Preview
1 GLYNN ti'c FINLEY, LLP
CLEMENT L. GLYNN, Bar No. 57117
2 ROBERT C. PHELPS, Bar No. 106666
MORGAN K. LOPEZ, Bar No. 215513
ELECTRONICALLY
3 One Walnut Creek Center
100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500 F I L E D
4 Walnut Creek, CA 94596 Superior Court of California,
County of San Francisco
Telephone: (925) 210-2800
5 Facsitnile: (925) 945-1975 09/24/2019
Email: cglynn@glynnf|nlcy.corn Clerk of the Court
BY: YOLANDA TABO-RAMIREZ
6 bphelps(eglynnf&nley.corn Deputy Clerk
mlopezNlglynnftnley.corn
7
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant/Plaintiff
8 Shirley Hwang
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10 FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
11
) Lead Case No. CGC-10-503332
12 COMMONWEALTH LAND TITI.E ) (Consolidated for all purposes with
INSURANCE COMPANY, ) CGC-11-512102)
13 )
Plaintiff, )
14 ) DECLARATION OF ROBERT C.
vs. ) PHELPS IN SUPPORT OF SHIRLEY S.
15 ) HWANG'S REPLY BRIEF IN
FEDEX OI'FICE AND PRINT SFRVICES ) SUPPORT OI&'OTION TO AMEND
16 INC WINSTON LUM; KAIJSHAL ) JUDGMV&.NT TO ADD JUDGMENT
NIROULA; JAY CHANDRAKANT ) DEBTORS
SHAH; ELVIA PALOMINO; MORAD ) (Code of Civil Procedure, section 187)
AFRAIMI; MELVIN LEE EMERICH; )
18 MARTINI CHNOOGLE GRACHELLE ) Date: October I, 2019
LANGUBAN; MERCHANTS BONDING ) Time: 10:00 a.m.
COMPANY, and DOES 1-24, ) Dept.: 303
)
20 Defendants. )
)
21 )
SHIRLEY S. HWANG, )
22 ) CASF. NO. CGC-11-512102
Plaintiff, )
23 )
vs.
24
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICFS )
25 INC,, WINSTON LUM, KAUSHAL )
NIROULA, JAY CHANDRAKANT SHAH, )
26 MELVIN LEE EMERICH, GRACHELLE )
LANGUBAN, and MARTINI & )
27 CHNOOGLE, and DOES 1-50, )
)
28 Cross-Defendants. )
)
DECL. OF R. PHELPS ISO PLTFF HWANG'S MTN TO ADD JUDGMENT DEBTORS
I I, ROBERT C. PHELPS, say:
2 l. I am Of Counsel to the law firm of Glynn & Finley, LLP, counsel of record for
3 plaintiff Shirley S. Hwang. I know the following facts of my own personal knowledge and if
4 called upon could and would competently testify thereto.
5 2. Mrudula Shah was personally served with the TRO and Order to Show Cause related
6 to this inotion on August 30, 2019. Chandrakant Shah was personally served with the TRO and
7 Order to Show Cause related to this motion on September 1, 2019. Attached hereto as Exhibits
8 A and B are true copies of the Proofs of Service on Chandrakant and Mrudula Shah.
9 3. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of the listing of attorneys of
10 record in this action, I printed on September 23, 2019, from this Court's Register of Actions.
11 This document lists Craig Bassett, Esq., as counsel for Jay Shah and Elvis Palomino in this case.
12 4. Attached hereto are true copies of the following proofs of service made on Mr.
13 Bassett as counsel for Jay Shah and the dates on which service was made:
14 Exhibit Document Date Served
15 D POS —Plaintiff s Moving Papers 8/15/19
16 E POS —Plaintiff s TRO application 8/15/19
17 F POS —Notice of Entry of TRO 8/20/19
18 G POS —Notice of Continuance of hearing 8/29/19
19 5. At no time has Mr. Bassett or anyone on his behalf notified Counsel for Plaintiff that
20 Mr. Bassett is no longer representing Jay Shah. The Register of Actions contains no similar
21 notice to the Court; nor does it indicate that Mr. Bassett file a motion to relieved as counsel.
22 6. Attached hereto as Exhibit H is a true and correct copy of the preliminary injunction
23 entered in Jay Shah's criminal case.
24 ///
25 ///
26 ///
27 ///
28 ///
-1—
DECL. OF R. PHELPS 1SO PLTFF HWANG'S MTN TO ADD JUDGMENT DEBTORS
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
foregoing is true and correct Executed this 24th day of September, 2019, at Walnut Creek,
California.
Robert C, Phelps
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-2-
DECL. OF R. PHELPS ISO PLTFF HWANG'S MTN TO ADD JUDGMENT DEBTORS
EXHIBIT A
leo/coy ov peels vllsocc Asolocyl For Cocci lla Doly
CLEMENT GLYNN ESQ, Bar «$ 7117
GLYNN 41 PINI.EY, LLP
100 PRINGLE AVENUE. SUITE $ 00
WALNUT CREEK, CA 94$ 96
rchys Iro 925 210-2e00 ¹4/I He: 925414$ vI 975
arf II o. oc r¹c Has
4cc~foa Cross Defendant I HWANG/FEDEX
Ioccrl eeoc efccvrl, ooe Jorlclol Dree Icl ocd arawn ccwrl
SAN FRANCISCO Countv SUPERIOR Court
Crow Ccotrlacoa: COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY
crea Dc/saevvl FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC., st al,
PROOF OF SERVICE Hcorlcs Deu: nial Dcpvolvc Cwc lnmta'l
PROOF OF SERVICE CGC-10-503332
l. 4I Ihc dae ojrocvloc I woe or /carl ldyrors ojogc ond nor o penly lo Ihh ocrlon
2, I smved oopies of the Order Onm¹ng Plalntiif ShMay 5Hwssg' Appllostion For Temporary Restraining Orden (hd¹ To Show
Causa; Notice Of Continusnoe Of Shirley S. Hwnng's Motion To Amend The Judgment To Add Judgnunu Debtors; Momorandu Of
Points And Authodtles ln Support Of Phuntlif Shirley S. Hwang's Motion To Amend Judgment To Add Judgnmat Debtors;
I?oclaretlon Of Morgan K. Lopez ln Support Of Shirley S. Hwsng's Motion To Amend Judgment To Add Judgment Debts; Request
For Judloial Nodus ln Support OI'Flaintitf Shlrloy S. Hwsng's Modon To Amend Judgment To Add Judgmsot Debtors
J.u porgr served:
d 4dchurs where Ihc polly w¹c salved: 26725 SHADY OAKS COURT
LOS ALTOS HILLS. CA 94022
R I served Ihe portyl
a, bypemonsl servke. I pemoaeliy delivered tho documents listed In Item 2 to the party or person uthnoimd to resolve
prooms for tho party ( I) on: Prl., Aug. 30, 2019 (2) at. 2:38PM
7.Person Iyho Served Paperer accovasslc coll ta ccr Isa?.5(sxsxu)
a. GABRIEL ARAOON d, The Peejhr Service was: $ 163.'/5
h. Ons Hour Delivery Sorvlse e. I am: (3)rogistmed California pmoess server
2920 Csmino Diablo Ste, 100 fi) Independent Contrsotor
WALNUT CREEK, CA 94$ 97 IN) /Icgtr/radon No.l 1623
e. 92$ -9474470. FAX 92$ -947.3490 fll 0Co¹¹(vl SANTA CLARA
g.
/'on
I declare under pe¹e/ty ojperj¹ry ~or die lorna njlhe Sleet ejC¹gfer¹le ther/he)orcgol
Deter T¹e, Sefs OK 2819
atkli@N'ttcv )Ssoccr t, tarr
r \
tc
*
tr¹e e¹doelreca
%)/JJ ubvweellal
EXHIBIT B
saaeesy or yany esesaw sseeasyu rc cawe Uu tsety
CLEMENT GLYNN ESQ, Bar 657117
GLYNN 4 FINLEY, LLP
100 PRINGLE AVENUE, SUITE 500
WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596
yweseeaurla 925.210.2SN yetglrw 925-945 197 5
save eyfae: Ctuss Delcndsnt
tawn eaeu cfcasn, cnd Jseseul Dlcera esw Aweek ceca;
SAN FRANCISCO Countv SUPERIOR Court
c ee c vtssesvsue COMMONWEALTH LAND TITI,E INSURANCE COMPANY
Crees tse'ceavve FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC., ct al,
esoovovessvscs Case lveseteee
PROOF OF SERVICE CGC-10.503332
A dr sAs lieu ofarrvau 7 was ar least I g Jeers qfage and nas a parry Sa sais acsloes
2. Applicatien Por Temporary Rcsualnlng Ordor Order To Show
I served copies oftho Ordor Granting Platnttif Shirley S. Hwang'
Gmss; Notice Of Continuance Of Shirley S. Hwang's Motion To Amond Tho Judgment To Add Judgnumt Debtors; Mcmorandu Of
Points And Authoritlcs In Support Of Plalntllf Shirley S. Hwang's Motion To Amend Judgnumt To Add Judgment Debtors;
Dcolaradon Of Morgan K. Lopes In Support Of Shirley S. Hwant(s Motion To Amend Judgmem To Add Judgment Dobtors; R«iuast
For Judicial Notice In Support Of Plalntllf Shirley S. Hwsng's Motion To Amend Judgment To Add Judgment Debtors
J.a Partyserved: CHANDRAKANT SHAH
4 ddeswss whew (tu parry was served 26725 SHADY OAKS COURT
LOS ALTOS HILLS, CA 94022
J. Jsvreudrtupuery;
a by personal scyvtae,I personally delivered the document listed In item 2 to tbs party or parson authortz«l to tscolve
pmccss for the party (I) on: Sun., Sep. 01, 2019 (2) st: 7t 19PM
7. Pceacn Wka Served popeyes acevewecle Ccn vcr Ccy 1 Os).stsXsXai
* GABRIEL ARAGON d, TAe Pcefay grrvlcs was: $ 163,75
b, Oue Ilour Delivery Ssyvtce c, I sm: (3)rcgistsmd California pmctcu sorver
2920 Csmlno Diablo Ste. 100 i)J Indepondsnt Contractor
WALNUT CREEK, Ch 94597 fli)Registration Ãtst 1623
u. 925-947.3470, FAX 925a)47.34$ 0 dtl) Coeaepc SANTA CLARA
g. ad cprred,
J declare aeedew pena((y afpcsfssry under lhc Anew epsna State elf Cent(ferule dwr sAejcragclng
Dares 7)ee, Sass 0$, JN9
sale atk.loglgievlcslwer L scot N88$ 8f SNI8
'"" """ * Wsss ~esses
EXHIBIT C
Contact Us
THE SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
Case Number: CGC10503332
Title: COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY VS. FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC et al (PROVIDE
ACCESS)
Cause of Action: FRAUD
Generated: 2019-09-23 9:07 am
Register of Actions Parties Attorneys Calendar Payments Documents
Attorneys
Show ~AS r enlnes Searcm
ear
Name Address and Phone Number Paltres Represented
Number
AUSTIN, TODD M. 232355 CLINTON it CLINTON FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC (CROSS COMPLAINANT)
100 OCEANGATE, 14TH FLOOR
LONG BEACH. CA 90802
562-2H!-5000
BASSETT, CRAIG JAY 106825 CRAIG J BASSETT PALOMINO, ELVIA (SUED AS PALIMINO. ELVIA) (DEFENDANT)
25 W FIRST STREET SHAH, JAY CHANDRAKANT (APPELLANT)
MORGAN HILL, CA 950374559 SHAH, JAY CHANDRAKANT (DEFENDANT)
409-779-0007
BRODY. HOINARD P 065307 FIDELITY NATIONAL LAW GROUP COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (PLAINTIFF)
915 145LSHIRE BOULEVARD HWANG, SHIRLEY S. (PLAINTIFF)
SUITE 2100
LQS ANGELES CA 90017
2(3138.44(4
BUSCH, RICHARD 102632 9
LAW OFFICES OF RICHARD MERCHANTS BONDING COMPANY (DEFENDANT)
BUSCH MERCHANTS BONDING COMPANY (INTERPLEADER)
2660 TOIAINSGATE RD STE 400
INESTLAKE VILLAGE, CA 91361
805-222-4234
CANNATA, THERESE YVONNE 088032 O'OOLE LLP'8
CANNATA, CHING It
100 PINE ST STE 350
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111
415-409-8900
CHING MICHAEL M. 209426 6 0'TQQLE, LLP
OANNATA, CHING
100 PINE STREET
SUITE 1775
SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
415-409.8900
CLINTON, DAVID A. 150107 CLINTON Ii CLINTON FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC (DEFENDANT)
100 OCEANGATE, 14TH FLOOR
LONG BEACH, CA 90802
562-216-5000
COOK, LARRY L. 2M W.CYPRESS CREEK
RD,STE210
FDRT LAUDERDALE, FL 33309
954-453-4892
EMERICH, MELVIN LEE 118180 209 PORTOLA CT EMERICH MELVIN LEE (DEFENDANT)
LOS ALTOS, CA 94022
415-949-4377
FONG, JERRY YEE 099673 CAREV 6 CAREV
P.o. BOX 1040
PALO ALTO, CA 94302
415-326-5510
Bar
Name Address and Phone Numbe Parbs Represented
~ umber
GLYNN CLEMENT LEO 057117 G LYNN8 FINLEY LLP COMMONIIIIEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (PLAINTIFF)
ONE WALNUT CREEK CENTER HWANG, SHIRLEY (CROSS DEFENDANT)
100 PRINGLE AVE, SUITE 500 HWANG, SHIRLEY S. (CROSS COMPLAINANT)
WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596 HWANG, SHIRLEY S. (PLAINTIFF)
925-210-2800
KUNNES, EDWARD A 160632 100 N. Wl GET LANE, SUITE 150 COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (CROSS
WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596 DEFENDANT)
925-930-9550 COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (PLAINTIFF)
HWANG, SHIRLEY S. (PLAINTIFF)
LONG, SCOTT D, 203505 FIDELITY NATIONAL LAIN GROUP COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (PLAINTIFF)
1550 PARKSIDE DRIVE HWANG, SHIRLEY S. (PLAINTIFF)
STE 300
WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596
925-930-9550
MOSS, BRIDGET M. 123652 FIDELITY NATIONAL LAW GROUP
91 5 WILSHIRE BOULEVARD
SUITE 2100
LOS ANGELES, CA 90017
213-438-7200
SCHAFFER, DYLANL 153612 KERLEY SCHAFFER LLP
STREET
I 939 HARRISON
SUITE 500
OAKLAND, CA 94612
510.379.5801
SMITH, MICHAEL L. 217751 MANNING 8 KASS, ELLROD, FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC (DEFENDANT)
RAMIREZ. TRESTER LLC
2 RINCON CENTER
121 SPEAR ST. STE 200
SAN FRANCISCO, CA 941 05
41 5-21 7-6990
TRESTER, FREDROC W. 096228 MANNING 8 KASS ELLROD, FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC (CROSS COMPLAINANT)
RAMIREZ, TRESTER LLP FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES, INC (CROSS DEFENDANT)
121 SPEAR STREET, SUITE 200
SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94105
415-217-6990
Showing1 entries
lo 17 of 17 Previous I Next
EXHIBIT D
I GLYNN & FINLEY, LLP
CLEMENT L. GLYNN, Bar No. 57117
2 MORGAN K. LOPEZ, Bar No. 215513
One Walnut Creek Center
3 100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500 ELECTRONICALLY
4
Walnut Creek, CA 94596
Telephone: (925) 210-2800
F I LED
Supertor Court of Colltomta,
Facsimile: (925) 945-1975 County at San Praneieeo
5
08/15/2019
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant/Plaintiff Clerk of the Court
6 Shirley Hwang BY: DAVID YUEN
Deputy Clerk
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
10
Lead Case No, CGC-10-503332
11 COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE (Consolidated for all purposes with
INSURANCE COMPANY, CGC-11-512102)
12
Plaintiff,
13 ) PROOF OF SERVICE BY U.S. MAIL
vs. )
14 )
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES ) Date: September 9, 2019
INC4 WINSTON LUM; KAUSHAL ) Time: 10:00 a.m,
NIROULA; JAY CHANDRAKANT ) Dept.: 303
16 SHAH; ELVIA PALOMINO; MORAD )
AFRAIMI; MELVIN LEE EMERICH; )
17 MARTINI CHNOOGLE GRACI-IELLE )
LANGUBAN; MERCHANTS BONDING )
COMPANY, and DOES 1-24, )
)
19 Defendants, )
20
SHIRLEY S. HWANG, )
21 ) CASE NO. CGC-11-512102
Plaintiff, )
)
vs. )
23 )
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES )
24 INC WINSTON LUM KAUSHAL )
NIROULA, JAY CHANDRAKANT SHAH, )
MELVIN LEE EMERICI-I, GRACHELLE
LANGUBAN, and MARTINI &
26 CHNOOGLE, and DOES 1-50, )
)
27 Cross-Defendants, )
)
28 )
POS BY US MAIL RE FTIFF SHIRLEY HWANG'S MOTION TO ADD JUDGMENT DEBTORS
I, Ciina M. Bcntlev, the undersigned, hereby certify and declare under penalty
ot'
perjury that the following statements are true and correct:
1. I am over the age of 18 years and am not a party to the within cause.
2. My business address is One Walnut Creek Center, 100 Pringle Avenue,
5 Suite 500, Walnut Creek, CA 94596.
3, I am familiar with my employer's mail collection and processing practices;
7 know that said mail is collected and deposited with the United States Postal Service on the same
day it is deposited in interoffice mail; and know that postage thereon is fully prepaid.
4, Following said practice, on August 15, 2019 I served a true and correct
10 copy of the attached document entitled exactly:
PI,AINTIFF SIIIRLKY S. IIWAN( S NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO
AMFND THF,,IUDGMKN'I'I'0 ADD JUDGMKNT l)KBTORS;
12
MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF
13 I'I,AliV'I'I Iris Sl I IRLKY S. I I WANG'S MOTION TO AMEND JUDGMENT TO ADD
JUD('IVIIIN'I'L&lpl'ORS(Co&le of Civil I'roccdurc, section 187l
14
DECI,ARATION OF MORGAN I(. LOPEZ IN SUPPOR f OF SIIIRLKY S.
15 IIWAN(P&I MO'I'ION 'I'0 AMEND .IUI)GMKN'I'O ADD JUDGMENT DKBTOIIS
(Co&le of Civil Proccdurc. section 1871; AND
16
Itl(O(IEST FOR,IUDICIAI, NOTICII IN SUPPORT OF I'LAINTII&F SIIIRLKY S.
17 HtVANG'S MO'I'ION 'I'0 AMEND JUDGMENT TO ADD JUDGMENT 1)KII'I'OIIS
(Co&le of Civil Procc&lnrc. ace&ion 1871
18
by placing it in an addressed, sealed envelope and depositing it in regularly maintained
19
interoffice mail to the following;
20
Craig Jay Bassett Yauheni V. Halavanau
21 Attorney at Law Law Offices of Gene Halavanau
25 W. First Street 55 Francisco Street, Suite 403
22 Morgan Ilill, CA 95037 San Francisco, CA 94133-2115
T: 408-779-0007; F: 408-778-6005 T; 415-692-5301; F: 415-692-8412
23 Email; cbassettQagarlic.corn Email: gene halavanau.corn
Attorney for Defendants Elvia Palomino and Association of Coansel for Defendant
24 Jay Chandrakant Shah Jay Chandrakant Shah
25 Executed this 15th day of Ant~oat 2 I't Walnut Creek, California
26
27 (Piina M. Bcntlcy
28
-1-
POS BY US MAIL RB PTIFF Sl IIi&1.EY JIWANG'S MOTION TO ADD JUDGMENT DBBTOl(S
EXHIBIT E
GLYNN & FINLEY, LLP
CLEMENT L. GLYNN, Bar No. 57117
MORGAN K. LOPEZ, Bar No. 215513
One Walnut Creek Center ELECTRONICALLY
100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500
Walnut Creek, CA 94596 FILED
superior Court of Cofffomio,
Telephone: (925) 210-2800 Coun(y of San Francisco
Facsimile: (925) 945-1975
08/15/2019
Clerk of the Court
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant/Plaintiff BY:YANassnwe
Shirley Hwang Deputy Clurlr
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
10
) Lead Case No, CGC-10-503332
11 COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE ) (Consolidated for all purposes with
INSURANCE COMPANY, ) CGC-11-512102)
12 )
Plaintiff, )
13 ) PROOIt'F Sf&.RVICK BY
vs. ) ELEC'I'RONIC MAIL
14 )
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES )
15 INC4 WINSTON LUM; KAUSHAL )
NIROULA; JAY CHANDRAKANT )
16 SHAH; ELVIA PALOMINO; MORAD )
AFRAIMI; MELVIN LEE EMERICH; )
17 MARTINI CHNOOGLE; GRACHELLE )
LANGUBAN; MERCHANTS BONDING )
18 COMPANY, and DOES 1-24, )
)
19 Defendants. )
)
20 )
SHIRLEY S. HWANG, )
21 ) CASE NO. CGC-11-512102
Plaintiff, )
22 )
vs. )
23 )
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES )
24 INC., WINSTON LUM, KAUSHAL )
NIROULA, JAY CHANDRAKANT SHAH, )
25 MELVIN LEE EMERICH, GRACHELLE )
LANGUBAN, and MARTINI & )
26 CHNOOGLE, and DOES 1-50, )
)
27 Cross-Defendants. )
)
)
POS BY ELECTRONIC MAIL RE PTIFF SHIRLEY HWANO'S EX PARTE APP FOR TRO
I, Gina Bentlev, the undersigned, declare:
l. 1am, and was at the time of service of the documents herein referred to,
3 over the age of 18 years, and not a party to the action;
2. 1am employed in the County of Contra Costa, California;
3. My e-mail address is ahcntlcvAa,elvnniinlcv.corn and my business address
6 is One Walnut Creek Center, 100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500, Walnut Creek, CA 94596.
4. On the date executed below, I electronically served the following
8 document(s);
PLAINTIFF SHIRLEY S, HWANG'S KX PARTE APPLICATION FOR
TEMPORARY RESTRATNING ORDER
10
PLAINTIFF SHIRLEY S. HWANG'S MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
AUTHORITIKS IN SUPPORT OF SHIRLEY S, HWANG'S EX PARTE
APPLICATION FOR TEMPORARY RESTRATNING ORDER
12
DECLARATION OF MORGAN K. LOPEZ IN SUPPORT OF
13 SHIRLEY S. HWANG'S KX PARTE APPLICATION
FOR TEMPORARY RESTRATNING ORDER; and
14
[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAITNIIrF SHIRLEY S. HWANG'S
15 APPLICAT'ION FOR TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER
16 on the recipients designated below:
1 7 Craig Jay Bassett Yauheni V. Halavanau
Attorney at Law Law Offices of Gene Halavanau
18 25 W, First Street 55 Francisco Street, Suite 403
Morgan Hill, CA 95037 San Francisco, CA 94133-2115
19 T. 408-779-0007; F; 408-778-6005 T: 415-692-5301; F: 415-692-8412
Email, cbassctt@garlic.corn Email: gene halavanau.corn
20 Attorney for Defendanrs Elvia Palomino anil Associarlon of Coarisel for Defendant
Jay Chandrakanr Shah Jay Chandrakanl Shah
21
22 Through OneLegal Filing Service and pursuant to the San Francisco Superior Court Local Rules
23 A copy of the filing receipt will be maintained with the document(s) in our office.
24 1declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the laws of the State of California that the
25 foregoing is true and correct. Executed on this f Auaust, 2019 at Walnut Creek,
26 California.
27 !Gina Bentley
28
-2-
POS BY ELECTRONIC MAlL RF PTIFF SIIIRLEY HWANO'S EX PARTE APP FOR TRO
EXHIBIT F
I GLYNN & FINLEY, LLP
CLEMENT L. GLYNN, Bar No. 57117
2 MORGAN K. LOPEZ, Bar No. 215513
One Walnut Creek Center
ELECTRONICALLY
3 100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500
Walnut Creek, CA 94596 FILED
Superior Courf of Coliforrrle,
4 Telephone; (925) 210-2800 County o(Sen Prencleoo
Facsimile: (925) 945-1975
5 08/20/2019
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant/Plaintiff Clerk of the Court
BY: MADONNA CARANTO
6 Shirley Hwang Deputy Clerk
8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
9 IN AND FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
10
Lead Case No, CGC-10-503332
11 COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE (Consolidated for all purposes with
INSURANCE COMPANY, CGC-11-512102)
12
Plaintiff NO'I'ICK OF KNTRY OF ORDER
13 GRANTING I'LAIN'I'IPR SIIIRLKY S.
vs. I I WANG'S APPLICATION Il'OR
14 TKMI'GEARY RESTRAINING ORI)IIR
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES
INC.; WINSTON LUM; KAUSHAL
NIROULA; JAY CHANDRAKANT
16 SHAH ELVIA PALOMINO MORAD
AFRAIMI; MELVIN LEE EMERICH;
MARTINI CHNOOGLE; GRACHELLE
LANGUBAN; MERCHANTS BONDING Original Trial Date: August 7, 2017
18 COMPANY, and DOES 1-24,
19 Defendants.
20
SHIRLEY S. HWANG, ) CASE NO. CGC-11-512102
21
P laintiff,
)
vs. )
23
FEDEX OFFICE AND PRINT SERVICES
24 INC WINSTON LUM, KAUSHAL )
NIROULA, JAY CHANDRAKANT SHAH, )
25 MELVIN LEE EMERICH, GRACHELLE )
LANGUBAN, and MARTINI & )
26 CHNOOGLE, and DOES 1-50, )
)
27 Cross-Defendants. )
28
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER GRANTING PLTl'V R HWANG'S APP. FOR TRO
1 TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on August 16, 2019, the above-entitled Court
entered the attached Order Granting Plaintiff Shirley Hwang's Application for Temporary
Restraining Order.
Dated; August 16, 2019 GLYNN &, FINLEY, LLP
CLEMENT L, GLYNN
MORGAN K, LOPEZ
One Walnut Creek Center
100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500
Walnut Creek, CA 94596
10
Shirley S. Hwang
12
13
14
15
16
17
19
20
21
22