We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Patsy Young v. Aventis Inc., Avon Products, Inc., Block Drug Company, Inc. (Sued Individually And As Successor-In-Interest To The Gold Bond Sterilizing Powder Company A/K/A The Gold Bond Company), Block Drug Corporation (Sued Individually And As Suc…

Torts - Asbestos case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of Erie County. Judge Raymond Walter presiding.

Case Details

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)   

Filing Date

December 10, 2020

Last Refreshed

July 26, 2023

Filing Location

Erie County, NY

Judge

Hon. Raymond Walter   

Category

Torts - Asbestos

Practice Area

Torts

Matter Type

Mass Torts

Status

Dismissal

Overview
Causes of Action

1. FOR NEGLIGENT FAILURE TO WARN AGAINST THE DEFENDANTS NAMED HEREIN, PLAINTIFF PATSY YOUNG ALLEGES:

2. FOR STRICT PRODUCTS LIABILITY AGAINST THE DEFENDANTS NAMED HERElN, PLAINTIFF PATSY YOUNG ALLEGES:

3. AGAINST THE DEFENDANTS NAMED HEREIN, PLAINTIFF PATSY YOUNG ALLEGES:

4. AGAINST THE DEFENDANTS NAMED HEREIN, PLAINTIFF PATSY YOUNG ALLEGES:

Parties

Plaintiffs

Patsy Young

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Comerford, John P.
Kagan, Leah Cylia
Morton, Mathew John

Defendants

Aventis Inc.
Avon Products, Inc.
Block Drug Company, Inc.
Block Drug Corporation
Brenntag North America, Inc.
Brenntag Specialties, Inc. F K A Mineral Pigment Solutions, Inc.
Charles B. Chrystal Company, Inc.
Chattem, Inc.
Colgate-Palmolive Company
Cyprus Amax Minerals Company
Cyprus Mines Corporation
Glaxosmithkline Llc (Sued Individually And As Successor-In-Interest To Block Drug Corporation, Successor-In-Interest To The Gold Bond Sterilizing Powder Company A K A The Gold Bond Company And As A Successor-In-Interest To Novartis Corporation And Novartis Consumer Health Inc.)
Gsk Consumer Health, Inc. F K A Novartis Consumer Health Inc. F K A Ciba Self-Medication, Inc.
Insight Pharmaceuticals Corporation, A Subsidiary Of Prestige Brands Holdings, Inc.
Insight Pharmaceuticals Llc
Macy'S Inc. F K A Federated Department Stores, Inc.
Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation
Prestige Brands Holdings, Inc.
Prestige Consumer Healthcare Inc. F K A Prestige Brands, Inc.
Sanofi-Aventis U.S. Llc
Sanofi Us Services, Inc.
Whittaker Clark & Daniels, Inc.

Attorneys for Defendants

Dimarco, Erik Christopher
Downey, Patrick F
Hanna, Sam Fahmy
Haque, Mohammad Muneeb
Herrscher, Mary Jo
Kozak, Christopher Stephen
Mahoney, Nancy
Mullins, Robert J
Naylon, Patrick Brennan
Novakidis, Stephen
Oxamendi, David
Ricci, Dana Marie
Rizvi, Syed Kazim
Ryan, Jodie L.
Sapon, Andrew
Seltzer, Whitney
Squitieri, Virginia Paula
Tempesta, Carol Maria
Van Gelder, Susan Elizabeth
Welter, Joseph J.

Case Documents

EXHIBIT(S) - 6

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 8

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 7

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 15

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 2

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 3

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 16

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 10

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 9

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 17

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 11

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 24

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 30

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 27

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 18

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 28

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 29

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 12

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 20

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 22

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 25

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 21

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 13

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 26

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 23

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 14

Date: Mar 17, 2023

AFFIRMATION

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 4

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 1

Date: Mar 17, 2023

EXHIBIT(S) - 5

Date: Mar 17, 2023

ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING

Date: Feb 08, 2023

PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)

Date: Jan 31, 2023

NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY

Date: Jan 18, 2023

ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING

Date: Oct 26, 2022

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Oct 13, 2022

STIPULATION - SO ORDERED

Date: Jul 28, 2022

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: Jun 13, 2022

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: Jun 13, 2022

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: Jun 13, 2022

ORDER - DISMISSAL

Date: Jun 11, 2022

ORDER - DISMISSAL

Date: Jun 11, 2022

ORDER - DISMISSAL

Date: Jun 11, 2022

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Jun 07, 2022

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Jun 07, 2022

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Jun 07, 2022

ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING

Date: Mar 23, 2022

EXHIBIT(S) - B

Date: Mar 23, 2022

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Mar 23, 2022

PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)

Date: Jan 18, 2022

EXHIBIT(S) - B

Date: Jan 13, 2022

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Jan 13, 2022

ORDER - DISMISSAL

Date: Jan 03, 2022

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: Jan 03, 2022

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Jan 03, 2022

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Dec 22, 2021

AFFIDAVIT

Date: Sep 02, 2021

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: Aug 09, 2021

ORDER - DISMISSAL

Date: Aug 09, 2021

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Aug 04, 2021

AFFIDAVIT

Date: Jul 26, 2021

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Jul 14, 2021

DEMAND FOR:

Date: Jun 23, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Mar 19, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Mar 19, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Mar 19, 2021

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Mar 19, 2021

ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING

Date: Mar 19, 2021

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: Mar 17, 2021

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Mar 17, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Mar 04, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Feb 12, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Feb 12, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Feb 12, 2021

ANSWER

Date: Feb 12, 2021

DEMAND FOR:

Date: Jan 26, 2021

EXHIBIT(S) - A

Date: Dec 10, 2020

SUMMONS COMPLAINT

Date: Dec 10, 2020

Case Events

Type Description
EXHIBIT(S) - 6
1-23-15 Capdevielle Depo in Winkel
EXHIBIT(S) - 8
4-6-11 & 4-7-11 Ohlmeyer Depo in Bernard and Tedrick
EXHIBIT(S) - 7
10-27-10 Briscese Depo in Bernard and Tedrick
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
EXHIBIT(S) - 15
Ex 15 - 12-2-10 Simko Depo in NY Asb Lit
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
EXHIBIT(S) - 2
Young DBE
NOTICE OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN LIEU OF COMPLAINT
EXHIBIT(S) - 3
Colgate Resp to First
EXHIBIT(S) - 120 (Motion #003)
Ex 120 - Consumer Talcums and Powders Mineral and Chem Characterization Rohl, et al 1976
EXHIBIT(S) - 142 (Motion #003)
Ex 142 - 2023 Moline et al
EXHIBIT(S) - 111 (Motion #003)
Ex 111 - RJL Yellowstone Testing Tremolite Asb
EXHIBIT(S) - 114 (Motion #003)
Ex 114 - A Textbook of Mineralogy - Dana 1932
EXHIBIT(S) - 124 (Motion #003) Ex 124 - 3-3-17 Malignant Meso Mortality US 1999-2015 CSC and Prevention Morbidity Mortality - Mazur
Ex 124 - 3-3-17 Malignant Meso Mortality US 1999-2015 CSC and Prevention Morbidity Mortality - Mazur ... show more
EXHIBIT(S) - 130 (Motion #003)
Ex 130 - Madigan Dec PYoung
EXHIBIT(S) - 117 (Motion #003)
Ex 117 - Fibrous and Mineral Content of Cosm. Talc - Cralley - Jul Aug 1968
EXHIBIT(S) - 134 (Motion #003)
Ex 134 - 2005_Welch, et al
EXHIBIT(S) - 132 (Motion #003)
Ex 132 - Dxing Path Report_030620_Young_signed_Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - 146 (Motion #003)
Ex 146 - LANDRIGAN ET AL 1999
EXHIBIT(S) - 158 (Motion #003)
Ex 158 - 11-6-17 & 11-7-17 Sanchez Trial Testimony in Herford
EXHIBIT(S) - 104 (Motion #003)
Ex 104 - 1966 Ltr from Pfizer to Customers Re Talc Coding System
EXHIBIT(S) - 116 (Motion #003)
Ex 116 - Pfizer Tech Report 1967
EXHIBIT(S) - 136 (Motion #003)
Ex 136 - 1997 Helsinki
EXHIBIT(S) - 121 (Motion #003)
Ex 121 - 12-9-83 Eval. by EM Techniques of Asb. Contamination - Paoletti
EXHIBIT(S) - 144 (Motion #003)
Ex 144 - 2-1-77 CTFA Meeting Minutes
EXHIBIT(S) - 131 (Motion #003)
Ex 131 - 1.6.2020 FDA Executive Summary on Talc and Asbestos
EXHIBIT(S) - 108 (Motion #003)
Ex 108 - Ex 48 - Montana DEQ Website
EXHIBIT(S) - 145 (Motion #003)
Ex 145 - EPA, A Guide for Ship Scrappers 2000
EXHIBIT(S) - 112 (Motion #003)
Ex 112 - TEM Asbestos Anaylsis of Yellowstone Ore Positive Chrysotile
EXHIBIT(S) - 141 (Motion #003)
Ex 141 - 2017 Jiang et al
EXHIBIT(S) - 123 (Motion #003)
Ex 123 - 10-23-84 Memo from Ashton re ASTM and ISO meetings re Paoletti paper
EXHIBIT(S) - 113 (Motion #003)
Ex 113 - Yellowstone IH Sampling Plan
EXHIBIT(S) - 143 (Motion #003)
Ex 143 - Keal 1960 Lancet Asbestosis And Abdominal Neoplasms (SA 0203)
EXHIBIT(S) - 109 (Motion #003)
Ex 109 - Yellowstone - PLM analysis postive chrysotile
EXHIBIT(S) - 115 (Motion #003)
Ex 115 - Commercial Talc Animal and Mineralogical Studies - Shultz Williams April 1942
EXHIBIT(S) - 140 (Motion #003)
Ex 140 - Rolland abstract (2006)
EXHIBIT(S) - 139 (Motion #003)
Ex 139 - Rodelsperger
EXHIBIT(S) - 163 (Motion #003)
Ex 163 - FDA Website - Cosmetics Q&A
EXHIBIT(S) - 127 (Motion #003)
Ex 127 - Stoiber and Fitzgerald 2020
EXHIBIT(S) - 129 (Motion #003)
Ex 129 - Moline TT Allen
EXHIBIT(S) - 137 (Motion #003)
Ex 137 - 2007-Welch-IJOEH-Not My Asbestos
EXHIBIT(S) - 135 (Motion #003)
Ex 135 - 2020-05 Kanarek
EXHIBIT(S) - 125 (Motion #003)
Ex 125 - FDA Advises Consumers to Stop Using Certain Cosmetic Products
EXHIBIT(S) - 126 (Motion #003)
Ex 126 - 2019-10-18 FDANewsRel
EXHIBIT(S) - 106 (Motion #003)
Ex 106 - 4-6-84 Report, Willow Creek Mine
EXHIBIT(S) - 107 (Motion #003)
Ex 107 -1992-03-25 Munro
EXHIBIT(S) - 138 (Motion #003)
Ex 138 - 2014 Lacourt, et al
EXHIBIT(S) - 122 (Motion #003)
Ex 122 - 9-26-84 Letter from Ashton, J&J to Luzenac re Paoletti Paper
EXHIBIT(S) - 105 (Motion #003)
Ex 104 - 1966 Ltr from Pfizer to Customers Re Talc Coding System
EXHIBIT(S) - 128 (Motion #003)
Ex 128 - Cottrell 1992, Surveillance of Sentinel Occupational Mortality in DC 1980 to 1987
EXHIBIT(S) - 155 (Motion #003)
Ex 155 - 6-10-77 J&J Internal memo from Schelz to Task Force
EXHIBIT(S) - 133 (Motion #003)
Ex 133 - 2016_Kanarek & Mandich
EXHIBIT(S) - 159 (Motion #003)
Ex 159 - 9-2-16 Urbach Ross Depo in Depoian
EXHIBIT(S) - 162 (Motion #003)
Ex 162 - 10-4-83 US Pat. 4,407,798
EXHIBIT(S) - 32 (Motion #003)
EX 32 - COMPTON DECLARATION w. Exhibits
EXHIBIT(S) - 34 (Motion #003)
Ex 34 - Moline Aff - PYoung
EXHIBIT(S) - 16
Ex 16 - JM testing 1968
EXHIBIT(S) - 10
Ex 10 - 3-5-76 Colgate lab book 6164-99 w add'l page
EXHIBIT(S) - 73 (Motion #003)
Ex 73 - Mortality Study of Talc Miners and Millers - Rubino - March 1976
EXHIBIT(S) - 19 Ex 19 - 12-10-73 Report of the CTFA Talc Subcommittee on Method to Detect Chrysotile and Tremolite i
Ex 19 - 12-10-73 Report of the CTFA Talc Subcommittee on Method to Detect Chrysotile and Tremolite i ... show more
EXHIBIT(S) - 9
Ex 9 - 9-20-71 Colgate lab book 4044-1
EXHIBIT(S) - 17
Ex 17 - 8-3-72 Letter from Lewin to Weissler
EXHIBIT(S) - 11
Ex 11 - 1-27-76 Colgate lab book 6164-85
EXHIBIT(S) - 35 (Motion #003) Ex 35 LONGO DEC WITH EXHIBITS
Ex 35 LONGO DEC WITH EXHIBITS Possible SSN Administratively Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - 24
Ex 24 - 3-10-76 NYT article Asbestos found in 10 powders
EXHIBIT(S) - 30
Ex 30 - 1-12-76 J&J Lee memo re Pooley finds fibrous anthophyllite in CB and Coty
EXHIBIT(S) - 27
Ex 27 - 3-11-76 Colgate lab book 6490-2
EXHIBIT(S) - 18
Ex 18 - 8-16-72 Letter from Roesch to Driscoll
EXHIBIT(S) - 28
Ex 28 - 8-18-17 Hopkins Depo in Herford
EXHIBIT(S) - 29
Ex 29 - 3-31-76 J&J Memo re Meeting with Mt Sanai
EXHIBIT(S) - 12
Ex 12 - 3-25-76 Colgate lab book 3-3388
EXHIBIT(S) - 20
Ex 20 - 9-30-72 NYU Report
EXHIBIT(S) - 22
Ex 22 - 3-1-76 Memo of call between Shapiro and Langer
EXHIBIT(S) - 25
Ex 25 - Wash Post article Asb found in baby powder 1976
EXHIBIT(S) - 21
Ex 21 - 3-22-76 Yates mtg memo
EXHIBIT(S) - 13
Ex 13 - 10-27-76 Colgate lab book 3-3388
EXHIBIT(S) - 26
Ex 26 - Ottawa Citizen article Asbestos in talc powders dangerous 1976
EXHIBIT(S) - 23
Ex 23 - 3-15-76 Letter from Costello to CTFA
EXHIBIT(S) - 14
Ex 14 - Letters re McCrone testing results 1976
EXHIBIT(S) - 49 (Motion #003)
Ex 49 - 8-6-71 Handwritten notes Amphibole minerals would be picked out
AFFIRMATION
EXHIBIT(S) - 80 (Motion #003)
Ex 80 - Van Gosen article
EXHIBIT(S) - 62 (Motion #003)
Ex 62 - Draft of Mineralogy and Chem in British Talc - Pooley, Rohl, Langer
EXHIBIT(S) - 48 (Motion #003)
Ex 48 - 4-12-60 Battelle letter
EXHIBIT(S) - 50 (Motion #003)
Ex 50 - 8-17-17 Hopkins Depo in Herford
EXHIBIT(S) - 71 (Motion #003)
Ex 71 - 4-12-18 Monticelli Depo in Weirick & Brick
EXHIBIT(S) - 79 (Motion #003)
Ex 79 - Talc and Chlorite Deposits in Montana - Berg 1979
EXHIBIT(S) - 63 (Motion #003)
Ex 63 - 3-17-76 Langer to Chalmers
EXHIBIT(S) - 51 (Motion #003)
Ex 51 - 1-24-68 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 74 (Motion #003)
Ex 74 - Critical Reappraisal of Balangero Chrysotile and Meso Risk - Ilgren 2015
EXHIBIT(S) - 52 (Motion #003)
Ex 52 - 8-16-17 Hopkins Depo in Herford
EXHIBIT(S) - 65 (Motion #003)
Ex 65 - 11-1-79 Mebus of Pfizer to S. Shope
EXHIBIT(S) - 81 (Motion #003)
Ex 81 - Ex 24 - Olson (Pfizer) Geology of MO Talc Deposits (Abreviated)
EXHIBIT(S) - 72 (Motion #003)
Ex 72 - J&J Memo - Worldwide Study
EXHIBIT(S) - 64 (Motion #003)
Ex 64 - 11-9-77 McCrone Report
EXHIBIT(S) - 75 (Motion #003)
Ex 75 - Cosmetic Talc as a Risk Factor for Pleural Meso - Inhalation Toxicology - Mirabelli 2017
EXHIBIT(S) - 76 (Motion #003)
Ex 76 - 11-2 and 5-18 Sanchez TT in Allen
EXHIBIT(S) - 86 (Motion #003)
Ex 86 - JM - Talc Analysis - 399 + 12-50 Positive
EXHIBIT(S) - 99 (Motion #003)
Ex 99 - LOC71F505-07-27-2000-BMIRegalMine-Non-Ore-Rock-Management-Vol-5
EXHIBIT(S) - 82 (Motion #003)
Ex 82 - Olson (Pfizer) 1976 Geology of MO Talc Deposits
EXHIBIT(S) - 84 (Motion #003)
Ex 84 - 6-1-12 Gunter Bernard
EXHIBIT(S) - 83 (Motion #003)
Ex 83 - 03-10-15 (Winkel)_Cond
EXHIBIT(S) - 53 (Motion #003)
Ex 53 - 8-6-71 J&J Survey of Val Chisone
EXHIBIT(S) - 78 (Motion #003)
Ex 78 - Asb. in Talc - Rohl - Dec 1974
EXHIBIT(S) - 77 (Motion #003)
Ex 77 - 3-6-14 FDA and DHHS to Pers Care Prods Council
EXHIBIT(S) - 100 (Motion #003)
Ex 100 - LOC71F605-05-09-01-Luzenac-America-Inc-Yellowstone-Mine-Waste-Rock-Geo-Eval-
EXHIBIT(S) - 85 (Motion #003)
Ex 85 - 1-20-16 Mulryan Depo in Dalis
EXHIBIT(S) - 87 (Motion #003)
Ex 87- 4-6-84 - CIM Willow Creek Report
EXHIBIT(S) - 54 (Motion #003)
Ex 54 - 9-29-71 Report of McCrone & Docs IDing Sample 2 as 1615
EXHIBIT(S) - 94 (Motion #003)
Ex 94 - CAMC lab reports-Depoian-000192-000193
EXHIBIT(S) - 56 (Motion #003)
Ex 56 - 6-12-72 ES Talc Analysis
EXHIBIT(S) - 88 (Motion #003)
Ex 88 - 6-12-72 ES Labs Report on WCD 1736 (Treasure)
EXHIBIT(S) - 98 (Motion #003)
Ex 98 - NATLSCO Treasure IH Study
EXHIBIT(S) - 55 (Motion #003)
Ex 55 - 2-16-72 Certificate of Analysis, Turin Polytechnic
EXHIBIT(S) - 96 (Motion #003)
Ex 96 - 3-2-16 & 3-3-16 Hubbard Depo in Dalis
EXHIBIT(S) - 97 (Motion #003)
Ex 97 - 2-8-91 Pfizer Inc.s Summary of Tremolite
EXHIBIT(S) - 90 (Motion #003)
Ex 90 - 6-12-72 ES Labs Report on WCD 399
EXHIBIT(S) - 89 (Motion #003)
Ex 89 - 6-12-72 ES Labs Report on WCD 1731 (Treasure)
EXHIBIT(S) - 92 (Motion #003)
Ex 92 - Gallo depo 8-17-17
EXHIBIT(S) - 95 (Motion #003)
Ex 95 - July 17, 1979 Inter-Department Memo jlm
EXHIBIT(S) - 93 (Motion #003)
Ex 93 - Memo Shepich to Wilson 10-2-78
EXHIBIT(S) - 91 (Motion #003)
Ex 91 - 6-12-72 ES Labs Report on WCD 1745
EXHIBIT(S) - 102 (Motion #003)
Ex 102 - 10-6-77 Ltr re customers finding tremolite in MT + CA Pfizer talc
EXHIBIT(S) - 57 (Motion #003)
Ex 57 - TEM 2011 Yellowstone Chrysotile
EXHIBIT(S) - 103 (Motion #003)
Ex 103 - 12-14-79 Pfizer Memo re Montana Talc Asbestos
EXHIBIT(S) - 110 (Motion #003)
Ex 110 - RJL Yellowstone Chrysotile Asbestos Finding
EXHIBIT(S) - 101 (Motion #003)
Ex 101 - 9-76 - Routine Analysis of Pfizer Talc
EXHIBIT(S) - 160 (Motion #003)
Ex 160 - 10-15-62 J&J Product Improvement, New Product Dev. Memo
EXHIBIT(S) - 157 (Motion #003)
Ex 157 - FDA Protecting and Promoting Your Health
EXHIBIT(S) - 151 (Motion #003)
Ex 151 - 10-7-76 CTFA Method J4-1
EXHIBIT(S) - 156 (Motion #003)
Ex 156 - 3-18-76 FDA Memo
EXHIBIT(S) - 4
Colgate Resp. to Std Rogs in Polakow
EXHIBIT(S) - 1
Young Disc Resp
EXHIBIT(S) - 5
4-16-15 Capdevielle trial testimony in Winkel
EXHIBIT(S) - 36 (Motion #003)
Ex 36 - 2020 Steffen et al 'Serous Ovar'
EXHIBIT(S) - 39 (Motion #003)
Ex 39 - Scala Dep 20160720
EXHIBIT(S) - 38 (Motion #003)
Ex 38 - Colgate objections and resp to P's Suppl Rogs in Schoeniger
EXHIBIT(S) - 37 (Motion #003)
Ex 37 - Colgate resp to RFA in Polakow
EXHIBIT(S) - 58 (Motion #003)
Ex 58 - 9-8-72 Pooley Report of Italian Talc Source Mine
EXHIBIT(S) - 43 (Motion #003)
Ex 43 - 7-31-59 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 42 (Motion #003)
Ex 42 - 5-9-58 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 41 (Motion #003)
Ex 40 - 10-15-57 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 41 (Motion #003)
Ex 41 - 5-23-58 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 66 (Motion #003)
Ex 66 - Geology and Genesis of Talc Deposits in Pinerolese - Peretti 1966
EXHIBIT(S) - 46 (Motion #003)
Ex 46 - 12-31-59 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 45 (Motion #003)
Ex 45 - 9-15-59 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 59 (Motion #003)
Ex 59 - 12-8-72 Stanley of Pfizer Rpt to Clements of Coty
EXHIBIT(S) - 44 (Motion #003)
Ex 44 - 8-31-59 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 61 (Motion #003)
Ex 61 - 11-19-73 Pooley Analysis of VT and Italian Talc
EXHIBIT(S) - 60 (Motion #003)
Ex 60 - 8-28-73 Internal JM Memo re Determination of Chrysotile by TEM
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
EXHIBIT(S) - 69 (Motion #003)
Ex 69 - 9-23-11 Lehman Depo in Bernard & Konopka
EXHIBIT(S) - 68 (Motion #003)
Ex 68 - 9-8-11 Lehman Depo in Bernard & Konopka
EXHIBIT(S) - 67 (Motion #003)
Ex 67 - 5-15-84 Memo from Olson of Cyprus
EXHIBIT(S) - 70 (Motion #003)
Ex 70 - 5-20-14 Lehman Depo in Diaz & Fishbain
EXHIBIT(S) - 147 (Motion #003)
Ex 147 - 027 Hillerdal 1999
EXHIBIT(S) - 154 (Motion #003)
Ex 154 - 3-31-77 J&J Internal memo from Schelz to Estrin
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
EXHIBIT(S) - 118 (Motion #003)
Ex 118 - 8-13-71 CSOM baby powder eval
EXHIBIT(S) - 47 (Motion #003)
Ex 47 - 3-8-60 Battelle
EXHIBIT(S) - 148 (Motion #003)
Ex 148 - Iwatsubo Y., Pleural Meso, Dose Response in French Population, 1998
EXHIBIT(S) - 119 (Motion #003)
Ex 119 - ID and Quant of Asb in Talc - Rohl, Langer - Dec 1974
EXHIBIT(S) - 153 (Motion #003)
Ex 153 - 12-20-73 Ltr Ronald Draftz
EXHIBIT(S) - 152 (Motion #003)
Ex 152 - 7-7-16 Weiss Depo in Polakow
EXHIBIT(S) - 149 (Motion #003)
Ex 149 - OSHA website
EXHIBIT(S) - 150 (Motion #003)
Ex 150 - 8-15-17 Hopkins Depo in Herford
EXHIBIT(S) - 161 (Motion #003)
Ex 161 - 5-15-72 International Technical Service Manufacturing Letter
EXHIBIT(S) - 22 (Motion #003)
Capdevielle Depo 10/5/10
EXHIBIT(S) - 24 (Motion #003)
DaSalva Depo 3/18/11
EXHIBIT(S) - 28 (Motion #003)
Simko letter
EXHIBIT(S) - 25 (Motion #003)
Turse Depo 11/10/12
EXHIBIT(S) - 23 (Motion #003)
Simko Depo 1/21/11
EXHIBIT(S) - 31 (Motion #003)
FDA Study 1973 (Lewin)
EXHIBIT(S) - 35 (Motion #003)
Ohlmeyer Depo 4-11-11
EXHIBIT(S) - 32 (Motion #003)
Yates memo
EXHIBIT(S) - 30 (Motion #003)
RMPS 2
EXHIBIT(S) - 33 (Motion #003)
Schwartz 1-10-12
EXHIBIT(S) - 34 (Motion #003)
Briscese 10-26-10
NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #002)
Insight Pharmaceuticals LLC
EXHIBIT(S) - 3 (Motion #003) Pltf Interrogatory Responses Redacted per 22 NYCRR
Pltf Interrogatory Responses Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - 8 (Motion #003)
Sahmel Affidavit
EXHIBIT(S) - 2 (Motion #003)
Colgate's Answer
EXHIBIT(S) - 9 (Motion #003)
Weill Affidavit
EXHIBIT(S) - 4 (Motion #003) Discovery Deposition of Patsy Young Redacted per 22 NYCRR
Discovery Deposition of Patsy Young Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - P (Motion #002)
U.S. Patent & Trademark Office's Trademark Assignment Abstract of Title on the Caldesene Mark
EXHIBIT(S) - 7 (Motion #003)
Burke Affidavit
EXHIBIT(S) - 6 (Motion #003)
Note of Issue
EXHIBIT(S) - 5 (Motion #003)
De Bene Esse Deposition
EXHIBIT(S) - O (Motion #004)
Pira, Mortality of Talc Miners & Millers in Italy (2017)
EXHIBIT(S) - 1 (Motion #003)
Complaint and Fact Sheet
EXHIBIT(S) - T (Motion #004)
World Health Org., Int'l Agency for Research on Cancer
EXHIBIT(S) - P (Motion #004)
2-28-23 Expert Report of Christy Barlow
EXHIBIT(S) - R (Motion #004)
US Dept. of Health & Human Svc, Qualitative Risk Assessment Committee
EXHIBIT(S) - Q (Motion #004)
FDA Memorandum of Heinz Eiermann, Dir. Div. of Cosmetics Technology
EXHIBIT(S) - L (Motion #004)
Rubino - Mortality & Morbidity Among Talc Miners & Milers in Italy
EXHIBIT(S) - N (Motion #004)
Coggolia, An Update of a Mortality Study of Talc (2003)
EXHIBIT(S) - S (Motion #004)
FDA Ltr by J.W. Swanson, Acting Assoc. Commissioner for Regulatory Affairs, FDA
EXHIBIT(S) - H (Motion #004)
WCD Sales Record to Chattem
EXHIBIT(S) - V (Motion #004)
IARC World Health Org., Int'l Agency for Research on Cancer
EXHIBIT(S) - U (Motion #004)
Copy of US Dept of Health & Human Svc, Report on Talc Workshop
EXHIBIT(S) - HH (Motion #004)
Grunert (1st Dept.)
EXHIBIT(S) - W (Motion #004)
Shields v. American Biltrite Inc. Index# 2016-3854
EXHIBIT(S) - D (Motion #001)
Exhibit D - Compiled Deposition Transcripts
EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #001)
Exhibit A - Plaintiffs Complaint
EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #001)
Exhibit B - CBC's Answer
NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #001)
CBC's Notice of Motion for MSJ
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
EXHIBIT(S) - 21 (Motion #003)
Formula Cards
EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #004)
Summons and Complaint
EXHIBIT(S) - 43 (Motion #003)
Diette Affidavit
EXHIBIT(S) - PP (Motion #004)
Copy of Dr. Moline's Sworn Dep Testimony - 10.16.2014
EXHIBIT(S) - 36 (Motion #003)
Lyons Order
EXHIBIT(S) - NN (Motion #004)
McNeal v. WCD
EXHIBIT(S) - 42 (Motion #003)
Longo 9-26-18
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION (Motion #004)
Affirmation of Christopher Kozak in Support
EXHIBIT(S) - 40 (Motion #003)
Nemeth Order
EXHIBIT(S) - 41 (Motion #003)
Longo 9-28-18
EXHIBIT(S) - 37 (Motion #003)
Stevenson Order
EXHIBIT(S) - II (Motion #004)
Olson (1st Dept.)
NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #004)
Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment
EXHIBIT(S) - S (Motion #002)
OTC Drug Review Process
EXHIBIT(S) - O (Motion #002)
Declaration of Michael Westhusing
EXHIBIT(S) - M (Motion #002)
Drug Applications for Over-the-Counter (OTC) Drugs
EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #002) Plaintiff's Answers to Interrogatories (1.21.21) Redacted per 22 NYCRR
Plaintiff's Answers to Interrogatories (1.21.21) Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - C (Motion #002) Condensed transcript of Plaintiff's de bene esse examination Redacted per 22 NYCRR
Condensed transcript of Plaintiff's de bene esse examination Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - K (Motion #002) Relevant excerpts from dep. of Sean Fitzgerald in Winkel v. Calaveras Asbestos Ltd., et al. (3.17.15
Relevant excerpts from dep. of Sean Fitzgerald in Winkel v. Calaveras Asbestos Ltd., et al. (3.17.15 ... show more
EXHIBIT(S) - R (Motion #002)
FDA Summary of Results from Testing
EXHIBIT(S) - L (Motion #002)
Talc Monograph from US Pharmocopeia
EXHIBIT(S) - N (Motion #002)
Letter from Mitchell to Johnson (5.7.12)
EXHIBIT(S) - T (Motion #002)
Over-the-Counter Monograph M016
EXHIBIT(S) - E (Motion #002)
Insight's Responses to Plaintiff's Supplemental Interrogatories and Requests for Production
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
EXHIBIT(S) - Q (Motion #002)
Relevant excerpts from video dep. of Jean Boyko in Schnacke v. 3M
NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #003)
Colgate-Palmolive Company's Motion for Summary Judgment
EXHIBIT(S) - C (Motion #001)
Exhibit C - Redacted Answers to Interrogatories
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT (Motion #002)
Attorney Affirmation of Robert J. Mullins, II
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION (Motion #001)
CBC's Attorney Affirmation in support of Motion for MSJ
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT (Motion #001)
CBC's Memo of Law in Support of Motion
EXHIBIT(S) - G (Motion #002)
Affidavit of Jean Boyko (5.9.22)
EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #002) Condensed Deposition Transcripts of Plaintiff Redacted per 22 NYCRR
Condensed Deposition Transcripts of Plaintiff Redacted
EXHIBIT(S) - D (Motion #002)
Correspondence from S. Kerley (1.13.22) with service of Pltf's Supplemental Demands
EXHIBIT(S) - H (Motion #002)
Letter from J.W. Swanson to P. Douillet (7.11.86)
CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY ) (Motion #001)
CBC's Attorney Certification
EXHIBIT(S) - F (Motion #002)
Affidavit of Alan M. Segrave, P.G. (1.30.23)
ORDER ( PROPOSED ) (Motion #001)
CBC's Proposed Order Granting MSJ
EXHIBIT(S) - I (Motion #004)
Signed General Affidavit by Alan Segrave
EXHIBIT(S) - Y (Motion #004)
Copy of Wagner v. Bondex Int'l Inc.
EXHIBIT(S) - LL (Motion #004)
Excerpts of Trial Ruling in the Robusto (2015) & Nemeth (2017)
EXHIBIT(S) - K (Motion #004)
Rubino, et al. - Morality Studies of Talc Miners & Millers (1976)
EXHIBIT(S) - X (Motion #004)
Copy of Collin v. Calportland Co.
EXHIBIT(S) - OO (Motion #004)
FDA August 3, 1971 Symposium on Talc
EXHIBIT(S) - 39 (Motion #003)
Nemeth 3-28-17
EXHIBIT(S) - C (Motion #004)
Plaintiff's Answers to Interrogatories
EXHIBIT(S) - M (Motion #004)
Wild, A Cohort Mortality & Nested Case - Control Study (2002)
EXHIBIT(S) - J (Motion #004)
Signed General Affidavit by Kenneth Mundt
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT (Motion #004)
Memorandum of Law in Support
EXHIBIT(S) - G (Motion #004)
WCD Sales Record to Block Drug
EXHIBIT(S) - JJ (Motion #004)
Justice Heitler Decision
EXHIBIT(S) - 38 (Motion #003)
Alfaro 6-15-16
EXHIBIT(S) - Z (Motion #004)
Copy of Lindstrom v. AC Product Liability Trust
EXHIBIT(S) - D (Motion #004)
Plaintiff's Dep Transcript
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS (Motion #004)
Statement of Material Facts
EXHIBIT(S) - CC (Motion #004)
Copy of Hanson v. Colgate-Palmolive Co.
EXHIBIT(S) - E (Motion #004)
WCD Sales Record to Avon
EXHIBIT(S) - EE (Motion #004)
See in Re NYC Asbestos Litigation
EXHIBIT(S) - DD (Motion #004)
Nemeth v. Brenntag N. Am.
EXHIBIT(S) - BB (Motion #004)
Copy of Berg v. Alta Bldg Material Co.
EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #004)
WCD's Verified Answer
EXHIBIT(S) - KK (Motion #004)
Justice Molton Decision
EXHIBIT(S) - MM (Motion #004)
Donovan v. A.O. Smith Water Products Co.
EXHIBIT(S) - F (Motion #004)
WCD Sales Records to Gold Bond
EXHIBIT(S) - FF (Motion #004)
Pomponi (1st Dept)
EXHIBIT(S) - GG (Motion #004)
Dyer (1st Dept.)
EXHIBIT(S) - AA (Motion #004)
Copy of Chap v. Borg-Warner Morse Tec LLC
EXHIBIT(S) - J (Motion #002)
2010 FDA Survey of Talc in Cosmetics
EXHIBIT(S) - 11 (Motion #003)
Rubino 1976
EXHIBIT(S) - 17 (Motion #003)
Madar Order
EXHIBIT(S) - I (Motion #002)
Memo from Dr. Alfred Wiessler to Robert M. Shaffner (7.31.73)
EXHIBIT(S) - 13 (Motion #003)
Coggiola 2003
EXHIBIT(S) - 14 (Motion #003)
Pira 2017
EXHIBIT(S) - 12 (Motion #003)
Rubino 1979
EXHIBIT(S) - 10 (Motion #003)
Zhang Depo 8/30/18
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
EXHIBIT(S) - 15 (Motion #003)
Ciocan 2021
EXHIBIT(S) - 19 (Motion #003)
Barlow Order
EXHIBIT(S) - 26 (Motion #003)
Ohlmeyer Depo 1
EXHIBIT(S) - 16 (Motion #003)
Moline Depo 10/16/14
EXHIBIT(S) - 18 (Motion #003)
Citizens Petition 1986
EXHIBIT(S) - 29 (Motion #003)
Capdevielle Depos (2009, 2010)
EXHIBIT(S) - 20 (Motion #003)
Black v Brenntag
EXHIBIT(S) - 27 (Motion #003)
RMPS
ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING
3RD AMENDED
PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)
Plaintiff's Exhibit List, Trial Witness List & Expert Reliance Materials
ORDER ( PROPOSED ) Proposed 3rd Amended Scheduling Order, TD = 5/23/2023
Proposed 3rd Amended Scheduling Order, TD = 5/23/2023 Possible SSN Administratively Redacted
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Note of Issue
ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING
SECOND AMENDED
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed 2nd Amended Discovery and Trial Scheduling Order
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
CONFIDENTIALITY
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
with Exhibit A attached
STIPULATION - CONFIDENTIALITY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice as to Avon Products, Inc.
Notice of Entry of Order of Dismissal as to Defendant GlaxoSmithKline LLC
Notice of Entry of Order of Dismissal as to Defendant GSK Consumer Health LLC
Notice of Entry of Order of Dismissal as to Defendant Block Drug Corporation
ORDER - DISMISSAL
de: Glaxosmithkline LLC
ORDER - DISMISSAL
de: GSK Consumer Health Inc.
ORDER - DISMISSAL
de: Block Drug Corporation
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Order of Dismissal as to Block Drug Corporation
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Order of Dismissal as to GlaxoSmithKline, LLC
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Order of Dismissal as to GSK Consumer Health LLC
STIPULATION - PARTIAL DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice as to GSK Consumer Health LLC
STIPULATION - PARTIAL DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance without Prejudice as to GlaxosmithKline, LLC
STIPULATION - PARTIAL DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance without Prejudice as to Defendant Block Drug Corporation
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING
Amended Discovery Order & Trial Scheduling Order
EXHIBIT(S) - B
Discovery & Trial Submission Schedule
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Discovery & Trial Submission Schedule
PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)
Notice of Intent to Offer Public Records at Trial
ORDER (PROPOSED) (AMENDED)
Amended Discovery & Trial Order for signature - JS 9/27/2022
EXHIBIT(S) - B
Amended Discovery & Trial Submission Schedule - JS 9/27/2022
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Initial Discovery & Trial Submission Schedule - JS 2/1/2022
ORDER - DISMISSAL
de: Macy's Inc.
NOTICE OF ENTRY
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Order re Macy's, Inc.
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Macy's, Inc.
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Answer of Charles B. Chrystal Company, Inc.
Affidavit of Service - Himmel - Third Party Complaint
RESPONSE TO DEMAND Objections and Answers to Plaintiffs Supplemental Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Doc
Objections and Answers to Plaintiffs Supplemental Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Doc ... show more
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Novartis Corporation and Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation's Notice of Entry of Dismissal Order
ORDER - DISMISSAL
de: Novartis Corp. & Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp.
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Novartis/NPC Proposed Order of Dismissal (Requested 7/14/21 Doc. No. 31)
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Colgate-Palmolive Company's Adjournment of Deposition of Patricia Foreman
Affidavit of Service - Himmel Media LLC
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Colgate-Palmolive Company - Stay of Proceeding Against Insureds of Bedivere
DEMAND FOR: Novartis Corporation and Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation request for Execution of Dismissal Ord
Novartis Corporation and Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation request for Execution of Dismissal Ord ... show more
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Novartis Corporation and Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation's Stipulation of Discontinuance
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Novartis Corporation and Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation's Letter requesting Dismissal
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Novartis Corporation and Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation's Stipulation of Discontinuance
DEMAND FOR:
Product Identification Letter o/b/o Macy's, Inc.
THIRD PARTY SUMMONS/COMPLAINT
ANSWER
Block Drug's Verified Answer to Verified Complaint
ANSWER
GSK Consumer Health's Verified Answer to Verified Complaint
ANSWER
GSK LLC's Verified Answer to Verified Complaint
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Discovery & Trial Submission Schedule
ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Discovery & Trial Order for signature - JS 2/1/2022
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Discovery & Trial Submission Schedule - JS 2/1/2022
ANSWER
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Colgate-Palmolive Company's Verified Answer
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Defendant Avon Products, Inc.'s Verified Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint
NOTICE OF BANKRUPTCY (POST RJI)
ANSWER
Sanofi
ANSWER
Chattem
ANSWER
Sanofi-Aventis
ANSWER
Aventis
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
DEMAND FOR:
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Answer to Complaint - CYPRUS MINES CORPORATION
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Answer to Complaint - CYPRUS AMAX MINERALS COMPANY
EXHIBIT(S) - A
Plaintiff's Statement
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT

Please wait a moment while we load this page.

New Envelope

Your free document request was received.

Your request has been received. We will email you this document within 4 business hours.

You have used out of 0 document requests this month.

Continue

Document Requested

You have exceeded your document request limit for this month.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue
Docket Refresh Requested

Your docket refresh request has been received. You will receive a notification when the docket is refreshed.

Docket Refresh Requested

A refresh is already in progress.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue