Preview
1
Michael T. Risher (SBN 191627)
2 Law Office of Michael T. Risher
2081 Center St. #154 ELECTRONICALLY
3 Berkeley CA 94704
Telephone: (510) 689-1657
F I L E D
4 Superior Court of California,
Facsimile: (510) 225-0941 County of San Francisco
5 Email: michael@risherlaw.com 07/09/2020
Clerk of the Court
BY: RONNIE OTERO
6 Deputy Clerk
Attorney for Plaintiff Michael Brodheim
7
8
9
10
11
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
12 COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
13 Michael Brodheim, Case No. CPF-20-516978
14 Plaintiff, Supplemental Declaration of Michael
Risher ISO Motion for Writ of Mandate
15 v.
16 California Department of Corrections and Judge: Hon. Ethan P. Schulman
17 Rehabilitation, Hearing Date: July 16, 2020 at 1:30
Department: 302
18 Trial Date: none set
Defendant. Reservation No: 03050408-08
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Brodheim v. CDCR
Supplemental Declaration of Michael Risher ISO Motion for Writ of Mandate
1
I, Michael T. Risher, declare as follows:
2
1. Exhibit A to this Declaration is a true copy of the verified Petition in Voss v. CDCR, No. CPF-
3 20-517117, filed on June 10, 2020, without exhibits. Counsel in Voss emailed a full copy of
4 this Petition to CDCR’s counsel in the present matter on June 10, 2020.
5 2. Defendant CDCR’s website includes what it calls “CDCR Inmate Locator, Public Inmate
6 Locator System,” at https://inmatelocator.cdcr.ca.gov/ . This website allows any person to
search for CDCR prisoner based on CDCR number or a full or partial name. It then returns
7
information about prisoner(s) who match the search criteria with each prisoner’s full name,
8
CDCR number, admission date, and current custody location. For example, searching for the
9 last name “Jones” returns 38 pages of names, each of which (except the last) appears to contain
10 20 names. By clicking on a prisoner’s name, the public can additionally see the prisoner’s age
11 and parole-eligibility year/month. Exhibit B to this Declaration is a true copy if this
12 information for one prisoner.
3. Defendant CDCR’s website additionally includes information about people who are being or
13
have been considered for parole, at https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/bph/. By clicking through to
14
hearing results, any member of the public can view a list of parole-suitability-hearing results by
15 week and month, currently extending back to October 2019. These lists include the prisoner’s
16 full name, CDCR number, county of commitment, the hearing date, the hearing type, and the
17 result of the hearing. Exhibit C to this Declaration is a true copy of the first two pages (out of a
18 total of 7 pages) of the CDCR’s report for June 1-5, 2020, downloaded from the CDCR
website.
19
4. Jails in at least some California counties make information about people detained in those jails
20
– including race/ethnicity -- available on the Internet.
21
5. For example, Alameda County allows the public to see apparently every person booked into
22 that county’s jail within the last 24 hours, with full name, file number, sex, race, occupation,
23 and date of birth. Exhibit D to this Declaration is a true copy of the first page of one such list,
24 downloaded from https://www.acgov.org/sheriff_app/inmateSearch.do .
6. Los Angeles County also posts information about persons detained in its jails, including full
25
name, any aliases, sex, race, date of birth, and age. Exhibit E to this Declaration is a true copy
26
of the first page of one such list, downloaded from https://app5.lasd.org/iic/ajis_search.cfm.
27
7. Orange County, too, post information that seems to include everybody whom it has jailed in
28 2
Brodheim v. CDCR
Supplemental Declaration of Michael Risher ISO Motion for Writ of Mandate
1 the last 30 days, including name, date of birth, race, height, weight, occupation, arrest date, and
2 other information, on its website at http://ws.ocsd.org/Whoisinjail/Search.aspx. Exhibit F to
this Declaration is a true copy of this information for one prisoner, downloaded from this
3
website.
4
8. Exhibit G to this Declaration is a true copy of the CDCR’s opposition to the ACLU-NC’s writ
5
of mandate in the case indicated.
6 9. After this Court issued its order partially granting the writ of mandate in ACLU-NC v. CDCR,
7 No. CPF-16-515083, CDCR provided individualized race/ethnicity information for 268 named
8 prisoners, using the following labels: White, Black, Mexican, Hispanic, Asian or Pacific
Islander, American Indian/Alaskan Native, and Other.
9
10. The information in this declaration regarding websites was accurate as of July 3, 2020.
10
11
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California and the United
12 States of America that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
13 July 7, 2020
14
Michael T. Risher
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28 3
Brodheim v. CDCR
Supplemental Declaration of Michael Risher ISO Motion for Writ of Mandate
Ex. A Ex. A
Exhibit A
Exhibit A Exhibit A
Ex. B Ex. B
Exhibit B
Exhibit B Exhibit B
7/3/2020 CDCR Inmate Information
Visit CDCR.ca.gov
Contact CDCR
Accessibility Settings
HomeC Rehabilitative Programs QuestionsC Visitation Information
Inmate Information
The information displayed below is subject to change and may update daily
Inmate Name RISHER, RICHARD CARLTON
CDCR Number C97107
Age 61
Admission Date 12/17/1997
Current Location California Substance Abuse Treatment Facility
Location Link Directions
Parole Eligible Date 03/2022
(Month/Year)
Parole Eligible Date The Parole Eligible Date displayed above is subject to
Information change.
The parole eligible date shown above is the first date the
inmate is (or was) eligible for a parole suitability hearing by
the Board of Parole Hearings to determine if the inmate
should be released. The inmate is eligible for a parole
suitability hearing under the Elderly Parole Program once he
or she is age 60 or older and has been incarcerated for 25
years. For more information on parole suitability hearings
under the Elderly Parole Program, please visit the Board of
Parole Hearings’ Elderly Parole Hearings Overview
Additional Information VICTIM NOTIFICATION: Victims who would like to request
notice and an opportunity to attend this inmate’s parole
suitability hearing or who would like to request notice of this
inmate’s release must register with CDCR’s O ice of Victim and
Survivor Rights and Services. For further information, or to
inquire about court ordered restitution, please visit CDCR’s
O ice of Victim and Survivor Rights and Services website or
call toll-free 1-877-256-6877
BOARD OF PAROLE HEARINGS: For more information about
the Board of Parole Hearings, please visit the Board’s website
View Board of Parole Hearings' Actions Information current as of: 07/03/2020
Back to Results New Search
Back to Top Privacy Policy Accessibility Disclaimer Contact Us
Accessibility Assistance
https://inmatelocator.cdcr.ca.gov/Details.aspx?ID=C97107 1/2
Ex. C Ex. C
Exhibit C
Exhibit C Exhibit C
7/3/2020 Week of June 1- 5, 2020 - Board of Parole Hearings (BPH)
Week of June 1- 5, 2020
June 1 through June 5, 2020 Weekly Results (Printable Version as of 6/9/2020)
(https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/bph/wp-content/uploads/sites/161/2020/06/Suitability-HRG-
Results-June-1-through-June-5_2020-Internet.pdf)
OFFENDER NAME CDC# COUNTY OF GOV SCHEDULED DATE HEARING TYPE RESULT
COMMITMENT CODE
ABALOS, MIGUEL, ANGEL P78254 Sacramento Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Waive 1 yr
2020 Hearing
ALONZO, DOREEN, BANKE WA6889 Imperial Friday, June 05, 2020
Subsequent Suitability Postpone 0
Hearing mo
ANDERSON, KARIS, LEMICHAEL K08881 San Diego,Monterey Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Stip 3 yr
2020
ARENDS, HAREM, DANIEL K47627 Solano Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
ARREOLA, JOSE, A K20484 Los Angeles Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
BAKER, TREY K00955 Los Angeles,Orange Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
BATTEN, ANDRE, LAMONT E28614 Los Angeles PC Wednesday, June 03, Subsequent Suitability Grant
3041.2 2020 Hearing
BEECHAM, ROBERT, A E25627 Los Angeles,Riverside Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 0
2020 Hearing mo
BELMONTES, ANDRES, H11079 San Bernardino Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 0
HERNANDEZ 2020 Hearing mo
BENTON, MICHAEL D67759 Solano Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 6
2020 Hearing mo
BOUNPRASEUTH, BOUPHA K31935 Los Angeles Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Grant
2020 Hearing
BOZEMAN, STEVE, ARNOLD C55589 San Diego Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 5 yr
2020
BRACAMONTES, CHRISTIAN, P70316 Riverside Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
ALFONSO 2020
BRAVO, KEVIN, DANIEL AX4859 Riverside Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 6
2020 mo
BROWN, RENE, MICHAEL C22590 Los Angeles Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 5 yr
2020
BROWN, RICKY D43181 Los Angeles,Kings Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 0
2020 Hearing mo
BROWN, WILLIAM, NATHANIEL B65042 Los Angeles Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Deny 3 yr
2020 Hearing
BUTLER, CHRISTOPHER T83516 San Diego Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
BUTLER, MICHAEL, EUGENE E59123 Los Angeles PC Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Grant
3041.2 2020 Hearing
CARR, REGINALD K85890 Los Angeles Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Grant
2020
CARREON, ALEX AG5171 Riverside Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/bph/2020/06/09/week-of-june-1-5-2020/ 1/7
7/3/2020 Week of June 1- 5, 2020 - Board of Parole Hearings (BPH)
OFFENDER NAME CDC# COUNTY OF GOV SCHEDULED DATE HEARING TYPE RESULT
COMMITMENT CODE
CASADOS, RICHARD, BENJAMIN E37375 San Bernardino,Riverside Wednesday, June 03, Subsequent Suitability Deny 3 yr
2020 Hearing
CASILLAS, RAFAEL J20041 Los Angeles PC Wednesday, June 03, Subsequent Suitability Grant
3041.1 2020 Hearing
CHAVEZ, JOE K18421 Los Angeles Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 0
2020 mo
CLARK, TARIK, AKIM P93422 Los Angeles Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
COLBERT, RONALD, DUANE J38688 Los Angeles Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 0
2020 mo
COMINS, JASON, MICHAEL F55737 Riverside Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 0
2020 mo
CONNOLLY, DAVID, SCOTT C77525 Monterey Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 6
2020 Hearing mo
CORRALES, WALTER, MANUEL J76822 Imperial,Riverside Friday, June 05, 2020
Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 0
mo
COSTALES, RUBEN E45896 Fresno Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Waive 3 yr
2020 Hearing
CUEVAS, ALEXANDER, JOHN B32373 Los Angeles,Kern,Solano Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Stip 3 yr
2020 Hearing
CUNNINGHAM, LORENZO, RENELL D98935 Los Angeles Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Waive 1 yr
2020
DARIA, AARON, CARNELIUS J52472 San Mateo PC Thursday, June 04, Subsequent Suitability Grant
3041.1 2020 Hearing
DELANEY, LONNIE, DEFORE T43223 Kern PC Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Grant
3041.1 2020 Hearing
DEW, DAVID, LEON C67417 San Diego,Monterey Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 6
2020 Hearing mo
DONALDSON, ERIC, BRUCE J72042 Los Angeles PC Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Grant
3041.1 2020
DUGAN, DAVID, DWAYNE D46449 Los Angeles,SacramentoPC Wednesday, June 03, Subsequent Suitability Grant
3041.2 2020 Hearing
ESTRADA, RICARDO P35664 Los Angeles Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 7 yr
2020
FELIX, JESUS, ANTONIO E12138 Stanislaus Wednesday, June 03, Subsequent Suitability Postpone 0
2020 Hearing mo
FRANKLIN, STEVEN K52395 Alameda Tuesday, June 02, Initial Suitability Hearing
Deny 3 yr
2020
GALLEGOS, MELVIN AE9897 San Diego Wednesday, June 03, Subsequent Suitability Deny 3 yr
2020 Hearing
GAMIO, GEAN, BAPTISTE K74639 Shasta Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Waive 4 yr
2020 Hearing
GARRETT, ROBERT J72048 Los Angeles Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 0
2020 mo
GOMEZ, CARLOS K91356 Los Wednesday, June 03, Initial Suitability Hearing
Waive 1 yr
Angeles,Imperial,Lassen 2020
GOMEZ, LOUIE, RUDY H05287 Kings Tuesday, June 02, Subsequent Suitability Grant
2020 Hearing
GONZALEZ, JESUS H26033 San Diego,Riverside Thursday, June 04, Initial Suitability Hearing
Postpone 0
2020 mo
https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/bph/2020/06/09/week-of-june-1-5-2020/ 2/7
Ex. D Ex. D
Exhibit D
Exhibit D Exhibit D
7/3/2020 Inmate List
Skip County Header
| Sheriff's Office | New Query
Frequently Asked Questions
About Inmate Locator
Inmate List
First Name Middle Name Last Name PFN Sex DOB
Not Specified Not Specified Not Specified Not Specified Not Specified Not Specified
Shows the bookings within the last 24 hours.
Holding
Name PFN Sex Race Occupation DOB Custody Status
Facility
SANTA RITA
ACOSTA, RIC DUSTIN BCO189 M HISPANIC 01/26/1982IN CUSTODY View Details
JAIL
SANTA RITA
ALLEN, KEVIN BKS043 M BLACK 10/08/1996IN CUSTODY View Details
JAIL
SANTA RITA View Details
ALMERAZ, IAGO ANTONIO BMS315 M BLACK NONPROFIT 04/04/1991IN CUSTODY
JAIL
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER View Details
ARUOBI, SHAMSUL RAHMAN BFD924 M UNCLASSIFIED WAREHOUSE 01/04/1986
BOOKING
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER
AUSTIN, MICHAEL BEG013 M BLACK 11/23/1985 View Details
BOOKING
SANTA RITA
BALUCAN, ALBERT BLD423 M FILIPINO UNEMPLOYED 07/10/1993IN CUSTODY View Details
JAIL
SANTA RITA
BELL, MICHAEL ALAN BCK867 M WHITE UNEMPLOYED 01/06/1983IN CUSTODY View Details
JAIL
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER
BERNAL, OCTAVIO BMS308 M HISPANIC 03/28/1981 View Details
BOOKING
SANTA RITA
BERRY, JOSHUA EMMANUEL BMD546 M BLACK 09/01/1998IN CUSTODY View Details
JAIL
BIDDLE, TAYRON ROMAEL BMK261 M BLACK MUSIC 09/30/1996BAIL BOND View Details
SANTA RITA
BRADFORD, ROBERT JAMES BFI271 M WHITE NOT LISTED 08/24/1987IN CUSTODY View Details
JAIL
CABALLEROS, LUIS CITATION IN JAIL AFTER
BLY857 M HISPANIC 10/23/1992 View Details
ANTONIOARRE BOOKING
TEMPORARY EMERGENCY
CEJA, RAUL ANGEL BKH047 M HISPANIC 07/26/1996 View Details
CITATION
SANTA RITA View Details
CLARK, KEYMAURIE BKU984 M BLACK 11/13/1996IN CUSTODY
JAIL
BERKELEY View Details
COMBS, JALISA NICOLE BKI640 F BLACK UNEMPLOYED 03/08/1990IN CUSTODY
JAIL
CONAWAY, AVON CITATION IN JAIL AFTER View Details
ANY436 M BLACK UNK 08/05/1963
CORNELIUS BOOKING
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER View Details
CROWDER, AUBREY DEEN BMF324 M BLACK 10/20/2000
BOOKING
SANTA RITA View Details
CRUZ, ALEJANDRO BMM149 M HISPANIC COOK 05/19/1980IN CUSTODY
JAIL
BERKELEY View Details
DAVIS, DEANTE D BHD104 M BLACK UNKNOWN 01/14/1986IN CUSTODY
JAIL
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER
DAVIS, TONY RAY AKK258 M BLACK NONE 09/26/1956 View Details
BOOKING
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER
DELATORRE, CHRISTIAN BLG710 M FILIPINO STUDENT 12/20/1996 View Details
BOOKING
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER
DONNELL, KAITLYN BMS309 F WHITE 06/02/1992 View Details
BOOKING
ESPINOZA, JOSE LUIS BKL209 M HISPANIC 08/29/1987BAIL View Details
FONTANILLA, DANTE CITATION IN JAIL AFTER View Details
BKB460 M FILIPINO UNEMPLOYED 10/15/1968
SOBREPENA BOOKING
SANTA RITA View Details
FULLER, JACK LEROY BFD728 M BLACK UNEMPLOYED 12/01/1984IN CUSTODY
JAIL
SANTA RITA View Details
GARCIA, CHRISTOPHER UMD350 M HISPANIC 09/29/1999IN CUSTODY
JAIL
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER View Details
GARCIA, ERIC BAYAUA BMM203 M FILIPINO UNEMPLOYED 10/07/1972
BOOKING
SANTA RITA View Details
GARCIA, HUMBERTO BMR546 M HISPANIC 11/17/1991IN CUSTODY
JAIL
CITATION IN JAIL AFTER View Details
GARDNER, ZACHARY ALDEN BGT540 M BLACK UNEMPLOYED 04/08/1989
BOOKING
SANTA RITA View Details
GILBERT, JESSE BKU584 M WHITE 04/05/1977IN CUSTODY
JAIL
https://www.acgov.org/sheriff_app/inmateSearch.do 1/3
Ex. E Ex. E
Exhibit E
Exhibit E Exhibit E
7/3/2020 LASD Inmate Information Center - Inmate Search
(The information was current as of: 07/03/2020 10:14 PST)
Please click on the booking number for inmate information and visitation
Search Result
ALSO KNOWN AS (AKA)
Booking No. Last Name First Name Middle Name Sex Race Date Of Birth Age
4298200 JONES MICHAEL M B 12/17/1960 54
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
4595898 JONES MICHAEL M B 02/28/1962 54
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
5276600 JONES MICHAEL M W 08/30/1976 41
JONES MICHAEL SHANNON
5311929 JONES MICHAEL M B 03/29/1972 46
JONES MICHAEL
5314536 JONES MICHAEL M B 01/21/1959 59
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL ANTHONY
JONES MICHAEL ANTHONY
JONES MICHAEL ANTHONY
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL ANTHONY
JONES MICHAEL ANTHONY
JONES MICHAEL ANTHONY
JONES MICHAEL
JONES MICHAEL A
JONES MICHAEL A
JONES MICHAEL A
JONES MICHAEL
5319494 JONES MICHAEL DOUGLAS M B 09/27/1959 58
JONES MICHAEL DOUGLAS
https://app5.lasd.org/iic/isearchresult.cfm 1/6
Ex. F Ex. F
Exhibit F
Exhibit F Exhibit F
7/3/2020 Who's In Jail - Inmate Info
Search By Name | List Inmate Names | FAQ | Visitor Information
Bail Agent Registration, click here.
Due to security concerns, we have discontinued posting detailed inmate information on this
website. Information required to be disclosed under Government Code section 6254(f)(1) of the
California Public Records Act may be obtained in person at any Orange County Sheriff jail
facility.
Results for booking number: 3167332
Inmate Name: AARON , JUSTIN ROBERT
Date of Birth: 03-19-1979 Next Appearance Date:
Sex: Male Next Appearance Court:
Race: White Custody Status: Released
Height: 5' 08" Bail Amount: $0.00
Weight: 168 Arrested on: 06-12-2020
Hair Color: Black Housing Location: Theo Lacy Facility
Eye Color: Hazel Release Type: No Complaint Filed at This Time
Occupation: FLOORING Release Date: 06-17-2020 14:50:00
Inmate charge information will be provided by e-mail to approved attorneys and licensed
bail agent only. All other requests for charge information must be made in person at any
Orange County Sheriff jail facility. To receive the active charges by email for this inmate
enter your username and password below. Bail agents and attorneys must be registered
and approved in order to receive active charges by e-mail.
Attorney registration, plea