsfim‘ nflOl’deI
\ NOE"; oi EnW 0‘ Judgme
“‘i§i\\\\\\\\\\\\\l\\‘\\‘\\\\\\\\\\\\
28
'
LAW OFFICES OF
Corcnm’r, Pmua NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER; Case No. CIV534431
& MCCARTHY, LLP
p—a
T OALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
PLEASE TAKENOTICEthat on October 18, 2016, the Court entered.the;Stipulation and
Order to Modify Ciass Certification Schedule. A true and Correct~ copy of the Order'isatlache'd
liegreto'ra's- Exhibit A,
Dated: October 19,2016 COT CHETT PITRE «St McCARTHY, LLP
\ooo’xloxg‘z'unwp
@QW
ALEXANDRA P SUMMER
Attorneysjbr Plaintiffs Kerrig‘cm Capital LLC and
.
Ryan J. .Kerrigan, as" 77:11.5'Ieef0r-Ihe .Kemtigan
Fai‘n’ily’ Ti'us‘l
\lmM-w-dO-Koooqox'm-bWNv-ao
NMNN’NNI‘om—‘ew—HHHaxe-Ha.
28.
LAW OFFICES OF
CU'I'CI'II'Z'I'I‘, PITRE. NOTICE O'F‘ENTRY OF 'ORDERjCase No. CIV53_4431
& MCCAR’I'I w, LLP'
EXHIBIT A
suumwmnemnnv
l- COOLEY LLP f-
MARTIN S. SCHENKER (SBN 109828)
2 101 California Street, 5th Floor
0“, T 1 8 2015
San Francisco, CA 9411 I
3 Telephone: (4l5) 693-2000 _
Clarke 9 arm
Facstmlle: (415) 693-2222 .33,
4
'
JESSICA VALENZUBLA SANTAMARIA (SBN 220934)
5 SHAWNA V. BENFIELD (SBN 290511)
JEFFREY D. LOMBARD (SBN 285371)
6 3175 Hanover Street
Palo Alto, CA 94304
7 Telephone: (650) 843—5 000
FacSImile: (650) 849-7400
8'
\3 Attorneys for Defendants
\\Li § 9 DA VID STROHM, TOM PA TTERS’ON, AIDA AL VAREZ, RA UL
VAZQUEZ, DAVE TOMLHVSON. CARL PASCARELLA
.
SUPEMOWALIEQRMA
\
-
«a \I 10
Q“
11 COUNTY OF SAN MATEO
'
12
13
-
KERRIGAN CAPITAL LLC and RYAN J.
KERRIGAN, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE
No. CW534431
STIPULATION AND [PR os D] ORDER
[
KERRIGAN FAMILY TRUST, individual‘ljy
and on behalf of all others similarly situate , To MODIFY CLASS ,0 RTIF CATION
14 SCHEDULE
_
15
Plaintiff,
Complaint Filed: June 26, 2015
16 V-
'
81-3
fizgérg'aizg7fig;{§:°m
DAVID STROHM, TOM PATTERSON. RE;
CARL PASCARELLA, AIDA ALVAREZ, _
RAUL VAZQUEZ, DAVE TOMLINSON,
GRBYLOCK XII L.P.. OREYLOCK XII-A
owoo‘l
”mu—n—
GSX‘V’j
L.P., GREYLOCK XII PRINClPALS LLC,
.v-_._-t.a-a..r..
MAPACHE INVESTMENTS L.P. FUND
V. MADRONE PARTNERS, LP. and )
DOES 1-20, inclusive,
.
Defendant
3
NGMAU’
NNNMN
-r
cwaaam
'lVNISlt
so .._-..v.
Bllpulaflon & order '
was .I
~
28 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
may
Amxmm A! um
my; SCHEDULE - CASE No. CIV534431
um Man STIPULATION AND [Pnofi . so] ORDER 1‘0 MODIFY CLASS CERTIFICATION
- ... . ..... . .... .0 .. _.... . .. .. -...... .. .0... . . u...
WHEREAS, Plaintiffs Kerrigan Capital LLC and Ryan Keu‘igan, as Trustee for the
2 Kerrigan Family Trust (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) filed a putative class action against Defendants
3 David Strolnn, Tom Patterson, Carl Pascarella, Aida Alvarez, Raul Vazquez, Dave Tomlinson,
4 Greylock XII L.P., Gneylock XII~A L.P., Greylock XII Principals LLC, Mapache Investments LP.
5 Fund V, and Madrone Partners, LP. (collectively, “‘Defendants”);
6 WHEREAS, on August 19,- 2016, the Court set the following class certification briefing
7 schedule:
8 gig; ‘
Event
Plaintiffs to tile Motion for Class
9 October 20’ 2016 16:51-22:52;
“
M
12
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification
January 9, 2017
13
WHEREAS, Defendants believe it is necessary to first depose non~party James Gutierrez
14
in order to adequately oppose Plaintiffs' class certification motion;
15
WHEREAS, Defendants counsel and Mr. Gutierrez are not mutually available for
16
deposition before November 29, 2016;
17
WHEREAS, Defendants have proposed to depose Mr. Gutierrez on November 29,
18 E
December 1, December 6, or December 7, 20l6,
19
WHEREAS, Counsel for Plaintiffs are available to attend Mr. Gutierrez’s deposition on
20 i
-'
November 29, December 1, December 6, or December 7, 2016;
21
WHEREAS, Mr. Gutierrez has not confirmed his availability to attend Mr. Gutierrez's
22
deposition on November 29, December 1, December 6, or December 7, 2016;
23
Ill
24
Ill
25
26
27
28
Amum Ar Law
91/
tum Am:
SmutA'non AND [PRO an] Oman TO MODIFY CLASS CERTIFICATION SCHEDULE - CASE no. CIVS34431
1 Accordingly, the Parties hereby STIPULATB that the deadlines for clean certification are
2 Med as follows:
3 DELI: Even
Plam’afi’s to file Motion for Class
4 November 10, 2016
mags;
5 Last Day for Defendants to File Opposition to
December 21’ 2016
'
Motion for Class Certification
6 Last day for Plaintiffs to File Reply in Support
3W“? '0’ 30” ofMotion for Class Certification
7 January 31, 2017, at 1:30 p.m., or any other Hearing on Motion for Class Certification
8
time that week that is convenient for the Comt
9 ,‘I
m Dated: October-fl, 2016 go -
. ,
-_
ll Byi “. Avg; -.' 5111,;-
31'
1.2
Jessica V; nzuela Santamaria
13 Shawna V. Benfield
Jeffrey Lombard
i4
Attorneys)?» Defendants
'5 David Strohm. Tom Patterson, Aida Alvarez, Raul
Vazquez, Dave Tomlinson, Carl Pascarella
l6
I7
“‘f Dated: Octoberlé 20“ COTCHE'1'I‘,PI’1'RE&M¢CAR‘1'HY,LLP
19
02 A MK Say—~—
20 Mark C. Molumphy
Alexandra P. Summer
21. Stephanie 13. Biehl
22 '
Attorneys for Plaintwfs
23' ,
,4 IT IS SO ORDERED.
- , I
26
-
Dated: 6Z [(7
% /g2016 13/; IL '
Mt
yHon. Steven L. Dylina
27. Judge of the Superior Court
28
mm
"rumA! Law
PM M'W
STIPULATION AND [lfiopdsubydnosk TO Moonw CLASS Commemorq SCHEDULE - CASE NO. Clv534431
PROOF-OF SERVICE
‘19
I am employed in San Mateo County where service of the document(s)
b)‘ refeired to below occurred. I am over the age of 18 and :not a party to' the within
act1on My. business address 13 Cotchett, Pitre, & McCarthy, San FranCisco Airport
_
Center, 840 Malcolm Road, Suite 200, Bu111ngame CA 94010 I am readily
familiar with the 111111 "3? p1act1ces for the service of documents. On this date, I
served or caUsed to _be served a time copy of the followmg
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER RE: STIPULAT ION AND ORDER TO MODIFY
-
CLASS CERTIFICATION SCHEDULE
BY E- MAIL: By e-n1a‘il I caused: service of- this document(s) occurred
on the date shown below; This document is being served electronically and
the transmission was reported as complete and without eiro'r.
__BY MAIL: I placed a tine copy of the aforementioned document(s) in. a
sealed envelope with postaoefully paid. I am familiar with this firm’ 3
of collection and p1ocessmg of mail fCr' delively by the United
p1 "161106
States Postal Service on the same day in the ordinary course: of business.
I declarC under penalty of perjury, unde1 the laws of the State of Cahf01n1a '
1-?that. the foregomg 1s true. and cor1ect Execute rat’Burlmgame Callforma .Cn
October 19-, 2016.
.: ‘k‘~.
1;. \W. OFFICLb
C1)'1'1;111;'1",1 ' i "
i i j
P111121
& .\-11:C}\11"11'1Y LLP
1111.10.01?101‘s“SERXHCICLE‘’~
' '
,1’
SERVICE LIST
Jessica Valenzuela Santamaria ~BYEMAIL AND MAIL
Shawna V. Benfield Counselfor Defendants David Strohm, Tom
Jeffrey Lombard Patterson, Aida Alvarez, Raul Vazquez. Dave
COOLEY LLP Tomlinson
3175 Hanover Street
Palo Alto, CA 94304
Tel: (650) 843-5000
Fax: (650) 849-7400
Email: isantamaria@coolex.com
sbenfield@coolex.com
ilombard@gooley,com
Matty Schenker BYEWIL ONLY
COOLEY LLP
10 101 California Street, 5“1 Floor
San Francisco, CA 941] 1
ll Tel: (415) 693-2000
Fax: (415) 693-2222
12
Email: mschenker@cooley.com
13
Dan Bergeson BY EMUL AND WIL
14 Caroline McIntyre
'Bergeson LLP Counsel for Deféndants-Mapache Investments L.P.,'
15 2033 Gateway Place, Ste. 300 Madrone Partners, L. P. ,' Greylock )0], LR;
San Jose, CA 95110 Greylock XII-A LP. & Greylock Pinicipals LLC
l6 Tel: (408) 291-6200
Fax: (408)297-6000
17
Email: dbergeson@be-law.com
cmcin e be-law.com
18
19
20 Lyn R. Agre BY EMAIL AND IMAIL
Gunnar K. Martz
21 KASOWITZ, BENSON, TORRES & Counsel for Defendant Carl Pascarella
FRIEDMAN LLP
22 101 Califomia Street, Suite 2300
San Francisco, CA 94111
23
Tel: (415) 421-6140
24 Fax: (415) 398-5030
Email: Iagre@kasowitz.com
25 gmamkasowitzcom
26
27
28
LAW OFFICES
CO'l‘CHEIT, Pmua
& MCCARTHY, LLP PROOF OF SERVICE;
Preview
MARK C. MOLUMPHY (168009) FILEB ' mmolumphy@cp_mlegal.com ALEXANDRA P. SUMMER (266485) asunnner@cpmlegal.com SAN MATEO COUNTY COTCHE'IT, PITRE & MCCARTHY, LLP San Francisco Airport Office Center OCT 1 9 2015 840 Malcolm Road, Suite 200 \OOOQGMAUJNu—n Burlingame, California 94010 Telephone: (650) 697-6000 Facsimile: (650) 697-0577 Attorneys fbr Plaintifis Kerrigan Capital LLC and Ryan J: Kerrigan, ,as Trustee for the Kerrigan Family Trust SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN MATEO KERRIGAN CAPITAL LLC and RYAN J. ) Case No. CIV534431 KERRIGAN, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE ) KERRIGAN FAMILY TRUST, individually CLASS ACTION and on behalf of all others similarly situated, 3 ) NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER RE: Plaintiffs, ) STIPULATION AND ORDER TO MODIFY ) CLASS CERTIFICATION SCHEDULE vs. ) ‘ ) Complaint Filed: June 26, 2015 DAVID STROHM, TOM PATTERSON, ) CARL PASCARELLA, AIDA ALVAREZ, ) NNNNNNNND—‘D—ll—lt—Ot-fiI-dF—IHHH RAUL VAZQUEZ, DAVE TOMLINSON, ) fl FAX _ GREYLOCK XII L.P., GREYLOCK XII-A ) {EN \IONMALDNHOOOOVOXUI-wi-‘C L.P., GREYLOCK XII PRINCIPALS LLC, ) MAPACI-IE INVESTMENTS L.P. FUND V,) MADRONE PARTNERS, LP. and DOES ) 1-20, inclusive, ) %~ ) Defendants. ) ’/ { cwsfim‘ nflOl’deI \ NOE"; oi EnW 0‘ Judgme “‘i§i\\\\\\\\\\\\\l\\‘\\‘\\\\\\\\\\\\ 28 ' LAW OFFICES OF Corcnm’r, Pmua NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER; Case No. CIV534431 & MCCARTHY, LLP p—a T OALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: PLEASE TAKENOTICEthat on October 18, 2016, the Court entered.the;Stipulation and Order to Modify Ciass Certification Schedule. A true and Correct~ copy of the Order'isatlache'd liegreto'ra's- Exhibit A, Dated: October 19,2016 COT CHETT PITRE «St McCARTHY, LLP \ooo’xloxg‘z'unwp @QW ALEXANDRA P SUMMER Attorneysjbr Plaintiffs Kerrig‘cm Capital LLC and . Ryan J. .Kerrigan, as" 77:11.5'Ieef0r-Ihe .Kemtigan Fai‘n’ily’ Ti'us‘l \lmM-w-dO-Koooqox'm-bWNv-ao NMNN’NNI‘om—‘ew—HHHaxe-Ha. 28. LAW OFFICES OF CU'I'CI'II'Z'I'I‘, PITRE. NOTICE O'F‘ENTRY OF 'ORDERjCase No. CIV53_4431 & MCCAR’I'I w, LLP' EXHIBIT A suumwmnemnnv l- COOLEY LLP f- MARTIN S. SCHENKER (SBN 109828) 2 101 California Street, 5th Floor 0“, T 1 8 2015 San Francisco, CA 9411 I 3 Telephone: (4l5) 693-2000 _ Clarke 9 arm Facstmlle: (415) 693-2222 .33, 4 ' JESSICA VALENZUBLA SANTAMARIA (SBN 220934) 5 SHAWNA V. BENFIELD (SBN 290511) JEFFREY D. LOMBARD (SBN 285371) 6 3175 Hanover Street Palo Alto, CA 94304 7 Telephone: (650) 843—5 000 FacSImile: (650) 849-7400 8' \3 Attorneys for Defendants \\Li § 9 DA VID STROHM, TOM PA TTERS’ON, AIDA AL VAREZ, RA UL VAZQUEZ, DAVE TOMLHVSON. CARL PASCARELLA . SUPEMOWALIEQRMA \ - «a \I 10 Q“ 11 COUNTY OF SAN MATEO ' 12 13 - KERRIGAN CAPITAL LLC and RYAN J. KERRIGAN, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE No. CW534431 STIPULATION AND [PR os D] ORDER [ KERRIGAN FAMILY TRUST, individual‘ljy and on behalf of all others similarly situate , To MODIFY CLASS ,0 RTIF CATION 14 SCHEDULE _ 15 Plaintiff, Complaint Filed: June 26, 2015 16 V- ' 81-3 fizgérg'aizg7fig;{§:°m DAVID STROHM, TOM PATTERSON. RE; CARL PASCARELLA, AIDA ALVAREZ, _ RAUL VAZQUEZ, DAVE TOMLINSON, GRBYLOCK XII L.P.. OREYLOCK XII-A owoo‘l ”mu—n— GSX‘V’j L.P., GREYLOCK XII PRINClPALS LLC, .v-_._-t.a-a..r.. MAPACHE INVESTMENTS L.P. FUND V. MADRONE PARTNERS, LP. and ) DOES 1-20, inclusive, . Defendant 3 NGMAU’ NNNMN -r cwaaam 'lVNISlt so .._-..v. Bllpulaflon & order ' was .I ~ 28 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII may Amxmm A! um my; SCHEDULE - CASE No. CIV534431 um Man STIPULATION AND [Pnofi . so] ORDER 1‘0 MODIFY CLASS CERTIFICATION - ... . ..... . .... .0 .. _.... . .. .. -...... .. .0... . . u... WHEREAS, Plaintiffs Kerrigan Capital LLC and Ryan Keu‘igan, as Trustee for the 2 Kerrigan Family Trust (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) filed a putative class action against Defendants 3 David Strolnn, Tom Patterson, Carl Pascarella, Aida Alvarez, Raul Vazquez, Dave Tomlinson, 4 Greylock XII L.P., Gneylock XII~A L.P., Greylock XII Principals LLC, Mapache Investments LP. 5 Fund V, and Madrone Partners, LP. (collectively, “‘Defendants”); 6 WHEREAS, on August 19,- 2016, the Court set the following class certification briefing 7 schedule: 8 gig; ‘ Event Plaintiffs to tile Motion for Class 9 October 20’ 2016 16:51-22:52; “ M 12 Hearing on Motion for Class Certification January 9, 2017 13 WHEREAS, Defendants believe it is necessary to first depose non~party James Gutierrez 14 in order to adequately oppose Plaintiffs' class certification motion; 15 WHEREAS, Defendants counsel and Mr. Gutierrez are not mutually available for 16 deposition before November 29, 2016; 17 WHEREAS, Defendants have proposed to depose Mr. Gutierrez on November 29, 18 E December 1, December 6, or December 7, 20l6, 19 WHEREAS, Counsel for Plaintiffs are available to attend Mr. Gutierrez’s deposition on 20 i -' November 29, December 1, December 6, or December 7, 2016; 21 WHEREAS, Mr. Gutierrez has not confirmed his availability to attend Mr. Gutierrez's 22 deposition on November 29, December 1, December 6, or December 7, 2016; 23 Ill 24 Ill 25 26 27 28 Amum Ar Law 91/ tum Am: SmutA'non AND [PRO an] Oman TO MODIFY CLASS CERTIFICATION SCHEDULE - CASE no. CIVS34431 1 Accordingly, the Parties hereby STIPULATB that the deadlines for clean certification are 2 Med as follows: 3 DELI: Even Plam’afi’s to file Motion for Class 4 November 10, 2016 mags; 5 Last Day for Defendants to File Opposition to December 21’ 2016 ' Motion for Class Certification 6 Last day for Plaintiffs to File Reply in Support 3W“? '0’ 30” ofMotion for Class Certification 7 January 31, 2017, at 1:30 p.m., or any other Hearing on Motion for Class Certification 8 time that week that is convenient for the Comt 9 ,‘I m Dated: October-fl, 2016 go - . , -_ ll Byi “. Avg; -.' 5111,;- 31' 1.2 Jessica V; nzuela Santamaria 13 Shawna V. Benfield Jeffrey Lombard i4 Attorneys)?» Defendants '5 David Strohm. Tom Patterson, Aida Alvarez, Raul Vazquez, Dave Tomlinson, Carl Pascarella l6 I7 “‘f Dated: Octoberlé 20“ COTCHE'1'I‘,PI’1'RE&M¢CAR‘1'HY,LLP 19 02 A MK Say—~— 20 Mark C. Molumphy Alexandra P. Summer 21. Stephanie 13. Biehl 22 ' Attorneys for Plaintwfs 23' , ,4 IT IS SO ORDERED. - , I 26 - Dated: 6Z [(7 % /g2016 13/; IL ' Mt yHon. Steven L. Dylina 27. Judge of the Superior Court 28 mm "rumA! Law PM M'W STIPULATION AND [lfiopdsubydnosk TO Moonw CLASS Commemorq SCHEDULE - CASE NO. Clv534431 PROOF-OF SERVICE ‘19 I am employed in San Mateo County where service of the document(s) b)‘ refeired to below occurred. I am over the age of 18 and :not a party to' the within act1on My. business address 13 Cotchett, Pitre, & McCarthy, San FranCisco Airport _ Center, 840 Malcolm Road, Suite 200, Bu111ngame CA 94010 I am readily familiar with the 111111 "3? p1act1ces for the service of documents. On this date, I served or caUsed to _be served a time copy of the followmg NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER RE: STIPULAT ION AND ORDER TO MODIFY - CLASS CERTIFICATION SCHEDULE BY E- MAIL: By e-n1a‘il I caused: service of- this document(s) occurred on the date shown below; This document is being served electronically and the transmission was reported as complete and without eiro'r. __BY MAIL: I placed a tine copy of the aforementioned document(s) in. a sealed envelope with postaoefully paid. I am familiar with this firm’ 3 of collection and p1ocessmg of mail fCr' delively by the United p1 "161106 States Postal Service on the same day in the ordinary course: of business. I declarC under penalty of perjury, unde1 the laws of the State of Cahf01n1a ' 1-?that. the foregomg 1s true. and cor1ect Execute rat’Burlmgame Callforma .Cn October 19-, 2016. .: ‘k‘~. 1;. \W. OFFICLb C1)'1'1;111;'1",1 ' i " i i j P111121 & .\-11:C}\11"11'1Y LLP 1111.10.01?101‘s“SERXHCICLE‘’~ ' ' ,1’ SERVICE LIST Jessica Valenzuela Santamaria ~BYEMAIL AND MAIL Shawna V. Benfield Counselfor Defendants David Strohm, Tom Jeffrey Lombard Patterson, Aida Alvarez, Raul Vazquez. Dave COOLEY LLP Tomlinson 3175 Hanover Street Palo Alto, CA 94304 Tel: (650) 843-5000 Fax: (650) 849-7400 Email: isantamaria@coolex.com sbenfield@coolex.com ilombard@gooley,com Matty Schenker BYEWIL ONLY COOLEY LLP 10 101 California Street, 5“1 Floor San Francisco, CA 941] 1 ll Tel: (415) 693-2000 Fax: (415) 693-2222 12 Email: mschenker@cooley.com 13 Dan Bergeson BY EMUL AND WIL 14 Caroline McIntyre 'Bergeson LLP Counsel for Deféndants-Mapache Investments L.P.,' 15 2033 Gateway Place, Ste. 300 Madrone Partners, L. P. ,' Greylock )0], LR; San Jose, CA 95110 Greylock XII-A LP. & Greylock Pinicipals LLC l6 Tel: (408) 291-6200 Fax: (408)297-6000 17 Email: dbergeson@be-law.com cmcin e be-law.com 18 19 20 Lyn R. Agre BY EMAIL AND IMAIL Gunnar K. Martz 21 KASOWITZ, BENSON, TORRES & Counsel for Defendant Carl Pascarella FRIEDMAN LLP 22 101 Califomia Street, Suite 2300 San Francisco, CA 94111 23 Tel: (415) 421-6140 24 Fax: (415) 398-5030 Email: Iagre@kasowitz.com 25 gmamkasowitzcom 26 27 28 LAW OFFICES CO'l‘CHEIT, Pmua & MCCARTHY, LLP PROOF OF SERVICE;