Preview
19CV348656 on 8/12/2020 8:45 AM
Santa Clara — Civil Reviewed By: R. Burciaga
Case #19CV348656 R. Burciaga
Envelope: 4749688
\
RICHARD DOYLE, City Attorney (#88625 Filed
NORA FRIMANN, Assistant City Attorney #! 93249) August 18, 2020
WESLEY KLIMCZAK, Senior Deputy City {torn e pens) Clerk of the Court
VANCE CHANGE, Deputy City Attorney (#29165 Superior Court of CA
San Jose City Attorney’s Office
200 East Santa Clara Street, 16" Floor County of Santa Clara
San José, California 95113-1905 19CV348656
Telephone Number: (408) 535-1900 By: fmiller
Facsimile Number: (408) 998-3131
E-Mail Address: cao.main@sanjoseca.go
Attorneys for CITY OF SAN JOSE
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA
UNLIMITED CIVIL DIVISION
10
11 CITY OF SAN JOSE, a municipal Case Number: 19-cv-348656
corporation;
12
Plaintiff, ORDER
13 APPOINTING RECEIVER
Vv.
14
AGNES LOPES, an individual; THE AGNES
15 LOPES TRUST, by and through trustee
Agnes Lopes; and DOES 1-10, inclusive,
16
Defendants.
17
18
19
20
{PROPOSED} ORDER APPOINTING A RECEIVER
21
Petitioner, City of San Jose (City) filed a Petition with the Court for the appointment
22
of a receiver concerning real property described in the City's moving papers and
23
commonly known as 4163 Piper Drive in San Jose, California, APN Number 299-
24
14-044 (Subject Property). The Subject Property consists of a single-family residence
25
that is currently occupied. Right, title, and interest to the property belong to Agnes Lopes
26
and the Agnes Lopes trust, both of whom were properly served with the Complaint and
27
this Motion and are on notice of the City’s intent to seek a receiver in this action. The
28
current occupant of the Property, Steven Lopes was also separately provided notice.
The Motion was made pursuant to Health and Safety Code section 17980.7(c)
and Code of Civil Procedure section 564 et seq. The Court, in the exercise of its legal
and equitable powers, having jurisdiction over the subject matter of the Petition and
having considered the evidence and the memorandum of points and authorities
submitted in support of the Motion, finds and orders as follows:
A. FINDINGS OF FACT
dl Agnes Lopes and the Agnes Lopes Trust are the Owners of the Property
which is the subject of these proceedings, and is commonly known as 4163 Piper Drive
10 in San Jose, California.
11 2 The Property is currently being maintained in such a condition as to violate
12
the Health & Safety Code and the San Jose Municipal Code.
13
3 The Subject Property is substandard as defined under California Health
14
and Safety Code section 17920.3 and constitutes a public nuisance.
15
4 The violations are so extensive and of such a nature that the health and
16
safety of the occupants, neighboring residents, and the general public is substantially
17
endangered pursuant to Health and Safety Code section 17980.6.
18
5. The City, as a local enforcement agency, properly issued Notices of
19
Violations and Orders to Abate directed to Lopes on multiple occasions.
20
21
6 Neither Lopes, nor any other interested party, has complied with the
22 Notices of Violations and Orders to Abate the Property within a reasonable time after
23 their issuance.
24 7 Lopes has been afforded a reasonable opportunity to correct the
25 conditions cited in said Notices of Violations and Orders.
26 8 Lopes was afforded all of the procedural due process rights guaranteed by
27 the California Constitution and the United States Constitution.
28 9 The substandard conditions at the Subject Property will likely persist
unless the Court appoints a receiver to take possession of the Subject Property and
undertake responsibility for its rehabilitation.
10. The City is the prevailing party in this matter and as such is entitled to its
attorneys’ fees and costs pursuant to Health and Safety Code §§ 17980.7(c)(11) and
17980.7(d)(1).
aie Health and Safety Code §§ 17960-17992 (Div. 13, Pt 1.5, Ch. 5, Art 1-3)
authorize the City to enforce the State Housing Law and to institute this special
proceeding.
fl: California Health and Safety Code section 17980.7(c), Code of Civil
10
Procedure section 564 et seq. and the Court's inherent equitable power authorize the
11
Court to appoint a receiver to take possession of the Subject Property and undertake
12
rehabilitation or demolition (Rehabilitation).
13
13. Lopes and all other interested parties were properly noticed and served
14
15 with the Motion and were provided a reasonable opportunity to be heard in connection
16 with the Motion.
17 14. Health and Safety Code § 17983 authorizes the Court to make “any order”
18 for which an application is made pursuant to Health and Safety Code §§ 17980-17992.
19 15. Pursuant to Health and Safety Code § 17992, any person who obtains an
20 ownership interest in the subject Property after notice of pendency of this action was
21 recorded shall be subject to any order to correct the violations cited herein.
22 16. California Receivership Group, Inc., a California Benefit Corporation,
23 through its President, Mark S. Adams, Esq., the nominee of the City, has demonstrated
24
the capacity and expertise to undertake and supervise a viable financial and
25
construction plan for the Subject Property’s rehabilitation.
26
Nite The Court finds that, given the severity and amount of work necessary to
27
abate the violations on the Property, the appointment of a receiver is a necessary
28
measure to coordinate and monitor the abatement of said violations.
ORDER
Accordingly, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED
1 Pursuant to Health and Safety Code § 17980.7(c), California Receivership
Group, Inc, a California Benefit Corporation, through its President, Mark S. Adams, Esq.,
(hereinafter referred to as Receiver) is appointed as the receiver over the subject Property
and is delegated the duty and power to correct all of the existing violations existing upon
the Property and to see to it that the violations do not reoccur.
2 Prior to performing his duties, the Receiver shall execute a Receiver’s oath
10 and file a bond in the sum of $50,000.00, conditioned upon the faithful performance of
11 the Receiver’s duties.
12 Powers and Duties
13
3 The Receiver is vested with the following powers and duties:
14
A To take full and complete possession and control of the Property, including
15
the tangible and intangible personal property located in or about said real
16
property or used in connection with said real property.
17
To manage the Property and pay all operating expenses, including taxes,
18
insurance, utilities, and general maintenance on the Subject Property. To
19
the extent there is any outstanding debt, the Receiver shall not be required
20
to pay for debt secured by the Property, including mortgages or promissory
21
notes secured by deeds of trust on the Property. The Receiver shall not be
22
obligated to contribute personal funds in the performance of the duties
23
hereunder. No obligation received by the Receiver of the duties in
24
accordance with this and other Orders of this Court shall be the Receiver’s
25
personal obligation, but shall be the obligation of the receivership estate.
26
To prepare a plan for rehabilitation of the Subject Property to remedy the
27
conditions giving rise to the appointment of the Receiver, and any other
28
conditions which require remediation as may be discovered by the Receiver
in the course of inspections of the Subject Property (Rehabilitation Plan and
Cost Estimate) and to seek court approval of that plan.
Following Court approval of the rehabilitation plan and the cost estimate, to
rehabilitate the Property consistent with the rehabilitation plan submitted to
the Court, to put the Property into compliance with all applicable state and
local codes, including the Uniform Housing Code, the Uniform Building
Code, the Uniform Plumbing Code, the California Building Code, the City of
San Jose Municipal Code and to otherwise render the Property as a whole
10 habitable as decent, safe and sanitary housing.
11 To enter into contracts for goods and services and employ licensed
12 contractors for repairs as necessary to bring the Property into compliance
13 with applicable codes and to render the Property habitable as decent, safe,
14 and sanitary housing, including without limitation contracts with:
15 . Any maintenance and repair companies or personnel and any
16 property manager or project manager;
17 Any licensed engineer or other building professional to inspect and
18
evaluate the condition and rehabilitation potential of the Property;
19
Any licensed architect, draftsperson, or other design professional to
20
furnish plans and specifications for the rehabilitation of the Property;
21
Any licensed general contractor, subcontractor, supplier or
22
manufacturer to provide labor, services, goods, materials or
23
equipment needed to manage, maintain, or rehabilitate the Property;
24
Any construction manager;
25
Any bank, lending institution, or government housing finance agency;
26
Any title company;
27
Any real estate appraiser;
28
Any accountant or bookkeeper; and
Any locksmith or security company to obtain access or to maintain
the security of the Property.
To temporarily or permanently relocate the Property’s occupants (if any) if
necessary to implement the Rehabilitation Plan and Cost Estimate.
Receiver is authorized to use receivership estate funds to pay for temporary
lodging for any occupants if necessary.
To issue and record Receiver’s Certificates of Indebtedness and/or a Deed
of Trust against the Property to evidence and secure the above debt, which
10 shall become a first lien on the Property with super priority over all
11 preexisting private liens and encumbrances, except for federal, state, and
12 county tax liens. The Receiver’s Certificate shall be issued for such
13 amounts and for such items as the Court may hereafter expressly authorize,
14 upon notice and after hearing as herein provided. The debt evidenced by
15 said Certificates shall be due and payable upon the completion of the
16 Receiver’s duties hereunder with respect to the rehabilitation of the subject
17 Property and, if applicable, the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy by
18 the City of San Jose. If at the time this debt is not satisfied, the Receiver or
19 the holder of the Certificate may apply to this Court on notice and hearing
20 to sell the Property pursuant to the California Code of Civil Procedure §
21 568.5 free and clear of subordinate liens and encumbrances.
22 To open one or more bank accounts in his name as Receiver or in the name
23 of the Receivership Estate at any federally-insured bank, savings & loan,
24 credit union, or similar financial institution.
25 To prepare monthly reports which must include the total amount of any rent
26 received, the nature and amount of any operating or repair contracts,
27 payments made to repair and operate the Subject Property, other payments
28
made, and the progress of necessary repairs to the Subject Property.
Receiver is to file these reports with the Court and serve on the parties.
To file with the Court within thirty calendar days of the effective date of this
Order an inventory containing a complete and detailed list of all property of
which the Receiver has taken possession, and to promptly file a
supplementary inventory of any subsequently obtained property.
To render a final accounting to this Court at the conclusion of the
Receivership.
To pay the City its attorneys’ fees and costs, as the prevailing party, out of
10 the Receivership Estate with the same priority as the Receiver’s lien(s),
11 pursuant to Health and Safety Code §§17980.7(c)(11) and 17980.7(d)(1).
12 To sell the Property, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure § 568.5 or by
13 private sale, if necessary, subject to the prior approval and confirmation of
14 this Court.
15 To record a certified copy of this Order with the County of Santa Clara’s
16 Recorder's Office.
17 To exercise the powers granted to receivers under section 568 of the Code
18 of Civil Procedure.
19 To apply to this Court for further or other instructions or orders and for
20 further powers necessary to enable the Receiver to perform its duties
21 properly, or to address unforeseen circumstances that may arise with
22 respect to this Receivership.
23 Possession and Control
24 4 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED That Defendants, their partners, assignees,
25 successors, representatives, managers, agents, attorneys, employees, and
26 all other persons acting under or in concert with Lopes are hereby ordered
27 to:
28
Immediately relinquish and turn over possession of the Property to the
Receiver;
Immediately turn over to the Receiver and direct all property managers or
other agents or employees to turn over all keys to the Property and any
books or records with respect to the Property as requested by the Receiver;
Immediately advise the Receiver as to the nature and extent of insurance
coverage on the Property, and name the Receiver as an additional insured
on liability insurance policies for so long as the Receiver remains in
possession;
10 Forward to the Receiver all bills which they may receive in connection with
11 the Property.
12 Injunctive Orders
13 5 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED Defendants, their partners, assignees,
14 successors, representatives, managers, agents, attorneys, employees and
15 all persons acting under or with concert with Respondent, are hereby
16 enjoined at all times until the Receiver is discharged from:
17 Demanding, collecting, receiving, or diverting any rents, profits, or income
18 from the Property;
19 Interfering with the Receiver, directly or indirectly, in the conduct of the
20 receivership;
21 Encumbering, mortgaging, liening, leasing, renting, selling or transferring
22 the Property or any interest in it;
23 Canceling, reducing, or modifying any existing insurance coverage with
24 respect to the Property;
25 Commencing or continuing any foreclosure or similar process, including
26 non-judicial foreclosure and trustee sale proceedings, and further including
27 the filing of any notice of default or notice of trustee’s sale;
28
Commencing or continuing any action which impairs or precludes the
Receiver’s ability to obtain policies of title insurance needed to implement
the actions authorized by this Order;
Claiming any deduction with respect to state income taxes for interest,
taxes, expenses, depreciation, or amortization paid or incurred with respect
to the Property for 2020 and all future years during the pendency of the
receivership.
Receiver’s Compensation
dl IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that the Receiver shall be entitled to
10 compensation for his services as Receiver over the Subject Property in the amounts set
11 forth in the Declaration of Mark Adams in Support of Motion For Appointment of Receiver
12 previously filed.
13 The Receiver’s compensation shall be subject to review and final approval by this
14 Court upon notice and hearing at the time the Receiver presents a Final Report and Final
15 Accounting, which accounting shall be accompanied by records adequately documenting
16 the rehabilitation and property management services rendered by the Receiver.
17 7 IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that the Receiver is permitted to fund
18 an initial $25,000 Certificate of Indebtedness with super priority status to cover the cost
19 of securing the Property, enlisting contractors to bid the cost of rehabilitation and the
20 initial cost of managing and stabilizing the Property and administering the Receivership
21 Estate.
22 8 IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that should any lawful order issued
23 by the Receiver, under the authority granted herein, be refused, that the Receiver is
24 authorized to enlist the assistance of the any duly authorized police officer(s) and further
25 that such police officer(s) are authorized to employ all reasonably necessary measures
26 to secure cooperation and compliance with any lawful order issued by the Receiver,
27 including but not limited to, the use of forced entry onto/into the Property should consent
28 to enter be refused, and the removal of any individual(s) occupying the Property.
9 IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that Receiver is granted possession
and control of the Property, and in his and staffs discretion can grant or deny access to
any party. Receiver is authorized to direct law enforcement to remove occupants as
necessary, and the Receiver is specifically authorized to order Steven Lopes be removed
by law enforcement if he determines it is necessary to abate nuisance conditions.
Reimbursement of City’s Fees and Costs
9 IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that the City, as the prevailing party,
is entitled to recover its attorneys’ fees, ordinary costs and administrative costs,
inspection costs, investigation costs, and costs to repair and eliminate all substandard
10 conditions. The amount shall be established at such time as the City makes a further
11 application or the Receiver is ordered to pay such costs, or the Receiver is discharged,
12 whichever comes first. The City’s costs and fees may be paid out the receivership
13 certificate as approved by the Court.
14 10. IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that Petitioner's attorney's fees and
15 costs are given the same priority as the Receiver’s and both are entitled to super priority
16 status over any preexisting lien(s), except for any federal, state, or county tax lien(s).
17 Status Conference
18 aie IT IS FURTHER HEREBY ORDERED that a STATUS CONFERENCE in
19 the above action has been scheduled for_September 29, 2020 ,
20 at 10:00 a.m./p-ra. in Department 21 of the Santa Clara County Superior
21 Court. Receiver is to prepare and file a Receiver’s Report in advance of the Status
22 Conference, with an update and request for any further instruction as needed. Petitioner
23 City of San Jose shall file with the Court and serve upon all parties a declaration setting
24 forth the status of the rehabilitation of the Property as well as any other names to be
25 completed before the Receiver is discharged.
26
27
28
10
Failure to Comply and Reservation of Right
fl: Failure to comply with any abatement order, or other order contained herein,
shall be punishable by civil contempt, penalties under Health and Safety Code §§ 17995-
17995.5 (Div.13, Pt. 1.5, Ch. 6), and any other penalties and fines as are available.
13. This Court shall maintain jurisdiction over the Subject Property (also known
as the “Receivership Estate”) during the duration of this receivership. The
Court issues this Order pursuant to its authority under California Health and
Safety Code section 17980.7 and Code of Civil Procedure section 564 et
seq. The Court expressly retains jurisdiction to modify this Order as the
10 ends of justice may require. The Court may hear and decide issues
11
regarding the scope and effect of the injunctive provisions, herein. The
12
Court can modify any of the injunctive provisions hereof and take such
13
further action as may be necessary or appropriate to carry into effect the
14 injunctive provisions hereof, and for the punishment of violations of same,
15
if any. Plaintiffs have the authority under California Law and the City of San
16
Jose’s Municipal Code to maintain this action for the protection of the
17
People of the State of California and the citizens of the City of San Jose
18
concerning the conduct alleged in the Petition.
19 IT IS SO ORDERED.
20 Dated:
21
22
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT
23
24
25
26
27
28
11